Clio crankshaft - Richie_green

I have just been told by our mechanic that our clio is noisy due to a problem with the crankshaft. I am not a knowledagble person when it comes to cars so dont know how serious this is.
Is it a costly repair?

Cheers

Richard
Clio crankshaft - John S
In a word yes! Crankshaft repairs require the engine to be removed and dismantled. Have you a better description of the fault though? How many miles has the car done? What exactly is the proposed repair?

JS
Clio crankshaft - RichardW
Well, the crankshaft is usually the first thing you put in when you build an engine, so if it needs replacement, another engine is usually the best solution - this will cost from several hundred pounds upwards, depending on the engine, and the option chosen for replacement. Having said that, quite a few modern cars have damped crankshaft pulleys that drive alternators PAS pumps etc, and these can break up and cause a knocking sound, so this might be the cause - replacing these usually costs less than £200. Did the mechanic not give an idea of the cost of what was necessary to repair?


--
RichardW

Is it illogical? It must be Citroen....
Clio crankshaft - Richie_green
The mileage is 76000. He didnt mention a price but he said he was confident it would not be too great a repair bill.

The knocking only seemed apparent when reving the car excessively.

Oh lord, yet another expensive car bill!!!
Clio crankshaft - cheddar
What age, model and engine Clio?
Clio crankshaft - Richie_green
It is a 1998 S Reg 1.2 RN Grande. 1.2 engine