Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Fishermans Bend

www.autocar.co.uk/car-news/industry/new-petrol-and...0

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - RT

I guess that sets the latest date when I give up caravanning, give up driving and scrap the Touareg - I'll be 93 - I'm looking forward to the next 23 years.

Of course, in the unlikely event that the government misses it's target that date will be extended

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Fishermans Bend

Looking forward to hearing those V8 electric TVRs of the future.

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - nellyjak

I guess that sets the latest date when I give up caravanning, give up driving and scrap the Touareg - I'll be 93 - I'm looking forward to the next 23 years.

Of course, in the unlikely event that the government misses it's target that date will be extended

I'll be 93 too.!...and well past caring (and driving) no doubt.

...and assuming I'm still drawing breath I will delight, however, in telling (boring) the "young 'uns" just what they missed when we used to drive proper cars..!

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Avant

The Government are probably hoping that by then the tide will have turned in favour of electric cars. It may well, but there are big provisos:

(1) there will be enough power stations to generate all this electricity, and they don't themselves push out noxious gases;

(2) someone invents a reliable way of remotely charging batteries, so that you can charge cars parked in the street (as most cars in towns and cities are). Audi's proposed new plate set into the road may be a start; and

(3) battery capacity is developed to give a range of at least 400 miles.

Edited by Avant on 26/07/2017 at 13:10

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Bolt

The Government are probably hoping that by then the tide will have turned in favour of electric cars. It may well, but there are big provisos:

(1) there will be enough power stations to generate all this electricity, and they don't themselves push ot noxious gases;

(2) someone invents a reliable way of remotely charging batteries, so that you can charge cars parked in the street (as most cars in towns and cities are). Audi's proposed new plate set into the road may be a start; and

(3) battery capacity is developed to give a range of at least 400 miles.

I think battery tech is well on the way, and point 1 is a good one which everyone seems to think we wont be needing them?

charging in the road may be easier than people think, though cost will be extortionate, they said mobile phone charging years ago could not be done,look were we are now

I think it will be a mix of all electric and Hydrogen powered IMO

Edited by bolt on 26/07/2017 at 13:06

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - davecooper

To be honest, we will probably be virtually there by 2040 regardless of the governments plans. Now that the big guns like BMW, Merc, VAG etc have got on board, things could move quite fast. Yes, there will be issues such as charging, range and grid capacity to sort out but these are not insurmountable and we have got 23 years..

Anyway, my understanding is that the government are saying that no new cars sold after 2040 are to be petrol or diesel. That is a lot different to saying all petrol/diesel cars will be banned from the roads in January 2040.

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Bolt

To be honest, we will probably be virtually there by 2040 regardless of the governments plans. Now that the big guns like BMW, Merc, VAG etc have got on board, things could move quite fast. Yes, there will be issues such as charging, range and grid capacity to sort out but these are not insurmountable and we have got 23 years..

Anyway, my understanding is that the government are saying that no new cars sold after 2040 are to be petrol or diesel. That is a lot different to saying all petrol/diesel cars will be banned from the roads in January 2040.

I think thats why they have come up with this 2040 because certain car companies have already said there will only be Hybrid/all electric by 2030

As for grid capacity, a couple of years ago one electricity supplier warned of electricity cuts during a bad cold spell, if they cannot keep up with demand in winter what will happen when thousands of cars want charging at once, and that has to happen at some point whatever anyone says

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Manatee

To be honest, we will probably be virtually there by 2040 regardless of the governments plans. Now that the big guns like BMW, Merc, VAG etc have got on board, things could move quite fast. Yes, there will be issues such as charging, range and grid capacity to sort out but these are not insurmountable and we have got 23 years..

Anyway, my understanding is that the government are saying that no new cars sold after 2040 are to be petrol or diesel. That is a lot different to saying all petrol/diesel cars will be banned from the roads in January 2040.

