Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - niceguyeddy
Who has had the fastest depreciating car or made the best gain come trade in time?
Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - pendulum
I was given my first car as a hand-me-down when my mum got a better one. After a year I sold it for £800 making £800 profit. Does that count? :o)
Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - niceguyeddy
Yes most definately .... all is fair in love and war etc etc .... just dont tell your mum though
Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - Billy Whizz
The last three cars I sold (1986 Range Rover, 1995 Jeep Grand Cherokee, 1996 Renault Clio) I sold for more than I paid for them and I had each one 3.5 years.

:-)

But...and it is quite a big "but"...all were bought tax-free second-hand in the Middle East plus:
[1] Range Rover was a worn out 16 year-old car that I spent money on rebuilding engine, gearbox, suspension and fitting rally equipment myself. (Used it to win the national 4x4 championship - priceless.)
[2] Jeep had a knackered auto box plus another very odd (but, in the end, easily fixed) problem with the centre diff.
[3] Clio was a delight - basic servicing, new battery, front pads and 4 tyres. Perfect. Sold it to a guy from the Polish embassy.

Still, not a bad result.
Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - Optimist
Doesn't niceguyeddy make his living out of buying and selling motors? In which case the answer would probably be: greatest depreciation on sale, not him; biggest profit on sale, him. :)
Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - madf
I bought my first car for £30 and sold it for a 150% profit .. ie, £75.

It's been downhill ever since :-(
Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - Steve Pearce
I bought an '98 Laguna Estate for around 18K, a year later I was offered 9.5K as a trade-in, I declined.
Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - whoopwhoop
Biggest LOSS, VW New Beetle bought for wife. 9 months later started a family and traded for a new CR-V (which turned out to be a terribly unreliable car, but thats another story). Lost £5k on the beetle in 6,000 miles.

Biggest GAIN, many years ago I bought a 6 year old Nova 1.4 Flair for £800. Had 135,000 miles on the clock. Someone wrote it off and the insurance valued it at c.£2,000 as they assumed it had 35,000 on the clock! (the odometer only had 5 digits!).

Best PART EXCHANGE was a 3 year old c-max with 3 owners, 23,000 miles, and which which needed : a £180 service. a £45 MOT. £120 worth of tyres. £160 worth of Tax. And had run out of warranty. Paid £3k to p/x for a brand spanking new Focus Sport. By the time you deduct what needed spending on the c-max it cost me (in real terms) less than £2k to change from old to new :-)
Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - nick
Worst, current Legacy 3.0R Spec B. Bought pre-reg but unused for £19k in July 2006, now probably worth £13k-ish after 25k miles.
Best, Daimler SP250, bought for £3750 back in the '80's, sold 18 months or two years later for £10k thanks to the classic car price boom. Blew it all on something else though. I rarely lose much if anything on classics if they're looked after.
Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - bathtub tom
I bought a Ford Pop 100E for a fiver with no brakes. I spent a bit on new wheel cylinder seals (ah, remember those days?) and boiled up the rear brake shoes. It passed its MOT, and the next, then its ends started rattling, and a section of box section complete with rear spring hanger popped through the boot floor.
I flogged it for two pound ten shillings.
Fifty per cent loss?
Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - Steptoe
I only paid £50 for my P4 Rover in 1973 but haven't yet made anything on it as I've still got it ;-)
Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - legacylad
Defender 90. Bought Feb 07 for £3350, spent £50 on CD player, sold August 07 for £5000. Only other costs were fuel and insurance. Profit paid for August & Sept in sunny California, AND the month of Feb 08 skiing in California.

Worst was an H reg Saab 9000 2.3 Turbo top o't range. Bought as ex lease at 3 years old for £10k. Sold 4 years later for only £6500....but the fuel costs, even in those days, didn't bear thinking about.
Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - Alby Back
Circa 1977. Bought a Triumph Spitfire for £250. Ran it for a year. Sold it for £350. Been trying to repeat the exercise in percentage or even actual terms ever since. To no avail :-(

One day I'm going to add up or at least guesstimate what being a "motorist" has cost me so far. Or maybe I won't. Suspect it could trigger deep depression! Better to take the view that most of it was money well spent on something I have had much pleasure from.
Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - Billy Whizz
>Triumph Spitfire
It wasn't yellow, was it?
Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - DavidHM
Best: Peugeot 406 2.0 HDi - bought for £1,650 and sold on for £1,650 after six months and 12k miles. Zero depreciation but a fair bit on servicing.

