BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - corax
This is unfortunately only a sound recording, but still great.

www.youtube.com/watch?v=wRSYTw9IBxg

Listen to the drive by around 2 mins in. Near the end there is an onboard sound recording. I can't believe this engine is only 1.5L.

Has anyone got any personal favourites sound wise. V8 perhaps?. Or straight five?

Any thoughts?



BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - SteveLee
Merlin V12!
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - DP
Merlin V12!


Seconded!

The 2.9 litre twin turbo V8 used in the Ferrari F40 is pretty special as well.
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - craig-pd130

Honda's RC166 from 1966 - the 250cc 6-cylinder, 24-valve GP racer

www.youtube.com/watch?v=vdDb7t2gCa0&feature=related
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - nortones2
Seconded re the Honda. I've heard it at Mallory Park, post TT, a long while ago:)
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Mick Snutz
The engine on Babs (land speed record holder from the twenties or thirties). Some massive aero engine or other.

I recall seeing something similar at Goodwood a few years back. Huge engine from an old plane, no silencers and a sound that made your insides runny.

Fantastic if a little scary.
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Glaikit Wee Scunner {P}
I saw and heard this BRM some years ago at Donington Park after a lengthy restoration.
By the lengthy revving in the paddock it took some time to get it running cleanly.
On the first or second lap it caught fire and driver Willie Green steered it on to the grass and leaped out.
Think that on its first ever outing, it broke one drive shaft and subsequently limped to the start line on the surviving shaft just to claim the starting fee. Or something like that. A dog from new.

Being a philistine I really love big American V8s. At another Donington meeting I remember the sound of the ex-Alan Mann Ford Falcon being wrestled around by Stirling Moss. Fantastic.

Oh and I do love big twin bikes, be they Norton, Triumph, Ducati or BMW.
Merlins are rather tuneful as well.
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Mick Snutz
A Merlin in full song with that wonderful supercharger whine as it gracefully turns in the blue skies over Duxford....mmmmm bring on the summer airshows.
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Sofa Spud
Or this one....?

Foden two-stroke supercharged 6-cylinder diesel engine? (Short clip)

www.youtube.com/watch?v=yAHFD_8eD70&feature=related
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Harleyman
Foden two-stroke supercharged 6-cylinder diesel engine?


Brings back happy childhood memories; my late father worked for Hoveringham Gravels (remember the bright orange Matchbox model?) and we lived only a couple of miles from the quarry. Every morning, there was a chorus of about twenty of these beasts leaving the yard; music!

Back in the mid-80's, I was doing a delivery to a firm called South London Pistons on Old Kent Road. The storeman there was an old boy (you know the sort, long brown coat, pencil behind ear, fag in mouth) who'd seen it all. I heard a Foden 2-stroke approaching, commented on it, to be treated with scorn.... "'Ow would YOU know, they ain't been around fer years!"..... and along came a pristine S20 wagon and drag on its way to a show. Storeman's face was an absolute picture!
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Mick Snutz
Does anyone recall that programm on channel 4 where a group of mechs and engineers repaired and renovated old vehicles. There was a woman mechanic and the program was presented by Sugs (Madness). What was it called?

Anyway they repaired some old car which had a copper body and I think was based on a Ford model T. I remember seeing that at Goodwood and it making quite an impressive noise. Can't seem to find any reference on the interweb.
Perhaps I imagined it all.
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Harleyman
Regarding the Hoveringham Fodens; here's a pic of one that's been restored.

tinyurl.com/yzsnnsd
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - corax
There was a woman mechanic and the programme was presented by suggs (MADNESS) What was it called?


Salvage Squad!

Edited by corax on 12/01/2010 at 21:41

BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Mick Snutz
thanks Corax. I knew someone would remember it. Any ideas what the car was though that they restored. It had a highly polished body which tapered at the tail.
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - DP
Nice F40 clip. Gives me goosebumps

www.youtube.com/watch?v=PqTj9NyVt00
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - CQ
3 Cylinder 6 pistons.
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - corax
I saw Stirling Moss being interviewed about the BRM V16. He said it was a pig to drive, the power and torque curves were in the wrong place, the handling was unpredictable, and it broke down a lot. No wonder it didn't win any races. I still like the sound though!

