Elephant racing - should it be banned? - Trilogy

The link is out of date. It only came up when I discovered HGVs taking a month to overtake each other is known as elephant racing!

www.autoexpress.co.uk/car-news/33735/lorry-overtak...g

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - jc2

Not just lorries-anyone taking more than 15 seconds to complete an overtaking manoeuvre should be banned permantly!

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - Manatee

And who would you penalise, the overtaker or the overtakee? Or both?

Not too bad on three laners, but on the A14...

Record I've observed was 11 miles I think. That was on the M1, I could actually have overtaken in lane three but I was transfixed. The overtaker was gaining uphill and losing downhill, but the overlap was there the whole time.

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - jc2

The overtaker-there is already a law in some countries-but not my suggested penalty.

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - Sofa Spud

If a lorry takes a mile to pass a slightly slower one, so what.

There are far more annoying and dangerous things to worry about on our motorways and dual carriageways. Tailgating, for example.

My pet hate on motorways when you're going down a sliproad to join a motoway or dual carriagway and a following driver decides to overtake you just as you're about to join, forcing you to give way to them, since they got on the motorway before you. In my book that's dangerous driving.

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - bathtub tom

>>My pet hate on motorways when you're going down a sliproad to join a motoway or dual carriagway and a following driver decides to overtake you just as you're about to join

Perhaps you're not going fast enough? I've undertaken on a slip road before now, because the mimser in front has hogged the outer lane of the slip road at 50MPH (or less).

I try to achieve 70 MPH by the bottom of the slip road, because I know I can slow far more quickly to 56MPH (if there's a train of HGVs in the inside lane), than I can accelerate if there's not.

I'll add my (late) FIL berated me for using the hard shoulder as a slip road, many years ago (M1, J10, northbound). He reckoned I should've stopped and waited for a gap!!!!!!!

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - alan1302

I'll add my (late) FIL berated me for using the hard shoulder as a slip road, many years ago (M1, J10, northbound). He reckoned I should've stopped and waited for a gap!!!!!!!

You should!

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - kerbed enthusiasm

My pet hate on motorways when you're going down a sliproad to join a motoway or dual carriagway and a following driver decides to overtake you just as you're about to join, forcing you to give way to them, since they got on the motorway before you. In my book that's dangerous driving.

I agree. About ten years ago this became a common practice. It is the only time I've ever given in to road rage and deliberately blocked the idiot who'd tried to force me onto the hard shoulder. The driver wan't a happy chappy but it may have given him cause to reflect on his overtly aggressive driving style. I'd probably not respond in this way again though.

In response to the subsequent post, I certainly wasn't mimsying when I joined.

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - jc2

My pet hate on motorways when you're going down a sliproad to join a motoway or dual carriagway and a following driver decides to overtake you just as you're about to join, forcing you to give way to them, since they got on the motorway before you. In my book that's dangerous driving.

I agree. About ten years ago this became a common practice. It is the only time I've ever given in to road rage and deliberately blocked the idiot who'd tried to force me onto the hard shoulder. The driver wan't a happy chappy but it may have given him cause to reflect on his overtly aggressive driving style. I'd probably not respond in this way again though.

In response to the subsequent post, I certainly wasn't mimsying when I joined.

If you put yourself in a position where you can be overtaken in that situation,that's careless driving!

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - dadbif
Yes, on two lane carriageways, A14 etc, HGV's should be confined to the inside lane. Overtaking slowly for a distance of some miles causes bunching and increases the risk of accidents.
Elephant racing - should it be banned? - Manatee
Yes, on two lane carriageways, A14 etc, HGV's should be confined to the inside lane. Overtaking slowly for a distance of some miles causes bunching and increases the risk of accidents.

That would be rather frustrating for the 'trapped' driver, even more so when the road is quiet and it is unnecessary.

I did question the benefit of overtaking a lorry that is 0.25mph slower once, on here I think, and was patiently put right on how essential it is - something to do with momentum I think, can't remember now.

What I didn't understand is why the overtakee doesn't just drop a couple of mph for half a minute. ISTR the answer to that was 'momentum' again, but many of these lorries must be empty or loaded well below their weight capacity with bulky loads, with power in reserve - particularly as speed is limited artificially and not by available power. And yet we rarely see it obviously happening.

It doesn't actually bother me much now as long motorway journeys are a rarity for me, unless I have the caravan on in which case I join them...

:)

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - Sofa Spud

QUOTE:..""Perhaps you're not going fast enough? I've undertaken on a slip road before now, because the mimser in front has hogged the outer lane of the slip road at 50MPH (or less).""

50-60 mph is a sensible speed for a slip road when joining a busy motorway as you want to be travelling at about the same speed as traffic on the inside lane.

