cars that should be more popular - Mr Carrot Cake

My vote goes to the Suziki Swift. The 1.2 petrol engine can manage over 51mpg, and the newer Dualjet 1.2 can do 55mpg+ I believe.

cars that should be more popular - alan1302

My vote goes to the Suziki Swift. The 1.2 petrol engine can manage over 51mpg, and the newer Dualjet 1.2 can do 55mpg+ I believe.

Is the in real life or from the lab tests?

My Hyundai i10 1.2 can do around 50/51 mpg in normal driving.

I would have been interested in a Swift but they've made the boot tiny.

cars that should be more popular - skidpan

The Swift suffers from Suzuki's poor dealer coverage. On paper it ticked the boxes for us earlier this year but with the nearest dealer 15 miles away and part of a multi franchise site that has already proved itself to be incompetent when it serviced my Seat last year it was never considered further.

Since then a Suzuki dealer has opened in a "tent" on another dealers site only about 6 miles from home. So perhaps next time.

As for mpg figures I would have been very surprized if it could have done 50 mpg (or more) since its bigger, heavier and more powerful than the 1.2 Micra we had which did 44 mpg.

cars that should be more popular - Mr Carrot Cake

The Swift suffers from Suzuki's poor dealer coverage. On paper it ticked the boxes for us earlier this year but with the nearest dealer 15 miles away and part of a multi franchise site that has already proved itself to be incompetent when it serviced my Seat last year it was never considered further.

Since then a Suzuki dealer has opened in a "tent" on another dealers site only about 6 miles from home. So perhaps next time.

As for mpg figures I would have been very surprized if it could have done 50 mpg (or more) since its bigger, heavier and more powerful than the 1.2 Micra we had which did 44 mpg.

Well according to my dad's onboard computer it has managed over 51mpg average. I was quite surprised when I saw it. They are nice handling cars, the only thing I dont like about it is the road and engine noise is a bit high at speed. It would be good if they put a 6 speed gearbox in it, I think the 1.6 Sport has a 6 speed but not the 1.2

Edited by Mr Carrot Cake on 14/10/2015 at 14:19

cars that should be more popular - Halmerend
For the record my wife's Swift (1.2) shows around 50.8 mpg local driving. Fantastic little car albeit a bit unrefined compared to other small cars.

Been utterly reliable although passenger electric window switch has just failed at 4 years old.
cars that should be more popular - Mr Carrot Cake

My vote goes to the Suziki Swift. The 1.2 petrol engine can manage over 51mpg, and the newer Dualjet 1.2 can do 55mpg+ I believe.

Is the in real life or from the lab tests?

My Hyundai i10 1.2 can do around 50/51 mpg in normal driving.

I would have been interested in a Swift but they've made the boot tiny.

Real life. My dad has had one for over a year.

cars that should be more popular - Engineer Andy

55mpg might be achievable - I managed (admitedly with some careful driving and keeping to 60-65 on dual carriageways/motorways as much as safely possible) an average of 52mpg on my (first car) 1 ltr Nissan Micra (K11/1996 3dr) in more than one year (mixed driving), given the 'official' combined figure was, if I recall correctly, 47mpg.

I get 41-42mpg out of my current Mazda3 mk1 saloon 1.6p, again more than the 38mpg (not to be confused with the figures on HJ for the 'mk1' which actually refer to the updated mk1.5 version from mid 2006 which had better mpg/emissions but reduced performance [0.5sec slower to 60mph]) that the manufacturer's 'combined' figure states.

A lot of this is due to how light (or not) your right foot is (without being Captain Slow [I'm nowhere near that bad, as my mum will attest to]), the passenger/boot load (only me in my car most of the time and just a couple of small items carried) as well as length/type of journey.

cars that should be more popular - skidpan

Well according to my dad's onboard computer it has managed over 51mpg average. I was quite surprised when I saw it.

And there is the problem. You believe the dash display. They have a tendency to lie.

My experiences:

Seat Leon - Dash says 49 mpg, real life calculated 45 mpg.

BMW 118D - Dash said 53 mpg, real life calculated 48 mpg.

Ford Focus 1.6 TDCi - Dash said 48 mpg, real life calculated 44 mpg.

Golf GTi - Dash said 45 mpg, real life calculated 35 mpg.

But some are close, the Micra was pretty much spot on and the Kia Ceed slightly under read.

Do several brim to brim fill ups in normal use, use a pencil and paper to calculate teh mpg and report back.

cars that should be more popular - Avant

You're right, Skidpan - they do vary, even on the same model of car. The average mpg reading on my last two Octavias was about 3 mpg optimistic in each case, whereas the current one is accurate, as tested several times by comparison with brim-to-brim filling.

Would any technical experts care to give an opinion as to why they vary so much? You'd think that the technology would be pretty similar.

cars that should be more popular - SteveLee

Anything without a German badge deserves to be more popular.

cars that should be more popular - Sofa Spud

Anything without a German badge deserves to be more popular.

