Very high mileage BMW's. - MichaelR
Hi guys,

I have found a 2002/02 BMW 525i Sport with Leather. It seems a very nice car.

But...

It has 155,000 miles.

I am no stranger to high mileage cars and have found them an excellent way of getting a newer car than would otherwise have been possible, or simply saving a pile of cash. My current Mondeo is now at 138k and is still excellent, and my first car, a Citroen Xantia, was traded in at 167k. Now, I had planned to buy a high mileage 5 Series anyway - again, to take advantage of the lower prices you get given they are undesireable.

But I had planned on 90-120k.

What are the potential pitfalls of a 155k car, and is it a bad idea? I have already figured the residual value of this car will be zero. If I buy it, I will never sell it, so depreciation is not a concern. My current thoughts are that it is entirely possible that this 2002 car with 155k could be in as good, if not better condition than 80-120k 2000 cars. My reasoning for this is as follows:

The car will have to have spent a considerable amount of time on the Motorway in order to rack up so many miles in so little time. Aside from stonechips, I would figure that a 200 mile motorway trip is less wear on the suspension, brakes, gearbox, engine, seats and interior than 100 miles of town mileage, which would feature frequent stop-start work, getting in, getting out, etc. So, in that respect, could it be the case that in reality the only negative aspect of this car over, say, a 2 year older example with 100k on the clock is the residual matter.

I am sure my feelings must be flawed - I would appreciate if some of the more learned members of this forum could point the flaws out. Remember, I am after flaws which DO NOT equally apply to an older, lower mileage example. I am aware of the pitfalls of E39 ownership of 80-120k mile cars, but not beyond this.

I do, however, envisage the price of this car will offer a significant saving over a 100k 2000 example, which can of course be used to offset higher maintainance costs, whatever these may be.

Finally, my copy of Glass's does not list mileage this high. What would be your estimation of this cars value? It is a Sport model, and it has full main dealer BMW SH. There are 10 stamps in the book, I think.

Half of me thinks I am silly to even contemplate this, and should revert immediatly to my previous plan of spending several thousand more on an older, lower mileage car. The other half says 'Errr hang on, its what, 15k more than your Mondeo? And thats a FORD!'.

What are BMW's like for rattles, squeeks and general feelings of old-and-naffness at this sort of mileage?

Many thanks.
Very high mileage BMW's. - jacks
I've got a BMW 323 E46 1999 with 160,000 miles up - this has the same 2.5 litre double vanos straight 6 engine.

The car runs perfectly, uses no oil and returns 30-35 mpg. As you have pointed out to rack up this mileage it MUST be almost exclusively motorway miles.
I've had no major problems - still on original clutch/battery/exhaust - front suspension bushes replaced at 100K, but since then nothings gone wrong. No rattles or squeaks, the only quibble is that there is some play in the gearchange linkage caused by wear in the 2 plastic bushes. I mentioned this to the independent BMW specialist who services my car and he waved my concern away saying "I've seen them much worse than this!"

I think this sort of mileage will reduce the value by about £3K.

My only advice would be - if you buy - to increase the oil change frequency (I change at 7500 using Fuchs Titan 0-30 syn) and to change the transmission and diff oil (BMW state these are lifetime fill but I think it needs doing). Also to change coolant every 2 years using the BMW coolant/distilled water rather than the 4 years stated in the manual.

You are right to suggest that the mileage reading alone is no definate guide, depends on how it's been driven/serviced etc..............the real downside is that cars with these very high mileages are very difficult to sell on but if - like me you intend to keep the car until it dies then so what! ............... but haggle very hard because most people want to buy with this mileage so you have the upper hand.
Very high mileage BMW's. - jacks
Edit ...........most people DON'T want to buy with this mileage....................

sorry
Very high mileage BMW's. - bell boy
perfect answer i think.
The only thing i would add is somewhere in my memory cells that you have to be very careful to get the correct oil for the diff ........
i would want it cheap as well as you will own it forever.....
good luck,

ps saw the update..
Very high mileage BMW's. - MichaelR
Looking again it appears to have covered an average of 19,000 miles between services. Given that E39's of this age use variable servicing, in order for this to be the case it must have either:

a) Literally used only Motorways
b) Been owned by somebody who frequently ignored the service lights.

So jacks, how does your car feel to drive compared to much lower mileage examples? I have thoroughly enjoyed the awesome feeling of solidarity in every BMW I have ever driven - no rattles, no squeeks, nothing - just smooth driving and a really nice, tight feeling car. But the highest mileage I have driven is a 92,000 mile 525i, which didn't feel any different to my fathers 40,000 mile 530d.

