MOT - no pass, no fee? - HF
Does anyone know anything about these offers?

I ask because it's the Astra's big day again tomorrow, and I happened to come across an ad in the local paper today with the above title.

Sounds too good to be true, in a way. What do the testers gain from it? Would they insist, for example, that any work needed would have to be carried out by them, and that then the customer would also pay the MOT fee?

So, if anyone has heard of or made use of this phenomenon, I'd be grateful to hear more.

Don't want to go to the place, which is a way away and unknown to me, completely ignorant, particularly as I hate driving to places I don't know. (I had a brief HF moment earlier where I though it would be easier to take the bus, before concluding that they'd probably want to see the car!)

Any help gratefully and desperately received.

HF
MOT - no pass, no fee? - Cliff Pope
I believe that a garage is free to charge anything or nothing subject to the statutory maximum. So you need to check exactly what their terms are first. But this could well be a genuine offer. What they stand to gain is the custom people might give them to get failures fixed. There would be the temptation I would have thought to fail on something relatively minor, make a good profit on fixing it, then get the full fee for an easy "retest".
But you are always free to take a car away after a fail and fix it yourself or somewhere else. Remember if it fails on something serious you may be committing an offence by driving the car at all, and they may try to scare you by filling in the box at the bottom of the failure sheet "this car is dangerous and should not be driven".
My only advice from years of taking old cars to MOTs is not to look too prosperous, and preferably like an experienced home mechanic they haven't a hope of getting any business out of. That way you're more likely to get an honest pass or an honest assessment of what needs doing. Smaller one man band garages are more likely to take the trouble to be genuinely helpful. Mass turnover operations just want to get the cars through quickly.
If you go in radiating "I don't care what it costs, just fix it" then they'll find something.
MOT - no pass, no fee? - HF
HI, thanks for replies. I'm sorry I'm going to have to answer individually because I need to be able to see what people have written (and still haven't mastered a way in which I can see multiple posts whilst replying).

So, first, Cliff - thanks. Of course I'd need to speak to the garage in question first, to try and find out terms etc. But since this is an unknown quantity I'm just a bit wary. Sure I see your point about maybe it being genuine - but I still feel that it would be in their interests to 'find' something wrong, even if there wasn't, so that they could fix it and get their money.

If I'm still free to take the car away and get it fixed elsewhere, then I guess that's ok - but I'm worried about what you say, that they could write that the car is unfit to be driven - then I'd be stuck, wouldn't I, and I'd have to let them do the work?

If I go this way, I'll do my very best to look like a knowledgable home mechanic! But I'm not sure my acting skills are up to this. Sure I won't say fix it at whatever price - and I'd say this doesn't sound like a one-man band, and already I'm balking at even trying them out. I'm tempted to hold out to speak to my regular mechanic, but need car fixed tomorrow really, no matter what.

Anyway thanks for your input - it helps.

HF

By the way, what *is* the statutory maximum for a test?

MOT - no pass, no fee? - frostbite
By the way, what *is* the statutory maximum for a test?


Last time I looked, it was around £34.85
MOT - no pass, no fee? - HF
So the ones I've seen for £37.50 are OTT then.
MOT - no pass, no fee? - Dynamic Dave
So the ones I\'ve seen for £37.50 are OTT then.


The current MOT fee is £40.75 according to:-

www.vosa.gov.uk/vosa/carlgvowners/mottesting/motte...m
MOT - no pass, no fee? - cockle {P}
HF
You don't have to have your car repaired at any MOT station regardless of whether they charge you for the test or not. They can however charge you for the retest if you take the vehicle away for repair and don't return within a certain period, a couple of days rings a bell but someone will no doubt be along in a moment who knows chapter and verse on that.
As to what they get out of it, well they get the first opportunity to quote for any work and if you think it's reasonable you won't bother to shop around and therefore they get the trade. I would imagine they would probably pick up at least 75% of the trade from failures that go through their door.