Yes. I think the point of the 2040 target is that it will indicate the glide slope to a gradual total conversion, and nfluence investment. A big bang change is neither desirable nor possible.

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Fishermans Bend

Can't see all petrol/diesel cars being banned from the road. How would classic cars move?

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - expat

There will have to be a big change in customers preferences between now and then. Right now most of the electric cars being sold are bought by government bodies and a few companies which want to big note themselves as being green. They are not being bought by ordinary private motorists. The only ones which are selling are the Prius which seem popular as taxis in some areas and Teslas which sell to the "Look at me brigade". I wouldn't touch one because I would be afraid of the cost of replacing the batteries when they die. I would not expect them to have any resale value for the same reason. Then there is the problem of lack of charging stations and the time taken to charge from empty to full. Try driving an electric car from London to Glasgow in a day. How many times would it need to be charged up? How long would each charge take? Where would you go to charge it? I would be amazed if many motorway services have charging points.

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - sammy1

FOR SALE Horse and cart, one faithful owner wih following extras, open top, 60inch multi-spoke alloys, stop start (whoa geeup) lane assist (blinkers) newly shod all round with great off road capability.Will tide you over until the FLUX Capacitor is proven technology.

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - madf

Toyota are developing a new battery system with 30 minute charging: production 2022.

tinyurl.com/y9fz9zwq

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Ian_SW

Latest version of the report confirms that petrol or diesel powered cars with a hybrid powertrain will still be allowed after that date.

At that point it's not exactly going to be a difficult target. Even if that were made law tomorrow we could carry on much the same. Hybrid cars (other than in supercars) may be a bit boring but are perfectly functional.

I was already considering one of the better ones such as the Lexus IS300h or Passat GTE as my next car on the grounds of reliability anyway.

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - skidpan

Can't see all petrol/diesel cars being banned from the road. How would classic cars move?

Its not about stopping the use of existing petrol or diesel cars on the road after the 31st December 2039, it's about stopping the sale of new petrol/diesel cars from 01 January 2040.

Latest version of the report confirms that petrol or diesel powered cars with a hybrid powertrain will still be allowed after that date.

If that is true it makes a total joke of the proposed law banning the sale of petrol and diesel cars. Anyone with 1/2 a brain cell knows hybrids are a waste of space. My Superb 1.4 TSi does the same (or better) mpg than the Auris Hybrid. OK, the hybrids will get better before 2040 but so will the VAG 14 TSi (or its successor).

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Manatee

Toyota are developing a new battery system with 30 minute charging: production 2022.

tinyurl.com/y9fz9zwq

All fine and well, but e.g. a Nissan Leaf uses 0.34kWh per mile. So a car with 200 mile range would need c 70kWh for full range from empty. At 100% chargng efficiency charging in half an hour would require a 140kW supply. At 240V that is a supply current of c. 580A.

A typical home might have 100A supply fuse.

I suspect fast chargers use higher voltages and lower currents, but as the supply coming into the house is 240V then transforming the supply to feed the car won't help.

So home charging will probably be at no more than 30A or 40A. At 40A, using Nissan Leaf efficiency, a 200 mile charge would take 7 hours - presently just right for Economy 7.

A separate network of high voltage charging in residential areas would presumably need its own substations and metering. And Economy 7 would be on its head, with millions of vehicles charging overnight the electricity might be cheaper during the day.

Using Nissan Leaf effciiency, 10 million average cars doing 32 miles per day (12,000 per year) would need a total of 111GWh of electricty per day(night).

Even in a world of very fast charging, most vehicles would need to be charged mostly at lower rates to make infrastructure and peak generating requirements realistic.Super fast charging would be useful for en route recharges on long journeys.

Not intended to be super-logical, just a stream of consciousness. Hope I haven't misplaced any decimal points.

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Metropolis.
More ecomentalist BS!!!!
This country has well and truly gone to the dogs.
Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - gordonbennet

At present rates of population growth, we'll be knocking on 80 or more million souls by then, does anyone seriously believe we'll have the electric capacity to keep the nation moving by electric alone.