Overtaking on the slip road itself is OK, it's the people who decide to overtake just as you're about to ease onto the motorway, and then force you to give way to them as they pass you.

QUOTE:..""What I didn't understand is why the overtakee doesn't just drop a couple of mph for half a minute""

Because dropping a couple of mph means losing momentum on a gradient, and possibly having to drop a gear or two, losing more momentum, and dropping back more and more compared to the vehicle that would have been overtaken - all to do with different power outputs, torque curves and gear ratios on different lorries.

However, a bit of background thinking might conclude that drivers can save a fair bit of fuel over time by making a habit 'slipstreaming' lorries in front of them on motorways (obviously not too close, though), even at 40-56 mph.

Edited by Sofa Spud on 19/06/2014 at 12:32

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - Wackyracer

The problem is not an easy one to solve, I remember some years ago when there was alot of work going on around the Winchester area of the M3 and equally alot of tipper trucks using that stretch of the road. As it has alot of hills going up and down, On the uphill stretches I'd be overtaking laden tippers that were doing about 30mph and on the downhill stretches they were flying past me while I was doing 56-60mph.

Another problem is, for some strange reason (and this happens in cars too) as soon as you start overtaking someone mimsing along they suddenly decide to stamp on the throttle.

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - gordonbennet

This subject has been done to death many times, i don't think i elephant race, but no doubt still manage to upset mr or mrs more important by daring to use an overtaking lane correctly.

Enjoy your time of freedom of speed choice, lorry drivers didn't ask for speed restrictors but they got them, cars will do so too in time, then the experts can show us how to not small elephant race correctly.

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - Manatee

I suspect you're right GB. What a depressing thought.

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - gordonbennet

I hope i'm not right MT, i drive a car (albeit an old one) too.

When lorry speed limiters came in they had to be retro fitted to vehicles registered from a certain date, if you had an E prefix you got a retro fitted limiter, if you had a D reg you looked after it and made it last as long as possible.

I'm hoping my cars are too old for retro fitting, but i suspect it won't actually be speed restrictors as such i think it will be linked in with satellite controlled road pricing, and your overspeeds automatically calculated alongside your road use bill.

As you rightly say, truly depressing but i wouldn't put anything past the blighters.

As an aside i drove down the A43 early thismorning and opposite the Green Man pub near Silverstone there is a Truvelo camera, well a chap in a car timed it perfectly to use me as a shield from the camera, he must have been doing 100+ as he overtook me exactly at the camera wires, though for some reason it didn't trigger the camera flash, if a picture was taken its going to be an interesting but short discussion with my boss as to how i managed to get the lorry to over a ton fully loaded..:-)

Edited by gordonbennet on 19/06/2014 at 18:19

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - Manatee

I don't think those forward facing Truvelos produce a visible flash, so you'll have to wait and see!

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - gordonbennet

I don't think those forward facing Truvelos produce a visible flash, so you'll have to wait and see!

The ones Geddington Northants do, i've seen them flash at night but not me fortunately, thismornings incident it was daylight so probably no need.

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - Ben 10

If all lorries are restricted to the same maximum speed then there's no need to overtake. They should all be in lane 1 leaving the rest of us to have enough space to get on.

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - gordonbennet

Absolutely Ben, best of luck entering and exiting the road unless you're going to beam yourself directly into your very own outside cruising lane.

The problem with your theory is that restricted max speed isn't a target or set figure its a maximum.

All cars are limited to the same speed by law also, so you won't need to overtake another one either.

The problem isn't lorries or cars or buses or anything else, its massive overcrowding of the country and thats only going to get worse, its what people voted for in their millions, so sit back and enjoy the crawl.

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - Wackyracer

Ben's comment regarding lane 1 only for lorries reminds me of someone saying that to me.

I simply asked them if they wanted trucks on the M25 to be leaving and rejoining at pretty much every junction as the nearside lane is almost all just a slip road going off and on the motorway.

Would be interesting at the Reading turn off from the M4, The times I been sat there at 4pm in the centre lane, stationary waiting for everyone to turn off so I could continue on my way to the severn bridge.

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - Trilogy

If elephant racing results in 0.5 mile tail back in lane 2, and no traffic in lane one behind elephant being overtaken, I now just amble up lane one until I reach the elephant. Then I await an appropriate moment to overtake. I've cleared this technique with local traffic police.

Elephant racing - should it be banned? - RT

If all lorries are restricted to the same maximum speed then there's no need to overtake. They should all be in lane 1 leaving the rest of us to have enough space to get on.

But they aren't - some companies voluntarily fit limiters set to less than 90kph (56mph), eg 80 kph (50 mph) in order to save fuel - and remember, speed limits are not a target, they're a maximum.