Why are they so cheap ? - Surrey_Scientist
Was just looking on autotrader for a possible cheap replacement for my corolla, and noticed that MkII primeras seem ludicrously cheap - the 96-99 version.

There were quite a lot of very nice condition, not outrageous mileaged cars with high spec for £1000 - 1500.

Any idea why ?

I had one for a while when they were new and they were an excellent car - quick, reliable, handled well, spacious, very high spec, excellent quality.

Why are they valued so low by the 2nd hand market compared to avensis/accords ?

Is it there are problems with them now they are getting older, or just as usual in this country a snob badge thing ?t

SLT including filing into the drop down classifications

Edited by Pugugly {P} on 28/10/2007 at 19:33

primera MkII - why so cheap ? - DrS
They're fine motors.
Buy one.


Social death ensues.
primera MkII - why so cheap ? - Aprilia
Social death ensues.


Can you expand on that please? My social life has never depended on the type of car I drive..


To answer original question - yes its a badge snob thing. Very very good cars. Go for 2.0i with the SR20DE engine. Brilliant motor and certainly better than the Mondeo and Vectra of the same vintage. Knocking front top links was about the only stock fault - but that can be bought for £25 each and take only about 30mins to replace.
primera MkII - why so cheap ? - Waino
My son bought a 2000W reg 1.8S Primera a year ago for £2.4k - 51,000 miles on clock. I believe this is the mk3 - but it too is a very good car. I agree with the badge snob theory. I'm currently running the old Mondy into the ground but, if it died tomorrow, I'd be looking at Primeras!
primera MkII - why so cheap ? - Chris White
I've had a 2.0 Mk2 Primera (97 P) for the last 7 months and have been very happy. Mine's the SE (so leather/heated seats, air con etc).

The engine pulls very strongly and the car comes as standard with an insurance approved alarm and immobilser (according to my insurer).

The only complaint is that after 10 years the wood trim is starting to fall off.......

Chris
primera MkII - why so cheap ? - De Smythe
Had one of these for 4 years - a 2.0 SRi on R plate

PLUS POINTS:
Sublime chassis with roadholding and steering way above its' class, would run rings round competitors and those from the next bracket up; massive boot; decent ride; comfy seats; bullet proof chain cam engine; all very solidly built; leave it anywhere, no one will interfere with it

NOT SO PLUS POINTS
Hopelessly drab exterior looks like stylists sabotaged all the hard work of the engineers (main answer to your question really); abysmal steering lock causes misery at mini roundabouts, car parks etc; alloys corrode easily, ditto area around boot spoiler; suprisingly thirsty; air con saps power (try pulling away from low speed in second gear with air con swicthed on); easy to drive with front fogs on because warning light obscured by steering wheel; friends shouting "Gatwick North Terminal please" whenever they got in it

Would highly recommend as a good budget buy and no need to pay a penny over £2k for last of 99/T shape from private seller.
primera MkII - why so cheap ? - J Bonington Jagworth
"leave it anywhere, no one will interfere with it"

Funny, isn't it, that the badge snobs never stop to consider that their preference is for something that attracts such interference? Still, if one must have a status symbol...
primera MkII - why so cheap ? - smokescreen
Cant complain in some ways, so many good bargains to be had (including the primera) thanks to their effect on the market :-)
primera MkII - why so cheap ? - J Bonington Jagworth
"Can't complain"

I'm not! My Xedos cost £600...

It's a mad situation, but long may it continue. :-)

Edited by J Bonington Jagworth on 29/10/2007 at 13:35

primera MkII - why so cheap ? - bell boy
highly recommended by me
bulletproof if you buy a good one
why so cheap? because they are in the same market as mondeo"s and dave down the pub will always recommend mondeos and vectra"s cos these are what he sees everyday darn the pub carpark so they got to be better aint they? therefore primeras are cheap cos sensible people buy them and keep the good news to themselves
i recommend the se spec with the full leather,be aware these cars sit a bit low so you may not like them on first sitting

edit,sorry chris didnt see your post, ive been watching dave on the tv and tabulating very slowly

Edited by bell boy on 28/10/2007 at 22:57

primera MkII - why so cheap ? - Stuartli
From the first Primera of 1989 they were always excellent cars (I used to recommend them to friends and family and all were very happy), but never had the right image as some have already pointed out.

In fact it was the first Primera that provided the design impetus for the suspension used on the first 1993 Mondeo models; Ford engineers made no secret of the fact.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
What\'s for you won\'t pass you by
Why are they so cheap ? - mrmender
Both my Dad & myself had 1.6's very good cars a bit gutless in 1.6 form & not that economical for 1.6's, as has been said turning circle is very poor
Most reliable car i've ever owned
Why are they so cheap ? - J Bonington Jagworth
"a snob badge thing"

That's it. Applies to most Japanese cars above a certain size, apart from some Hondas and Lexuses (Lexi?) although I suspect you can get an old Legend* for buttons. Take advantage of Joe Public's timidity/prejudice/stupidity...