Its more than likely that motoring will have changed completely by then, they won't be able to build enough roads to cope with just the commercial transport needed to feed and service 80 million people, and the roads will be at a crawl 24/7 all lanes with just lorries and vans.

Going to the seaside for the day or long weekend will i suspect be something our great great grandchildren read about on a strictly monitored state supervised device via their compulsory microchip.

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Manatee

What a depressing chap you are GB. You sound like me!

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - bazza

Although I am as far from Mr Gove's politics as is possible, he is correct in that we cannot carry on as we are. The horsepower race, cars and trucks becoming bigger, more powerful, more widespread ownership, it's consumption gone mad. I freely admit I'm a petrolhead and I've loved owning different bikes and cars, it's been great fun during my lifetime. But when you look at the bigger picture, our needless greed for more and more cannot be sustainable. My kids ( now adults) are much more in tune with our need to develop sustainable processes and see over-consumerism and excess as unethical and selfish. That I think is the mood of the next generation. I can't say I disagree with the goal, and it's going to be fascinating watching battery development and charging infrastructure taking shape over the next decade. I suspect that a good many of us on here will be driving hybrids within the next 10 years or so, and I also believe they will improve so much over current offerings that we won't have a problem with it either. I certainly won't though I may miss my clutch and gearbox for a while. Change is always difficult and we have 100 years of petrol engine culture to rid ourselves of. It's going to be interesting!

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - sandy56

A few comments on the latest plan to change over to battery powered cars; currently electric cars make up a tiny percentage of cars sold, less than 1% world wide. Where government subsidies( paid by the taxpayer) exist like Norway, then there is a few more electric cars.

currently we dont have the manufacturing capacity, anywhere, to build enough batteries to supply the new millions of electric cars, nor are they any published plans to build these new factories to supply the millions of modern power packs required;

where is the plans for handling the safe and environmentaly friendly disposal of these millions of large battery packs;

rare earth metals as used in modern batteries are in short supply, where will the huge amounts of these rare metals etc come from?;

currently we have little if any spare power generation capacity. We will need a new fleet of modern non polluting power stations to supply the required large increase in electrical power. Again, there is no plans in place for additional power plants. It takes approx 10 years to build a large power plant so we will need to get started very soon.

Maybe someone can educate us on how these questions will be answered?

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - gordonbennet

What a depressing chap you are GB. You sound like me!

Realism the way things are going i think, remember i've been permanently on the road since 1973 and seen the constant increases, despite weights and volumes carried being massively increased.

twenty odd years ago when there was no M25 we'd navigate our way around via favourite routes to criss cross the south east, now there's a steady stream of commercial vehicles almost filling two of the four lanes and the old routes are absolutely chocka too, it doesn't take much imagination as to what another 20 odd years will bring, and thats just the M25 district, M1 and M6 are heading to 4 lanes and by the time the 'smart motorway' misleading term is finished that extra lane will be rammed solid too.

Sorry for the gloom predictions, but we are going to reap the results of what we have voted for.

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Warning

We could have electric cars, but also hydrogen cars.

Car Battery techonlogy will be better and better all the time.

There are some big sky thinkers, who think electric cars will all be connected. So if No 37 has solar panels, and they are not at home, they coudl sell their unwanted electricity to charge the car at No. 53

If No. 37 needs electricity, rather then buy it from the electric grid, they tap into the surplus electrcity from their neighbhoors's cars. . For instance, if pensioners only use the car for 10 miles a day, having 200 miles car battery, they can afford to give some.

If we have a day when our wind turbines are generating a lot of electricity and it is unwanted, that electricity can be held in car batteries. Think of it as an energy bank.

There are people currently researching the best way to manage these things....

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - RT

We could have electric cars, but also hydrogen cars.

Car Battery techonlogy will be better and better all the time.

