How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - keeron

Hi guys, i need your help please.

So, im basically a few days away from registering as a business with HMRC & Companies house. (Im going self-employed as a motor trader). I have Trade Insurance, Capital & money to fund start up costs, aswell as a garage sorted out and will have Trade Plates & stock to sell also(obvious)..

But there is one last hurdle to jump and another pain in the ass to sort out, which is basically proving that each car i sell is roadworthy, im hearing more and more stories that buyers buy a car that the seller claims is roadworthy and then returns it a few days or even a few weeks later, claiming the car is knackered and not fit for road and then eventually going to court, ringing the police, etc.

I know im going to face problems but this just sounds like one of the biggest problems i will face due to dishonest buyers, nevermind dishonest sellers or dealers lol... I want to prove in paper that each of my cars are roadworthy. An MOT is not enough. What do you suggest... A service ? A manufacturer service ???

Im just trying to be as legit as i can and sell roadworthy cars, but need paper or physical evidence that my cars are roadworthy, so no buyer can try and play games or mess me about and ask for refunds on cars i sold as roadworthy and perfectly fine when i sold them.

Thanks...

Edited by keeron on 15/09/2014 at 21:37

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - Mike H

Not sure what you are getting at here. The MOT test certifies that a car is roadworthy at the time the MOT was undertaken, but you're claiming that this is not enough. What more do you want?

Edited by Mike H on 15/09/2014 at 22:47

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - gordonbennet

I expect you'll soon develop that shrewed people judging skill that most good dealers have.

If a waddling quacker comes into your place, and you realise pretty quickly its a duck, then like any sensible person you'll make sure you don't sell anything to it.

If you deal fairly and pleasantly with decent people then the odd time it goes wrong should pale to annoyance level only.

Edited by gordonbennet on 15/09/2014 at 22:57

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - oldroverboy.

I suggest you read some of tony g,s posts.

just out of curiosity do you have any motor trade experience?

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - RobJP

Much like an MOT, an inspection will only 'prove' that a car was roadworthy at the time of inspection. It's entirely possible for anything to break on a car a week later, whether that's an exhaust mounting bracket, or a shock absorber, or a turbocharger, or .... you get the picture, I'm sure.

I'd strongly suggest you go and read some of the online consumer guides from trading standards, or those by HJ on here.

You certainly won't be able to turn round to a customer with a broken-down car and say 'it was fine when it left here, here's the inspection report to prove it, so go away', you have a liability in law to ensure that goods you supply last for a 'reasonable time'. Exactly what constitutes a 'reasonable time' is variable. You'll see some people saying 6 years, which is a load of nonsense. What the law says is that if someone comes back to you within 6 years, then YOU have to look at it and see whether it is reasonable for the goods to last that long or not. Price, and the age of the car, are both major factors in determining what is 'reasonable'.

For example, if you sell a 3 year old car to someone for £10k, their expectations, and the time that the car is expected to be fault-free, will be a lot higher than for a 14 year old, £999 car. They can 'reasonably expect' the 3 year old car to be fully working in every detail, whereas the 12 year old one may have non-working aircon, or non-workng parking sensors, etc.

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - barney100

don't the RAC inspect cars so you can be much urer the car is ok. No guarantees of cours but it tips the balance in your favour.

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - brighteyes
I'm not sure what insurance an AA/RAC inspection offers, it would be worth looking at bearing in mind the cost to you, which I would guess other dealers tag on the price of the car. Another option is to offer the prospective buyer the opportunity to have the car inspected by an independent of their choice but again the approximate cost being built into the "windscreen price". I would hope that this would at least offer both you and the buyer a come back if anything drastic went wrong in the first few months. On the other hand some may say the onus is on you to buy "sound" cars in the first place. As the majority of indie car dealers buy their cars from auctions or as trade ins you always stand a chance of getting a lemon, so "buyer beware" applies as much to you as to your customers.
How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - Andrew-T

I would have thought that if you intend to set up in business selling 'guaranteed roadworthy' vehicles, you may be making life harder for yourself? Not many traders would risk making such a challengeable assertion IMHO. Naturally any buyers would hope that a car they buy is 'roadworhy' (as you would when buying), and probably most of them are. The problem is when one becomes un-roadworthy a week later. No-one can sell cars guaranteed roadworthy for X months afterwards.

A long-established trader in Northwich advertises an association with Cheshire Trading Standards (there are others), which may add credibility. I have bought from them twice over the years and had no complaints.

