Breakdown service - anthony
Dear all

I am relatively new to this 'place' and assume what I am about to ask, has been thrashed over a thousand times in the past - notwithstanding that, I wish to take on some sort of breakdown service.

For roadside, relay and homestart for 2 people, the AA is quoting £129, which sounds a bit steep to me. I will not join the RAC as long as PR man and self-confessed, non-car owner, John Simpson is working there.

What about CSMA or Green Flag, blah, blah?

Personal recommendations are so much better - look forward to reading your replies.
Breakdown service - dave18
The AA are good, and Relay is worth forking out for. Try and find a lower price - I paid £111 for the same; if you pay by credit card, monthly, it may be less, strangely. I've been towed twice and since found out that the journeys would have cost £300 and £500 respectively, and the cover includes 3 day European cover, for which the RAC charge.
Breakdown service - Andy
Anthony,

I can recommend Green Flag I was with them for years and they used to give free European cover if you take their comprehensive deal, although this may have changed. I think they do special rates for civil servants as you mentioned the CSMA. I'm now with the RAC because I now own a Volvo and I get free RAC for the 1st year and a pefererential price thereafter of about £80 for the full cover.
Breakdown service - Keith S
I cant comment on price. However the service I have had from the AA has been excellent.
Breakdown service - Humpy
So far Green flag have been fine the once I've needed them. I got full comp cover including European assistance through Eagle Star, my insurance company for £80.
Breakdown service - Martin Wall
Andy wrote:

"I'm now with the RAC because I now own a Volvo and I get free RAC for the 1st year and a pefererential price thereafter of about £80 for the full cover."

I have a relative who owns a Volvo that's almost a yr old so the 1 yr RAC cover must be due to expire - what did you do to get the preferntial rate?
Breakdown service - richard price
Try the www.csma.uk.com web site you might qualify as a member as it is not just civil servants. Britannia rescue is pretty good.


Richard Price
Breakdown service - Import ant
Im in the CSMA and they are very good. Yes they were set up for the civil servants so they do pay slightly less. Britannia Rescue is also very good and often beats the AA, RAC and Green Flag in independent monitored surveys.

Is that advertising or not>
Breakdown service - Armitage Shanks {p}
Despite being called CSMA they actually have a VERY wide net in which to trawl for members! They have a list of over 20,000 firms which are deemed to have strong Government connections (ICI for one. A relationship to a civil servant will do; your old uncle or aunt, son, daughter or whatever. Their breakdown service is pounds cheaper than the main ones although I can't comment on response times. Also their car insurance is well priced and I can comment on their claim handing - very good! Nobody could get within £50 of CSMA on a £180 quote - the highest I had was £460 for the same risk! It's cheap enough to call to see if you are eligible, give it try!
Breakdown service - Roger K.
I can recommend GEM Recovery.
They have been very efficient.
They have a special offer at present for new members of £38
which includes recovery!

See www.gemrecovery.co.uk
Breakdown service - terryb
Another vote for CSMA/Britannia Rescue from me. Also, if you buy a new car with free breakdown cover for 1/2/3 years, they will freeze your BR membership and re-start it when asked.

For CSMA members they will even use any un-used portion of the BR subscription to offset all or part of your next CSMA subs.

Terry
Breakdown service - MarkyMarkD
I've been with Autonational Rescue for a while now and had to call them out twice - both reasonably quick turn-outs and helpful friendly mechanics (from local independent garages).

"Total SuperService" includes rescue, recovery, home start for £57 or £57+£28.50=£85.50 for two cars. This has to be one of the best deals for two cars!

Not to mention new members internet-only deal of 15 months for the price of 12.

www.autonational.co.uk
Breakdown service - KB.
Yes the Autonational deal of £85 is good. They used to be MUCH cheaper when you arranged your own contractor to attend and fix or tow back to your destination - then you claimed the cost back from them. (It was £11 per year back in 1984.

