Road rage lorry driver jailed - paul2007
hi

having read the article a couple of times, intially i felt that the lorry driver was treated too harshly,


however, road rage is one thing and then not coming clean is another hence the 2 years which equates to a few weeks behind bars.

i wonder if the guy will be allowed to driv these massive lorries again?

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1244685/Road-rage...l

Edited by Pugugly on 20/01/2010 at 15:01

Road Rage lorry Driver jailed - Lud
i wonder if the guy will be allowed to driv these massive lorries again?



Perhaps when he gets his licence back he will be able to take up driving on a smaller scale in another town.

One possibility would be to hire a London black cab, after doing the Knowledge of course. He certainly seems to have the right attitudes.

Road Rage lorry Driver jailed - pmh3
You only have to read some of the "viewer" comments to gain a view of the intellect of the average reader of the Daily Wail. Frightening.

Road Rage lorry Driver jailed - pda
I see Peter Sutcliffe is still being held up as an example after all these years.

Pat
Road Rage lorry Driver jailed - Birdie
Whilst the lorry drivers actions were unacceptable, its a shame that the car driver wasn't prosecuted for not looking properly before pulling out of the junction.

Road Rage lorry Driver jailed - paul2007
Hi

You have a valid point but his actions did not cause an accident because of the alertness of the lorry driver. however, the lorry driver then proceded to show his true colours and tried to hide his mistakes from the judge.

If i was the judge and the lorry driver had been honest with me, i would have have not locked him up but banned him for 10 years and sit an extended re-test for any vehicle.
Road Rage lorry Driver jailed - CraigP
Has Mr Mondeo ever done the "me first" routine again?

Reprehensible behaviour from both drivers, obviously more so the HGVs response.
Road Rage lorry Driver jailed - paul2007
pmh3

the posts are relatively well balanced between pro, law and order and those that are wrongly blaming the car driver.

in my many years of driving, i've unwittingly cut two people up, turned left from a side road and did not realize the car coming down the road - he had to slow down and i apologised by the wave of my hand.

the other time was about 20 years ago, turned right from a main road to side road in an area unfamilar to me as i was travelling to an mp's home - the car i unwittingly cut up had to stop, i apologised by hand gesture.

there have been countless incidents when i've been cut up and only about 105 bother to apologise and a loory driver has never apologised.

(there are many good, caring lorry drivers out there and i'm aware of that. but quiet a few in the mid sized lorries do tend to drive about 2 feet from the rear of your car and one did crash into mine at the traffic lights - he said his foot slipped of the clutch - i said did he have to pull up so close - he apologised - there was damage to the car but the guy had apologised and that made it easier for me to accept)
Road Rage lorry Driver jailed - ifithelps
The lorry driver is a pig ignorant bully who, by going to trial, showed he lacks the moral fibre to admit what he had done.

He got two years, which is the maximum for dangerous driving.

This gives you a good idea what the judge thought of it.

Good on yer, your honour.

Road Rage lorry Driver jailed - CraigP
It's hard to imagine a human responding in this way, had the other person apologised with a flash of the hazards. No mention of Mr Mondeo pulling over to get out and say sorry.

Everyone makes mistakes.

I make them (thankfully rarely) even though these days i enjoy the challenge of spending every second behind the wheel analysing how i can be a safer, efficient & accomodating driver.

The HGVs response was inexcusable no matter how egregious the act Mr Mondeo committed.

Considering Mr Mondeo's act seperately (with what truly limited facts we have, especially coming 3rd hand via the source it did![1]), I'm not of a mind to brush off Mr Mondeo's behaviour as ok either (dangerous mistake, deliberatly selfish or otherwise!).

Just like im reluctant to write off "accidents".

[1] i'm never one to pass off a chance to comment tho, eh :-P
Road Rage lorry Driver jailed - helicopter
This happened very close indeed to my home and the lorry driver in my view got everything he deserved. He was a selfish moronic bully using his vehicle as a weapon.

It is regrettable that the sentence was not longer. I 'd like to see him lose his licence for life.
Road Rage lorry Driver jailed - paul2007
On reflection i agree that he must lose his lorry drivers licence for life. Also sit an extended re-test for a car and not allowed to drive anything larger than a ford Ka.
Road Rage lorry Driver jailed - pda
The lorry drivers reaction is inexcusable, no doubt about that.
The Mondeo drivers action in pulling out, leaves a lot to be desired.

