Gadgets, do we really need these? - pda
tinyurl.com/ydmf5oh


Would you use any of them?

Pat
Gadgets, do we really need these? - Pugugly
Bring them on !
Gadgets, do we really need these? - TheOilBurner
Yes, I definitely need a better way of managing my swelling MP3 library on the move.

At present in the artists view I have about 150 name, and about a 350 in the albums list.

Trying to select what you want on the move is nearly impossible.

HUD display and dual view sat-nav/DVD sounds nice too. I wouldn't say no.

Edit: just checked, now over 240 artists and 560 albums, it was worse than I thought!!

Edited by TheOilBurner on 27/01/2010 at 11:26

Gadgets, do we really need these? - movilogo
As long as they don't fail I have no problem with gadgets.
Gadgets, do we really need these? - ifithelps
...Yes, I definitely need a better way of managing my swelling MP3 library on the move...

As someone who is about to dip a toe in this particular pool, I guessed track/album selection might be a problem.

An MP3 player on the front seat still represents a giant leap forward over a pile of CDs.

I saw an iPod car charger with the basic arrow controls on the back of the plug that goes into the cigarette lighter.

Gadgets, do we really need these? - dimdip
Not a lover of gadgets, but the dual screen satnav and HUD sound genuinely worthwhile; HUDs should make driving significantly safer I'd have thought. Also Ford's Killjoy key should be A Good Thing. The last two sound like the product of underemployed minds, though...
Gadgets, do we really need these? - ifithelps
...The last two sound like the product of underemployed minds, though...

That's probably what someone once said about electric windows, air conditioning, car radios, intertia reel seat belts, power steering, electric starters, reclining seats, two speed wipers, electric washers, dipping headlights, etc etc.

Today's gadget is tomorrow's must have and the next day's standard fitting.

Gadgets, do we really need these? - dimdip
That's probably what someone once said about electric windows air conditioning car
radios intertia reel seat belts power steering electric starters reclining seats two speed >> wipers electric washers dipping headlights etc etc.


No doubt true to some degree, but you can't compare genuinely useful systems like aircon and seatbelts with something to represent a music collection by coloured blobs, or a VR video game.

Some items serve a realworld purpose while others are of no consequence beyond novelty and light entertainment. I don't doubt that they will find their way into cars, unfortunately... FWIW, I don't think people should be fiddling around with ipods etc on the move anyway. Bah humbug, etc.
Gadgets, do we really need these? - ifithelps
... FWIW, I don't think people should be fiddling around with ipods etc on the move anyway. Bah humbug, etc...

I agree, fiddling with an iPod could be as distracting as fiddling with, but perhaps not talking on, a mobile.

Speaking on a mobile while driving is definitely an offence, as is texting.

Dunno about, say, looking up a phone number in the memory, which could be compared with tinkering with an iPod.

Driving without due care would cover most of these sins.

Gadgets, do we really need these? - tyro
As the BR's paleolithic
"what-do-we-need-the-wheel-for-anyway- feet-are-a-perfectly-good-way-of-getting-around"
luddite, I think that my view of these silly gimmicks will be fairly obvious.

The fewer bells and whistles in a car, the better, IMHO.

(But I will admit that I quite like having a radio. Sometimes.)

Edited by tyro on 27/01/2010 at 11:52

Gadgets, do we really need these? - TheOilBurner
The fewer bells and whistles in a car the better IMHO.


It depends, doesn't it? I don't want gadgets that are cheaply made or badly designed.

But if they work and last the lifetime of the car, then what's the problem?

I hate the auto wipers on my Citroën, but the version fitted to my old Volvo was superb, especially in mixed light rain/misty conditions where lowest speed normal wiper setting would be too much and manual intermittent would mean constant adjustment by hand...
Gadgets, do we really need these? - Waino
I'm afraid I'm with Tyro on this. With all the CDs, MP3s, blue teeth, satnavs, mobiles etc, I'm surprised that anyone is able to concentrate on their driving any more ....... oh, I see, you're not expected to.
Gadgets, do we really need these? - TheOilBurner
An MP3 player on the front seat still represents a giant leap forward over a
pile of CDs.


I have mine integrated with the cars built-in stereo system, so I can view the normal iPod menus on the cars display screen and select using the steering wheel controls, with the added bonus of charging the unit and keeping it hidden from view.

It's still tricky to use though! Even stopped at lights, there's rarely a red light sequence long enough to find and select a different album, especially if it comes quite far down the alphabet...
Gadgets, do we really need these? - old crocks
What you need is the selection on the head-up display. ;-)
Gadgets, do we really need these? - TheOilBurner
LOL! With voice command control, of course... :)
Gadgets, do we really need these? - old crocks
...and Killjoy control of that to stop the kids changing the tracks...
Gadgets, do we really need these? - TheOilBurner
Grand idea. Fix some 70s prog rock on the stereo and they'll never ask to borrow the car again!