There are some big sky thinkers, who think electric cars will all be connected. So if No 37 has solar panels, and they are not at home, they coudl sell their unwanted electricity to charge the car at No. 53

If No. 37 needs electricity, rather then buy it from the electric grid, they tap into the surplus electrcity from their neighbhoors's cars. . For instance, if pensioners only use the car for 10 miles a day, having 200 miles car battery, they can afford to give some.

If we have a day when our wind turbines are generating a lot of electricity and it is unwanted, that electricity can be held in car batteries. Think of it as an energy bank.

There are people currently researching the best way to manage these things....

How does that work in winter in Northern England and Scotland, especially if it blowing a hooley as wind turbines have to be feathered and stopped above certain wind speeds.

Only one thing is certain - the future will happen - what it brings we'll just have to wait and see!

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Bolt

what it brings we'll just have to wait and see

I think Hydrogen will get further than all electric as that can also be used to power a house,apart from charging stations and keeping the recharge price at a reasonable level I think theres more to like than using mains charged cars

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Ethan Edwards

More ecomentalist blocks.

New cars made from pure unobtainium driven by unicorns gently f***ing channel no 5.

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - hillman

I remember when I was working on a factory design we planned to use electrically driven fork lift and tow trucks. These used two batteries, one in use on the truck and one on charge in the charging bay. At the end of the shift the batteries would be swapped over in minutes and the vehicle would be ready to start the next shift.

Some years ago (maybe 30) somebody proposed a similar scheme for electric vehicles. A standard battery shape and plug and socket connections. The vehicle would draw up in a refuelling station and swap the battery for a fully charged one.

Think of that; two batteries per vehicle. The owner of the car would own one and the refuelling company the other.

There was an electric bus, single decker, running for a number of years as a trial of battery technology.

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - corax

what it brings we'll just have to wait and see

I think Hydrogen will get further than all electric as that can also be used to power a house,apart from charging stations and keeping the recharge price at a reasonable level I think theres more to like than using mains charged cars

Hydrogen is the ideal fuel- plenty of it and clean, but it's expensive to produce by current methods and hard to transport and store. To liquify hydrogen would mean cooling it to -423.17 degrees farenheit, then storing it in insulated fuel tanks. That would take a lot of energy in itself.

I wish I lived in a world where there was a quarter of the population and there were still vast swathes of forest keeping the atmosphere pleasant, so that we could carry on as we are but unfortunately the human ape is too greedy and self destructive, and I wager will last nothing like as long as the dinosaurs.

Edited by corax on 26/07/2017 at 21:28

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - gordonbennet
I wish I lived in a world where there was a quarter of the population and there were still vast swathes of forest keeping the atmosphere pleasant, so that we could carry on as we are but unfortunately the human ape is too greedy and self destructive, and I wager will last nothing like as long as the dinosaurs.

Amen to that, but we've gone way past the sustainable/sensible human population now, which is irony of biblical proportions if we as humans are the most intelligent but too stupid to prevent what is coming, the overrun of the inhabitable planet.

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Ethan Edwards

Unless there's some miracle breakthrough the hydrogen bond to the oxygen atom is always going to be really hard to break. Requiring vast amounts of energy and massively inefficient.

That's just the facts.

Hydrogen itself is difficult to store. Imo it's a technological blind alley.

Lpg or Cng is practical feasible and here and now.

The dead hand of government will never spur technological innovation.

Or I'd pass a law last week, legalizing time travel.

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - davecooper

The main comments regarding the move toward electric/fuel cell cars seems to be the supporting infrastructure. This is a chicken and egg situation but the infrastructure will have to grow to support the number of cars on the road. You would also imagine that the growth of alternative fuel cars will be self limiting. Until there is sufficient support for the technology, many people will not consider going the completely electric/fuel cell route. We will certainly all be driving hybrids long before 2040 however and perhaps it will be plug in hybrids that help the growth of charging facilities.