A point I would like to make is that as a lorry driver in someone's way, I become a 'juggernaut', I immediately 'thunder' everywhere, I become a 'cretin' and what's more, as a 'professional' driver, I should be punished more and lose my licence for longer.

Yet we have a thread in here stating categorically that lorry drivers are NOT professionals if we choose to class ourselves as such.

It has to be one way or the other, I'm afraid.

Can we class ourselves as professional drivers and aspire to conduct ourselves accordingly, taking the extra punishment advocated by one and all as soon as a mistake is made, or should we give up all hope and just behave like the cretins so many think we are?

Pat
Road Rage lorry Driver jailed - Number_Cruncher
>>It has to be one way or the other, I'm afraid.

I don't agree with that logic.

Yes, driving a truck brings with it some degree of responsibility, but then most jobs bring some degree of responsibility with them - there can't be that many people being paid for truly inconsequential work.

This awful truck driver fell far below the driving standards one would expect of a 10 year old on the dodgems, never mind a holder of a vocational licence.

Road Rage lorry Driver jailed - pda
OK NC. is a vocational licence holder a professional or not?

If you think driving a lorry ( trucks are pick ups) actually brings 'some' degree of responsibility, then I suggest you get out there and have a go.
I can tell you from years of experience that it carries a huge degree of responsibilty.

Even more so in the light of this last few weeks weather conditions.

Have you any idea what a tanker, full of fluid does to a vehicle when it all rushes to the front? Isn't it time that car drivers in general started to take some responsibility for their actions?

My initial post in the BR, some 2 years ago was caused by an incident very much like this one, where I avoided an accident solely by skill. On that occasion a car had deliberately pulled in front of me and braked. He thought it was funny. I thought he was going to die with my lorry on top of him. I was angry and while I can't condone the tanker drivers actions, I can understand his anger after a very near miss that could have been avoided by a car driver paying more attention to driving.
Even more so since he had his son in the car.

Pat
Road Rage lorry Driver jailed - Number_Cruncher
>>OK NC. is a vocational licence holder a professional or not?

No, not a professional.

>>If you think driving a lorry ( trucks are pick ups) actually brings 'some' degree of responsibility, then I suggest you get out there and have a go.

I really don't know why you're trying this tack with me Pat - you know I've been out there and done it. If I can't sort myself out with a new job before my current contract ends, who knows?, I may be back behind the wheel again - although I really will do almost anything to avoid it.

>>Isn't it time that car drivers in general started to take some responsibility for their actions?

All drivers face the same responsibilities, it's just that the consequences of an accident with HGV involvement is usually more serious.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - FotheringtonThomas
Goodness. That tanker must've been going like stink.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
More to the point FT any, tanker that is forced to brake sharply becomes very unstable and would have taken some skill to control it.
Let's not forget what could have been a very different result of the Mondeo's actions.

Pat
Road rage lorry driver jailed - paul2007
hi

as members will note, i have already commended the lorry driver for his 'alertness'!

He must be aware that once a truck goes out of control or hits a car, it will always cause a lot more damage and possibly massive collateral damage. For this very reason, he deserves the 2 years and then trying to lie its way out of it.

Imagain if this lorry when he was trying to cut up the car with the child passenger and the lorry had shoved the car on to the pavement, trapped the car under the lorr or the lorry had struck other vehicles! IMO, the person must be banned for life from drving.

many times I've seen big lorries shoot down narrow country lanes/roads, around bends and i think, what if their front tyre purst, how many cars/homes/people would they hit before they stopped.

After forcing the car to crash, he goes over and abuses the family. the mondeo driver made a mistake and not sure if he'd apologised but the truck drivers actions could have resulted in many deaths. these types are better off locked up.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
>>>>Imagain if this lorry when he was trying to cut up the car with the child passenger and the lorry had shoved the car on to the pavement, trapped the car under the lorr or the lorry had struck other vehicles! IMO, the person must be banned for life from drving<<<

He obviously had no thought about his son being in the car when he pulled out of a side road in front of a lorry Paul.

If you want to go down the route of imagining scenario's, try this one.
Imagine if the lorry driver hadn't managed to brake hard enough to avoid hitting him. Or even, imagine he did manage it, and when the liquid in the tank pushed the vehicle forward as he came to a halt and the liquid didn't, as it will, he still hit him............

Pat
Road rage lorry driver jailed - paul2007
Well pat my friend, the lorry did NOT indeed hit the car.

