Changing tyres - cilvilservant
Hello all

It's coming up to changing all four 17 "tyres on my V50 and obviously I'm keen to find a bargain - especially as I'm keen to fit a premium brand. I have always changed tyres previously by only going to places where they do all the extras such as tracking and balancing. But I'm on a very tight budget at the moment and would like to ask if it's absolutely necessary to pay for the extras.

Would I be daft to simply go to a fitter who can just change the tyres without doing the balancing and tracking?

Thanks.

Changing tyres - daveyjp
I've never had a tyre fitted which didn't include balancing as part of the deal and never would. Have you ever driven a car with unbalanced wheels?

Tracking can be left if you are confident there are no problems with it.
Changing tyres - cilvilservant
Thanks - so balancing is a must. I note that one of the rear tyres has worn down more than the other side - all over. I was thinking maybe it was a 'suspect' tyre but is this a strong enough reason to get the tracking checked?

There is no undue vibrations at any speed.

Changing tyres - rtj70
How much more? Ask the tyre fitter for advice.
Changing tyres - doctorchris
Checking and adjusting tracking will make no difference to rear tyre wear.
If the wear across the tread of all your tyres is even then I would stick to new tyres with balancing and see how it goes.
Tracking only checks one aspect of front wheel geometry, namely toe in/ toe out. There are other aspects of this geometry. Then, rear wheel geometry is a whole new issue. You can have a full 4 wheel geometry check if needed but it gets expensive.
Changing tyres - Cliff Pope
Checking and adjusting tracking will make no difference to rear tyre wear.
.


Rear tracking will.
Changing tyres - fredthefifth
>>Post from doctorchris above
>>Checking and adjusting tracking will make no difference to rear tyre wear.

That what I thought until I got my SAAB. Apparently the rear wheels have to be tracked too!

Regards.
FTF
Changing tyres - rtj70
I would have thought balancing is included in a price at a tyre fitter. Even the mobile vans have equipment to do this. I would also think they have to do this. It's part of what needs doing and cannot cost much - the wheel is already off.

I'd have thought the cheapest option is find a local tyre fitter who will fit the tyres at a reasonable rate and buy the tyres online.
Changing tyres - danensis
The place I use charged me £11 for doing the tracking, toe in castoring and many other things I'd never heard of. It took the guy nearly an hour to get it spot on - he had to take the wheel off each time to make the adjustment - and he was very apologetic that if it went into another hour it would cost another £11.
Changing tyres - cilvilservant
It isn't the cost of the tracking that is prohibitive per se. The available fitters that do tracking seems to command a higher price for the tyres, whereas the local fitters who charge less for the tyres do not have the requisite systems for tracking.

As I'm expecting to pay £130 ish per tyre - I'm having to shop around hard! Buying tyres online is all well and good but I find the local fitters can be bartered down to cheaper than online prices.

Will ask about the tyre when I do go. Funnily enough, it's on the side where the spaniel resides in the boot. Maybe the dog needs to lose some weight although he's only 17kilo!

Thank you all for your helpful replies.
Changing tyres - able1

Without wishing to state the obvious, and assuming I understand, buy the tyres at the cheapest place for tyres and then have the tracking done at the cheapest place for tracking.

If I was looking at £130ish per corner and buying all four I would be looking at achieving
£400 max, and probably less.
Identify the tyre you want and phone around at least a dozen suppliers and ask for their best price.
Changing tyres - quizman
I wouldn't have the tracking done if the front tyres are wearing evenly. I would definitely have them balanced and new valves, you can usually get this free if you ask when getting your quote.

I have found that firms do not like fitting tyres when bought from somewhere else, even if it tells you to go there on the website.

I have found that you can get tyres cheaper at local independents than on the web. So ring a few, I know plenty in Derby who do good deals.

Before you ask, a friend has had Pirelli P7s on his last 2 V50s. He has been very pleased with them, they seem to go well with the Volvo. I've got them on my Passat, they are good in the wet or dry.
Changing tyres - Number_Cruncher
To confirm the advice you've been given;

If the tyres you're replacing have lasted well, you have no reason to suspect any suspension geometry problems, so, don't pay to have tracking or wheel alignment done - you don't need it.