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Bolt

We will certainly all be driving hybrids long before 2040 however and perhaps it will be plug in hybrids that help the growth of charging facilities.

I`ve said before hybrids will be driven before all electric, but see no reason why if the engine emissions are clean you need a plug in hybrid which will save the expense of installing power points in every house/garage which personaly I think is going over the top

emissions warnings have been talked about as long as I can remember, and now they want to take drastic measures they could have sorted out a long time ago, reminds me of our useless government

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Terry W

I think we are on the cusp of a radical change in transport and other technologies - not dissimilar to the electronics and media revolution.

23 years ago sat nav, internet, smart phones, online shopping etc etc were either in their infancy or a figment of the designer/inventors imagination. They are now ubiquitos.

So change can evidently happen very very fast with few barriers left to be resolved.

Electric vehicles are starting to become a feasible option. Main barrier is range which is improving and will be solved through more numerous fast charging points and/or 5 minute replacement battery packs. Possibly induction charging loops under trunk raods and m-ways..

Many new vehicles in 10 years could be driverless - not everyone enjoys driving

In 20 years new build may be mandated to have charging points and/or PV cells. Public parking and work place parking may be similar.

Vehicle charging may use an Economy 7 type tarriff where base load demand is low.

The transition will be gradual - possibly over 10-12 years as existing vehicles reach end of life. Any conventional cars bought from around 2030 will rapidly become valueless as they fail to meet increasingly severe local emissions regimes.

But driving will become no cheaper - to recover lost tax revenues expect progressive changes in car tax and possibly road pricing.

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Sofa Spud

A couple of years ago I was saying on here that range-extender hybrids would become the norm in a few years' time. Now I think I'm wrong on that because the developments in pure battery electric cars have been so rapid that I think hybrids will be a short-lived stop-gap. as manufacturers are pouring their resources into developing pure electrics

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Bolt

A couple of years ago I was saying on here that range-extender hybrids would become the norm in a few years' time. Now I think I'm wrong on that because the developments in pure battery electric cars have been so rapid that I think hybrids will be a short-lived stop-gap. as manufacturers are pouring their resources into developing pure electrics

I think hybrids will stay as it will be the cheaper option than spending fortunes on charging points all over the country and building powerstations, which so far on the news I have only heard one MP mention.

its not been thought out properly as usual !

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Stanb Sevento

I think we are on the cusp of a radical change in transport and other technologies - not dissimilar to the electronics and media revolution.

23 years ago sat nav, internet, smart phones, online shopping etc etc were either in their infancy or a figment of the designer/inventors imagination. They are now ubiquitos.

So change can evidently happen very very fast with few barriers left to be resolved.

Electric vehicles are starting to become a feasible option. Main barrier is range which is improving and will be solved through more numerous fast charging points and/or 5 minute replacement battery packs. Possibly induction charging loops under trunk raods and m-ways..

Many new vehicles in 10 years could be driverless - not everyone enjoys driving

In 20 years new build may be mandated to have charging points and/or PV cells. Public parking and work place parking may be similar.

Vehicle charging may use an Economy 7 type tarriff where base load demand is low.

The transition will be gradual - possibly over 10-12 years as existing vehicles reach end of life. Any conventional cars bought from around 2030 will rapidly become valueless as they fail to meet increasingly severe local emissions regimes.

But driving will become no cheaper - to recover lost tax revenues expect progressive changes in car tax and possibly road pricing.

While in the main I agree the difference in this "revolution" is the vast investment in infrastructure required, it would take a push like the war effort to achieve this and we will need the will to pay for it. Tens of millions of us cant park at our house to charge a car. A commitment would need to be made and work started now but it's not risk free, if we commit to the current system it makes it very hard to change a few years down the road when a scientific breakthrough emerges making the current system redundant. Long term planning is like Russian roulette.