My personal opinion on MOT testing is that no station should carry out repairs, that they should all be independent and therefore have nothing to gain from anything but an impartial test. I know others don't agree with me, for various reasons but I still believe it would be the ideal.

Can I just ask a gentle question, not designed to antagonise, but.... Why do you wait for the due date to get the test done?
If it now fails tomorrow you are without wheels, and I know that causes you problems.
Why not get it tested a week or two early? Then if it fails you have still got cover on the old MOT while you arrange any repairs and if it passes anything up to a month on the old MOT can be added to the new one. I must add that if you do this you should take into account the failure reason, you should never take the risk of driving on defective brakes for instance but a chipped windscreen is not necessarily life threatening and you can get the repair done at your convenience as much as possible.

Having said all that, Good Luck for tomorrow.

Cockle
MOT - no pass, no fee? - HF
Hello Cockle - and good to hear from you!

I've seen various ads stating about no retest fee if done within a limit - 14 days seems to be fairly typical. Of course if I go with this 'no initial fee' thing then I'd expect to pay a fee for a retest, that's fair enough, of course!

I guess as you say they get their business from it simply being the easiest option to leave the car with them for whatever needs to be done. What I am really anxious about, is people making up things that need to be done, simply to get some revenue. Which is why I agree totally with you that the testing stations should be totally independent from the repair centres. If they have nothing to gain by deliberately failing me, then K'd have more faith in the system.

My car is at the stage where there could well be something catastrophically wrong, or it might sail through - I just don't know. It's been battered about a bit too much since its last MOT so I'm a bit worried.

Your gentle question does not antagonise me one little bit. You're absolutely right, it would have been far more sensible for me to have done this in advance. I think it's a mixture of pure HF inefficiency, combined with a burying head in sand mentality. We're pretty destitute at the moment, and I think I was just putting off the car bill because there were others overwhelming me! However, as you say, I *need* the car, and other bills will have to be dealt with later. Next time hopefully I will be a bit more sensible and deal with this as you say a few weeks early.

Too late now - oh how I wish I'd done this sooner!

I am praying really hard that there won't be too much wrong - that I can get it sorted tomorrow - thanks for your good luck, and keep fingers crossed for me please?!

Hope all is well in your world,

HF
MOT - no pass, no fee? - volvoman
Sounds distinctly dodgy to me HF - steer clear (pardon the pun). Nobody does anything for nothing these days so if the car fails (which they could very easily ensure) you'll probably find they'll demand any remedial work is done by them if the test fee is going to be waived. You're then trapped - you either get them to do it at their prices (probably not the cheapest) or pay up for the test and face having to pay again somewhere else. If you do get the work done by them you'll still have to pay the original fee anyway on top of anything else. If you haven't already done so after our chat about this the day before yesterday, why not speak to Alan first - that'll cost you nothing.
MOT - no pass, no fee? - volvoman
As a confirmed cynic I should add that there are many people out there who devise schemes to con desperate people out of what little money they've got. These poor people are easy prey to sharks. Why do you think there are so many ads out there for secured consolidation loans and the like? Yeah, you're up to your eyes in debt so just take out another loan to help pay off the original debt. This time, however, it's secured on your home or at an exorbitant interest rate! I know this is just an MOT but the principle's the same. Promise something that people want to believe and they'll queue up for it whether it's true or not. Don't go there HF.
MOT - no pass, no fee? - Doc
I have used these places and yes, you can walk away if the car fails.

What they tend to do is find a fault on emissions or lighting and offer to do the adjustment for a fee (garages that charge an MOT fee in the usual way will often do these minor adjustments for free)

They will also charge you the full MOT fee on passing-most other garages will be cheaper.

MOT - no pass, no fee? - frostbite
The majority, if not all, specify an car age limit for the NPNF offer.
MOT - no pass, no fee? - HF
The majority, if not all, specify an car age limit for
the NPNF offer.


