DVLA in Covid Trouble - Bromptonaut

DVLA in the news regarding workplace outbreak of COVID:

www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jan/23/minister-fac...y?

DVLA in Covid Trouble - Brit_in_Germany

What is the average infection rate in the Swansea area? According to another report (DM), there are currently no positive cases.

DVLA in Covid Trouble - catsdad

Misleading until you read the article. 535 cases since September so nearly 5 months. This is not the figure who are sick now. I also wonder if they were all confirmed, or include self isolating potential contacts?

I know we are in a dire situation but this is not measured presentation.

DVLA in Covid Trouble - Brit_in_Germany

Covid: DVLA staff in Swansea 'scared to enter the workplace' - BBC News

This says 500 cases since the start of the epidemic.

DVLA in Covid Trouble - Bromptonaut

Covid: DVLA staff in Swansea 'scared to enter the workplace' - BBC News

This says 500 cases since the start of the epidemic.

What's that in terms of infections per thousand employees in (a) other workplaces (b) the population as a whole, locally or nationally?

Edited by Bromptonaut on 24/01/2021 at 13:31

DVLA in Covid Trouble - Engineer Andy

DVLA in the news regarding workplace outbreak of COVID:

www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jan/23/minister-fac...y?

What exactly do you hope to achieve here other than to stir up more trouble by deliberately polarising things yet more? You don't see me starting a debate about Labour's antisemitism, etc, etc.

You're a member at the Guardian - why not discuss the matter there with fellow travellers of the Left? Given that I've never seen you concede you were wrong on a political issue, I really don't see the point of you talking about it other than to further divide people here.

As catsdad says, your framing of the report is misleading, and you've already said on the MIA thread that you are 'considered' in your posts, so all I can believe is that it was deliberate.

According to the DVLA themselves, they employ 6000 people, with I suspect the vast majority of those at their Swansea HQ. What none of the reports show is how many people currently have or are self-isolating due to possible close contact with COVID infected people.

Ministers cannot be responsible for every manegerial decision made on the ground - they take overall strategic decisions, with working conditions being the responsibility of the DVLA's own management, both nationally and locally.

They've had 9 months to make alternative arrangements. Maybe it is they who should 'get a grip'? Perhaps they should talk to some businesses who appear to have managed far better under similar circumstances.

DVLA in Covid Trouble - Bromptonaut

What exactly do you hope to achieve here other than to stir up more trouble by deliberately polarising things yet more? You don't see me starting a debate about Labour's antisemitism, etc, etc.

You're a member at the Guardian - why not discuss the matter there with fellow travellers of the Left? Given that I've never seen you concede you were wrong on a political issue, I really don't see the point of you talking about it other than to further divide people here.

I posted it because it's relevant to motoring and comments others have made about problems getting stuff processed by DVLA where it's not, like VED, all on line.

The buck stops with Ministers. That's why the honourable ones like Amber Rudd resign.

DVLA in Covid Trouble - dan86

The buck stops with Ministers. That's why the honourable ones like Amber Rudd resign.

Not many of them though is there.

But maybe less politics in the thread as we've all seen where that descends.

DVLA in Covid Trouble - Middleman

My local area has seen just under 20,000 recorded infections since September 1st - about one case for every 15 people. The DVLA figure of 535 in 6,000 is one in 11, so not wildly dissimilar.

The buck stops with Ministers. That's why the honourable ones like Amber Rudd resign.

Mr Shapps is no more responsible for the day to day management of the DVLA building and its staff in Swansea than Ben Wallace (Secretary of State for Defence) is for running "Main Building" in Whitehall or Matt Hancock is for managing your local hospital. Ms Rudd resigned because of a political disagreement with the Prime Minister following which she felt she could no longer serve under him. Somewhat different.

Edited by Middleman on 24/01/2021 at 14:45

DVLA in Covid Trouble - Bromptonaut

Mr Shapps is no more responsible for the day to day management of the DVLA building and its staff in Swansea than Ben Wallace (Secretary of State for Defence) is for running "Main Building" in Whitehall or Matt Hancock is for managing your local hospital. Ms Rudd resigned because of a political disagreement with the Prime Minister following which she felt she could no longer serve under him. Somewhat different.

Grant Shapps is the Minister. Of course he's not responsible for the day to day running of Swansea; that's what 'Next Steps' agencies were supposed to achieve. He is however accountable for his Civil Servants (do you recall Crichel Down and Thomas Dugdale?) to both the public and the House of Commons.