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Terry W

I think we are looking at a 20 year transition to electric. The costs will be barely noticeable against a reduced spend on the renewal of existing facilities as they would otherwise need to be refurbished or replaced:

  • planning rules can mandate a minimum number of charging points in domestic and business settings
  • to rovide further encouragement a transitional policy of a community charge credit could make it economic to retrofit charging points
  • recharging points could be given priority over parking only - a bit like disabled parking
  • central generating capacity will need upgrading. Even with their long lead times, 15-25 years will allow new capacity to be brought on line as required

I think we tend to underestimate the capacity of the private sector to respond to changing circumstances. We just need to create the right environment to encourage them.

  • 75% of petrol stations shut in last 40 years
  • Mobile phone masts non-existent 40 years ago. Patchy 20 years ago.
  • Number of coffee shops doubled in 10 years
Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - RT

I think we are looking at a 20 year transition to electric. The costs will be barely noticeable against a reduced spend on the renewal of existing facilities as they would otherwise need to be refurbished or replaced:

  • planning rules can mandate a minimum number of charging points in domestic and business settings
  • to rovide further encouragement a transitional policy of a community charge credit could make it economic to retrofit charging points
  • recharging points could be given priority over parking only - a bit like disabled parking
  • central generating capacity will need upgrading. Even with their long lead times, 15-25 years will allow new capacity to be brought on line as required

I think we tend to underestimate the capacity of the private sector to respond to changing circumstances. We just need to create the right environment to encourage them.

  • 75% of petrol stations shut in last 40 years
  • Mobile phone masts non-existent 40 years ago. Patchy 20 years ago.
  • Number of coffee shops doubled in 10 years

Planning rules specifying minimum number of parking spaces, let alone charging points, are ineffective in congested cities. Roadside parking will still be the norm, so local authorities would need to provide charge points every 4.8 metres along every urban road.

Motorway Service Areas would need EVERY space equipped for charging as well as over-size spaces for things like caravans and motorhomes.

Edited by RT on 27/07/2017 at 12:51

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - davecooper

Chris Evans made a good comment this morning, "the government are using natural evolution to set policy". How true.

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - The Gingerous One

And don't forget we'd need to have built all those vastly expensive nuclear power stations by then as well.

anyway, the chances of this happening are about the same as me being able to claim my state pension when I am 67.

All that will happen is that another government will come in and undo the legislation should it get passed, or change it in some other way. at the minute it's just government pub talk...

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Wayne Dibbley

Fusion power stations are the future.

A step up the evolutionary ladder for mankind.

I enjoy driving and look forward to electric vehicles becoming the norm.

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - madf

I have backup systems for our PCs as we used to have annual blackouts in winter. Now much less frequent .. but would I want to rely on a mode of transport totally dependent on the electricity supply?

One terrorist sofware bug and the economy is stuffed..

Do I want to rely on a sytem which depends on the Government (of any hue) making a decision in time on electricity generation? Based on history, it will be late and wrong...

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - Manatee

Interrupt the supply of petrol and diesel and it won't last long either. Panic buying means the stations sell out in hours.

Problem is the politicians can't bind their successors and the ones making this decision will either be retired or dedded by 2040.

Edited by Manatee on 27/07/2017 at 17:03

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - RT

Interrupt the supply of petrol and diesel and it won't last long either. Panic buying means the stations sell out in hours.

Problem is the politicians can't bind their successors and the ones making this decision will either be retired or dedded by 2040.

This latest statement doesn't even bind the present government, let alone the successors - it's just a target - like immigration numbers and reducing the national debt.

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - gordonbennet

- it's just a target - like immigration numbers and reducing the national debt.

seen through the wrong end of the binoculars then and pick numbers out of thin air depending if there's an election due

Only ZZZZ electric from 2040 - corax

One terrorist sofware bug and the economy is stuffed..

Central bankers and politicians want to move away from cash. I want something tangible in my pocket as a back up. We rely on computers and technology too much these days, it all relies on a power supply, who's to say it won't go belly up one day?

We may have all the modern aids but in some ways the quality of life has gone down.