Edited by Andrew-T on 16/09/2014 at 11:39

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - skidpan

I suspect form the OP's original questions they have little knowledge of the used car trade.

If that is correct my only suggestion is to forget about your enterprise until you have gained some.

But then again perhaps I am miss reading the OP's first post and maybe they are experienced and are really looking for a way to avoid paying our for any issues that arise with cars after purchase.

If that is the case perhaps its yet another rogue trader wanting to appear legit.

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - keeron

Hi there guys thanks for tyring to help.

I have only about 1 years motor trade experience, who im working with has about 25 years experience with cars(mechanic), but not with the ins and outs of trading. What Im talking about is, is there any way to prevent dodgy buyers falsely claiming the car is unroadworthy 1 week later when the car was fully roadworthy when i sold it.. Im only saying this because, many people on different forums have said this has happened to them and this is one of the last problems on my list, that i will have to face when going into business, i never knew this was such an issue, which is why im trying to troubleshoot it before i start selling.

Im only going to be buying cars from 2003 - 2007, not too old and not too new. Im mostly buying cars right now as soon as i start trading from 2003 - 2005, so they are fairly old.

But the cars will be made sure they are roadworthy and sold with 12 months MOT, but within 3 months anything can happen. i grant that 1 week and then the car legitamately has severe faults then that is the traders issue, but at 3 months , how is that the trader's fault ?

I think to save hassle and time i can guarantee 3 months free mechanic, so we fix any problems with the car, but yet again some people will just abuse this and try and get anything fixed that is not legitimate.

My original question was basically saying that i have sorted everything else out, and i am trying to minimise problems by trying to prove the car is roadworthy even though we know it is, i just want to guarantee that my car is roadworthy, i know i cant prove its roadworthy for the next 6 months, but i mean if the car is fine when i sold it then that is all i can do ??

Im just trying to run a legitimate business.. Thats all.

Edited by keeron on 16/09/2014 at 12:40

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - RobJP

You're selling cars that are up to 11 years old - things WILL break on them that YOU will be liable to fix.

The best suggestion I can make is to have all your MOTs done at council MOT garages. That, and learn rapidly how to be a good judge of character, so you can fob off the timewasters and comedians.

However, I struggle to see how someone is going to come back to you a week later and say that a car is unroadworthy (if you have sold them a roadworthy car). They can't just SAY that it's unroadworthy, they have to say WHAT is wrong with it.

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - redcard

What Im talking about is, is there any way to prevent dodgy buyers falsely claiming the car is unroadworthy 1 week later when the car was fully roadworthy when i sold it..

I'm no expert, but I don't think this is something you really need to worry about. People generally want to just want to get what they paid for.

Do you think they're going to intentionally break it then come back for their £1,250?

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - keeron

I guess im being paranoid in thinking like this. I guess im reading too many forum posts where this has happened and sellers are acting like buyers are intentionally breaking things..

And thanks rob..

I also never thought of someone bringing a car back after a week, until i started reading up on this happening ..

Everyones input is really helping .. thanks..

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - RobJP

Just remember that forums aren't really representative of real life. Most people only come onto forums like this when they've got problems (apart from those of us who like to help out, where we can). If you purely looked at forums, you'd expect every VAG with a 2.0diesel engine and a DSG box to be parked up on the hard shoulder, all the time.You'd expect BMWs to be throwing timing chains up and down the country, causing chaos to traffic reports.

Hondas and Toyotas would be serenely passing them by, their owners knowing that even though their cars were 10 years old, and with no service history, the manufacturer would fix any problems for free ... allegedly.

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - Andrew-T

I also never thought of someone bringing a car back after a week, until i started reading up on this happening ..

Everyones input is really helping .. thanks..

You keep using the description 'roadworthy'. As I understand it, roadworthiness should be proved by a recent MoT certificate (which should come from a reliable source). If you satisfy yourself that your vehicles are OK, it should be hard for a buyer to claim otherwise. I would guess your problems will come from buyers who find the aircon doesn't work or the sunroof leaks, or something else that has nothing to do with roadworthiness, and may be an excuse to dispose of a car they find they don't really like. You will try very hard to avoid those, so I wish you luck.

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - madf

A long-established trader in Northwich advertises an association with Cheshire Trading Standards (there are others), which may add credibility. I have bought from them twice over the years and had no complaints.

