BMW 1 Series - Petrol bmw high mileage avoid or not? - Gav37
Looking at buying a (57) BMW 1 SERIES HATCHBACK 116i SE 5dr [Dynamic] . It's done 90,000 miles. I'm a bit unsure about the high mileage on the petrol engine? Also anything else to look out for? Thanks
BMW 1 Series - Petrol bmw high mileage avoid or not? - RobJP

If you go to the top of the page, there's a whole section of the website devoted to reviews. Not just test-drives, but entire reviews of faults, problems, owner reviews, what's good/bad, what modifications were made to cars throughout their production.

The lot, basically.

BMW 1 Series - Petrol bmw high mileage avoid or not? - RobJP

And if you cannot be bothered finding the facts In my opinion I would avoid like the plague run a mile forget you have ever seen it the vehicle has the chance to bankrupt you.

Utterly unhelpful comment, as usual. Any 8-9 year old vehicle can go horribly wrong. A moderately easily-engineered 4-cylinder petrol engined car won't 'bankrupt you' to fix.

BMW 1 Series - Petrol bmw high mileage avoid or not? - Gav37

Thanks for the feedback. I've looked at all the reviews and just wanted to hear if anyone had a high mileage petrol BMW or if anyone had a bad experince getting past the 100,000 mark.

I've always owned Audis & VW diesels, kept them well maintained and got 150,000 with no major problems.

Thanks again, don't be falling out now.

BMW 1 Series - Petrol bmw high mileage avoid or not? - RobJP

It's OK. Llos was on here on another username in the past.

I'll let you judge for yourself as to why he is now here under another pseudonym.

BMW 1 Series - Petrol bmw high mileage avoid or not? - Avant

Welcome to the forum, Gav. HJ's review of the 1-series, which Rob helpfully refers you to, shows that this car is no worse than many for reliabilty and better than quite a few.

Personally if I were buying a car of that age I'd go for something Japanese and petrol-powered (better chance of getting a good one), but the mileage on this 1-series isn't unreasonable for a car that's coming up for 8 years old. Do make sure that it's got a full service history, and walk away if it hasn't.

As moderator I'm sorry that you received such an unhelpful, useless comment from 'Llos'. He was here as Collos25 up until some time last year and then left us: I have no idea why he's come back, but he seems as unhelpful as before.

Llos, someone has already complained to us by E-mail about your post on this thread. In future if anyone reports a post of yours as offensive, I will simply delete it. You may find some other motoring forum more to your taste.

BMW 1 Series - Petrol bmw high mileage avoid or not? - John F

I have always been somewhat irrationally prejudiced against BMWs. They seem to tune their engines to be just a little bit more powerful and edgy than their competitors. Their acronym is well known among used car buyers for translating to 'big money worries'. People do seem to have had to spend a lot on them, what with their history of chain failures, grotty cylinder liners, crumbly heads etc. I suspect BMW garage owners are some of the wealthiest in the land.

I would stick with what you know has served you well unless its a new company car which you will offload after 4yrs at the most, in which case a nippy bimmer is just the thing!

BMW 1 Series - Petrol bmw high mileage avoid or not? - gordonbennet

I have always been somewhat irrationally prejudiced against BMWs. They seem to tune their engines to be just a little bit more powerful and edgy than their competitors.

Thats a very fair point, something my son and i were discussing only last week, not BMW's as neither of us is particularly impressed nor desirous of the marque (though i bitterly regret not snapping up a low mileage and most unsual tan leather/wood spec E39 M5 a few years ago for a very fair price), but the opposite method of tuning being for long life.

In my sons chequered car past only two cars survived his youthful unceasing hammering, both Hyundais, one a Accent MVi, the other a Coupe F2, these cars took everything he threw at them and lived to be sold on.

Hyundais if you look at their specs don't provide massive BHP figures from their engines for a given size, but you don't hear about the regular failures that plague not long out of warranty examples of other premium makes.

Maybe this is part of the reason Hyundai can offer 5 year unlimited mileage warranties and the others won't.can't, Hyundai know their engines are tuned for a long life and not necessarily for maximum power.

I'm not suggesting Hyundai are in direct competition with BMW, far from it, just an example of two polar opposites in design.

BMW 1 Series - Petrol bmw high mileage avoid or not? - Avant

I think what John says is truer of the smaller-capacity BMW fours than the larger, relatively unstressed sixes. When I sold my 2.2 straight-six Z3 it was 12 years old and still as healthy as ever. It had lots of torque and pulled from low revs as well as any diesel; whereas the fours seem to be at their best when given plenty of revs - leading possibly to faster engine wear.

BMW 1 Series - Petrol bmw high mileage avoid or not? - slkfanboy

I have own 3xAudi 1xBMW 1xMerc 1xVolvo 4xFord 1xHonda & 3xVW and can say the BMW I did 150K in 3 years with one new clutch being need. Servicing costs around the same on all execept ford (slightly cheaper). Merc/Volvo i did lower milages but had no issues. Interesting Honda/VW had number of issues and Audi having the most issues. Dealer wise the VW dealers showed little interest in my issues others all seam ok.

BMW 1 Series - Petrol bmw high mileage avoid or not? - skidpan

Hyundais if you look at their specs don't provide massive BHP figures from their engines for a given size,

Don't agree with that comment. The specs below are for cars of the vintage the OP is looking at.

Hyundai i30 1.4 petrol, 109 PS (78 PS/litre)

Hyundai i30 1.6 petrol, 126 PS (79 PS/litre)

BMW 116i 1.6 petrol, 122 PS (76 PS/litre)

In about 2010 the 116i was fitted with a 2.0 engine producing 122 PS (exactly the same as the 2007 1.6) meaning only 61 PS/litre.

Both Hyundais are more highly tuned than similar sized BMW's.

I have driven both 116i's and found a 2008 116i with the 1.6 engine to be complete slug with no torque whatsoever. However, a 2010 116i fitted with the 2.0 was a totally different animal, punchy low down with no need to rev the nuts off it, was very tempted at the time but kept my 118d.

Not driven any Hyundai petrols but have driven 1.6 Kia petrols in Ceeds which are essentially the same. To get any decent performance you need to rev the nuts off it, no low down torque. This is not a critisism of Hyundai/Kia, in my experience it applies to all similar engines from all makes.

That is why my car has a turbo 1.4 and the wifes a supercharged 1.2. Better drivability, better economy and in my 1.4 turbo incredible performance with no need to thrash it.

BMW 1 Series - Petrol bmw high mileage avoid or not? - John F

There has been such progress in the last 10-20yrs in metals, machining and oil that even small revvy engines seem to be durable as long as they remain leak-proof. I expect our 15yr old Focus 100PS 1.6 Zetec to last for ever (even its cambelt ;-). It's quite nippy enough for SWMBO. What I'd really like to know is how durable the new generation of turboed 3cyl engines are. These seem to be the future for small cars.