£3k less - I was hoping it would be more, this car with average mileage is worth what, £12k? So £9k for a 150k car doesn't exactly seem like bargain of the century.
Very high mileage BMW's. - Dalglish
an average of 19,000 miles between services. Given that E39's of this age use variable servicing

>>

nothing to worry about that. i have got 22k between services.

just check that the drivers seats have not worn excessively, and that the rubber seals on the drivers door are ok (big fat driver getting in and out can wear them out as much as the seats !).

friend emigrating just sold his e39 2002 45kmiles 525sport to bmw franchised dealer for £10k.
dealer serviced it, put four new tyres on it, with a fresh mot, and sold it on as official approved used bmw for £14k within a week.

personally, i would offer no more than £5k to the seller of your example.

Very high mileage BMW's. - jacks
The nominal service interval is 15K and the computer adjusts this up or down depending in the usage. Actually the interval is calculated by the amount of fuel used (in fact there is a hidden menu on the on board computer that shows - amongst other things - litres of fuel consumed since last service rest) ..........mine tends to indicate a service interval of 16-17K as I get good fuel economy living in the sticks and my driving is either country roads or motorway - no town work or urban commute. So an interval of 19K suggests that the car in question has been driven on motorways by someone with not too heavy a foot.
I doubt if the service interval have been deliberately ignored - presumably it's an ex company owned/leased car?
Most company drivers get the services done on time & lease companies tend to be strict on this type of thing.
If you phone a BMW dealer with the reg/VIN they should be able to confirm the history from their computer.

Mine drives the same as it did when I bought it (3 years old 80K first owner was Lex leasing), in fact better since the bushes/wishbones were replaced.

My wife has a MINI and had a BMW 320D coupe 05 reg as a curtosy car when hers was in for service and although it was nice it kind of reinforced my decision to keep going with my car as there wasn't that much difference to mine - certainly not £20K + worth of difference.

The £3k was just an estimate, I don't have any books/guides or anything..............the traders (Oldman?) will know
just how much this mileage will chip the price. I've never seen a E46 3 series with as many miles as mine for sale anywhere so I'm only guessing but for what it's worth the BMW trained independent guy who services the car tells me that it should go into the 200 thousands

Might be worth phoning an independent BMW garage near you and asking them what could go wrong at over 150K as they tend to serive/repair the high mileage cars once they drop into private ownership.............
The John Burns website
www.unixnerd.demon.co.uk/bmw.html
and BMWland
both contain good garage guides with owner recommendations/contact details

You didn't say if the car is at a trader or auction ?
Very high mileage BMW's. - Manatee
I have no special knowedge of these cars, but I would be thinking there are two critical things to consider -

- is it OK at the point you are buying it? If it's fault free now then that's the first hurdle out of the way. If necessary pay for a professional opinion.

- consider how you can keep it going for another 50,000 - 100,000 miles ( you might be buying a 50k car but you will be owning a 200k + one) or whatever you hope to get out of it - common sense says it should have a much higher level of preventative maintenance, as Jacks suggests - I would add brake fluid to the oils and coolant changes too, especially if it has not already been done.

I know someone who bought a 10 year old 525 earlier this year with 150k and has run it for a few months - it was very cheap, everything works, and so far nothing has gone wrong with it, and 150k over 10 years will have taken more out of it than the same mileage over 4 years.
Very high mileage BMW's. - Aprilia
Just take a look at the car and consider it on its merits. I recently saw a 4-year old A4 with 120k on the clock, FSH and the engine sounded like a helicopter - severe top-end wear. Nothing can be taken for granted.
Inspect it very carefully and if you want it make sure you get it at a low price - it will be very difficult to sell on.
Very high mileage BMW's. - rtj70
If it was originally a lease car, with that mileage it will have been ex-lease before 80k I'd have though.

I do relatively low personal/business miles so my lease on the company car will run for 4 years. But it's based on 4 years or 80k miles. If I did say 30,000 miles per year I'd have been in a new car by now.

So 155k... well that's not been a lease car for a while in my opinion.
Very high mileage BMW's. - MichaelR
Original owner, who it is I'm not yet sure, had the car for 3 years before a change of owner was registered.

I thought leases were usually based on age rather than mileage?
Very high mileage BMW's. - Screwloose
Aprilia

Was that A4 a 20-valve by any chance?
Very high mileage BMW's. - blue_haddock
Most lease companies have a maximum mileage of approx 120k, however some of the smaller more independant ones will look at higher mileage contracts. Now these types of contract aren't cheap but it does give the driver of the vehicle peace of mind knowing that it will be fully maintained if anything goes wrong over the mileage.