One of the contributors to PPC magazine has built a Rover SD1 with a Meteor engine, which is the non-supercharged version of the Merlin V12. He sits where the back seats used to be.
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - FotheringtonThomas
Any thoughts?


That was a real racer. Well over 500BHP. Rules change too much.
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Altea Ego
www.youtube.com/watch?v=YBxw4whvBiA
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - DP
www.youtube.com/watch?v=YBxw4whvBiA


Sato is a loon! :-) I remember him literally destroying a set of rear intermediates on one run up the hill at the Festival of Speed a few years back. Donuts until you couldn't see anything, up the track with the rears smoking. Stop, egg the crowd on by waving his fists until the air horns and cheering got loud enough and repeat. About 30 times.

Those things really do sound amazing.
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - bazza
Anyone else fondly remember the sound of the Ford/Lotus Twin Cam unit, particularly in works prepared Escort RS 1800 or 2000 with twin Webers, preferably being driven Roger Clark or Ari Vatanen? Music to my ears!
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - gordonbennet
Sweetest engine sound
www.youtube.com/watch?v=wCYl3I91aKA

Best sounds at the start...4.30,6.22,8.55, enjoy this sweet Napier Diesel fix..

thanks for an ideal excuse to sooth my ears with sounds of engines that kissed the very air
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Mick Snutz


tinyurl.com/yahchru
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Alby Back
Brilliant Mick !
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - J Bonington Jagworth
Best with sound only, IMO :-)

The dirt-bike impression (single-cyl 4-stroke) is amazing!
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Dave_TD
Has anyone got any personal favourites sound wise?


Anything at the Goodwood Revival, frankly. I spend the entire day there slightly weak at the knees.

The Festival Of Speed is good in its own way too, but the Revival does it for me without fail.
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Sofa Spud
Re the 2-stroke Fodens - I used to live on a hill on a main road where there was a lot of lorry traffic and as a boy I could tell all the different noises and the Fodens were particularly distinctive with their bellowing sound - very loud too, and also because they had (I think) 12 speed gearboxes and the drivers were always changing gear to maintain speed.

Most Fodens, of course, had Gardner diesel engines - only a minority had Foden's own 2-stroke engines (4 or 6 cylinder variants). But one real rarity owned by a local coach firm was a rear-engined Foden luxury coach, complete with the 2-stroke engine. It had wild body styling too - I've discovered since that it was bodied by a firm called Windovers.

The other really distinctive sound we used to hear was a guy who had a Jensen Interceptor who used kickdown to pass slower vehicles going up the hill!
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - SteveLee
Re the 2-stroke Fodens - I used to live on a hill on a main
road where there was a lot of lorry traffic and as a boy I could
tell all the different noises


I liked the industrial sound of the unstoppable Commer TS3 better known as the Double Knocker, (oh-er misses) I believe this pre-dated the similar Foden.
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - corax
enjoy this sweet Napier Diesel fix.


You can't beat the Deltics when it comes to locos GB. Putting cars aside for a minute I always liked these too

www.youtube.com/watch?v=W-USZJqkeYU

You could hear that throbbing (oo-err) for miles across the countryside on a still summer night.

I'll take my anorak off now!
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Sofa Spud
It seems that we've hijacked this thread with posts of 2-stroke diesel sounds....

Here's another - Detroit 12V71 V12 supercharged 2-stroke diesel

After the first minute or two of playing about in the yard there's a good ride in the cab...
www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZmytwZnXgjM&feature=related
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - focusman
hi
one to beat
the vulcan, on reheat on a sharp turn and climb.
that makes your insides quiver
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Group B
Car engines - old yank V8's sound best to me:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=nHzTu3yXaK4

Audi straight fives are pretty special.