I have bought form them. They were excellent. The car has been 100% reliable over 11 years..

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - tony g
( But there is one last hurdle to jump and another pain in the ass to sort out, which is basically proving that each car i sell is roadworthy, im hearing more and more stories that buyers buy a car that the seller claims is roadworthy and then returns it a few days or even a few weeks later, claiming the car is knackered and not fit for road and then eventually going to court, ringing the police, etc.)

Hi keeron, I'm a motor trader dealing in exactly the same stock as you describe ,I've been in the trade for about fourty years working for franchised dealers ,used car dealers and selling for myself ,most forum members would agree I'm qualified to comment .

So having said that ,I have to say your worried about something that just doesn't happen .

You must make sure to the best of your knowledge and belief that any car your selling is both roadworthy and in reasonable condition ,checking safety related items brakes , lights etc should always be a priority . I only sell cars that have a new mot .its an automatic defence if you genuinely sell an unroadworthy car.

If it does happen that you sell an unsafe car you have the right to involve the garage that did the mot for you .

Basically buyers of cars in the £2k to £5k market may shout and bluster about suing ,involving trading standards ,solicitors etc .It very rarely happens ,it never has to me .

The main thing to be aware of , is that consumer law is subjective ,the idea that a car has to have a 1 month ,1 year ,6 year warranty etc is nonsense .simply sort the cars out ,before you offer them to the public .

Finally present your cars properly ,the cars must have a good quality valet ,if a buyer makes an appointment to view make sure that the car will start on the first turn of the key,give it a coat of polish before they arrive ,tyre sheen on the wheels improves the look of a car .

Your opting to join a tough and complicated business ,if your any way near West Yorkshire ,let me know and we can perhaps get together and I could help with more information .

Good luck with your venture

Tonyg



How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - keeron

hi tony !! thanks alot for the input..

I think i have now worked out my problem and ive just decided to offer 6 months warranty for all vehicles i sell, provided by someone like warranty wise or another company that provides warranty.. This saves hassle on both my part and the buyers.

Do you think this is a good option Tony ? To get warranty and just pay for the warranty cost, but make sure i still make enough profit ?

Is warrantywise a good company or should i look around more, specifally warranty for car traders etc. ??

Thanks again guys!! I Really appreciate all the help. Thanks rob..

Edited by keeron on 16/09/2014 at 14:54

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - RobJP

The problem if using an external warranty is if something breaks down that is NOT covered by the warranty (and we hear stories on here all the time about things not covered by warranties), YOU are still liable for the repairs. In addition, you're sending a nice large chunk of your profit to the warranty company.

You've said that you've got a good mechanic. I'd be more inclined to take the job on with any warranty work myself, if possible.

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - keeron

hmm, ok..

So i need to make sure what is and what isnt covered by the warranty. And if its not covered by a warranty i am still responsible for repairs ? wow, there is not easy way around this lol! .

Im going to have to get the facts on what i will have to repair if anything does go wrong in the sales of goods act etc... For example, the cars i am selling are no newer than 2007, so my cars will eventually have wear and tear, and faults with them.

But i guess, the fact that i am giving the customer a warranty which i am paying for out of my own money, then i guess they are less likely to be an awkward customer, like trying to take me to court other stupid things i dont have the time for..

I can only try and make sure my cars will last, but this is literally impossible, as we have no control on how the customer drives or what will go wrong with it in the future. If my 2004 plate car is roadyworthy with 12 months MOT and 6 months warranty, then i am less likely to recieve an hassle, that i would if i sold a car with 3 months mot and no warranty..

Every time ive bought a car 7+ years old and something went wrong ive never took it back to the seller, because its a car!! What do people expect ? lol.. But i can also get most problems fixed without going to a garage, but still what do buyers expect from a 7-10 year old car?... All i can offer is a roadworthy car with a new MOT, 6 months warranty and i will throughly test my cars to make sure they are above average for the age.

For example, ive just bought a VW Polo 53 plate with only one previous owner and 80k miles. And is in great condition its only got minor scratches and one bit of rust, were going to get the one piece of rust out, remove the swirl marks and remove as many scratches, polish it up, get it through its MOT, give it a service and re sell it with 6 months warranty.


Edited by keeron on 16/09/2014 at 16:25

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - Andrew-T

I can only try and make sure my cars will last, but this is literally impossible, as we have no control on how the customer drives or what will go wrong with it in the future.