The other possible option is that the contract was 3 years with a total mileage of 120k and they simply paid the excess mileage at the end of the contract.
Very high mileage BMW's. - Cliff Pope
I'm surprised you even consider 155,000 high anyway. In the world of well-maintained quality cars (BMWs, Volvos, probably several others nominated by others) that is absolutely trivial, hardly run-in. i bought a 5 year old Volvo with 180,000 miles without giving it a thought, other than looking at the condition and the service record (and the low price!). It's now on 350,000 and drives the same as when I got it.
A high mileage in a short time with proper servicing is the best possible way of making a car last - obviously lots of fast cruising, very little gearbox, clutch, steering, suspension use. Compare that with a 50,000 mile example that has spent its life running cold driving over lots of speed bumps and parking in tight places, and then wonder why you might want to part with an extra £3000 for a dubious advantage?
Very high mileage BMW's. - DP
I completely agree with Cliff.

High mileage in short time = fewer cold starts and even fewer short journeys

In some ways, 150k is better than 80-100k, as it's likely that items such as clutches and suspension bushes which tend to start going in the early 100's have already worn out and been replaced.

I had a high mileage Sierra, bought with 120k on it (and FFSH). 120-130k it needed a clutch, various suspension bushes, an ignition coil, water pump and a few other bits and pieces. Once this was all done, it did the next 100,000 miles with just two trivial problems and was still driving brilliantly when sold at 230k.

My current Mondeo is the same. Coming up on 120k it's had a few stupid bits go (CV joint, engine mount, clutch in the near future), but it will make a better buy for someone in 30,000 miles time with all this done than it would now, even though it will be near worthless.

Buy on individual merit.

Cheers
DP
Very high mileage BMW's. - Roger Jones
On high milers just watch out on the servicing front.

I've bought two in the past 18 months: in one case the servicing record petered out several years ago after a superficially impressive history of main-dealer servicing; in the other case the servicing documentation of which the vendor was so proud turned out to be a lot less substantial than it appeared at first sight, much of the paper revealing prolonged disputes between one of the car's two previous owners and a main dealer of dubious competence, and again the solid servicing record had thinned out of late.

Perhaps there's less risk of this with young high-mileage cars. My cases were both well over 100k but also over ten years old. However, I discern a general tendency for owners to skimp on servicing when the miles pile up.

And then, of course, even that suite of main-dealer stamps may disguise a history of omission, negligence and incompetence.

As ever, a very careful check (ideally by an expert) will pay dividends when it comes to bargaining.
Very high mileage BMW's. - jacks
And then, of course, even that suite of main-dealer stamps may
disguise a history of omission, negligence and incompetence.


Very good point..........................It's always presented as very desirable to have the "main dealer" stamps in the book - but in many cases main dealer workshops are the subject of many complaints by owners

How many times have you heard of incompetence by main dealers:

skimped servicing, important tasks skipped by bonus hungry mechanics, wrong oil used , parts invoiced but not actually fitted (taken home by the tech for his weekend foreigner), etc etc

In fact - as we're discussing BMW - on another (BMW) forum a poster has recently asked about the costs associated with servicing an M3, specifically the very expensive Inspection 2, and received a reply froma BMW technician who said that this (specific M3) service carries a 2 hour (ie - £200+) premium as the valve clearances needed to be checked and reshimed as necessary - however he went on to say that the usual routine for the techs was to rev the car hard and if the engine ran quietly then they simply ticked the box on the service sheet/laptop "checked and adjusted" and pocketed a nice 2 hour bonus.
Urban myth ? maybe.............but a smaller independent who relies on local reputation and repeat customer business for his living is less likely to pull this kind of stunt - surviving as they do without the steady stream of company/lease owned < 3 year old serviving/warranty work that makes up the bulk of the main dealer workshop income.


Jacks
Very high mileage BMW's. - Stuartli
It's a bit unfair to tar every BMW main dealership with the same brush - you could suggest the same scenario with any marque and it would be equally applicable.

As suggested a thorough examination by a qualified vehicle inspector would help to allay any fears, backed up by a reasonable period of parts and labour warranty.

Frankly I'd rather buy a high mileage car such as this (though perhaps not quite that high!) than a low mileage, never been above 40mph around urban areas equivalent.

In fact I once part exchanged a 25k car for a 66.5k saloon with a 1.3-litre engine and a four-speed gearbox - the newcomer, my first Jetta back in 1992, served me well for the next three years and was happily accepted as a PX (allowance of £1,800) for a £3,999 stickered big bumper 1990 Jetta 1.6TX with 52k on the clock by a main VW dealership.