Which isn't on the ad. I'll find out if I phone them - I'd imagine my 1992 car would be too old to qualify!
MOT - no pass, no fee? - HF
Thanks Doc - the emissions is one of the things I'm worried about (although kind of hope that's all that will be wrong). - am going to take car on a longish fastish drive in the morning anyway, in 3rd gear, as DavidHM advised me last year and which made it pass emissions test.

I think after reading all these points, I'm safer with the devil I know, if he can fit me in.

MOT - no pass, no fee? - HF
V-man, I take your points - in this and the other post. That's why I'm wary.

From what others have said, it's unlikely they could demand to do the work, but they could tell me the car is undrivable and thus render me stuck. I certainly don't want to pay test fees to two separate places, and I know I'll have to pay a fee sometime, just wanted to check what this free initial failure thing was all about.

By the way, I went to Alan's today - and the shop was closed up. I phoned him too, and left a message on his answerphone - hopefully he'll get back in the morning. With my luck it's his summer holiday break!
MOT - no pass, no fee? - Mark (RLBS)
HF,

There is not a big, underground conspiracy out to get you.

An offer, like no pass no fee, is a gimmick to increase the likelihood of them getting to repair your car, at which time they would recover the expense of any failed tests. It is very unlikely that it is a front for an international organisation dedicated to falsely determine cars as unsafe, hence trapping people in their premises until they pay huge sums to have their car repaired.

They cannot "demand" they do the work, although they are free to use discounts and the like to encourage you.

These places are checked from time to time. Of course there are bad places, but most of them are just fine. Its just mroe fun to talk about the bad ones and war stories.

Get it down there and get it tested. See if it passes.

If they mark it as unsafe to drive (which is incredibly unlikely), ask them to show you why, investigate it as much as you can with them, and then tell them you're taking it for a second opinion.

Don't forget, if they say it is unsafe to drive, then it probably is and you should not drive it.

Sometimes the world really isn't out to get you.
MOT - no pass, no fee? - volvoman
[snip]

>>but HF\'s situation is.........

....hers to explain or not as she chooses.

Mark.
MOT - no pass, no fee? - Cliff Pope
All everyone has said is true - you need to be careful in accepting "free" services, but they can be genuine if you don't let yourself be pressurised into paying over the odds for the extras.
I think the ones that charge a full fee to start with, then a reduced fee for the retest, are better value.
From recent but imperfect memory, the retest is always free if you leave the car there and they do the work. It is free if you take it away and return within 24 hours for a minor thing - bulbs, wipers etc.
It is half price if you return within I think 7 days for a wider number of specified things, and for anything else, especially the more serious faults, it is full fee the second time.
Those are the maxima - most stations IME charge less than that, some even always free for the retest.
The "dangerous to drive" box is usually just to cover themselves. My recent slightly worn track rod end was hardly dangerous, especially now I new about it and drove carefully. They didn't mention it, and knew very well I was going to drive away anyway. But if the chassis was on the point of collapsing from rust I'm sure they would have said so.
For the non-mechanically inclined motorist I think the best routine is to find a good honest small private garage and build up a long term relationship with them. They don't have to do MOTs themselves - a good option is when they do pre-tests and then get the car MOT'd for you.
MOT - no pass, no fee? - helicopter
HF - Take my tip and use the 'devil you know 'if you have a regular spannerman.

I have on a couple of occasions tried the 'free MOT ' offers and as others have said they tend to be a sprat to catch a mackerel.

If you find a good independent mechanic who you trust, stick to him like glue and if he doesn't do MOT's himself maybe ask if he can go with you when the car is tested or take it himself. It may well be it costs a little extra but will save you in the long term because he talks the language and won't take any bull.

Good Luck for the test - I'll keep my fingers crossed for you.
MOT - no pass, no fee? - Mapmaker
It's a good offer for people who drive old cars & MOT their cars every 6 months.

If you follow this procedure, at the point when it fails too badly to be worth repairing, you still have a car with 6 months MOT that you can sell (and the failed test has cost you nothing!). If you pass, you pay up £40 in exchange for 6 months' more motoring.

