Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - Trilogy

Fascinating.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-23587916

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - unthrottled

Holland is flat and the weather is better. Cycling is very popular in Oxford and Cambridge and it is perhaps no conicidence that the terrain and climate are very similar to the Netherlands. Pottering along St. Giles on a balmy summer's evening is one of life's joys. Ploughing your way up Gilesgate Hill in Durham on a wet November night isn't.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - Bromptonaut

Thanks for the pointer T. Just a completely different culture over there. Only other near neighbour with similar provision is Denmark.

The 'bakfiets' cargo bikes are spreading in UK though. As well as being used for deliveries I often see kids conveyed that way in London. There were a couple of families using them on the lorry protest ride following the recent fatality in Holborn.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - groaver

If there were more separate lanes in the UK I'm sure people would adopt bike use more readily.

IMO, there is nothing more intimidating than being passed by a large lorry on A roads in the country.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - Andrew-T

If there were more separate lanes in the UK I'm sure people would adopt bike use more readily.

Very true. But just imagine the outburst from the motoring fraternity if space were taken from the already narrow roads just for bikes ...

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - unthrottled

If there were more separate lanes in the UK I'm sure people would adopt bike use more readily.

This falls into the same catagory as:

"I would use public transport if it were reliable",

and

"I would love to volunteer to help the elderly if only I had time"

of things that people say because they feel they ought to but have no intention of doing in practice. The primary reason for not cycling is laziness. Cycle lanes don't change that.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - Dutchie

My sister lives in Rotterdam she is seventy years and uses her bicycle daily for shopping.When I visit my brother in Assen we often go for a cycle ride,center of Assen is car free and plenty of wide cycle paths.It is a way of live in Holland,we grow up with a bicycle.When I went to school in Dordrecht for two years,I always cycled home to Rotterdam over 40 years ago.Cycle path all the way.Dutch climate similair to the UK,one of the oldest bicycle firms is Batavus.My first bicycle was a Simplex.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - John Boy

When I moved from London to the south coast in 2001, I started cycling again, but only because there are plenty of cycle paths which I can drive to and enjoy riding on. I rarely cycle on roads, with or without that pathetic white line a foot or so from the kerb, as it's just too dangerous. I'm appalled to find that, when driving, even I often fail to give cyclists the space they need. In the UK, Car is King and that need's to be changed.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - Basser

Having visited Amsterdam for the first time a few months back, I was amazed at the sheer amount of cyclists around. You take your life in your hands trying to cross the road, they just keep riding and dont want to stop. There is a cycle park next to Amsterdam Centraal Station where it holds thousands of bikes and has turned into a tourist attraction. It must take ages to find your own bike. Also where ever you go alleyways and lamp posts are full of bikes secured to them.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - Dutchie

Just to add on regarding cycling in Holland.When the car ownership took off in Holland more and more cyclist where killed on the roads.People's protest and blocking roads woke the politicians up.Den UIL a prominent Dutch politican fought for the cyclist to inprove and make lives safer on Dutch roads.It is the culture of tolerating each other and be carefull driving in Holland regarding cyclist,the police will favour them if there is a accident.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - Dutchie

First time in Amsterdam Basser? Hope you didn't get lost amongst the coffee shops and the Red light district.>;)

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - Basser

No red light district for me with wife and daughter in tow, purely sightseeing seen Van Gogh Museum and shopping etc. Plenty of iffy smells about but seemed pretty civilised and I quite liked the place.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - mss1tw

First time in Amsterdam Basser? Hope you didn't get lost amongst the coffee shops and the Red light district.>;)

He wasn't lost ;-) :-D

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - groaver

If there were more separate lanes in the UK I'm sure people would adopt bike use more readily.

This falls into the same catagory as:

"I would use public transport if it were reliable",

and

"I would love to volunteer to help the elderly if only I had time"

of things that people say because they feel they ought to but have no intention of doing in practice. The primary reason for not cycling is laziness. Cycle lanes don't change that.

And your response falls into the arrogant assumption that you know my mind.