Even if it were required, a tyre fitters is not the place I would choose to have wheel alignment checked and adjusted.

Definitely have the tyres balanced, and, definitely have new valves fitted.

Changing tyres - bathtub tom
Make sure you get them balanced properly.

I've just had a couple of new front tyres fitted to 6J ally rims. I noticed they removed the adhesive weights from the inside of the wheels and just used 'knock-on' weights on the inside of the rim.

A hundred mile round trip proved it wasn't right, with the steering wheel shimmying from 60MPH up.

I took it back and they immediately removed the weights and re-balanced them with a combination of stick-on and clip-on weights. One wheel has got about a 20cm (8") strip inside it! These are Avon ZV5s, not a cheap tyre.

The fitter hovered around as if (futilely) expecting a tip. If they'd done it right in the first place it wouldn't have wasted our mutual time and my petrol.
Changing tyres - MikeTorque
What characteristics of tyre are you looking for to fit the 17" wheels ?
Which brand & type of tyre do you currently have fitted ?
Changing tyres - cilvilservant
Hello again

I currently have Pirelli P7s - very impressed with them except the noise gets quite bad as the tyres wear. I'm thinking possibly Continental Sport Contact 3 or even the Pirelli P7s again if I can get a better deal. I would love to get the top spec Michilens but at approx £160 per tyre this is too expensive.

I too have experienced incorrectly balanced tyres and I noticed these immediately so I have on ocassions returned within 15-30 minutes to the fitters to get them rebalanced.

Cheers boys.
Changing tyres - MikeTorque
It's worth having a look at the tyre reviews via the link below.

tinyurl.com/n6kcxx
Changing tyres - 659FBE
If you have a tyre on a balanced and true rim which requires an 8" strip of lead, the tyre is not accurately made. I would reject this out of hand.

I have never found Avon tyres to be good in any respect other than (possibly) price. If you do a "car park" test on tyres (see how much lead there is fitted to them, averaged over a number of vehicles) the differences are appreciable.

Continental and Michelin tyres generally require the least additional weight - I'll leave you to find the bad ones. These named makers get my tyre money.

659.
Changing tyres - Dynamic Dave
It's coming up to changing all four 17 "tyres on my V50 and obviously I'm keen to find a bargain


What is the rest of the size? Is it 215/50/17? If so, see if there is anything in the handbook suggesting that you can also use 225/45/17. There is in my Vectra-C handbook, and as the 225/45/17 is a more common size it's cheaper than the 215/50/17.
Changing tyres - MikeTorque
Also what is the required load index for each tyre ? This depends on the axle weight (e.g. 91V for example).
Changing tyres - bell boy
who would have a new tyre fitted without a new valve being fitted and having the wheel and tyre balanced up?
really? show your hand
Changing tyres - Martin Devon
AND make sure you have the correct tyre for the car's speed. Under rated (speed) tyres will invalidate your insurance. Sometimes it's a cost temptation, but NOT one to be taken.

Regards.............MD
Changing tyres - gordonbennet
AND make sure you have the correct tyre for the car's speed. Under rated (speed)
tyres will invalidate your insurance.


Some don't seem to get this though MD, i had quite a discussion with a chap on another forum who was convinced that a car specified with V speed rated tyres could be retrofitted with S or T rated as he never went above 70mph.

Amazing what things some will (falsely) economise on.
Changing tyres - Martin Devon
Amazing what things some will (falsely) economise on.

Amazing how soft in the head some folk are though.

MD
Changing tyres - Brian Tryzers
>...the noise gets quite bad as the tyres wear...

I suspect this is true of most tyres, even all. As the tread blocks wear down, more rubber makes contact with the road, producing more noise.

I wonder how much of the stuff people post here along the lines of "These new Yellow Brand tyres are fantastic, so much better than the Purple Brand tyres I had before" comes from the simple fact that new tyres generally work better than old ones.

