all - Road humps etc - barney100

The government has urged councils to remove humps and cushions as they double harmful vehicle emissions. Here in sunny Basingstoke our County council has installed some of the daftest items of road furniture imaginable. On a country road a protrusion with a priority indication has drivers stopping for little reason. Thousands have been spent on hump removal and replacement. There is nothing anywhere near. Our new roundabouts have multiple lanes which have vehicles changing lanes in confusion with dotted lines,arrows, and traffic lights in profusion. Anyone any idea on what damage humps and cushions do to cars?

all - Road humps etc - Bolt

our councill so far have done nothing to remove humps,if anything they are remaking the damaged ones, but if drivers went over them at a reasonable speed instead of racing over them I doubt they would suffer damage

I`ve been driving over them for years and never had a problem with my cars, I do get tailgating in humpy roads because I take them slow and easy, but hard luck if they dont like it!

all - Road humps etc - RichT54

HJ has been campaining against speed humps for several years in his Telegraph column. He has warned of damage to the inner shoulders of car tyres, increasing the risk of a blowout. He has also mentioned damage to suspension components, including broken springs.

A couple of new cars I have bought in recent years have come with leaflets warning about straddling speed humps as this can cause damage to tyres.

The main damage I have noticed is when people go over speed humps too fast, the nose of the car can dip quite sharply, causing the bottom of the front spoiler to scrape on the road surface. Doesn't seem to deter the drivers, however.

all - Road humps etc - Ethan Edwards

Why not take all the humps materiel and fill in the potholes with it.

Kill two birds with one stone.

all - Road humps etc - Bolt

You can warn people as much as you like, but whether they take any notice is another thing, from what I`ve seen not many do,or, do not care which I think is more like it!

people MUST get from A to B as fast as possible, and its getting worse

all - Road humps etc - Stanb Sevento

These things are a pet hate of mine. There is very little to be said in their favour, most don’t slow down the type of driver they are aimed at. Speed cushons were introduced because bus companies were complaining the bumps were damaging the buses, they are made so buses can straddle them so you only see them on bus routes in the main.

They cost a fortune ti install and more any time there is maintenance work, they also stop the road being snow ploughd in the winter because they wreck the plough because the driver can’t see them when covered in snow.. They also cost the councils a great deal in admin and legal costs defending themselves against spurious liability claims for damaged vehicles.

In my area, apart from a few around the schools most of these things were installed at the demand of the residents complaining about the speed of the traffic then when they are in place they complain about the noise the traffic makes going over them during the night.

I'd better stop before going into full rant mode.

all - Road humps etc - Terry W
We spend a lot of money on road humps and street furniture. We could solve the problem simply by allowing potholes to reach an appropriate size and density.

Traffic calming without the cost is natures way.
all - Road humps etc - Bolt

These things are a pet hate of mine. There is very little to be said in their favour, most don’t slow down the type of driver they are aimed at. Speed cushons were introduced because bus companies were complaining the bumps were damaging the buses, they are made so buses can straddle them so you only see them on bus routes in the main.

They cost a fortune ti install and more any time there is maintenance work, they also stop the road being snow ploughd in the winter because they wreck the plough because the driver can’t see them when covered in snow.. They also cost the councils a great deal in admin and legal costs defending themselves against spurious liability claims for damaged vehicles.

In my area, apart from a few around the schools most of these things were installed at the demand of the residents complaining about the speed of the traffic then when they are in place they complain about the noise the traffic makes going over them during the night.

I'd better stop before going into full rant mode.

I very much agree, but for the biggest problem and main reason why government has asked councils to remove is Air quality, they have suddenly come to the conclusion humps are no good for emissions

they were told some time ago of the adverse effects of installing these useless things but insisted they did a good job

now they have been told to do something about our air quality, they are feably asking councils to remove them, not sure how many are but one that isnt is my area

but there are lots of things in place that hold traffic up in places where there never used to be, where there was problems has been made worse by there stupid departments that probably never drive (possibly travel by train) and who know nothing about free moving traffic that was.

the sooner these are removed the better but I suspect councils will claim they cannot afford to and we will be stuck with them untill they can!

all - Road humps etc - Terry W
Potholes are natures way of telling us to drive more slowly.
all - Road humps etc - gordonbennet

There's very few in my home town, those that are of the straddle sort, they make little if any difference to traffic flow, the worse ones by a country mile are those on Asda's own approach road which are those really nasty rubber bolted in pads, they are so bad we avoid using the shop despite it being very close to us.

