R-32 or golf GTI - smilingvulture
which car?
R-32 or golf GTI - Sprice
R32
R-32 or golf GTI - DavidHM
Either. It depends entirely on who you are; how much you value the smoothness of the V6, the four wheel drive, or the ~£4k price difference. Drive them both and see.

I can certainly see where the extra £4k goes - four wheel drive system, better looks, V6 engine - but equally, I can see why you'd rather have £4k.

Drive them both and see; neither has a fatal flaw but neither is £4k such a small amount of extra cash that you'd be spoiling the ship for a ha'porth of tar if you didn't pay it, especially given that the GTi is quite expensive for what it is in any case.
R-32 or golf GTI - MichaelR
Audi A3 3.2 V6 instead.

It's not that much more expensive and if you are spending 25 grand would you rather not have a nice badge rather than a peoples car? Rest of the car is pretty similar..
R-32 or golf GTI - DavidHM
Michael's got a good point, actually.

In fact if you try www.broadspeed.co.uk you've got a fighting chance of a discount to make the Audi cheaper than the Golf.

Of course the R32 will have the hardcore nutter car reputation so I can't say that the A3 won't depreciate more but the A3 has to be worth a very serious look indeed at this money.
R-32 or golf GTI - wantone
Audi a3 v6 costs more.
Doesnt drive as well as the r32
Isnt as desired as a r32(popular opinion not personal)
Will not hold on to its value like the r32.
There fairly good reasons to choose the r32!!
R-32 or golf GTI - nutty_nissan
NO BRAINER - get the R32!
R-32 or golf GTI - MichaelR
Surely it will drive the same as they are basically the same car, and with it being an Audi not a VW, will have superior residuals?

Compare the price of, say, an S3 with a Mk4 GTI Turbo or a Leon Cupra R!

As for desired - errr, one is a VW Golf, nothing desireable about that, the other is an Audi..
R-32 or golf GTI - Sprice
Imagine a nice country mansion...an R32 would look more at home parked on the drive than an A3. In general yeah, Audi will have better residuals than a normal Golf (or any VW) but the R32 is a different breed!
R-32 or golf GTI - barchettaman
Neither. Get an old-shape Seat Leon Cupra, save 10k/14K!
One of the chaps on the backroom sold his example for 8.4k last week...
R-32 or golf GTI - wantone
R-32 or golf GTI - wantone
cut out those last remarks.
too personal and i shouldnt have said them,
SORRY
R-32 or golf GTI - smilingvulture
?????

i asked the question---but ive already ordered the golf gti
had test drive--enjoyed it.


first car i hav ever bought new---and prob--last.personaly I dont know why they brought both these cars out--the same time.THATS LIFE
R-32 or golf GTI - MichaelR
As for desired - errr, one is a VW Golf, nothing
desireable about that.
You must be daft!!
Of course golfs are desirable thats why there prices are >>

above
any other hatchback.


Compared to a Focus or an Astra, sure, but Audi A3? It's more desireable than a Golf for sure, thats why it costs more and has an Audi badge.
Mind you driving the car you doo i dont expect you
to know anything about used car prices?


I'm not entirely sure what that is supposed to mean?
R-32 or golf GTI - Burnout2
The A3 3.2 is better looking, more understated, has a much nicer cabin and is available with a nice fat £2.5k+ discount via internet brokers, which actually makes it considerably cheaper than an equivalently specced R32. The badge is obviously nicer to have on your steering wheel boss too!

The drive is more comfort orientated and a bit more refined than the Golf but the performance is more or less identical. Can't argue with the latter's residuals though; the spectacular performance of the Mk IV R32 suggests that the new model will be a similarly good investment.

Having driven the GTi, it's a very nice, well-sorted car but rather off the pace for power these days, when you consider that a Civic R was making the same numbers the best part of five years ago. Outright peformance is only part of the package, of course.

R-32 or golf GTI - Adam {P}
I disagree with the looks really. I don't like the small Audis at all. And I certainly don't like the new Audis full stop (barring the A8 and A6).

I didn't like the Golf when it came out but seeing the GTi in the flesh (and the R32 on film), I have quickly changed my mind. Very nice looking cars indeed and in my opinion, looks a lot nicer than most (including the ST) similar cars today.
R-32 or golf GTI - MichaelR
I would be suprised if the R32 has residual performance similar to that of the Mk4. The Mk4 R32 was launched over 4 years after the rest of the Mk4 Range, and was only ever available in small quantities until it was discontinued only a year or two after production started.

It would appear none of this is the case with the new R32. It is available not that long after the rest of the range and presumably has many years of production left.