Let me cite an example from my own experience - and be warned, it concerns the reviled Pirelli P6000. Back in 2002 my Volvo S60 came new on four P6000s and was fine. It subsequently had a couple of Michelins but eventually went back to P6000s. As the last set of P6000s wore down, I noticed a horrible squirming or tramlining effect on rutted or broken tarmac. The worn front tyres went, two new Primacy HPs went on the back and the other pair of P6000s, still with about 6mm of tread, moved to the front. The squirming still happened but seemed much reduced. I wondered then if the 'superior' Michelin tyres were helping from the back, and they may have been, but I suspect the bigger effect came from the fresher Pirelli rubber on the front.
As a footnote, the car is now on four Primacy HPs, and the front pair will need replacing soon. (They've lasted about 22,000 miles since moving from back to front, which is more than the Pirellis ever did.) I've driven the bit of road again recently that induced the worst squirming (the A40 near Uxbridge, just before it becomes the M40, for those who know it) and it happened again, although less unpleasantly than before.

Tentative conclusion: The Primacy HP is a better tyre than the P6000, and is what I'll buy again in spite of the higher price. But a new P6000 is probably better than a well-worn Primacy HP.
Changing tyres - quizman
The P7s are so much better than the P6000s you wonder why Pirelli still make them.

I also understand that if you put on a lower speed rating tyre your insurance is void.

When tyres are so crucial to your own and others safety, I cannot understand why people cut corners. All this shall I buy some cheapo ditchfinder/second hand rubbish makes me wonder.
Changing tyres - ifithelps
...I cannot understand why people cut corners....

quizman,

Money.

At the garage, we used to call them 'marginal motorists'.

By any sensible measure, they cannot afford to own and run a car, but insist on doing so.

The weekend breakdown customers were the worst.

Anything we'd offer was wrong because 'our kid works at the Leyland and he can get the parts cheaper than that'.

The way some went on, you'd think they were arguing from a position of strength, not a position of stranded on a Sunday morning.

Changing tyres - captain chaos
I also understand that if you put on a lower speed rating tyre your insurance
is void.

>>

I think you'd be hard pressed to find a tyre shop that would fit a lower speed rated tyre anyway
Changing tyres - gordonbennet
I think you'd be hard pressed to find a tyre shop that would fit a
lower speed rated tyre anyway


Quite so CC, however some still manage to do so.

The thing that really gets me is that certain groups of car users spend many hundreds and sometimes thousands of pounds on 4 ugly as sin chromed wheels and then £40 a corner elastic band ditchfinders on them...bizarre.
Changing tyres - captain chaos
Bizarre indeed, GB. At the monthly American and custom car meet there was a Chrysler 300 Hemi, left hand drive American import loaded with every conceivable option. Bling aftermarket 22 inch rims which must have cost a couple of grand apiece, shod with WanLi rubber. Amazing. Must have been a special wheel and tyre "deal."
Changing tyres - FotheringtonThomas
Some don't seem to get this though MD i had quite a discussion with a
chap on another forum who was convinced that a car specified with V speed rated
tyres could be retrofitted with S or T rated as he never went above 70mph.


So. Please explain why this shouldn't be done. "V" is for maximum continuous speed of 150MPH. "S" is maximum 112. As far as I know, all else being equal, this would be quite safe, and not illegal.
Changing tyres - gordonbennet
As far as I know all else being equal this
would be quite safe and not illegal.

>>

Have a read of these, both construction and use regs breach and insurance refusal are likely outcomes, though not apparently technically illegal i wouldn't want to put it to the test for the price of the difference.

tinyurl.com/lc6bvc
tinyurl.com/lfptle
tinyurl.com/la5t6m
Changing tyres - FotheringtonThomas
Unfortunately, those don't tell me anything beyond what I already know about speed ratings (and the third, in fact, contains an inaccuracy). I would like to know why, rather than "Oh, that's the way it is".
Changing tyres - fredthefifth

Main tyre replacement issue for me is punctures.

