Skoda - Any suggestions a next second hand car please? - VW Whatnext

My husband and I both have back problems and now edging 70s My VW Golf GT Tdi is brilliant on fuel and was purchased second hand. We now need to get a replacement as we are both 'tumbling' out or finding back ache on long journeys so a more raised seat would be so good.

I would appreciate any advice on what has worked for some of you. Our first stumbling block or advantage? is my husband was a HGV mechanic so wants to do as much servicing/repairs as he can. Hence hates price of parts, etc, etc. but likes to find parts easy to obtain.

We live in the countryside and have 2 cars, and although a 'luxury,' it does mean neither of us have to be back if the other one needs the car. We may only do 5k miles a year.

Our decision is for my OH to do up his Morris Minor as his car and the next one to be suitable for both of us. His car at moment is a Ford maverick - great for countryside and getting in and out - poor for running costs. So the plans are to let this one go when we have found the VW replacement. I thought a Skoda Yeti would be good but price - I think it is not justified for us at moment and maybe when they become 'second hand'. Hence we are both of the view we do not want to buy new.

So we are looking to spend around £7k maximum have you any thoughts?

Edited by VW Whatnext on 22/06/2014 at 15:22

Skoda - Any suggestions a next second hand car please? - gordonbennet

One make spings to mind here, especially seeing as your husband is a (presumably retired) former HGV mech, thats Subaru, so Forester or Outback.

Apart from spark plug changes (flat 4/6 engines very awkward for this) these Subies are made to be fixed in the field, better than virtually anything else made now for self maintenance IMO, i recently bought a 100k 2002 Outback H6 and have just finished going right through it, hopefully making it last for many years to come, the car is a pleasure to work on, even down to having three dipsticks under the bonnet, yes and one behind the wheel.

Parts have been no bother at all via the net (£134 for Mintex pads and discs all round), the only sting in the tail with Subies is exhausts, these are simply scandalous prices, so when that fails it will be a custom made stainless jobbie..

..though i dare say your husbands old workmates could soon knock one up for him out of old scaffold pipes..:-)

Skoda - Any suggestions a next second hand car please? - Avant

It's difficult to give you reliable advice, as what's comfortable for one person may not be for another. Also we've found that a higher seat isn't always the answer, as there's also the distance between door sill and seat to think about. My wife has an arthritic knee, and an Audi Q3 was no easier for her to get in and out of when we tried one than her current Mini Roadster; and my Octavia vRS is easier than either.

The only thing to do is to try various cars in the showroom, and test drive the ones that seem comfortable to sit in and get into and out of. Put a Volvo on your shortlist (most people agree that Volvos have some of the most supportive seats in the business), and also the Ford C-Max and Nissan Note or Qashqai (depending on how much room you need). The Ford and the Nissans are higher off the ground.

Finally if your budget is £7k and you're doing a low mileage, go for petrol power rather than diesel: diesels have a greater chance of going expensively wrong as they get older.

(Edit - having just seen Gordonbennet's post above, I'd agree: add Subarus to the list as well.)

Edited by Avant on 23/06/2014 at 16:11

Skoda - Any suggestions a next second hand car please? - John Boy

Like Avant, I'd recommend that you try getting in and out of a few cars. Lots of cars, especially crossover types, now have high seats and you certainly don't have to lower yourself down into them. Many of them, however, have a low roofline and the top half of your body needs to be flexible so you don't crack your head on it as you get in. HJ demonstrates what I'm referring to in his video on the Suzuki Splash/Vauxhall Agila B:

www.honestjohn.co.uk/road-tests/suzuki/suzuki-spla...o

Edited by John Boy on 22/06/2014 at 16:39

Skoda - Any suggestions a next second hand car please? - Manatee

From an engineering perspective GB has a point about Subarus. I like them, especially the Outback though it's fairly low; I find the Forester a bit small, but it's probably on a par with a Yeti size wise. The petrol ones are also drinkers I think.

If you like VW/Skoda then look at the Roomster.

My aunt and uncle (84 & 78) have just bought one in the quest for higher seats and big door openings. I was tasked with finding one and liked them so much that I ended up buying one to replace our second car.

Some versions have height adjustable driver and passenger seats.

I'd avoid the 3 cylinder 1.2 (the "1.2 12V"). There are some naturally aspirated 1.4/1.6 petrols, and later 1.2TSIs with 85 or 105ps.

At £7000 I'd be looking for 1.4/1.6 petrol manual (if they float your boat). There are a lot of diesels around of course.

