Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - davidh
Economy special. Popped in to my head on a another thread. Its not a word we hear these days as its probably not a great way of selling cars in todays image concious society.

Can anyone think of any?

My starters for 10 is

1.3 Montego.
1.4 Cavalier
1.4 405

Edited by Dynamic Dave on 19/09/2008 at 01:16

Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - De Smythe
This is more like an exercise in losing the will to live. I can only speak from experience of the Cav (as a pool car) and it was shockingly underpowered with an engine that has no place in a car that size. It was also in flat beige, thus tormenting the unfortunate driver with its' terminal dullness even further. It offered no better fuel consumption that 1.6 engine because it had to be driven so hard to gain any form of momentum. Not to be confused in any way with other Cavs, of which I am a huge admirier incidentally.

If any of these poverty variants still exist outside of a scrap yard then I fail to see an attraction for even the most miserable, penny pinching (or genuinely cash-strapped) individual.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Group B
BMW 525e

Like a 525i but less power and everything configured for economy? My Dad was given one as a company car for 3 weeks in about 1987 (an auto). Performance was underwhelming IIRC.

Edited by Rich 9-3 on 18/09/2008 at 14:42

Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - DP
I seem to recall the 525e used a longer stroke engine too, which was optimised for torque at low to medium revs. What Car ran one as a long termer and loved it.

Ford did the E-Max version of the Sierra 1.6 in the mid 80's which was their first attempt at a lean burn engine. No performance penalty over the standard engine, but they claimed 10% better economy.

Cheers
DP


Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Group B
I seem to recall the 525e used a longer stroke engine too which was optimised
for torque at low to medium revs.


Yes I checked on Carfolio.com. Engine capacity was 2.7 litres with 123bhp but 177lbft peak torque.
I got it into my head that they were only available as an auto with shift pattern optimised for economy, but Carfolio says they did a manual too.

I think I only passengered in it 2-3 times before it left us; I remember it made a good noise, but Dad was not used to autos and was happy to get a 2-litre Cavalier afterwards.

Edited by Rich 9-3 on 19/09/2008 at 12:42

Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - GroovyMucker
I think I only passengered in it 2-3 times


Who was drivering it at the time?

[/grumpy old man]
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Jase
Think there was a Sierra 1.3 originally in 1982. can't imagine that was much fun.

The economy model I most remember fom Austin was the Maestro 1.3HLE, complete with econometer in the dashboard (horizontal strip of green and red leds).

BMW 518 from the 1980s when there was a tax bracket for 1.8s was quite slow I would think.

Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Armitage Shanks {p}
The 1.3 Montego was using the same engine as the Mini - think about it! My recollection is that most of the small engined options were less economical that the larger engines. Think Escort, Montego and I am sure there must be others - Pandas, Puntos and the like, even today.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - skorpio
My dad had a Y reg Mark 1 Fiesta which had two lights on the instrument binnacle. From memory one was yellow, the other red. Yellow would light when it was time to change up a gear and red would light letting you know you were driving like a div and need to slow down in order to maximise economy. It was grossly underpowered for a family of four and a labrador! Eventually dad covered the lights with electrical tape as he got sick of them winking on and off. A real gimmick.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - kithmo
Cortina Mk3 1.3 OHV
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Nickdm
Who remembers Ford's "Popular" and "Popular Plus" model specs on Escorts and Fiestas in the 70s and early 80s?! Nasty!
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Alan
Capri 1.3
Magane Scenic, single piont injection 73bhp
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - TheOilBurner
Who remembers Ford's "Popular" and "Popular Plus" model specs on Escorts and Fiestas in the
70s and early 80s?! Nasty!


I had an '87 Fiesta Popular 950cc. I was lucky enough to have a heated rear screen as an optional extra!!

No head restraints, centre console, radio, nearside mirror, parcel shelf, clock, glovebox, trip counter, rear wiper, intermittent wiper controls, etc..

It was the kind of car where you were grateful it even had an interior light, although it was only switched from the driver's door!! I'm not even sure whether there was a passenger sun visor or not. I'm pretty sure it also had less air vents than the normal spec Fiestas too!

Fun to drive at low speeds though, which was all it could reasonably do. Uphill on the motorway it couldn't maintain 70mph even with one person in it...
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Baskerville
While these engines were no doubt too small even then, they seem even more pathetic now because equivalent cars these days weigh twice as much and make electrical demands equivalent to a small town at Christmas.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - b308
Think the Metro had an E version as well - higher 4th gear to normal.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - MondeoMonkeyMagic
I think from memory VW did a Golf Formel E model which had a 4 plus E gear - none of this blue motion nonsence!
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - mike hannon
Economy specials are still sold today, aren't they? The same sort of under-powered stuff but now aimed at attracting a lower rate of VED.
Maybe in a few years, when the current financial and ecological scaremongering is over, they will be seen in the same light as some of those mentioned above.
BTW, lots of VW Passats had economy displays, IIRC, as did the Lancia Prisma (the quite nice booted version of the Delta). I guess most of both versions ended up covered in insulating tape but, come to think of it, they weren't much different from the super computers some people's lives are ruled by these days, that tell you to the last yard what you have left in the tank - as long as you don't touch the throttle or go up or down any hills.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - JohnPug
Peugeot 309 1.1 55bhp and 0-60 in 17.3s
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - cheddar
I remember the Escort MkII Popular being £499 in around 1977 when a Granada MkI coupe 3ltr was £1300.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Alan
A friend had an escort 1.1 popular which had a very high top gear. He said that going into a gale force wind it struggled to get over 70 and then coming back the other way with a tail wind it would do about 95. The aerodynamics in those days were pretty carp.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Marc
"I had an '87 Fiesta Popular 950cc. I was lucky enough to have a heated rear screen as an optional extra!! No head restraints, centre console, radio, nearside mirror, parcel shelf, clock, glovebox, trip counter, rear wiper, intermittent wiper controls, etc.."