In al honesty traffic now moves mind numbingly slowly in many areas due to the incompetence of drivers who cannot maintain normal progress, the only time it gets to silly pushy aggressiveness is at shift work times eg 6am and 2pm and early evenings, especially Friday nights when the baseball hatted types take to the roads to show off their prowess.

My MB indy says much of his work is suspension related, though that could be due just as easily to Nothants patented tank training ground standard pot holes and bodged constantly dug up roads.

Traffic can only get slower as the population gradually increases towards the magic 100million, the roads will suffer increasingly and people will have to think laterally about their car purchases, ie cars designed soft riding and not sitting on 35 or so aspect elastic bands, can't recall a single spring breakage on any of my Japanese cars nor can i recall ever having to change anything on the suspension other than dampers (at the expected age/ mileage) and the odd drop link, its always been European cars which have provided breakages and prematurely worn components, poor suspension design of old Brit cars and rubbish springs and ball joints on German cars.

Edited by gordonbennet on 30/07/2017 at 11:33

all - Road humps etc - concrete

I agree with previous comments. Road humps are a real pain. Invariably tailgating between them occurs, because I like to ride them slowly with one side of the car over the centre of the hump. Doesn't suit those really important people who must be in front of you at all costs and want to arrive before they set off. Tough. Driving through France and Spain this summer I did not encounter on road hump. Sometimes slightly raised white lines before entering a village but usually some sort of chicane that is easily negotiable at low speed and seems to have the desired effect of slowing down vehicles. We really do put up with serious sh**e in the country from our local authorities. Oh to be a government minister in the Ministry of Common Sense.

Concrete

all - Road humps etc - argybargy

I used to live on a road which was used as a rat run between two main drags. The noise, particularly early in the morning during the rush hour and at teatime, was a continuous rumble that could be heard in any part of the house and which I never got used to. Later at night the overall volume decreased, but the boy racers would take over, razzing up and down the road in their souped-up sheds.

We shared this rat run status with two other local roads, and some of the residents got together to put pressure on local councillors to take action. After about two years they agreed to install various traffic calming measures including road humps.

Well, as others will know we'd merely exchanged one problem for another. For the first few weeks after the humps went down there was less traffic, but a hardcore of folks who were determined not to be diverted from their preferred route carried on driving as before, despite the humps, and almost certainly gradually ripped their sumps and silencers to shreds. Gradually a greater volume of traffic returned, and instead of the constant hum of traffic we had the speeding up, revving down then revving up again as cars slowed, crossed the humps then accelarated away. Five or six humps on our road, five or six chances for cars to go through that cacophonous, infuriating rigmarole.

So no, road humps are not the answer; far from it, though I think that if used sparingly with other measures they MIGHT have worked for us. We asked for a chicane on the junction between our road and the main drag, but were told by the council that because lorries parked at the top of the road to deliver to local shops, the Road Haulage Association would object. Which may well have been borrox.

all - Road humps etc - RickyBoy
...has anyone driven through Chinnor in recent times?....

...and Nettlebed a bit further along!....

...and, and Ledborough Lane in Beaconsfield!!

Jeez, all delightful places in their own right but humps-a-plenty all placed equidistant to each other so as soon as you just got into 2nd you have to immediately get out of it!!!

This country...

all - Road humps etc - bathtub tom

I've suggested to local neighbours we should purloin some white road-marking spray and put down a vernier pattern, at night, either side of our local 'pinch points'.

Not been met with much success.

all - Road humps etc - Snakey

Several of the local councils in my area seem to be increasing the use of humps and pinch points. Although they are also embarking on a crazy (and expensive) wave of replacing roundabouts with traffic light nightmares.

So despite goverment advice they are making the queues worse, without exception.

all - Road humps etc - Bolt
...has anyone driven through Chinnor in recent times?.... ...and Nettlebed a bit further along!.... ...and, and Ledborough Lane in Beaconsfield!! Jeez, all delightful places in their own right but humps-a-plenty all placed equidistant to each other so as soon as you just got into 2nd you have to immediately get out of it!!! This country...

I once thought (wrongly) that we had sensible and caring councillors running our councils that actually cared for its constituents, when in fact they are a bunch of non listening non caring (apart from wallets) non sensicle idiots who have not a clue about local life and the air they breathe.

So I very much doubt, like my council anything will happen to rid our roads of these stupid humps and cushions

yet our london mayor wants to stop diesels going into london and surrounds earlier than 2019 to reduce smoke and dirty air, if our government listens to him as well as the councils have,I think he will end up banging his head against a brick wall,he may get more satisfaction out of that than the plonkers in downing st