For example Seat, Skoda, Bentley, Lamborghini, Bugatti, Mini, Rolls-Royce !!!

cars that should be more popular - Big John

My 2006 fiat Panda 1.2 is about 3mpg optimistic on the on board computer

My old 2003 Superb I 1.9 pd was 4mpg pessimistic

My current 2014 Superb II 1.4tsi is fairly accurate

Under the same driving the Superb 1.4 is more economical than the Panda (calculated!)

Edited by Big John on 14/10/2015 at 23:00

cars that should be more popular - Engineer Andy

I'm wondering whether the same people who program the trip computers also did the -ahem- 'engine mapping' on certain cars? A possible pattern here? :-)

cars that should be more popular - Mr Carrot Cake

Golf GTi - Dash said 45 mpg, real life calculated 35 mpg.

LOL

cars that should be more popular - KenC

Ref Suzuki Swift (your dads)

Can you tell me anything about the tyre wear ?

Some of the early swifts had a poor reputation for excessive tyre wear

and the the alloywheel tyre size fitted were strangely expensive

cars that should be more popular - Mr Carrot Cake

Tyre size for the 16 inch alloys is 185/55 R16. They do not appear to be overly expensive.

cars that should be more popular - Big John

On the original topic of cars that should be more popular. I must be nuts - I really liked my 1973 Austin Allegro(sorry!!) - although it was a 1750 Super Sport - Really grunty engine (was also used in Maxi), had a 5 speed box (nearly unheard of then) , had fantastic seats and did 40mpg on a run (good power to weight ration, SU carb and 5 speed) - oh and a cam chain!

Saying that you needed to turn up the stereo at the traffic lights to drown out the noise of munching rust!

Edited by Big John on 14/10/2015 at 23:08

cars that should be more popular - SteveLee

On the original topic of cars that should be more popular. I must be nuts - I really liked my 1973 Austin Allegro(sorry!!) - although it was a 1750 Super Sport - Really grunty engine (was also used in Maxi), had a 5 speed box (nearly unheard of then) , had fantastic seats and did 40mpg on a run (good power to weight ration, SU carb and 5 speed) - oh and a cam chain!

Saying that you needed to turn up the stereo at the traffic lights to drown out the noise of munching rust!

My Allegro 1750 Equipe gave a few hotted-up Ford Escort drivers a scare or two at the traffic light GP!

cars that should be more popular - Avant

That 1750 engine was a good one, especially in twin-carbiurettor form- I had two Maxis which both did high mileages in my hands without trouble.

It was a pity that the Allegro was such a missed opportunity for BL. After the pretty, popular 1100/1300 it was dumpy and unattractive to look at, and should have been the hatchback that customers were starting to want. Having set the trend with the Maxi, they failed to follow it up, and VW cleaned up with the Golf.

cars that should be more popular - groaver

Suzuki Kisashi?

Admittedly a 2.4 petrol engine with a CVT box isn't going to win many fleet awards.

It was a pretty well finished and good handling car.

www.honestjohn.co.uk/topten/top-10-forgotten-cars-...8

A bit harsh with the, "average build quality and a less than average driving experience, to put it kindly."

Cheap plastics do not make average build quality.

Edited by groaver on 16/10/2015 at 18:43

cars that should be more popular - Mr Carrot Cake

Suzuki Kisashi?

Admittedly a 2.4 petrol engine with a CVT box isn't going to win many fleet awards.

It was a pretty well finished and good handling car.

www.honestjohn.co.uk/topten/top-10-forgotten-cars-...8

A bit harsh with the, "average build quality and a less than average driving experience, to put it kindly."

Cheap plastics do not make average build quality.

It looks quite nice. Don't think I've ever seen one.

cars that should be more popular - Engineer Andy

Didn't even see one at my local (combined) Mazda/Suzuki dealership. I wouldn't be surprised if they sold less of them in the UK than the MG6. Looks ok-ish on the outside, typical cheapo-grey plastic on the inside, but not terrible, just, well, bland.

That, plus below par handling, thirst for petrol (and no diesel version) and the hefty price tag/VED band (high CO2 figure) and cheaper and/or far better alternatives meant this car was doomed from the get-go. You can see why they sold it in the US (though, I bet, at a much cheaper price) - it fits right in with their home-grown naff cars they like buying.

cars that should be more popular - daveyK_UK

Van based MPV's are alot more popular on mainland europe than the UK.

Excellent value for money.

cars that should be more popular - groaver

Didn't even see one at my local (combined) Mazda/Suzuki dealership. I wouldn't be surprised if they sold less of them in the UK than the MG6. Looks ok-ish on the outside, typical cheapo-grey plastic on the inside, but not terrible, just, well, bland.

That, plus below par handling, thirst for petrol (and no diesel version) and the hefty price tag/VED band (high CO2 figure) and cheaper and/or far better alternatives meant this car was doomed from the get-go. You can see why they sold it in the US (though, I bet, at a much cheaper price) - it fits right in with their home-grown naff cars they like buying.

