Toyota Yaris - Replacement car for daughter - MGspannerman

Our daughter now has the Yaris we bought new 16 years ago. The last MOT had advisories for corrosion on the sills and subframe, imbalance of brakes and several other things. She has no off road parking and maintenance is not a word she is familiar with, hence the vehicle is pretty unloved and looks battered to say the least. The plan was to run it until such time as it became uneconomic. With the next MOT looming, I am wondering if that time is now.

I see three options –

A – keep going to the next MOT and repair or buy another car as circumstances dictate

It would be helpful to have a more planned transition rather than cope with a carless crisis, as whilst she doesn't do a lot of miles a car is almost a necessity.

B – Get a years MOT, sell with a new ticket and look for the next car. With a retail sale price of £1-1.5k. Possible net gain around £500/750 after paying for repairs and expenses

This would optimise finances but a lot of, potentially carless, faff getting the work done and putting up with tyrekickers etc for a modest gain. A degree of pressure to get another car to fill the gap.

C – Trade in now and accept the inevitable

The easiest but most expensive route forward.

With a budget of max £7/7.5k and the need for a car capable of the odd 300+ mile trip but compact enough for town centre, on road parking slots. I am rather surprised at the high price of another used Yaris, an obvious choice. Possible alternative vehicles could include Mazda 2, Hyundai i20, Ford Fiesta and Ka+, Suzuki Swift, Kia Rio and maybe Ceed. Not on the list would be anything with DSG, powershift, pure-tech, 1.0 ecoboost. A preference for Japanese/Korean and as young as possible, and to avoid small city type cars.

I would be interested in views of others who have faced similar circumstances. I am not sure how bad the corrosion is and whether the Yaris will last. As we don't change cars too often, and mainly buy Toyota anyway, I don't have a lot of insight into suitable alternatives.

Toyota Yaris - Replacement car for daughter - Orb>>.

With a budget of max £7/7.5k and the need for a car capable of the odd 300+ mile trip but compact enough for town centre, on road parking slots. I am rather surprised at the high price of another used Yaris, an obvious choice. Possible alternative vehicles could include Mazda 2, Hyundai i20, Ford Fiesta and Ka+, Suzuki Swift, Kia Rio and maybe Ceed. Not on the list would be anything with DSG, powershift, pure-tech, 1.0 ecoboost. A preference for Japanese/Korean and as young as possible, and to avoid small city type cars.


Kia Venga 1.4 manual or Hyundai Ix20

Tardis like, smallish outside . we went over to france and belgium in 0urs.

We still have a 11 reg 1,4 2 spec which soldiers on.

Plenty around in that budget.

Toyota Yaris - Replacement car for daughter - Andrew-T

Presumably as you have owned the car from new, it has proven reliability which any 'cheap' replacement may not. It will also be less complicated than a newer car, which may be a plus. Corrosion on sills and subframe may not be a immediate threat, but that should be verified. It may seem 'uneconomic' to keep a reliable old car running, but that depends on how big a picture you are looking at.

When the next MoT beckons, get it done well before expiry date so there is time for possible repair work. We have owned our 2008 Peugeot since nearly new, and expect to continue to do that - it has been written off twice after minor incidents.

Toyota Yaris - Replacement car for daughter - SLO76
Good sensible list. Just get out there shopping. Buy something with a full history and low ownership. It’s best to do so while not under any pressure to jump, that way you can take your time and get the right thing. Buy on condition and history over anything else from that list, as you’ve already excluded all the troublesome makes and models.

If all things were equal and if buying with longterm reliability in mind I’d favour the Mazda 2 or a Fiesta 1.25 (82PS) as they’re great fun to drive, cheap to run and mechanically very robust.

Hard to say without looking at it, but I doubt the Yaris would be worth spending much money on with a view to selling it on as a private seller. People want everything for nothing in the private ads and you can’t offer any guarantees. Flogging cheap cars is a proper pain in the tail, as your typical buyer has no money and will pester you when it ultimately goes wrong. I’d avoid the grief, unless it’s very tidy and worthy of the effort.

Edited by SLO76 on 18/08/2025 at 14:41

Toyota Yaris - Replacement car for daughter - Lee Power

Would a Toyota Aygo be suitable?

If an Aygo is suitable dont forget the Peugeot 108 / Citroen C1 but only if its the 1 litre Toyota power unit, don't touch a 1.2 as its the PSA Purec*** engine.

The 108 & C1 normally cheaper then an Aygo as they dont have a Toyota badge.

Toyota Yaris - Replacement car for daughter - gordonbennet

If you're going to change an Auris 1.2 turbo would fit the bill nicely.

You should train your daughters up so they don't get fleeced and are truly independent, mine just replaced all 4 calipers plus new discs and pads and 2 new drop links on one of her Civics, she only called on me to lop off the one drop link bolt which was seized solid, now she knows how to use an angle grinder safely too..

Toyota Yaris - Replacement car for daughter - MGspannerman

Thank you all for your various inputs. looks like we are on the right track. The ix20/Venga and Auris will be added to the shortlist. She did have an Aygo at one time, but it was not really up to the infrequent but long distance journies she made. As with one of the comments I wonder if it is really with the hassle of getting the Yaris through the MOT and then selling as an old banger to a knuckle dragging tyrekicker.

Whilst my daughter has a good range of useful skills that I encourage her to practice I doubt she will be doing any major repairs any time soon, but can certainly draw on the skills of others as and when required.

We definitely want to avoid another "car crisis", having recently experienced one with her elder sister's unreliable car. A planned swap process starting with an MOT for the Yaris well in advance of expiry and identifying of a suitable replacement is now under way to conclude within the next month or so.