I had an 83A 950 Pop Plus (first of the MkIIs) and on this you got all of your above list except the radio and centre console - which was optional. Still no synchromesh on 1st though.

I remember my 86C Volvo 340GL 1.4 OHV had a picture of a gear lever on the dash and a bulb used to light up when it was time to change up. Bit of a joke really as the car was never economical due to being underpowered.

I remember test driving a J or K plate Sierra 1.6 EFi "Azure". Nice car but dog slow, didn't seem to do anything when you put your foot down.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - uk_in_usa
Can anyone think of any?


They did a 2 door 1.3 Sierra originally. I can't imagine what it must have been like because the 1.6 was unbelievably slow and gutless. It didn't last long. They used the same 2 door bodies for the early Sierra Cosworths.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Alby Back
Betcha there is one kicking around with all the Cossie kit and the 1.3 lump though. Bless.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - scrapmetal
In about 1997 when rover stopped making the 100, they brought out a rover 211, a rover 200 with a 1.1 8valve engine as a 'replacement'.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Pugugly
Any Jags with less than 12 cylinders.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Alby Back
Cough........Sko.....Cough....das.....

;-0

Edit - old ones that is........

Edited by Humph Backbridge on 18/09/2008 at 19:11

Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - SpamCan61 {P}
Cough........Sko.....Cough....das.....
;-0
Edit - old ones that is........


Oi! SWMBO's D plate Estelle 120 LSE was way better equipped than the rotbox B plate metro 1.0L it replaced, 5 speed box for starters ;-)

I recall Vauxhall sold some Viva HCs and Firenzas in the mid 70s with a seriously poverty spec, 'orrible 1256 engine and all; it was the 'ES' I think. A mate managed to buy a 'special' edition Astra Mk2 in '86 with no clock, which was pretty unusual by then.

In terms of poverty engines another mate had a 2 door X plate cavalier mk2 in snot green, 1300cc, hardly nippy but would regularly do a ton with 5 of us in it, impressive if a little scary.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - oilrag
1985 1.05 litre Polo C - 40 BHP (I think) very steady progress as I remember ...

But luxury compared with the Fiesta Popular Plus I had before it. This was one up from the base Popular, but still with a bare metal handbrake lever. I was using that in 1984 when the surf froze on the beach in Swansea bay.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - ifithelps
Someone mentioned 1.3 ohv Cortinas.

I beg to differ, brilliant heating/ventilation, carpets, radio, think one of ours even had a clock.

Top speed 85mph, which it would do easily, and cruise all day at 70mph - not bad for the late 1960s.

Reliable, too. Has to be one of the first cars which enabled someone of average means to confidently take on a 100/200 mile journey.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Lud
Economy cars these days can do 60mpg plus in the real world. Twenty or so years ago they could do better than 50mpg. I can vouch personally for the Peugeot 205 diesel because I had one (1985 or early 86), a very good car indeed although let down by flimsiness and in that example a faulty rear brake from new. The other example that springs to mind is the Renault 5 GTL, which although petrol was cunning and French, and like the Peugeot had the winning combination of a big engine for its size and high gearing.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Miller
A diesel model of the Skoda Octavia was available with a non turbo 68 bhp engine.....quite a popular taxi up here in the north east, despite a 0-60 of just under 20 secs!
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - DP
We had a 1.6 naturally aspirated diesel mk2 Golf a few years back, which made a whopping 54 bhp. I have no idea of the acceleration figures, but to say it was pedestrian would be an understatement. It would do about 90 mph flat out, but had had enough 10 mph before that.

It was staggeringly economical though. Even thrashed mercilessly and in stop/start local running, it would do 55 mpg, with 74 mpg being the best we achieved on a run. We had this car through the fuel protests, and having just filled it up when the blockades started, had no worries at all as the queues formed at the petrol stations.

We used to fill the thing up once a month!

A few years later we had a Polo 1.9D which was rubbish in comparison, despite being barely any quicker.

Cheers
DP
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Group B
We had a 1.6 naturally aspirated diesel mk2 Golf a few years back which made
a whopping 54 bhp.


A friend of mine had a Mk1 Golf diesel; I think it was the same 1.6 NA engine. It had alloys on it and looked alright, almost resembled a GTi, but was dog slow..
ISTR him complaining about heavy unassisted steering; and there was epic vibration of the dashboard at low revs.