"Few are likely to discover as much, but Suzuki has blessed the Kizashi with excellent handling. Taut and responsive yet quite refined and compliant with it, it would give this car an entirely convincing selling point as a provider of affordable driver thrills were it not for the shortcomings of the powertrain."

Autocar thought it handled well as did a few other reviewers.

"It feels very together. The Sport suspension package includes 18in rims and 10mm lower ride height, yet the Kizashi four-door feels composed on all but the bobbliest road surfaces."

Car

Agree entirely that they killed it with the powertrain.

cars that should be more popular - NorthernBoy

Any one got a Dacia?

The seems too cheap to be true????

cars that should be more popular - balleballe

I've seen a few around. Apparently they had some serious rust issues, don't know if that's resolved now.

cars that should be more popular - Avant

All covered in car-by-car reviews (of the Dacia Duster) on this site. After September 2014 production of UK-bound Dusters was moved to Romania from India, and I don't think there has been a rust problem since.

I see quite a lot of Dusters on the road - a cheap 4x4 is attractive in our rural area - but not many Sanderos or Logans.

cars that should be more popular - alan1302

Any one got a Dacia?

The seems too cheap to be true????

It's all tried and tested Renault mechanicals underneath and there doesn't seem to be many reviews reporting much in the way of problems.

Think there biggest problem is many people will be put off by the badge on the front.

cars that should be more popular - daveyK_UK

Rust issue only affected Indian built Dusters, easy to tell the difference between Indian and Romania built Dusters -Romanian build has the new front grille.

New Duster due out in 2016, im 90% certain I will order one if they put a decent petrol engine in it.

cars that should be more popular - Trilogy

A shame the Maxi engine was so harsh.

Harris Mann designed the Allegro beautifully, however, BL ruined the proportions when they decided they wanted to fit the 1500//1750 engine in addition to the 1100/1300................so I've read elsewhere.

cars that should be more popular - 72 dudes

My vote goes to the Citroen C5 (2008 on).

The magazines raved about it when it came out, but now it's regarded as a quirky also-ran.

I've driven two with the 2.0 HDi (138) engine and they were excellent. Good quality materials inside and put together almost as well as a German brand.

The ones I tried (VTR+) had the steel springs, not the Hydropneumatic system, yet the ride was sublime and the handling, whilst not as sharp as a Mondeo, was fine.

Massive step up from the original C5 - I had a 2001 2.2 HDi.

In the end I opted for a Volvo S40, the unwarranted depreciation on the C5 was too high.

cars that should be more popular - NorthernBoy

The Triumph Acclaim - have any been saved from the scrapyard over the years???? www.jenningsforddirect.co.uk/blog/the-last-triumph.../

cars that should be more popular - Avant

One from the Dept of Useless Information:

The German for Triumph Acclaim is.......Sieg Heil.

cars that should be more popular - Sofa Spud

I would have said a year ago that electric cars should be more popular, but now they are rapidly gaining popularity.

cars that should be more popular - alan1302

I would have said a year ago that electric cars should be more popular, but now they are rapidly gaining popularity.

They have sold about 7,000 up to September 2015 - think they have a long way to go before they can be seen as popular.

cars that should be more popular - John Boy

Northern Boy asked "The Triumph Acclaim - have any been saved from the scrapyard over the years????"

It looks like it:

www.carandclassic.co.uk/list/41/acclaim/

cars that should be more popular - Sofa Spud

I would have said a year ago that electric cars should be more popular, but now they are rapidly gaining popularity.

They have sold about 7,000 up to September 2015 - think they have a long way to go before they can be seen as popular.

90,000 Tesla Model S sold worldwide so far, and more than twice that many Nissan Leaf. The Tesla Model S was recently the top selling car in Norway with over 1400 sold in one month.

Edited by Sofa Spud on 24/10/2015 at 00:10

cars that should be more popular - alan1302

I would have said a year ago that electric cars should be more popular, but now they are rapidly gaining popularity.

They have sold about 7,000 up to September 2015 - think they have a long way to go before they can be seen as popular.

90,000 Tesla Model S sold worldwide so far, and more than twice that many Nissan Leaf. The Tesla Model S was recently the top selling car in Norway with over 1400 sold in one month.

Like I said - still a way to go until they are seen as popular - more Ford Fiestas get sold in the UK per year than tesla sell worldwide.

cars that should be more popular - Mr Carrot Cake

The Triumph Acclaim - have any been saved from the scrapyard over the years???? www.jenningsforddirect.co.uk/blog/the-last-triumph.../

My dad had a Triumph Acclaim back in the day. It was quite fast due to its light weight.

cars that should be more popular - buspasser

Sales of electric cars in Norway get rather favourable treatment

"Among the existing incentives in Norway, all-electric cars are exempt from all non-recurring vehicle fees, including purchase taxes, which are extremely high for ordinary cars, and 25% VAT on purchase, together making an electric car purchase price competitive with that of a similarly sized conventional car. Electric vehicles are also exempt from the annual road tax, all public parking fees, and toll payments, as well as being able to use bus lanes"

Not surprising people are buying them