The Roomster has some commonality with the quite small Fabia, but has a longer wheelbase and is really quite capacious, though poor for 3 in the back (2 is fine, with good legroom).

You can also wear a top hat in them, but it isn't compulsory.

If you follow up on anything from the Skoda used car database

www.skoda.net.r66.co.uk/carview.aspx?id=604394560

the check the extras with the dealer - the factory options are usually wrong (populated from VIN data apparently but often inaccurate).

I do have Roomsters on the brain just now, but you did mention Skoda...

Skoda - Any suggestions a next second hand car please? - corax

I do have Roomsters on the brain just now,

It'll soon pass :)

Skoda - Any suggestions a next second hand car please? - daveyK_UK

£7k just might get you a higher than average mileage Skoda Rapid with the excellent 1.2 tsi engine on a 62 plate.

Skoda - Any suggestions a next second hand car please? - SteveLee
By a new Dacia Sandaro Stepway.
Skoda - Any suggestions a next second hand car please? - Happy Blue!

Given the mileage you are doing, running costs (or more accurately fuel economy) are irrelvant compared to reliability and longevity. Should your husband keep his Maverick??

In my family we all love sitting higher, partly from the perspective of ease of access. Apart from the Subarus (which we had three of and loved), my father now likes the Suzuki Splash as it is nippy, comfortable and easy to get into. For the money you will find Nissan Qashqais plentiful and these are also easy to access.

Strangely, I woud also recommend the Mazda 3. I have been driving one for a week and found that with the seat set high, it is easy to access. ALso the last model Ford Fiesta (and the similar Mazda 2, were good for ease of access, being tall and blocky in shape.)

I strongly recommend petrol over diesel for this annual mileage. Bear in mind the more cars that were sold new several years ago, the more choice you will have now and possibly find newer cars for the money you are wishing to spend. So we can all

Skoda - Any suggestions a next second hand car please? - RobJP

Given the mileage you are doing, running costs (or more accurately fuel economy) are irrelvant compared to reliability and longevity. Should your husband keep his Maverick??

I'd be tempted to agree with that. The Maverick probably has almost no real value, they're basic and easy to work on. Though, as the OP says, not the cheapest things in the world to run, if it's not doing a lot of mileage then that really doesn't matter that much.

When you look at the 'real MPG' section on here, and see that the petrol Yetis average between 30-40 mpg depending on engine, and the fact that you're talking about wanting to keep 2 cars going, then I wouldn't really consider getting rid of the Maverick

Skoda - Any suggestions a next second hand car please? - VW Whatnext

Really helpful and my husband can sit and read these tonight. (Doesn't get on with computers but if I sit with him all will be well.)

Interesting some of you suggested keeping Maverick - I wondered that. BUT my only issue is it has a tempermental clutch which you have to get used to or it stalls. So at moment I would only drive it in an emergency as I am nervous in traffic when it stops. My husband finds it really comfortable and of course the stalling hasn't bothered him just a chance to let off steam.

The other problem with the Maverick he thinks we are into problems with the ABS unit. Of course any second hands cars will have their unknown problems anyway.

All have you have given food for thought and some of you coming up with keeping Maverick was really interesting. I actually said maybe find out costs to get clutch fixed and see how long she keeps us going and then maybe second hand Yeti will come down to our price.

I also think OH wants to get on with his restoration project on Morris Minor without worrying about repairs on 2nd vehicle.

Edited by VW Whatnext on 23/06/2014 at 13:38

Skoda - Any suggestions a next second hand car please? - Big John

As others have mentioned re car seats - varies from person to person. I can have back probelms and found the Saab 9000 (sadly long gone) amazing although I do like the seats in Volvos but I am 6ft 4".

One stage left suggestion - a previous model Nissan Note(just changed):-

  • Very comfortable with high seating position
  • Simple oily bits - especially petrols
  • Reliable
  • Refined
  • Pretty good economy
  • Great 1.6 petrol auto with overdrive(old fashined tourque convertor - but economical)
  • Good value - you would get a lot of Note for 7k

Edited by Big John on 29/06/2014 at 18:24

Skoda - Any suggestions a next second hand car please? - daveyK_UK

I don't believe there was ever or will ever be a car seat that wrecked so many peoples backs as the drivers seat in an astra van.

Everyone and I do mean everyone I have meet who drove an astra van loved the vehicles speed but hated the seat on a long term journey.

Skoda - Any suggestions a next second hand car please? - barney100

I asked the chap who runs a garage where I get mine serviced which cars were the least hassle to own and he said without doubt a Ford Focus. Providing the discs and pads are ok he reckoned it was the most sensible car on the road.