I live in the country with two young children.

To ride our bikes as a family means putting them on the back of the car to take them somewhere that is free from traffic as all the roads around me are narrow and main roads.

I guess you know best however.

Edited by groaver on 10/08/2013 at 17:53

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - unthrottled

To ride our bikes as a family means putting them on the back of the car to take them somewhere that is free from traffic as all the roads around me are narrow and main roads.

Don't be such a Guardian Reader. I lived in the country as a child-and cycled on twisty country lanes and fast A-Roads. I still do. Didn't wear any hi-Viz paraphernalia then and still don't now. Never had any major problems.

You can't shield your children from normal everyday hazards.Statistically speaking, cycling is not especially hazardous. Stop worrying and get on your bike!

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - John Boy

Hopefully, your will specifies a coffin with an internet connection so you can let us know what happened.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - unthrottled

Ultimately, your chance of ending up in a coffin is the same as mine: 1

Being safe is about being conscientious (with a large helping of luck)-not a road marking or an item of clothing you mindlessly put on like a hi Viz jacket merely so some jobsworth can tick the 'best practice' box on his risk assessment form.

'It's not safe enough' is just an excuse for lazy people to not cycle. I'm lazy too sometimes, but I blame myself not a straw man.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - groaver

My work colleague was hit by a car coming around a corner on the wrong side.

He survived, just.

But to you he is just an unfortunate statistic.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - Bromptonaut

My work colleague was hit by a car coming around a corner on the wrong side.

He survived, just.

But to you he is just an unfortunate statistic.

That's exactly what he is. He could have been in a car and met a lorry on wrong side of road.

I dislike the KSI statistical conflation of killed (dead for ever) and seriously injured (maybe no more than a broken wrist) but the KSI per mile for cyclists is much the same as for ordinary pedestrians. Considerably less than that for drunk pedestrians homebound from the pub.

Commuting daily in Central London since 1999 I've garnered no more than the odd bruise.

My SI moment came from foolishly riding over wet sheet metal car park decking. Bike did what aviators would call a flick roll and I landed on hip (cracked neck of femur) and shoulder (broken collar bone).

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - Trilogy

Brompoton 'bakfiets' seem quote popular in Cambridge.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - Dutchie

The bakfiets originated from the baker delivering bread.Very common on Dutch roads.Latest news is that the government is spending money on cycle paths which is a move in the right directions.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - gordonbennet

My work colleague was hit by a car coming around a corner on the wrong side.

Justice never seems to be about when she should be, the car on the wrong side of the road should in an ideal world have met a 40 ton mobile crane on the correct side...how many innocent people have suffered for fools who learn nothing even the hard way and casually drive off into the sunset.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - Rockvilla

I used to cycle everywhere when I was younger, main roads, country roads, urban, city etc etc etc without a helmet or hi-viz clothing (lights though!). Never had any probs. Done less so as I got older but now I am thinking of taking up some 2 wheeled fun again, mainly to improve my fitness level.

I live 4 miles from work and its a mix of urban road, dual carriageway national limit, and country, national limit. And 2 very steep hills. The thought of going up those hills frightens the bejeezus out of me but they'll be easier on the way down!!!

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - Smileyman

going down may be less hard work, but surely it is more dangerous .... the danger of building up too much speed with potential to loose control or need of sudden braking, especially in the wet.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - unthrottled

the danger of building up too much speed with potential to loose control or need of sudden braking, especially in the wet.

Only if your brakes don't work! It's actually less of an issue than in a car because there is no risk of aquaplaning on a bicycle. That's why tyre tread is extraneous on road bikes and should be avoided.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - Smileyman

point noted .. I've not been on a bike since childhood, and have no plans to do so, except perhaps in a controlled environment, eg centre parcs type place

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - Smileyman

too many cyclists in my part of the country on the road at dusk / night without lights, and / or reflectors .... life as a motorist is challanging enough without unseen 'targets' being presented, no-one wants to injure a fellow road user but a clash between cyclist and motorised vehicle is always going to have the same one victim. The comment about police taking cyclist side make this an even more worrying situation.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - gordonbennet

This is part of the reason why the battle for light supremacy in cars isn't helping.