Dunno why but I get more than my fair share and have had to replace perfectly good tyres at least twice in recent years. Came close a week ago when I had my second puncture in a month on estimated third worn 235x45x17 97W Conti's. The second was a near thing but both were reparable.

I would not wish to comprise on safety, but when I replace the Conti's I am not going to be putting £150 premium tyres on when I can get mid range Avon ZV5 for £100. Their might not last so long but performance is good enough and the consequence of puncture that requires tyre replacement not so severe!

BTW these are genuine puntures not tyre damage by hitting kerbs etc.

Regards.
FTF




Changing tyres - cilvilservant
My hanbook says fit only 205/50 R17 93W and I assure you all - I will only fit these - no cutting corners from me.

The P7s have been fantastic both in wet and dry - and in fact, I may stick with them as I know they can be trusted. I would love the Michilens and would get more miles with them, but I simply cannot afford 170 per tyre x 4 at the moment!

I think I have also worked out why one of the rear tyre has worned quicker than the other side. We had a puncture on the tyre last year that was worn. It was spotted pretty much immediately and was not driven much with a deflating tyre. I also check the tyres' pressure at the very least, every fortnight.

So my logical conclusion is that the puncture and subsequent repair, has affected the tyre causing it to wear quicker. I'm sure some will disagree but I have the evidence! There is nothing else I can think of unless it was a faulty tyre in the first place!

Now, I need to count my pennies in my jar to see if I have £520+ in pennies!
Changing tyres - bathtub tom
Are you certain the punctured tyre isn't sitting in the spare wheel well and the previously unused spare is on the road?
Changing tyres - Kevin
quizman said:

>The P7s are so much better than the P6000s you wonder why Pirelli still make them.

I think P6000s are still the only recommended tyre for some cars.

My XJ is on P6000Js and every tyre place I've asked has recommended that I stick with them. My only complaint is that they are a bit noisy on some road surfaces.


fredthefifth said:

>I am not going to be putting £150 premium tyres on when I can get mid range Avon ZV5 for £100.

That might be false economy.

www.honestjohn.co.uk/forum/post/index.htm?v=e&t=74...6

Kevin...
Changing tyres - captain chaos
>> tyres could be retrofitted with S or T rated as he never went above
70mph.
So. Please explain why this shouldn't be done. "V" is for maximum continuous speed of
150MPH. "S" is maximum 112. As far as I know all else being equal this
would be quite safe and not illegal.


The speed rating may be for a maximum continuous speed of 150 mph. Even if you never go over 70mph, if the vehicle is fitted with those tyres as standard equipment, it's for a reason. S rated tyres won't stand up well to a vehicle with 400 bhp at the wheels if you use it to its full potential acceleration wise?
Changing tyres - Graham567
I would recommend Blackcircles.com for your tyres and buy them with the fitting inc.I bought some recently and it came to £95 delivered or £97 fully fitted and balanced.I bought the Toyo Proxies and can recommend them highly as do many other drivers do.
Changing tyres - motorprop
if you buy off the Internet , where do your tyres get delivered to ? Your home to arrive when you are out or block up your entrance , not to mention the smell , or to a tyre shop who may swap them for inferior / older stock before you arrive , or claim they arrived damaged ??


You'd be surprised how much room 4 tyres take - more than an average car boot...
Changing tyres - MikeTorque
Internet ordered tyres can be purchased for delivery to home, direct to a tyre fitter/gararge or mobile fitter, depends on who is selling them.

cilvilservant, Goodyear Excellence tyres 205/50/17 93W are available for £112.05 (free mobile fitting) at tinyurl.com/ko69w2 , other quality tyres are available for your required specification.
Changing tyres - Dynamic Dave
You'd be surprised how much room 4 tyres take - more than an average car boot...


In which case put the two that won't fit in the boot on the back seat (remembering to cover it with something first). Or if your rear seats fold down, then all four should then fit in the boot.