*Memorably described by one critic as an 'old people's home on wheels'!
Why are they so cheap ? - quizman

>>>a snob badge thing


The use of the word snob is getting rather overused on this site lately.

It would seem that if you don't drive a downmarket car, with used Chinese tyres, brakes bought from a car boot sale and running on supermarket fuel, you are considered a snob.

My wife was quite pretty when we got married, does this make me a snob? There's nothing wrong with an ugly woman, I can hear you saying. They can cook and clean just as well and the mantlepiece thing as well.

Just in case anyone thinks that I am a snob, well I have owned 1Mini, 2 Vauxhalls, 6 Fords, 1 Citroen and 2 VWs. All with brand tyres of course!
Why are they so cheap ? - quizman

I forgot to say, Primeras are cheap because they are very ugly, in fact horrible. Just in my opinion.
Why are they so cheap ? - J Bonington Jagworth
"the word snob"

Don't take it to heart - it's just shorthand for anyone who pays over the odds solely because of a badge. It's the state of mind rather than the choice of car...

BTW, I hope Mrs QM doesn't read this forum! :-)
Why are they so cheap ? - quizman

>>>BTW, I hope Mrs QM doesn't read this forum

Luckily she doesn't!
She is in what one might call "good condition for years and miles, with a full service history". However she was a sporting and good firm handler some years ago.
Why are they so cheap ? - Mike H
I've never owned one through choice - when I was looking for a compay car back in 1997 I had one for the weekend. It felt nippy enough but I couldn't have put up with the noise or the ride. Don't laugh but I went for the Mondeo instead - it felt much more civilised.
Why are they so cheap ? - v0n
The P11.144's (99-02) with late Almera lookalike front are cheap as chips - trade in values for SE and Sport (harder suspension, better seats) for 2002 examples are borderline joke - around £1500 mark, so there are bargains to be had at auctions and from private buyers.

Completely invisible to everyone, you can leave it unlocked virtually in any part of the country and noone will ever pinch it. As stated before, they suffer from complete lack of respect from anyone else on the road, turning circle of an 18 ton lorry and severe cost cuts in interior design department - passenger airbag in literally slapped on top of the dash, radio casette connected to low budget carton speakers is the top "hifi" offered in 2002 while sound insulation of the floorplan is practically non existant. All that is amplified by absymal quality control - plastric trim panels often have gaps larger that those of pension fund at Sunderland, loose window control panels rattle around very nighties looking door cards, uneven door sills whistle at speed and corroding alloys have a habit of welding themseleves permanently to hubs.

That said - late examples of rare "exec mad enough to buy Primera" - such as Sport+ or SE+ often feature full heated leather and Xenons and can be found from "trade" for as low £2500 and £3000. Choose clean and well kept car and it will serve you for years, with quite a few niggles, rattles and whistles perhaps, but relatively bulletproof under the bonet....
--------------------
[ Anything I drive can and will be used against me ]

Edited by v0n on 29/10/2007 at 17:05

Why are they so cheap ? - McP
"very nineties looking door cards"

As a Primera owner I find this very offensive.
They are more like 1980's jumpers.

After 4 years/70K with a 97 1.6, I bought a X reg 2.0 Sport a couple of months ago.
Great car in my opinion although the suspension is a little hard.

Very important that the oil is changed regularly to keep the chain healthy.
Why are they so cheap ? - jbif
Hello Quizman.
You say "My wife was quite pretty when we got married, "
And something happened after the honeymoon was over? ;-0

Why are they so cheap ? - Aprilia
v0n

Some entertaining prose, but just not true.
The Primera was taken as a benchmark by Ford and GM for their own new-car development programmes. Quality control was excellent, and far superior to anything Ford or GM could boast. The Sunderland-built Primeras were exported to the US and sold as the Infiniti G20, and won US JD Power survey. Around 97/98 CAR magazine did a back to back test of the Primera 2.0 against BMW 320 and declared the Primera a better drive. P11 had exceptionally stiff chassis.
Stereo components were supplied by Blaupunkt - yes there was no CD, but not many cars of this age had CD.
Don't understand where comments about 'corroding alloys' come from - yes, on a 8-10 year old car you may find some corrosion, but they were well above average for finish and way way better than Ford alloys.
Primeras tend to corrode around the back of the sill/rear arch junction, but again better in this respect than most of the competition.
But lets not spoil a good story...
Why are they so cheap ? - v0n
Aprilia - we are not talking about the same car - you are talking about P11, I'm talking about P11.144. What's more - there is one standing on my driveway, so I can take pictures to prove just how bad quality control at Sunderland was in 2002.
--------------------
[ Anything I drive can and will be used against me ]
Why are they so cheap ? - bell boy
i have a p11-144 on my drive von
it doesnt rattle
the doorcards are fine in my opinion
my alloys have no corrosion (suggest garage copperslip your hubs)
no whistles at any speed
the fit of trim and panels is first class,it really amazes me that this car was indeed built in britain

complaints with my 96/99 primera ? absolutely non(appart from the lousy turning circle)
complaints with my 99/02 primera? absolutely non (apart from the lousy turning circle and the radio is a bit poor unless the fm signal is strong)
Why are they so cheap ? - Martin Devon
Are they any good in auto form? Tell me yes and I'll tell 'e' why. Tell me no and I sharn't........No Porkies please lads.