Ms Rudd resigned as Home Secretary while Theresa May was PM over her failure to understand what was going on in her department. The resignation over serving under Johnson was as Work and Pensions Minister; a role in which she is sadly missed.

DVLA in Covid Trouble - sammy1

We are talking about Public sector workers here. It is well documented that the sickness rates are in a far higher percentage than the private companies. But in any case the numbers quoted are about 12 per week on average which is no great reflection considering the size of the complex and the city of Swansea population

DVLA in Covid Trouble - Bromptonaut

We're talking positive tests for Covid not duvet days with 'flu'!!

DVLA in Covid Trouble - Engineer Andy

What exactly do you hope to achieve here other than to stir up more trouble by deliberately polarising things yet more? You don't see me starting a debate about Labour's antisemitism, etc, etc.

You're a member at the Guardian - why not discuss the matter there with fellow travellers of the Left? Given that I've never seen you concede you were wrong on a political issue, I really don't see the point of you talking about it other than to further divide people here.

I posted it because it's relevant to motoring and comments others have made about problems getting stuff processed by DVLA where it's not, like VED, all on line.

The buck stops with Ministers. That's why the honourable ones like Amber Rudd resign.

'The buck stops with ministers' Why then bother with upper and middle ranked civil servants then? Why not just give the minister full control and they tell the people on the ground what to do in every aspect of their job. It would certainly save on wages.

I wonder why you mentioned Rudd? Could it because she was a rabid remoaner who then said she wouldn't be a Tory any more because of that? You always have an angle, don't you?

PS. I see that, despite my earlier plea to stop turning this forum into politic+motoring that you've mirrored this topic from the C4P website forum. Can't you think of anything else to constructively do with your time than stir up a hornet's nest so one half of the backroomers want to leave the site?

Just give it a rest. Jeez.

DVLA in Covid Trouble - FP

"You always have an angle, don't you?"

"Can't you think of anything else to constructively do with your time than stir up a hornet's nest so one half of the backroomers want to leave the site?"

The above contributes nothing to the discussion. You sound offended - aggrieved, even. You're making it very personal. I thought you didn't do things like that?

"Play the ball, not the man." Or something like that.

P.S. Half of the BR is going to leave because of a tetchy discussion? Don't be silly. Most of us have more sense and a longer perspective than you give us credit for.

Edited by FP on 24/01/2021 at 21:26

DVLA in Covid Trouble - alan1302

PS. I see that, despite my earlier plea to stop turning this forum into politic+motoring that you've mirrored this topic from the C4P website forum. Can't you think of anything else to constructively do with your time than stir up a hornet's nest so one half of the backroomers want to leave the site?

Just give it a rest. Jeez.

The only person here that seems to want to stir things is yourself but you either are blind to it or are just doing deliberately try and get a reaction. If you don't want to discuss something no one is forcing you to - and no one is forcing you to even post replied on here or even read it.

DVLA in Covid Trouble - Manatee

DVLA in the news regarding workplace outbreak of COVID:

www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jan/23/minister-fac...y?

What exactly do you hope to achieve here other than to stir up more trouble by deliberately polarising things yet more? You don't see me starting a debate about Labour's antisemitism, etc, etc.

Bromp didn't even pass an opinion unless I missed it.
I don't think the DM version is much different. Nor is the BBC's although it doesn't mention Shapps.


www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9180229/More-500-...l


www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-55785912

I'd say there is a story there. And it may well have implications for the services. A perfectly legitimate bit of info for a motoring website surely? It never occurred to me it was divisive until you mentioned it. Then again whenever I see Shapps I think he's due an egging just for being so smug.

It's the unions who are going for Shapps isn't it? - reasonable if they think he can do something about it. The cause looks like a local management issue, perhaps they just haven't implemented safe working well enough.

DVLA in Covid Trouble - sammy1

500 people at the DVLA have been reported to have Covid. With people coming and going from home to the workplace and socialising when allowed, who is to say that the virus was transmitted to them while at work. The DVLA are reported to have taken measures like all employers to keep working. Precautions practiced by some outside the workplace are not good as being reported daily in the media.

DVLA in Covid Trouble - Avant

This thread started with a piece of information which Bromptonaud thought might be of interest, and was simply a link to a newspaper article.

Then we get this:

"What exactly do you hope to achieve here other than to stir up more trouble by deliberately polarising things yet more? You don't see me starting a debate about Labour's antisemitism, etc, etc."

Rudeness like that is the reason why people may no longer want to post on here. It's got to stop. Thread closed.

Edited by Avant on 24/01/2021 at 23:13