The second Jetta remained in the family for the next eight years and the parting only came because I was offered an immaculate 46k Bora at a very attractive price by a pal who runs a quailty secondhand cars business. The PX allowance in this case was £600 - not bad after eight years' use. The price I paid for the Bora was very little more than I would have expected to pay for a late model Vento.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
What\'s for you won\'t pass you by
Very high mileage BMW's. - .lister&wotmofo.
Hi I've owned many high millage bmws 4 of which were m's e36 m3 which had done over 240,000 miles when I sold it I brought it for my 21st birthday got a traders pollicy it had 98,000 on the clock when I brought it & I literally thrashed the hell out of it did doughnuts every where , services it my self when nessessery allthough I did once miss it reset the lights & let it go all the way until the lights went out again! But apart from a new clutch , brake pads , wheel bearing , tyres it never once let me down I even thrashed it all the way to Valencia with 4 of us taking it In turns , covering over 4000 miles in 5 days & I still see it driving around now & then , god forbid if the new keeper only knew , next car e39 m5 24th birthday same scenario thrashed the life out of her drive to Prague, nurnbourgring Amsterdam , French alps every where , also serviced my self , with only fan belt & viscous fan coupling letting me down also brought with 90,000 which it had just had a new clutch I sold it on 180'000 still running mint , next 1 , e36 m3 convertible brought on 110,000 had Carmed down a little by then but still no problems , sold at 130,000 theming made the stupid mistake of buying an Audi s4 it was never right cost me thousands in repairs wot a heap of junk , also many people I no that own audis problem after problem , so any way next 1 e46 m3 thrashed it again serviced it my self sold at 160,000 clutch slipping a little & wheel bearing whining where I had drifted it so much but it never let me down apart from a new battery , now I've got an e46 330d with a veizu performance remap , can't afford to run m's any more due to pump prices again coverd 150'000 thrash it to work 100 miles a day still loves it , the moral of this is that bmw's are bullet proof don't waste your money on other cars , I'll never own another make .
Very high mileage BMW's. - balleballe

I agree they are well built cars but many BMW enthusiasts take the stance that their quality has decreased in recent years.

It may be due to the fact that they are selling more cars now - hence more 'problems'

It may be due to the fact their quality is no longer as good.

Who knows

Very high mileage BMW's. - LastV8

Hi, I'm aware that this post is 6 years old now but i've stumbled across it becuase i'm in a very similar position. Did you go ahead and get the high milleage 525i? Did you regert it or has it been a flawless cheap way of getting hold of a lovely car?

Thanks.

Steve

Very high mileage BMW's. - CJay{P}

Go for it. My 2002 530i is on 147k, and my 2003 318Ci is on 118k. Both have provided me with cheap motoring for the last couple of years.

Very high mileage BMW's. - newcomer 1
Hi,

I am also in a similar kind of situation. I have come across 3 series touring (320d SE) that has clocked 86 K in three years since its registration. It still has got it's one year of manufacturer's warranty remaining. BMW dealer says that the warranty could be extended. The offering price is 11K at the moment. any suggestions please. Thanks in advance for the suggestions.
Very high mileage BMW's. - Avant

We haven't heard from the original poster for a long time, so we'll never know. But the advice given by others is good: it very much depends on how the car has been used)(which you can't be sure of) and whether it has a fuill service history (which you can).

Very high mileage BMW's. - 1litregolfeater

I'd be more wary of BMWs with a low mileage shown, as we all know how easy it is to flash the memory.

Lots of high mileage BMWs will be sold on forecourts with a low mileage, they could still be good cars as they have probably been serviced at the correct times.

Just makes them a bit more appealing to the second hand buyer.

Very high mileage BMW's. - barney100
I bought a car with 160k on the clock and it was good as gold. (Volvo 750) if you buy from a dealer there should be some sort of comeback anyway. Do the usual checks for blue smoke from the exhaust etc and make sure all the electrics work and you could be on a winner.
Very high mileage BMW's. - BMWTOP

Well I have to say my trusty automatic 1999 bmw 328i sport coupe is still going strong after over 234000 miles, it has done most of these miles on the motorway, i bought it with 67k on the clock and its has all the original running gear. I will state that it gets serviced at least twice a year. It does not lose oil and its not smokey either although the interior is getting a bit tatty. Most reliabe car i have ever had, it has seen off two golfs and is on par with our lexus for reliability. Like they say if it aint broke dont fix it.