And you certainly have no control over what has already happened to the car - which you may or may not be able to discover. Setting a lower age limit of 7 years must make selection quite tricky.

I would second others' advice about warranties. Many customers expect them, but even though you will up your price to allow for the cost, those companies only provide cover to make money - some of it yours. I don't think you should buy warranties if you intend to fix faults yourself within any warranty period.

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - tony g
(I think i have now worked out my problem and ive just decided to offer 6 months warranty for all vehicles i sell, provided by someone like warranty wise or another company that provides warranty.. This saves hassle on both my part and the buyers.

Do you think this is a good option Tony ? To get warranty and just pay for the warranty cost, but make sure i still make enough profit ?)

Hi keeron ,
Don't put to much faith in warranties ,I use warranties 2000 from leeds ,a three month warranty costs very little from them , and covers very little ,but it does satisfy a car buyers need for a warranty . No warranty will cover ware and tare items ,the way to deal with warranty claims is give a buyer the three months warranty as above ,if he has a problem your confident is genuine then repair it at your expense .

Don't worry about the law and consumer rights ,trading standards and citizens advice are both ineffective and only get involved in extreme cases of mis selling .

Just try to be fair and reasonable with buyers ,if your confident a buyers trying it on tell him to see a solicitor ,they never do .
How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - keeron

Ok, thanks mate.. Im local to leeds, so i may check out warranties 2000.

My mind is alot clearer now, i guess i was overthinking things, but its better to know what to do in certain situations instead of not preparing for things like customers wanting returns or repairs etc...

Edited by keeron on 16/09/2014 at 23:26

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - bathtub tom

>>,tyre sheen on the wheels improves the look of a car .

Personally, that's one thing that puts me off a car, along with that shiny silicon cleaner they put on dashboards and engines. If a car's clean and polished, with a clean interior and a relatively clean engine, then to me it looks 'honest'.

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - Andrew-T

>>,tyre sheen on the wheels improves the look of a car .

Personally, that's one thing that puts me off a car, along with that shiny silicon cleaner they put on dashboards and engines. If a car's clean and polished, with a clean interior and a relatively clean engine, then to me it looks 'honest'.

I'll second that, Tom. Shiny tyres just look like an attempt to cover up, or distract attention from something else.

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - tony g
Used tyres on a car are always stained from use ,mud etc leaves them looking scruffy and detracts from the look of a car .silicone type tyre sheen applied the day before a viewing , makes the tyres look new . The black tyre paint looks wrong as it stays permanently shiny .

Again interior silicone spray is ok ,providing it's applied lightly and then gone over with a lint free cloth ,it leaves the interior clean and smelling fresh .
How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - keeron

Regarding tyre shine, i honestly prefer car tyres to be black, rather than faded, muddy or worn. If a first car buyer or young male or even female was buying, then having black and shiny tyres could help with the sale from a cosmetic view and first impressions of the whole car.

But saying that, i prefer the cars i buy to have terrible looking tyres, so i can get the price down :) or so it reduces the price of the car overall... On the cars i drive i like to keep my tyres black with tyre shine. But thats just me.

And as a trader, i will clean the tyres before any car viewing or sale. This is just me, i like to get the car looking as good as possible when a buyer is interested. I can see as a car trader or dealer how it could make you think they are hiding other problems by making the car look cosmetically better, but at the same time a buyer wants the car to look as good as it can if they are paying top dollar for a car.

Edited by keeron on 16/09/2014 at 23:37

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - Andrew-T

And as a trader, i will clean the tyres before any car viewing or sale. This is just me, i like to get the car looking as good as possible when a buyer is interested. I can see as a car trader or dealer how it could make you think they are hiding other problems by making the car look cosmetically better, but at the same time a buyer wants the car to look as good as it can if they are paying top dollar for a car.

As a very occasional buyer I am not put off by seeing a car in unvaleted condition - it gives me a chance to look under the rear seats or spare wheel, places which are often passed over. But of course I expect a clean car when I collect.

If you as a trader have enough spare time to prep every car before it goes on display, you may be missing trading opportunities. And you may have wasted time (and a bit of cash) on a car which doesn't sell...

How to prove a car is roadworthy in the UK ? - keeron

If you as a trader have enough spare time to prep every car before it goes on display, you may be missing trading opportunities. And you may have wasted time (and a bit of cash) on a car which doesn't sell...

yeah that's true..