Toyota Yaris - Replacement car for daughter - galileo

For a budget of about £7000 I would consider a Hyundai i10 or Kia Picanto, both similar in size and performance to a Yaris and likely newer for the same price.

Toyota Yaris - Replacement car for daughter - pd

After a very good experience with the current one I think I'd seriously consider just getting another Yaris!

Toyota Yaris - Replacement car for daughter - badbusdriver

After a very good experience with the current one I think I'd seriously consider just getting another Yaris!

I agree.

For the budget stated, there is a reasonable choice of the previous shape Yaris with the (non hybrid) 1.5 petrol (they have 110bhp). Leggy ones (and being a Toyota, this is nothing to worry about with FSH) could be as young as 2019/20.

A Suzuki Swift with the 1.0 Boosterjet is also worth considering.

SLO mentioned the Fiesta with the 82PS 1.25 earlier. Just to clarify, there was a 60PS version which would be best avoided.

She did have an Aygo at one time, but it was not really up to the infrequent but long distance journies she made.

As someone who had a Daihatsu Sirion with the same engine (bigger and about 100kg heavier than an early Aygo) for three years, I just want to point out that they are more than capable of motorway travel and will sit at 80mph all day long (provided there are no steep hills or strong headwinds in the way). I drove our Sirion from Peterhead (Aberdeenshire) to Solihull via Wigan twice, and it managed absolutely fine on the motorway!

Toyota Yaris - Replacement car for daughter - MGspannerman

Thanks again all for the further input. Another Yaris is certainly on the cards, as a family we have had four over the years and all were good. However a good one needs some finding. There were none on the HJ used vehicle finder on this site within thirty miles of our postcode when I looked. Autotrader showed 28 having removed the autos and/or diesel models. The youngest in the price bracket up to £7.5k was 2016, and of course some very leggy ones. I agree, there is nothing wrong with that providing there is a good service history.

Looking at the selection available I checked the MOT history of a number of high milers. There were obvious signs of neglect with some, mechanical faults particularly suspension components or, a problem with the current vehicle, corrosion. The advisories were very informative. Several were advertised as full service history, as was one I drove 30 miles to see recently - the service book showed two stamps and the third service was essentially somebody writing the date in. No invoices were available. Winnowing down the shortlist of 28 doesn’t leave a lot of choice. Of course cars don’t come for free, but I am prepared to widen the scope and at least consider value elsewhere.

I think that a Picanto, i10 and Aygo cars are possibly too small. She had an Aygo for four years and it was very tight at time getting all her kit in it. Yes, the engine is unburstable and goes well but with her trips several times a year of 300+ miles a car with less drone and road noise together with more road presence especially on motorways appeals. Anyway, the plan is in place and with the helpful comments received hopefully we can take time and care without having to worry about a car crisis necessitating more immediate action.

Toyota Yaris - Replacement car for daughter - gordonbennet

Yaris has a reputation which is adding to the price in my opinion.

Auris is more anonymous, here's one i'd probably look at though no idea where you live.

www.ebay.co.uk/itm/177254446391?_skw=toyota+auris&...g

Toyota Yaris - Replacement car for daughter - Adampr

Yaris has a reputation which is adding to the price in my opinion.

Auris is more anonymous, here's one i'd probably look at though no idea where you live.

www.ebay.co.uk/itm/177254446391?_skw=toyota+auris&...g

It might not been much newer than the outgoing Yaris, but a friend of mine has a Verso S, which is essentially a slightly longer Yaris. He loves it and they don't seem to attract quite the same premium either.

Toyota Yaris - Replacement car for daughter - galileo


I think that a Picanto, i10 and Aygo cars are possibly too small. She had an Aygo for four years and it was very tight at time getting all her kit in it. Yes, the engine is unburstable and goes well but with her trips several times a year of 300+ miles a car with less drone and road noise together with more road presence especially on motorways appeals. Anyway, the plan is in place and with the helpful comments received hopefully we can take time and care without having to worry about a car crisis necessitating more immediate action.

I have had an Aygo as a courtesy car and agree they are very small.

Picanto and i10 are a size bigger, much the same as Yaris - we previously had two Yarises and I'd say there is little difference in size or interior space.

Go look at one and see.

Toyota Yaris - Replacement car for daughter - MGspannerman

Thanks,yes we will. Daughter is away at the moment and then we are too, so this will be on the list for when we can all get together. if she is happy with a Picante then fine by me. Her cousin has one and is very pleased with it

Toyota Yaris - Replacement car for daughter - badbusdriver

I'm not knocking either Picanto or i10, I do prefer small cars as a rule and MIL loves her i10 (automatic). However there does seem to be some misconceptions over how small they are relative to a Yaris. If we are assuming a Yaris of the previous shape (so 2012 through, via a couple of facelifts, until current shape in 2020), then both Picanto and i10 are closer in length to the Aygo then Yaris, more so in the case of the Picanto which is both 70mm shorter then the i10 and 20mm narrower than an Aygo.

Toyota Yaris - Replacement car for daughter - John F

Changing cars is almost always costly, not just initially but also ongoing depreciation, which a 16yr old Yaris would no longer suffer from. I may have missed it in this long thread, but ..what is its mileage? Toyota are renowned for their powertrain reliability, so should not be causing major problems much below 150,000 miles if kept oiled and watered. The killer for most Asian cars seems to be rust, but it can't be that bad if it's only 'advisories' at this stage. If the mileage has been no more than around 5k p.a. it would make financial sense to get underneath and spend a few hundred or so (or do it yourself) to halt the existing corrosion. Brake problems on cheap mundane cars are not usually expensive to fix.