VBR....MD
Why are they so cheap ? - bell boy
thought you newer i hadda tauto
velly good indeedy suu smooth
not the most economic tauto ive ever haddad though
Why are they so cheap ? - Martin Devon
SNIPQUOTE!
You been on the same plonk as me BB??


HaHa.........MD

Edited by Dynamic Dave on 30/10/2007 at 00:49

Why are they so cheap ? - bell boy
im dry this week afore i get banned ;-)
wifes got a bottle of some of nettos finest french reserve though
Why are they so cheap ? - Martin Devon
im dry this week afore i get banned ;-)


On a more sobering note. My offspring and her b/friend run a banger which can last not much longer methinks. They like what they like as we all did at that age and most of us still do. However they are a sensible pair and I have been left wondering by your posts whether one of these highly undesirable transportation machines may suit them next. I will suggest it and then run for cover. How would a decent one, say a 2.0 litre be viewed by the Ins' co's. He 26/7 I think. Clean everything. She, the offspring may wish to take up the wheel again after 'dropping out' of attempting to drive some 3 years ago. She 22 in Jan' 08.

TIA.......MD
Why are they so cheap ? - bell boy
MD i sold my old r reg primera to my son in law nearly a year ago ,he still loves it,they have just had a baby and theres loads of room in the back they tell me,the car has even paid for itself these last ten months as i took his old omega off him and crushed it to save the ozone .
The alloys on my car were mint,ok i dont know if they were originals but then again i hate high mileage abused cars ,so just choose wisely MD
Why are they so cheap ? - v0n
I bet yours is also whisper quiet inside at any speed and turns on a six pence.
Look. You are selling sugar back to sugar factory. I'm a Primera owner. 6 cars in a row were Nissans. I'm always ready to give credit where it's due. This isn't one of these cases - P11.144 was designed in UK and introduced in 1999 for new millennium. Over 600 main components and elements were redesigned. And yet interior is dated and drab, it's a budget driven modification of the old P11. Exterior was simply unattractive. Quality control of finish was patchy at best. It didn't sell anywhere near the numbers of P10. The model was pulled out after only 2.5 years.
--------------------
[ Anything I drive can and will be used against me ]
Why are they so cheap ? - bell boy
beauty is in the eye though von,i think this model is quite good looking and is one of the few saloon type cars that has yet to bite me back on a fast corner unawares,i did say the turning circle is abysmal but one remembers this and makes allowances surely?
Why are they so cheap ? - De Smythe
>> Don't understand where comments about 'corroding alloys' come from - yes on a 8-10 year
old car you may find some corrosion but they were well above average for finish
and way way better than Ford alloys.


My '97 Primera was just 3 years old when I bought it and all the alloys were bubbling between the spokes to some extent. Nissan dealer had two of them refurbed (on the cheap I imagine) but the corrosion returned after a year.

Similar era Primeras on their forecourt all showed the exact same symptoms to one degree or another.
Why are they so cheap ? - Sheepy-by-the-Sea
Based on experience of my '99 Sport+ (since sold when I converted to bikes), and my wife's '95 2.0L, I'd say go for it.

At that price, why worry about a bit of bubbling on the alloys or a 'dated' interior if it works? Besides, I remember corroding alloys on some Mondeos of the late nineties.

My wife's car was traded in for £300, with the rusting sill/wheelarch issue - two years later, we still see it on the local roads. It never let her down.

My Sport+ was a superb car for the price; it suffered an ABS fault due to a crack in the toothed ring bit (can't remember what it's called!) - that needed a new drive shaft to fix - watch out for ABS kicking in as you come to a stop even in dry conditions. Otherwise - perfect.

Both had the chain-cam 2.0 engine - a bit noisy, but in a sporty kind of way. Between services it never leaked any fluids, and the oil almost looked as fresh as new when it came to changing it.

Both Nissans were so good my wife traded in for an Almera Tino - which has been disappointing to be honest - reliable, but too many electronic gimmicks, especially the horrible heating and radio controls.
Why are they so cheap ? - Mapmaker
>>It would seem that if you don't drive a downmarket car, with used Chinese tyres, brakes
>>bought from a car boot sale and running on supermarket fuel, you are considered a snob.

Chill! I think you've just proved the point. If you think a Nissan is a downmarket brand, then fair enough.

I can't remember what you drive, but it's probably a BMW, because they're not downmarket. Obviously they're much better cars than mere mortals can afford, and they never go wrong. Hurrah!

:)

It doesn't make you a snob, but it does mean that your motoring costs you more than it costs some of the rest of us. And the main difference is that 'feel good factor' that both parties feel:

You because you smugly know that your top of the range petrol is helping your car to run better.

Me because I smugly know my bottom of the range petrol keeps my costs down.

Horses for courses.