Back in the early 90s it was a source of amusement to the rest of us in our late teens, when we associated diesel with black cabs, buses and nothing else.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - AlastairW
I had a 1986 Polo C. It had all of 45 bhp, though felt slower than the Panda 1000Fire that preceded it. I used to change up at the little dots on the speedo (2 dots, change up to 3rd, 3 change to 4th) to make reasonable progress for quite a heavy little car.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Dyane 6 Mehari
Any 1.1 Citroen AX - used fuel so slowly you became convinced the fuel gauge was faulty.

I had a 957cc Fiesta too - A-reg Popular Plus, last of the Mk 1's. The windscreen washers were operated by a foot pump - it must have cost Ford more to de-spec to a foot pump than an electric one would cost. It did have a radio, rear wiper, heated rear window and a radio.

Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - steveo3002
they did a mk2 polo with stop/start equipment, it stoped the engine somehow at traffic lights etc and restarted when you put it in gear

also had a dash light for gear changes and a 4 plus E gearbox
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Pugugly
Oh the ultimate - the Honda Civic IMA we have in work, a gutless hybrid, with that nonsense auto-stop thing (as mentioned by Stevo) cheap to tax but wouldn't take the skin off a rice pudding.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Dave_TD
A diesel model of the Skoda Octavia was available with a non turbo 68 bhp engine.....quite a popular taxi up here in the north east, despite a 0-60 of just under 20 secs!


19.6 seconds to be exact, top speed of +-98mph too. I did 267k miles in mine though, averaged 44mpg around town and 52mpg on a run, not bad for a proper 5-seat estate car!

Edited by Webmaster on 21/09/2008 at 13:32

Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - runboy
Probably related to the Octavia post above - the SDI diesel engine seen in Golfs. No turbo so a 0-60 in about 19 secs I think.

With the advent of VW using turbo/superchargers in their range, how about the 1.4l engine in the new Skoda Superb (big beast of a car, small cc engine but hyped up with a turbo charger).
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Alanovich
Fiat Regata 70 ES (Energy Saving), 1983.

It had some modifications to the aerodynamics, e.g wind deflectors around the windows and a small boot spoiler, it was a 1300 cc with 65 bhp, and it had an engine shut-off system when idling.

Fiat, as usual, years ahead of the competiton.

Cue the Fiat knockers!

I had a standard Regata 70 (1.3) in about 1989/90, teriffic car with plenty of oomph for the engine size, very roomy and very cheap to run (I was a student then). Not to mention reliable - even when the cambelt bust through my neglect to change it, it was fixed for very little money as it hadn't caused any lasting damage. I actually miss that car still - I did two runs to Gibraltar and back in it from Nottingham. Happy days.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - stackman
My neighbour at the end of the seventies had a Capri 1.3. All the show but no go was how she would describe it.

I had a Morris Ital Estate 1.3 which had the 1275 A series engine and a four speed box. It could carry a lot of stuff just not very quickly or especially economically. If you needed to work on it you could almost stand in the engine bay with it as there was so much room around the engine.

It was fun to drive on only one occasion and that was when it snowed.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Brian Tryzers
Apparently Volvo is preparing special versions (to be called DRIVe - really!) of the C30, S40 and V50. They'll have the 1.6D engine but with higher gearing and aerodynamic modifications to reduce fuel consumption.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - The Gingerous One
Rover SD1 2000.

The 2L version had the 2L engine from the Ital in it, horrifically slow and fantastically de-specced as well, no alloys, hardly any electrical toys etc. etc.

My dad had one as a company car in the late 80s and it was pov-striken.

I bet theres almost no 2L ones left now, they would have all been mercilessly thrashed into the ground to get anywhere.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - b308
I'd have thought that the economy version of the SD1 was the 2.3D? I think that we have perhaps to differentiate between the "economy" versions for mpg and the "economy" versions for price (such as said 1.3 crapy and the Pop versions of the escort/fiesta).
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Bagpuss
Ford did a version of the Mk1 Ford Escort for some markets which had a 950cc 34bhp engine.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - stackman
Land Rover offered the Discovery for a while with the 2.0l 16V petrol engine from the Rover 800.

Aparently it offered the performance of the diesel with the economy of the V8 so was quickly dropped.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - mikeyb
I had a Polo Formel E as my first car. It had a guage to indicate MPG, but I think that it was much use. Also had a nice little light to tell you when it was best to change gear. Best feature was the high ratio gearbox - could do over 80 in third
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - Tornadorot
I'd have thought that the economy version of the SD1 was the 2.3D?


Do you mean the 2400SD (diesel)? The 2300 was petrol.
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - b308
Sorry, slip of the finger...
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - injection doc
The gingerous one! yep that was a bargin special. I had a SDI 2000 & it was so basic. I have to say that it appeared to perform better than the 2.3 which was a slug. The 2.4 with the Italian VM engine was an odd ball. the 2.6 was niether one thing or the other.The 3.5 vitesse was the right power plant for the car
Economy Specials - Can you think of any? - The Gingerous One
I was actually going to mention the 2.4 TD as well, but then amended my post.

But, yes, feel free to include it!

cheers
Stu