But I've just renewed my CSMA for two cars, and any driver in them, (i.e. it covers myself and my Mrs.) and that cost £76.65. for Roadside and Recovery, using what they call "Personal cover" (£28.20) + "Standard Cover" for ONE vehicle(£33.45) + Membership (£15). This arrangement covers ANY car you or your spouse are IN or DRIVING

The list of trades/jobs/professions that qualify is vast (see their website) and they do accept your word that you do the job you say you do - they don't requre any written confirmation - that is to say they rely on your honesty in what you say - that is to say if you weren't strictly up front notifying your EXACT occupation, you'd still get the cheaper cover - that is to say anyone misinterpreting their occupation in order to align it with one of those listed, you'd get the favourable rate.

But none of you would do that..........would you?

Would you?

But what it does say is that you still qualify even if you've retired from one of their nominated occupations or even just worked for one of them for a short time......so you can see that they are quite flexible in their criteria.
KB.
Breakdown service - jc
You don't have to be a civil servant to join Britannia Rescue but it is cheaper if you are.I've used them twice-outstanding and quick service both times.
Breakdown service - Robert Fleming
I've been in the AA and am now in the RAC, but only for the sake of saving a few quid. 6 AA callouts, 3 RAC. Based on this...

AA are reluctant to listen to your pet theories on what's wrong, preferring to work it out for themselves. They're genuinely interested in getting you going, rather that towing to nearest garage. They don't always find the cause of the problem though. E.g. they said change fuel filter, carb gasket really leaking; they said new ECU, ignition control module gone (thankfully).

RAC will tow you to a garage/home if things get too difficult for them. They can't be a***d to do anything tricky, especially late at night. Some RAC areas have sub-contractors only working after 10pm. If you try and talk technical with them, they don't seem as clued up as AA guys.

I reckon that the 'old school' fix at any cost old guys are gradually being replaced by younger chaps who will give you 20 mins fixing time before moving to another call.

Both AA and RAC give enormous peace of mind, AA perhaps the most.
Breakdown service - iisark

Dear Anthony,

I have used AA breakdown services for over 10 years. But two years ago i found a local company called Kings Recovery. They offered me a full cover for £49/ year. The service guys at the company are very reliable. There are so many small companies similar to this one, but is very hard to find because the web is dominated buy the big boys ( AA, RAC..). I found Kings Recovery on this site: toppages.co.uk/city/london/c-breakdown-recovery

Breakdown service - FP

When somone replies to a thread that's thirteen years old (thirteen!) you know there's only one thing on their mind - free advertising!

Spam, in other words.

Breakdown service - Peter.N.

I have been with the AA since 1958 and now get a few freebies, I'm sure I am paying them to much but they are reliable.

Breakdown service - iisark

Hi,

How have you decided my post is spam? I tried to help the community to because people say they pay over £120 for brakedown cover.

My point was that there are pletny of companies out there ( aprat from AA, RAC) which offer cheaper prices.

About the thread age - i didn't noticed that is thirteen years old.

To forum mods: please delete my post if is not useful to the community.

Breakdown service - skidpan

iisark

Your "local company" will be no good if you break down several hundred miles way will they and they are certainly no good to me living in the North Midlands. Their own site sates "We are ideally located near M11 / A11 / A12 / A406 within easy reach of East London and South Essex" and go on to say "If you require the services of a recovery vehicle, please phone anytime for a reasonable quote". They do not provide a service like the AA, RAC, Green Flag etc.

If you want reliable and cost effective break down cover look no further than Aviva rescue. We have a Joint Personal policy that cover myself and the wife whilst we are driving or passenger in any car for at home, rescue, recovery and onward travel.

The price for this, £59 a year.

The service is provided by the RAC who send exactly the same operatives/transport like they do to their own customers who are paying well over double the rates. When I called them out the last time, my car had broken a spring and was immobile, the attended within 30 mintes on a Friday teatime, sent the correct vehicle and took the car to my chosen garage. Previous that this we had called them out once before and they were equally as good.