The power of technology...
Gadgets, do we really need these? - Rattle
A balance is needed, a PSA or FIAT with all the gadgets would really scare me, but a GM or Ford wouldn't so much.

That said a friend has a Clio with all the gadgets like digital climate control its getting on a bit now (6 years old, 67k) and everything still works.
Gadgets, do we really need these? - mike hannon
I hardly ever turn on the stereo, me. What with chatting with SWMBO, listening to the engine (Vtec or V12) and defending myself from other motorists the time just flies by.
If I'm alone I do press the on button occasionally. That 'Greatest Hits of Matt Monro' must have been in the Honda stereo for years...
Gadgets, do we really need these? - Brian Tryzers
>That 'Greatest Hits of Matt Monro' must have been in the Honda stereo for years...

You found out the hard way that you shouldn't put an eight-track cartridge in the CD slot, Mike?
};---)

The iPod control issue probably deserves a thread of its own. There's probably no going back to a stack of CDs on the passenger seat, so we need some improvement on button-based systems designed for navigating a 15-track CD, not a 4,000-track music library. Voice selection might be the way to go - although perhaps not for fans of Schutz or Schnittke (played by Schnabel, of course), unless they can also wipe the inside of the windscreen on the move.
Gadgets, do we really need these? - TheOilBurner
The iPod control issue probably deserves a thread of its own.


And the fact that iPod integration is still badly done in most marques, with little more than an aux plug on offer.

Or if they do offer a built in hard drive it has some paltry capacity of 10GB or something silly...
Gadgets, do we really need these? - Group B
>> The iPod control issue probably deserves a thread of its own.



MINI music map sounds easy to do yourself, with your own selections, not what the software thinks you want to hear.

I have about 10 playlists for different genres, decades etc., set up via iTunes, and listen to these 90% of the time. Alternatively I just play all 2200 tracks at random and when something comes on that Im not in the mood for, skip it.

Its amazing I never had a problem listening to CDs in the car until the advent of iPod. Now changing CDs seems a massive fiddly chore; I end up listening to things 3-4 times over and getting bored of my favourite albums.
Gadgets, do we really need these? - Clanger
MyKey - I guess it will be a matter of hours before the underground teens will have a hack for this and will make it all pointless anyway. It's not just the speed issue, how are go going to get the teen drivers to clear up the Macdonalds detritus off the seats, fill up the tank and give the car a wash before handing it back ?

Dual view is cute - every car should have it.

Head Up Display - my excuse for a rant. Many of the problems modern drivers have conducting their 'journey appliances' around seems to be because they are not aware of their surroundings. They stare fixedly ahead ignoring events happening at their side or behind. Anything happening outside their TV-shaped view of the world is irrelevant. They get sideswiped by foreign trucks because they fail to see indicators blinking in their side windows. They can't park because they have no idea of their car's dimensions. Legitimate moves by anything that isn't car-shaped makes no impression on them. Anything that encourages a fixed view ahead and discourages head-turning and eyeball movement is going in completely the wrong direction IMO. Concentrate, yes. Comatose stare, no thanks.

Race yourself - not for me.

Music Map - not for melophobic me either.
Gadgets, do we really need these? - mike hannon
WillDeBeest - yes! ;-)
Hawkeye's 'head up display rant' - yes indeed.
Gadgets, do we really need these? - Altea Ego
have you guys never heard of playlists? set them up afore ye go
Gadgets, do we really need these? - Brian Tryzers
So before I set off for work in the morning, AE, I'm supposed to fire up my iTunes computer, make a list of everything I might want to listen to on the way, then plug in the 'Pod and wait for it to synchronize before making my way out to the car? That's the ergonomics of the madhouse!
Gadgets, do we really need these? - Alby Back
I miss Terry Wogan.
Gadgets, do we really need these? - bell boy
I miss Terry Wogan.

> and me ,cant do with ..................im
--as for gadgets why has no one yet invented a built in we we machine that lets everything out between the wheels just like trains but stops you using it while in sainsburys car park?
Gadgets, do we really need these? - TheOilBurner
That's the ergonomics of the madhouse!


Exactly. It would be quicker to browse the CDs, pick what I want and put them in the car ready....

Oh hang on... :D

Let's face it, the iPod in the car is great because it lets us be lazy. Have all (or a fraction if you're Smokie!) of your collection with you to play whatever thing pops into your head as and when you feel like it.

Brilliant, but it does so desperately need better in-car selection.

Edited by TheOilBurner on 27/01/2010 at 17:07

Gadgets, do we really need these? - Lofty Boy

I love gadgets. The more the better.