2 wrongs do not make a right = FACT
there is no evidence that the car driver deliberately did this = FACT

there is clear evidence that the lorry driver was up to no good with a leathal weapon in his hands = FACT

I'm sure we'll find out if this driver had previous!!

Good lorry and psv drivers rarely have any points on their liecence even after years of driving - fact!
Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
Let me get this straight Paul, you see nothing wrong at all in what the Mondeo driver did, and don't appreciate the skill needed to avoid an accident with a tanker full of liquid behind you?
And do see lorry drivers as professional drivers then, because I can't recall you contributing to that thread some time ago?

Lorry drivers and points...............I won't even dignify your view with a response:)

Pat
Road rage lorry driver jailed - paul2007
Open challenge!!

i challenge you to direct me and others here where I've I indicated that the i did not see the car driver do anything wrong!!!!!

stop clutching at straws mate! Admit it that this lorry driver was 100% out of order re what he did when the car pulled out in front of him and this lorry driver behaved like a typical bully with a large weapon and chased his victims into an accident and then got out of his lorry and went over to abuse the guy who had his five year old son in the car. This lorry driver must be banned for life from driving anything larger than a ford ka.

it's dangerous enough and risk to public health and safety when car/van drivers bully other drivers with their vans/cars but when it comes to lorries and very large/heavy lorries at that, its a miracle that no innocent person was seriously injured or killed because of this lorry driver.

Regards

Paul
Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
I totally agree with your last statement Paul, it's truly a miracle that the Mondeo and his son wasn't both killed when they pulled out in front of a lorry.

It could well have had a lorry driver with far less experrience in it, who had only just passed his test, and had no knowledge of how to handle that situation.

Who knows, the Mondeo driver could have been chatting on his mobole phone and of course if he was he wouldn't have been taxed or insured, would he?

Or shall we tar all Mondeo drivers with the same brush, or even all car drivers because one has no concentration or powers of observation?

Isn't that your usual level of reasoning, Paul?

And a Ford Ka can be a lethal weapon in the wrong hands.

Pat

Edited by pda on 20/01/2010 at 17:56

Road rage lorry driver jailed - paul2007
hiding from the challenge and all can see.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - perro
This lorry driver is a maniac and should never be allowed to drive HGV's again (IMO)
Road rage lorry driver jailed - Lud
Quite right perro. But when rehabilitated perhaps he can be trusted with a rented black cab?
Road rage lorry driver jailed - paul2007
This is SICK (i'll post a link soon and quote)

''''The 24-year-old trucker made obscene gestures and flashed his lights before ploughing into them, pushing them 100 yards in his 26-ton Scania waste disposal tanker. ''''

Ban him for life!
Road rage lorry driver jailed - paul2007
the link

www.theargus.co.uk/news/4859499.Crazed_tanker_driv.../
Road rage lorry driver jailed - perro
>>> But when rehabilitated perhaps he can be trusted with a rented black cab? <<<

I've never forgotten the cabbie who knocked me orf my Lambretta SX 200 as I was turning left into Old Compton St. from Wardour St. in 1968 Sire ... and trying to pin the blame on moi :)
Road rage lorry driver jailed - Lud
Old Compton St. from Wardour St. in 1968 Sire ... and trying to pin the blame on moi :)


Aye lad, they think they own that corner (and many another in that part of town), the carphounds...
Road rage lorry driver jailed - ifithelps
Pat,

No need for the bunker mentality.

I don't think any of us think badly of lorry drivers as a body of men - and women - as a result of this case.

We think badly of this bully as an individual, who happened to use his lorry to do his bullying with.

It's bullies who come out badly from this case, not lorry drivers.



Road rage lorry driver jailed - paul2007
Seconded
Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
IIH, it's not about this case, if you notice I agree what he did was totally out of order.
It's these two words

Paul said>>>>massive lorries <<<<<

It was a 17 tonner, a rigid not even an artic.

If you read the comments on the original article we are once again, all likened to Peter Sutcliffe.

We can take the blatant exaggeration every time one of us let's the rest of us down, providing you don't beat the last little bit of pride out of the rest of us, by telling us we are NOT professionals.

Pat
Road rage lorry driver jailed - woodster
The lorry drivers actions are inexcusable - I don't think anyone disagrees on this point. But I'd like to know a little more about the Mondeo driver - we know nothing of his attitude to driving, his driving history or general attitude. Difficult to miss a 17 ton lorry at any time, but apparently he managed to do so. Mistake?