In reverse order then

98 BMW 523i - bought for £2,000 - sold for £1,260 after 8k in 10 months. 9.25ppm.

96 406 1.9 TD - bought for £1,800 - sold for £1,200 after 30k in 18 months. 2ppm.

89 Renault R19 - bought for £475 - sold for £345 after 14k in 14 months. 1ppm.

94 Peugeot 306 DT sedan - bought for £495 - sold for £450 after 9k in 10 months. 0.5ppm.

All, with the possible exception of the BMW, were in better condition when sold on and had a fair bit spent on maintenance - and the BMW was cosmetically nicer but had too many minor faults ever to be fixed at any realistic price (i.e., less than twice the cost to change into a mint example).

Current Clio I estimate to be about 9.4ppm over the life of the four year finance deal but hopefully little or nothing in unscheduled maintenance or cosmetic improvement.

Edited by DavidHM on 15/04/2008 at 00:41

Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - krs one
I bought a Morris 1000 for £150 and sold it on for £500 , not bad profit percentage wise.
My dad did well though, some years ago he bought a Plymouth Barracuda for £700, sold the number plate off it for £2000 , used some of this money to pay for a respray then sold it on for £3500.
Of course we have both lost fortunes on every other car deal ever done.
Losing a couple of grand over a year on a Fiat Bravo is the worst I remember, if you don't count writing off a car that was only insured 3rd party.
Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - Alby Back
No, it was navy blue. Bought and sold in Edinburgh.
Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - Billy Whizz
>spitfire
I bought my first car (a yellow Spitfire) for £350 at the tender age of 18. It was the first car I looked at and I paid full asking price! Unsurprisingly, it was a nail and failed the MOT terminally 4 months later. However, over the next couple of years, in my uni holidays, I stripped all the good bits off and sold off the very rotten body tub for £25. Then I bought an abandoned restoration project (red body) for £90 which had all the bits I wanted. I cobbled it all together, sprayed up the remaining yellow bits with tins of red paint from Halfords, brush painted the inside and the underneath with Hammerite and set off with a fresh MOT for a month camping round Europe with my girlfriend.

The smile has still not faded and I still have the car 20 years later!
Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - movilogo
Knowledge I gathered from this thread

Lowest loss/gain - buy oldest cars as possible
Worst loss - buy as new-ish cars as possible

In the limiting case, buying a brand new car means best guaranteed loss.

:)



Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - nick
You've hit the nail on the head!
Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - DP
I've had two good ones, both with bangers and both in the early days of my driving career.

Acquired a running, but badly misfiring Rover 216 EFi VDP for "what the scrapman offered" -£25
Towed it home.
Cleaned up the throttle pot which cured the misfire.
Fixed the blowing exhaust with a beer can and two clamps.
Sanded and filled the rust spots on the bottom of both front doors and resprayed them from the rubbing strip down (looked quite good actually)
Got a new window motor and regulator from a scrappie for £30 to fix the non functioning drivers side window.
Spent hours cleaning and treating the leather (came up A1) and detailing the car.
Put her in for MOT and she sailed it.
Thought about keeping it, but decided it just wasn't me.
Sold in Autotrader in 2 days to the first guy that came to see it for £800.

The other was when one of my sisters friends' dad had an old Sierra that had just failed its MOT on terminal rot, plus the engine was knocking badly. It had just had four new Goodyears put on it, plus a load of other new parts, so I asked him how much for the bits I wanted, as I was running an identical one at the time. He said, take the whole car for the £30 he was being offered by the scrappie.
Deal done, I had the wheels and tyres, and several hundred quids worth of other spares out of it (half filled an 8'x10' shed) Stripped off all the engine ancillaries, switchgear, light clusters, trim, mirrors etc. Even took the 2 gallons of fuel that were in the tank.
Neighbour approaches and asks what's the gearbox like? "Fine" I say. "Will you take £150 for it?" "If you take it out, no problem." We shake on it. Next day he turns up with a couple of mates, hands over £150 in notes and they set to work.
This done, I call the local breakers. One happens to be doing a couple of collections in the area at the time, and after a little negotiation they swing by 20 minutes later, and hoist what's left onto the back of the truck, and off it goes. Four new tyres, enough spares to keep mine going for years, 2 gallons of petrol and £120 in cash profit.
I was smiling for weeks.

Cheers
DP


Edited by DP on 15/04/2008 at 14:17

Whats your biggest loss or gain on a car - mjm
1965 Lotus Elan Series 2.

Bought for £550 in 1974.

Sold (dismantled) for £4300 in 1994. With new Lotus chassis and re-built engine.