The poor old cyclist and pedestrian unless donning a full set of reflective clothing like the motorway maintenance crews simply vanish into the backround.

The fetish for rather camp DRL's doesn't make the roads any safer, especially for the more vulnerable road user, as it takes some responsibility for adequate observation away from the motorist.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - galileo

Last night's local news featured an item about millions being spent on a cycle route between Leeds and Bradford.

Fair enough, I suppose, but then some dimwit held forth about how the percentage of cycle journeys in West Yorkshire was lower than the national average and it was his wish for it to be higher than the average.

Obviously never seen much of West Yorkshire (or a contour map) and the differences with Holland, East Anglia, Lincolnshire et al.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - Bromptonaut

Last night's local news featured an item about millions being spent on a cycle route between Leeds and Bradford.

Fair enough, I suppose, but then some dimwit held forth about how the percentage of cycle journeys in West Yorkshire was lower than the national average and it was his wish for it to be higher than the average.

Obviously never seen much of West Yorkshire (or a contour map) and the differences with Holland, East Anglia, Lincolnshire et al.

Well up to a point Lord Copper.

I've battled across the grain of the land in WY on quite a few occasions and it's a challenge even for the fit. OTOH there are plenty journeys, including the Leeds to Bradford example quoted, that follow valleys. They may even already have the basis for a cycle route such as canal towpaths or disused rail infrastructure.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - galileo

I've battled across the grain of the land in WY on quite a few occasions and it's a challenge even for the fit. OTOH there are plenty journeys, including the Leeds to Bradford example quoted, that follow valleys. They may even already have the basis for a cycle route such as canal towpaths or disused rail infrastructure.

Absolutely correct, my point is that for the percentage of cycle journeys to be greater than the national average is quite unrealistic. Unless your journey is along such a route, fitness and dedication are required. The few who cycled to work in my office usually changed clothes on arrival and departure, they were fortunate there were facilities to do so, not all would have these.

Edited by galileo on 13/08/2013 at 19:14

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - unthrottled

The reason that I'm wary of retro-fitting bus/cycle lanes is because of my experience of them in Cheshire.

They are dressed up as an addition to existing road space-when really they take away road space from other road users. The result is very often a clumsy and inefficient one-way system that does nobody any favours at all.

If you want nice wide boulevards with separate lanes for mopeds, bicycles, buses and ricksaws, move to Milton Keynes or any of the new towns. Personally, I'd rather move to Easter Island.

Our old towns are short of road space and we need to make maximum use of every square foot. There isn't the luxury for special lanes for client minority groups.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - RT

A road safety training presenter today was explaining that many "cycle lanes" are painted on the road as traffic-calming restrictions for motorised traffic, ie road narrowing, and nothing to do with facilities for cyclists!

Just don't ask why I had to attend his course!

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - Bromptonaut

A road safety training presenter today was explaining that many "cycle lanes" are painted on the road as traffic-calming restrictions for motorised traffic, ie road narrowing, and nothing to do with facilities for cyclists!

Whoever sent you there needs to find a new provider. Professional trainers really should not be spouting such rubbish. Not saying it never happens but it's rare in extreme.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - Ordovices

I was told a similar thing, though what was explained to me was that the broken nearside line looks like a cycleway border, but has no cycle logo. This does have the effect of narrowing the perceived road (without physically restricting it), as does central hatching.

Why is cycling so popular in the Netherlands - Leif

I recently cycled to the nearby town, only 4 miles as the crow flies. I took the route through the woods, which was virtually unpassable, due to mud. On the way back I took the direct route on the dual carriageway. It was terrifying. Some car drivers seem happy to drive past at 70mph with no more than 2 foot between them and me. The next time I went via the country lanes, it was almost twice as far.

I used to cycle and on one occasion run the 7 miles to work when I lived elsewhere, it was fine, the country lanes slowed down the nutters, most drivers were good, a tiny minority were b******s.