I'm afraid it's all too frequent that people behave badly behind the wheel and seem to think they're in some sort of protected zone. When they upset someone who becomes so enraged that an assault takes place they seek the help of the authorities. Whilst assault is not the answer some of these situations wouldn't happen if people drove a little less aggressively.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
Thanks woodster, the voice of reason at last.

Pat
Road rage lorry driver jailed - ifithelps
...some of these situations wouldn't happen if people drove a little less aggressively...

Was that posted with a straight face, woodster?

There would have been no 'situation' were it not for the actions of the lorry driver.

Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
>>>>Gary Sutton pulled out of a side road in front of him, forcing him to brake hard.<<<<

That may not be classed as a 'situation' to a car driver, but it requires the very limits of a lorry drivers skill to brake hard SAFELY.

Take the blinkers off IIH.

Pat


Road rage lorry driver jailed - ifithelps
...Take the blinkers off IIH...

Pat,

Can't see how observing it was the lorry driver who carried out the offence of dangerous driving can be described as blinkered.

Yes, he did well to avoid the Mondy by the sound of it, but he also made a pretty good fist of undoing that good work within the next few minutes.

Were the Mondy a getaway vehicle in an armed robbery, we would all be applauding the lorry driver for bringing it to a halt.

But it wasn't, so we're not.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - CraigP
There would have been no 'situation' were it not for the actions of the lorry driver.


... and luck.

Lot of luck on the lorry drivers side by the sounds off things to avoid crushing the innocent bystander (child in the passenger seat of the mondeo) by overridding the car...

Of course there was a situation, caused (we wont know the reason) by the mondeo driver.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - paul2007
2 wrongs never make a right.

importantly, the lorry driver carries more responsibility as far as I'm aware as their driving tests/exams are much more intense because of the massive vehicle they drive. In the wrong hands these lorries are WMD


i
Road rage lorry driver jailed - CraigP
Difficult to miss a 17 ton lorry at any time, but apparently he managed to do so. Mistake?


Just as well it was a mondeo and not a pedal cyclist. Can you imagine if the pedal cyclist had pulled out in front?

Tanker drivers have been known to get out and chase after cyclists for less!

Poor show CraigP, it's all Lud's fault :-P
Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
Imagine if it was a tipper driver:)

GB & harleyman will understand that one"

Pat
Road rage lorry driver jailed - FotheringtonThomas
>> going like stink
(snip)
Pat


It was carrying "organic waste".

Sorry...
Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
I missed that one, FT:) :) I bet it was Poo!

Pat
Road rage lorry driver jailed - Dave_TD
Didn't Mr X used to post Daily Mail articles to start a topic? :-)
Road rage lorry driver jailed - CGNorwich
indeed
Road rage lorry driver jailed - paul2007
snip - not needed in here thank you

Edited by Pugugly on 20/01/2010 at 19:13

Road rage lorry driver jailed - paul2007
hopefully the lorry driver showed some remorse!
Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
That is sad.

Why would you want to post his Facebook details on here?

Now I can probably see why the Black Cab thread disappeared last night.

Pat



Road rage lorry driver jailed - paul2007
Hi

Stir it as much as you want mate but you forewell know that the 'facebook' link has been deleted = FACT! If it had not been deleted, I would not have posted the 'Google' result = FACT

importantly, the lorry drivers details are available via media and clealry state approx where he lives. many will be aware where he lives. You may think I run the internet information system but i do not.

Trust me the national press will carry this story big time tomorrow.

thankfully the judge saw sesne this time.

hopefully, the lorry driver has seen the errors of his way and will be released in 8/9 months and lead a normal life!

thankfully the loory driver did not kill/maim inncoent people in his road rage stint!
Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
Paul

Can I ask you a question please?

Why do you think it's acceptable on here to call me 'Mate'

You've done it twice now and I'm intrigued as to why I'm the only one in the BR you address this way.

Pat
Road rage lorry driver jailed - corax
If Mondeo man pulled out by and didn't see the lorry (!), then OK, it was a mistake. Though these days, many people pull out in front of you despite the fact there is nothing behind you, which is rude, and selfish.

However, I don't praise the drivers actions, although some of the blame could be aimed at his age. Some 23 year olds, not all, will let their emotions get the better of them, and when armed with a 17 tonne lorry, could result in severe consequences as seen here.

I agree with woodster, some less aggressive driving wouldn't go amiss, it makes everyone else on the road calmer, which will lead to less accidents.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - ifithelps
...Now I can probably see why the Black Cab thread disappeared last night...