MOT - no pass, no fee? - PoloGirl
HF...

What's the verdict then? Hope it all went ok today.

MOT - no pass, no fee? - HF
Cliff, Heli, Mapmaker, PG, and all others who have posted here -

First, it PASSED!!! For the first time in 10 years of driving, I have had a straight pass - and I am so chuffed you wouldn't believe it!

My normal mechanic wasn't able to fit me in, but suggested to me a small local MOT test centre which he uses himself. (the idea being for them to test it and him to do the work next week when he has time). This test centre's own terms are 14 days between test and free retest, which sounds very generous compared to the people Cliff mentioned.

I would of course have stuck with trusted mechanic if I'd had time, but I didn't - and I was very lucky!

I had decided, anyway, from information here, not to go for the NPNF garage, because I'd have to pay a fee in any case, whether at the start or at the end, so I decided that didn't matter too much.

Testing people changed a couple of bulbs for me, adjusted a headlamp arm (?) and all I paid for was the test and the bulbs. Fantastic.

Apparently there are a couple of 'advices' which will need sorting for next year - and I will be asking about these at some stage to get an idea what they mean.

But, for now, I am one very happy driver.

Many, many thanks to all who have posted here.

HF

Oh and DD - your MOT price was exactly what they charged.
MOT - no pass, no fee? - Dynamic Dave
Oh and DD - your MOT price was exactly what they
charged.


I should hope so; after all I'm on commission ;o)

MOT - no pass, no fee? - HF
>>I'm on commission

What's your price these days? A crumb off the end of someone's vegetarian ploughman's? Or are you still having to scrape around the floor for the ringpulls after Mark and HJ's indulgent nights out? ;)))
MOT - no pass, no fee? - Cliff Pope
I'm so glad it passed. I well know the feeling of elation, especially sweet if you had all-but given up hope of a straight pass. It's silly really - it's only a car, not a child!
Have you ever sat in one of those viewing areas? Don't - it's nerve-wracking.
MOT - no pass, no fee? - volvoman
Well done HF - a good and much deserved result. The moral of the story is though, don't leave it to the last minute next time. It won't cost you any more to get your next MOT done a few weeks before (up to a month IIRC) the old one expires and then if the worst happens you've got more time to sort out any problems - hopefully as cheaply as possible. Also, have a look at the advisory notes and get a 'quote' for the work. At least if you know what this work may cost next year you'll be able to plan ahead for it and if it doesn't happen you'll have a little fund for other emergencies.
MOT - no pass, no fee? - helicopter
HF - I'm so pleased for you. Excellent news.
MOT - no pass, no fee? - Mapmaker
>Cliff: It's only a car not a child

But a child doesn't go expensively wrong at 24 hours' notice, and you don't rely on your child for transport!

Huge relief when they pass for no cost. Well done!
MOT - no pass, no fee? - volvoman
Yeah and, of course, some people totally rely their cars for various reasons.
MOT - no pass, no fee? - HF
Thanks all!

And Cliff - I nearly fell into the viewing area when I dropped the car off! (that's if the 'viewing area' is the big hole in the ground that was cleverly camouflaged so that I nearly missed it (so you see Mark, it *is* just a huge conspiracy theory!).

Anyway, again thanks for all comments - I was very lucky this year, and will really try and heed advice to be a bit more efficient next year.

Best regards to you all
HF

MOT - no pass, no fee? - Jetarch1

My experience of no pass no fee MOT garages has been they tend to more lenient on marginal faults, and may issue an advisory where other garages might issue a fail. It is in the tester's interests to pass the car if they can, and the offer attracts more business.

If the car fails, or even if it passes, they may well offer to do work on it, but it is up to you whether you accept their offer. I usually take the car away and do the work myself, or get it done somewhere else if I can get it done cheaper.

Whilst I usually go to no pass no fee garages, my advice, if you do the same, is to get any issues raised attended to in the interests of reliabilty and safety.

MOT - no pass, no fee? - leef

11 years later?