Anything loud, raw, and dangerous sounding, like this TWR XJS:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=1RM2N_8CfQo


Merlin is obviously the best sounding aero engine.
I once went out for a walk at Derwent reservoir with my brother, we were on the grass in front of the Derwent dam and heard the unmistakeable sound of WW2 aero engines. The sound got louder then all of a sudden the Battle of Britain flight flew over the dam at very low altitude, right over our heads. Words cannot express how incredible that was.
I spoke to a bloke in the visitors centre afterwards and he said it had not been publicised because last time they did, 80000 people turned up and caused traffic chaos for hours..

Edited by Group B on 13/01/2010 at 10:48

BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - mike hannon
The Rootes TS3 two-stroke horizontally opposed diesel - as fitted to Commers and Karriers - sounds lovely, particularly with the transverse front exhaust box. There's lots of clips on Youtube. It's worth Googling for an explanation of how it works, too, with its three cylinders, six pistons, twin superchargers and rockers turning the crankshaft. All designed as a bus engine more than 50 years ago. They don't use imagination to make engines like that any more.
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Harleyman
They don't use imagination to make engines like that any
more.


If you'd ever worked on the Chieftain tank engines (same configuration as the Foden but MUCH bigger) you'd know why!

Just as an aside, I often hear the comment "They don't make 'em like that any more" when at shows with the pick-up or the old side-valve Harley.

My stock reply.... "They wouldn't dare!"
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - J Bonington Jagworth
Straight fives do sound surprisingly nice, but I would still like a V8...

I also like radial aero engines, as presumably does this guy:

www.youtube.com/watch?v=K_fatXJoz4s

(which gives new meaning to the phrase 'blown away')

Not to mention this one, who is probably certifiable. You can hear it go at about 3:20...

www.youtube.com/watch?v=1TIdQFnUvCA

BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Sofa Spud
Or this - a 42-cylinder liquid-cooled radial engine - specially built - like 7 in-line 6's around a common crank. This is said to be the largest and most powerful petrol engine ever built! It was made specially for this tractor, Dragon Fire!

www.youtube.com/watch?v=8oWGhgkd2Ss

10,000 bhp !!!

Edited by Sofa Spud on 13/01/2010 at 13:30

BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - J Bonington Jagworth
Thanks SS. I was going to mention drag racing, but it's something you really have to hear (and smell) yourself - recordings tend to be a pale imitation! Impressive tractor, though...
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Sofa Spud
More on Dragon Fire - the 42-cylinder petrol engine (10,000 bhp) is 147 litres and has 126 spark plugs - triple ignition!!
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - piston power
www.youtube.com/watch?v=SZo1KBPKa7c&feature=related

Pity this is not real but cgi stuff but these sounds do it for me than any car or f1............
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - turbo11
For me, other than a Merlin it has to be a V10 F1 engine. some years ago we were doing static vibration tests of the whole car rather than just the engine and transmission, using large fan coolers and copious amounts of dry ice for cooling,we were revving to 19000 rpm. continuously for some minutes It certainly makes your insides buzz when standing two feet away. Awesome.
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Group B
www.youtube.com/watch?v=SZo1KBPKa7c&feature=related
Pity this is not real but cgi stuff but these sounds do it for me
than any car or f1............



I love this clip of the Mustangs in Empire of the Sun. Great low flying and Merlin sound effects.

www.youtube.com/watch?v=02BBtN-P0lc
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Tomo
Thanks!

That takes me back to Turnberry in the fifties. The BRMs and the Thinwall Ferrari certainly made music.
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - Aretas
If any of you are interested in the history of the BRM V16, author Karl Ludvigsen gave a lecture at the RAC Club a couple of years ago and it can be seen here. About an hour long.

tinyurl.com/y8zfa7r
BRM V16 - Best engine sound? - corax
Thanks for all the input people. Judging by the examples so far, I think its safe to say that the old'uns are the best!