I thought the black cab thread disappeared last night because it had started raining.

That's what normally happens to black cabs when the heavens open. :)
Road rage lorry driver jailed - paul2007
I had it removed because of the abuse posted by one person.
i was the author of the thread and I asked for it to be removed and the mod here obliged.
Regards
Paul.


Btw, if there any lorry drivers reading here apart from the one that claims to be and i have challenged re their statement about my post which he/she has failed to appropriately respond to - I reiterate that the vast majority of lorry drivers like any other professional are sensible/caring people and the last thing they would do is to commit road rage.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
having tried to save your face again, would you care to answer myquestion above Paul, or is that too hard for you.

As for my credentials as a lorry driver just google PDA or PDF Paul.

Pat
Road rage lorry driver jailed - Lud
had it removed because of the abuse posted by one person.


I wonder who that was? I can only think of three candidates including myself.

Are you a secret wimp 2007? Surely not...
Road rage lorry driver jailed - woodster
Pat,

I don't know why some of us bother (you included!) - feeling the need to post on here is akin to the need to answer the phone - frequently a pointless conversation with someone you don't know and probably don't want to know!!
Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
Well, you got the last bit right Woodster, but every now and again I get sick of the one sided view everone seems to have!
If only life were that simple eh?
I've had to re-stack 26 pallets of jars of jam after a car driver pulled out in front of me and I had to brake hard. They all lean forward and are refused, TM says it's my fault I braked hard, I restack them by hand.
That's a lot of jars!

Now, let's wait until someone says they should have been secured better!!

Pat
Road rage lorry driver jailed - paul2007
So, did you chase the driver and the five year old in his car by flashing your lights, sounding your horn, runing him off the road and making him crash, then reverse, get out of your giant lorry and go over the the man and child and shout abuse like the lorry driver in question?!!!!

Just to help you - the above is a rhetorical question - lol.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - paul2007
Well!!!!!
Road rage lorry driver jailed - smokie
Paul - in answer to your rhetorical question (!!) I have been chased, forced to stop and verbally (and nearly physically) abused by another driver, also in a lethal weapon (Sierra I think), some years back.

In that instance, if I was honest, it was virtually entirely my own fault - I took a chance but slightly misjudged gaps/timing, resulting in Jack The lad wanting to beat me up cos of the near miss. I had the family in the car too. Had it gone to court for some reason, I may have been inclined to play down my contribution.

So, having been there (have you, Paul?) I can see that, while the lorry driver is most clearly in the wrong on a number of counts, there could have been provocation, which the papers may have chosen to play down for the sake of a story. Does it say whether the Mondeo "brake tested" the lorry after he'd made his mistake? Or that the Mondy driver gave the lorry driver a two fingered salute, thinking he'd never catch up with him? No. We just don't know the full facts.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - paul2007
Smokie - you speaking on behalf of Pat - lol (just jesting)

'''we just don't know the full facts.'''!!!!

please stand corrected, the judge did have the full FACTS for him to reach a decision to lock up this bully. the events leading up to the car driver and his 5 year old son being forced of the road were witnessed by independent witnesses as well as the fact re lorry driver recersing and running up to the car that he caused to crash and shout and swear at them.

we've all made mistakes and I've posted mine here - but i never push in, but if i relaize a mistake, i apologise, but appreciate your honesty here.

you will agree with me that this ex lorry driver got what he deserved if not less all thanks to law abiding citizens that were prepared to stand up in court and spell out the facts re this lorry drivers actions

Regards

Paul
Road rage lorry driver jailed - maz64
please stand corrected the judge did have the full FACTS for him to reach a
decision to lock up this bully.


smokie was only saying that we (not the judge) don't know the full facts, only what's been reported.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - maz64
please stand corrected the judge did have the full FACTS


And please could you stop 'shouting' (using CAPS)? It tends to wind people up.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - rtj70
And calling us all friend or mate when we don't know you from anyone else. I could be anyone on a motorway man.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - CraigP
Paul, you've (deliberately? again...) missed Smokie's (& pda's & mine & ... so on) POINT.

To reap the benefits of a civilised society, we cannot allow people to take the law into their own hands. Ergo Mr Mondeo couldn't & shouldn't be punished once Mr HGV did what he did. Justice was served everyone in agreement there.

To get to the point you keep skipping...

Our own experience on the roads suggests Mr Mondeo likely provoked the situation, or at the least failed to mitigate it with an apology.