Why risk these unknown companies who may not exist when you next need them or even operate in the area you break down in.

Edited by skidpan on 20/07/2015 at 14:55

Breakdown service - John F

I wish I had taken a gamble 40yrs ago and not bothered. I have paid around £90 per annum for ages and used it twice - once about 20yrs ago when an invisible/missed crack in the antiroll bar on an old Audi 2.0GL finally broke, and once on the same car shortly after my cheap replacement of a corroded patch of fuel line with a tube from a scrap washing machine succumbed to the high pressure! Both within a few miles of home. Mea culpa.

I have now cancelled it and just keep some emergency numbers to ring and will pay the full cost if I need it - most of these firms contract locally and I suspect even a call to the police would produce help pretty quickly if needed wherever one might be.

Breakdown service - skidpan

You used a

tube from a scrap washing machine

to repair a fuel line.

You deserved all you got. Luckily the car did not go up in smoke, or did it.

Fit the correct parts especially when the consequences from a bodge can be serious (or even fatal).

Breakdown service - skidpan

But I cannot remember the last washing machine that was capable of suppling highly volatile fuel at very high pressures.

But then again i cannot remember a car that would do a 5kg load at 30 dgrees for 30 minutes.

Breakdown service - FP

"How have you decided my post is spam?"

Sorry if I assumed wrongly. But when someone pops up with little previous history on this site and appears to be promoting a business, gives a link and doesn't even say anything along the lines of "I'm a satisfied customer only, I don't work for these people" some of us are suspicious - the freeloaders are frequent visitors here.

Edited by FP on 20/07/2015 at 15:29

Breakdown service - iisark

Hi FP,

Firstable, the link i have posted is not to Kings Recovery website. I just posted a link where i found some local companies. You are right to be suspicious, but believe me - I'm not a spammer. I have these type of people.

Breakdown service - Avant

We don't allow free advertising but I'll let this one stand as the link is to a directory rather than the actual breakdown service.

Breakdown service - Railroad.

I've worked as a patrol for both major UK motoring organisations, and in so doing I've attended hundreds if not thousands of breakdowns in all sorts of locations, and all sorts of vehicles and problems. The AA and RAC utilise their own patrol force and are more expensive, while Green Flag tends to rely more on the garage trade and so their costs are less. In theory you should get a better quality and more consistent service with those who use their own patrols, although anyone would be lying if they said this was true in every case.

There's good and bad in both. The AA and RAC are in effect insurance companies, and both could be regarded as a waste of money if you never use the service, which many members don't. I once attended a Roadside only member who needed a 150 mile recovery when he was only entitled to a local tow of 10 miles or to the nearest approved garage. When I told him he wasn't entitled I got the opposite response I was expecting. Most members in that situation would blow a fuse insisting that they were covered even though they aren't, but this member was quite calm stating that he'd been a member for 10 years and only ever had Roadside cover. He said that the money he'd saved by not having Relay had more than paid for this recovery, so there's always more than one way to look at it.

You have to weigh up the cost against how likely you are to use the service, and make a decision on what's best for you. If you only ever do local journeys, or are not likely to need breakdown cover at home then you could opt for a lower level of cover. You could also opt for vehicle based cover rather than personal cover. This means the car is covered regardless of who is driving, rather than the driver, spouse and family being covered regardless of what they're travelling in. Vehicle based cover is usually cheaper, but obviously not as flexible to you.

Breakdown service - sparky100

Hi, i have been a member of Autoaid Breakdown for the last few years. (08003284439) Have used it once in that time and had a very quick response. Had to be towed home about 4-miles. You have to pay the breakdown company and get a receipt and then claim back from Autoaid. Received payment within a week. Not bad for £43 which covers you personnly and also my wife.