Had Mr HGV kept his composure, what should have been done with Mr Mondeo? Nothing? Telling off? Points on the licence? Disqualification? Hung drawn & quartered?
Road rage lorry driver jailed - Old Navy
Maybe Paul2000 thinks the tanker driver should just have lifted his feet so that the Mondeo didnt take his feet off as it went under the cab.

Edited by Old Navy on 20/01/2010 at 18:56

Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
He still hasn't answered my question and it really was quite a simple one.

Why do you think it's acceptable to address me as Mate Paul?

Just to help you this isn't a rhetorical question, it requires an answer.

Pat

Edited by pda on 20/01/2010 at 19:02

Road rage lorry driver jailed - CGNorwich
"I've had to re-stack 26 pallets of jars of jam after a car driver pulled out in front of me and I had to brake hard"

Obviously the origin of the phrase "to jam on the brakes" :-)
Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
I said to the Transport Manager 'What do you want, jam on it''

Pat
Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
Female Lorry Driver 1
Paul2007 0


:):)

Pat
Road rage lorry driver jailed - Bromptonaut
There's nothing in the press report beyond that the Mondeo driver (tempted to add allegedly) pulled out in front of the tanker.

Could have been anything between what was frankly speeding/lack of attention by the effluent container to a full on "stuff you" pullout by the car.

The rest is speculation.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - paul2007
Hi guys

I've spent too much time on this thread but have made my point.

Re the poster mentioning my 'cap' letters, not meant to offend but i apologise anyways.

The bottom line is this IMO: When we all get behind the wheel of our vehicle, it is potentially a leathal weapon if not treated with respect and highway code followed. However, HGV/PSV drivers have even more responsibility if that is possible, ie, a mistake on their part or an accident involving a larger vehicle usually results in a nastier accident.


When i drive, i drive defensively, ie, assume the other drivers will make a mistake.

i too can cause mistakes and will apologise if I note I've made a mistake.

It is easy to get wound up if you feel you are in the right and got cut up and then abused by the very same person.

i try to practice what i post = road rage is not cool and could result in something that you and others may regret for the rest of your lives - so drive away!!!!

Thank you all for your comments

Regards

Paul.


PS: Great site, great posters!

PPS: This is my final post on this thread.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - Nsar
>>i try to practice what i post = road rage is not cool and could result in something that you and others may regret for the rest of your lives - so drive away!!!!<<

On 27 December you posted this gem..>> I got out of the car as it was slow moving traffic along the embankment & went over to the fool by Chelsea bridge traffic lights and rebuked the fool.<<

Can we believe anything you write?

Edited by Nsar on 21/01/2010 at 00:33

Road rage lorry driver jailed - Lygonos

Edited by Dynamic Dave on 21/01/2010 at 10:27

Road rage lorry driver jailed - perro
In a previous life, I committed road rage on another car driver I am sorry to say.
My wife's Mother had just died from a massive brain tumor at the age of 45 so I wasn't in the best of moods at the time.
I was charged with the serious offense of dangerous driving which was reduced to careless driving on the day resulting in quite a large fine plus endorsements so it was nowhere near the seriousness of the OP.
There are absolutely no excuses in a case like this - whatever the car driver may have done,
only lies and bullies.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - Cliff Pope
If the report in the paper is accurate then he got off incredibly lightly. Deliberately driving a lorry into someone and being careless of the consequences is attempted murder.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - ifithelps
...being careless of the consequences is attempted murder....

Not quite.

To prove attempted murder the prosecution would have to prove the lorry driver intended serious harm to the car driver.

The crucial word there is 'intended'.

Yes, he might have intended to run him off the road, he might even have intended to knock him about a bit, but with the facts as presented, the prosecution could never prove he intended serious harm.

Road rage lorry driver jailed - helicopter
I mentioned to SWMBO about this case last night.

As stated above it happened very close to where I live.

Her reaction was also that he should have been prosecuted for attempted murder.

I'm sorry Pat , I understand the instinct to protect your own but his behaviour was inexcusable irrespective of the 'cutting up ' . There is no doubt in my mind the intention was there to cause serious harm to the car driver due to the fact that it happened some three miles down the road from the perceived cutting up by the Mondeo of the lorry.

In a 40 zone the lorry driver had probably 5 minutes to cool down before he caught up the Mondeo and he then deliberately rammed the car using his lorry as a weapon.

You will note from the car photos that the serious damage is on the drivers door. To me that indicates deliberate intent to cause harm to the driver. he then lied through his teeth and got IMO less than he deserved but the most they could impose for dangerous driving from a judge and jury.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - Nsar
I'm no fan of the CPS, but I think they do try to go for the most serious count that they can, ie if there was a chance of trying him for attempted murder, they would have gone for it.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - Cliff Pope
I'm no fan of the CPS but I think they do try to go for
the most serious count that they can ie if there was a chance of trying
him for attempted murder they would have gone for it.


I'd have thought this covered it:

"Proof of mens rea
There must be more than merely preparatory acts and, although the defendant may threaten death, this may not provide convincing evidence of an intention to kill unless the words are accompanied by relevant action, e.g. finding and picking up a weapon, and making serious use of it, or making a serious and sustained physical attack without a weapon"

"Finding a weapon and making serious use of it" = deliberately swiping a lorry several times into the side of a car ?

Road rage lorry driver jailed - Nsar
>>I'd have thought this covered it:<<

Seemingly not.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - Westpig
I'm no fan of the CPS but I think they do try to go for
the most serious count that they can ie if there was a chance of trying
him for attempted murder they would have gone for it.


The CPS are measured on their successes, not for giving the more serious offences 'a run'.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - b308
I'm sorry Pat I understand the instinct to protect your own but his behaviour was
inexcusable irrespective of the 'cutting up ' .


Having just read the whole thread, I too am wondering why Pat is being so defensive... Pat, you are not protecting "one of your own" or even putting a "HGV's view of events" as I know that you and the vast majority of HGV drivers would not have reacted in the way this chap did.

I'd leave it be, he could have been driving a white van or even another car and would probably reacted the same way, the only reason it made the headlines is that it was a big heavy truck... but that doesn't automatically make all you truck drivers baddies... and most (!) of us have the sense to realise that! ;-)
Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
In that case b308 and helicopter, please go back and read each of my posts again and you will see that I have stated in many posts that what this driver did was totally out of order and supported the treatment he's received.
I have however attempted to point out that had the Mondeo driver NOT pulled out in front of him this wouldn't have happened either so in my book he has to shoulder a part of the blame.
I have also explained the potential consequences of cars pulling out and causing heavy braking to a lorry.
It's something we face every day, simply because too many car drivers look right and decide 'I don't want to be stuck behind that'.
Most of us expect it to happen and are already covering the brake and slowing down.
The lorry driver was just 23 yrs old, he would not have had an HGV licence until he was at least 21 yrs old and therefore didn't have that experience.

I am not defending 'my own' at all, I am defending the right to be judged objectively in the terms used in reporting, as you will see by my first post.
I am defending the right for lorry drivers to consider themselves to be professional if the public want them to have a professional attitude.

And I will forever defend that right.

Now, is that clear?

b308 please don't do a Paul on me and not watch my lips:)

Pat

Edited by pda on 21/01/2010 at 11:24

Road rage lorry driver jailed - b308
Pat, I'm not the only one who thought the same about your posts, in fact I quoted from Helicopter's post.

I think you are over-reacting, most of us with a little common sense have already made the judgement that it was a physco driver involved here and the fact that it was a lorry he was driving was not really relevent to what he did after the initial incident. All of us get angry, he went overboard, and was punished appropriately. No need to defend your fellow HGV drivers as we already know that most would not do this but just grin (!) and bear it.

Lets just be thankful that there's one less road rage driver off the road for a few years, eh!

Edited by b308 on 21/01/2010 at 11:46

Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
b308, you have turned into Paul and I shal have to SHOUT at you in a minute:)

It's because we grin and bear it we never receive the credit we deserve and for every time we allow others to call us cretins, and liken us to Peter Sutcliffe then we deserve no better.
I'm pleased about that too, but I would happily have let the Mondie driver restack my 26 pallets of jam. He would have looked twice the next time he thought of pulling out.:)

Pat
Road rage lorry driver jailed - b308
b308 you have turned into Paul and I shal have to SHOUT at you in
a minute:)


You are beginning to get to the stage with Paul as I was with MrX and his rants against the disabled and motability... the majority of us are already on your side... step back, its not worth it. :)

Edited by b308 on 21/01/2010 at 14:06

Road rage lorry driver jailed - FotheringtonThomas
driving a lorry into someone and being careless of the consequences is
attempted murder.


No it isn't.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - Ben 10
"but you have to admit that his threads are popular"

"No they're not. They are repetitive and too many of you rise to the bait. Which he wants" FACT! ;-)


"A very narrow minded view spood, if I may so so.
Others may not agree with you, have you considered that?
Pat"

Changed your mind on him yet Pat ?

Edited by Cpt. Flack on 21/01/2010 at 11:31

Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
Not at all.
Paul has every right to his view and to voice that view as we all have.
All we need to do now is to teach him how to debate his point without abuse:)

Pat
Road rage lorry driver jailed - perro
I believe Paul may be a tad Dyslexic?
He is learning to 'present' himself on ere, through usage - like we all do.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
I think he's a secret MP:)

Let's look at the facts here.
He can't answer a direct question, he wears blinkers and he believes he's always right!

Pat
Road rage lorry driver jailed - FotheringtonThomas
He can't answer a direct question he wears blinkers and he believes he's always right!


Across:

1) "Trip-trap trip trap" (5)


I missed the moment on this one, but for anyone reading this "old" post I personally regard this kind of post (and the one which preceded it) equally as offensive, humourless and unnecessary as any other supposedly anti-social posts seen on this forum. Being "one of the the regulars" gives no special privileges when it comes getting away with being offensive. Especially when it's done repetitively, like FT has done. So please desist.

Smokie, Moderator

Edited by smokie on 21/01/2010 at 21:52

Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
Well FT, that's too cryptic for me, but that's hardly surprising.
care to explain?

Pat
Road rage lorry driver jailed - helicopter
Pat....

Depending on how old you are it refers to a song of the 1950's. I'm harking back to Uncle Mack on the old Light Programme Childrens Favourites on Saturday Mornings before Brian Matthew started shaving....

I believe sung by IIRC Frankie Howerd...... called I'm a troll - troll de roll.......and I'll eat you for dinner.

In Norway Trolls are ugly creatures who live supposedly under bridges..

The words of the song go something like .....

.......'trip trap trip trap ' ......( You understand now )

hop and skip , hop and skip over the rickety rackety bridge'
Road rage lorry driver jailed - ifithelps
Well worked out, helicopter.

You pilot chaps really are clever fellows.



Road rage lorry driver jailed - Dipstick
No no, the trip trap referring to a troll is surely from "The Three Billy Goats Gruff" fairy story?



Road rage lorry driver jailed - Nsar
Oh...I was thinking along the lines of pony &......
Road rage lorry driver jailed - pda
No here's the lorry driver in me showing..................

I thought it was cockney rhyming slang :)

trap....

Pat

Edited by pda on 21/01/2010 at 16:35

Road rage lorry driver jailed - helicopter
Dipstick.....

In the song it was indeed the three billy goats gruff who went trip and trap, hop and skip over the rickety rackety bridge.

The song came from the fairy story....

My word it makes me feel old.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - woodster
< >

Nsar, if you think about it, that makes no sense whatsoever. The CPS can charge whatever they like, so in theory, they could have charged attempted murder, but if there's no realistic prospect of a conviction having reviewed the available evidence and considered the law and stated cases in the area concerned, then what would be the point?. An acquittal would follow and justice would not have been served.

Additionally, to continue the practice of trying to charge beyond the circumstances would result in a woeful conviction rate for the CPS.

I may be wrong, of course, and in my years of working very closely to the CPS I may have missed whatever it is that you've seen. What evidence do you have of such CPS practices?
Road rage lorry driver jailed - jbif
<> >>


woodster, FYI :

The <> in your post above indicates to me that you may have tried to enclose some text inbetween the arrows. I think you did the same in the now hidden "black cabs" thread.

The preferred method of quoting posts, on this forum, is explained by DD here:
www.honestjohn.co.uk/forum/post/index.htm?v=e&t=81...6

HTH.

Edited by jbif on 21/01/2010 at 17:42

Road rage lorry driver jailed - maz64
>> <> >>


jbif - sorry to be pedantic but is the >> at the end of the line deliberate?
Road rage lorry driver jailed - jbif
jbif - sorry to be pedantic but is the >> at the end of the line deliberate? >>


Yes, it is my personal tweak to the DD "recommended" method; I use to indicate "end of quote".

p.s. to woodster:
the reason your text disappeared between the <> arrows is that ending text with >, having begun it with <, has a special meaning in HTML as used on this site.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - Nsar
Woodster, perhaps my posting was a bit woolly. What I was trying to say is that despite its shortcomings, I think the CPS would have pressed for attempt murder if they thought it had a realistic chance.
Road rage lorry driver jailed - woodster
Jbif, thanks.

Nsar, yes, you're right. With you now.