Renault - Future of diesel cars - Big John

I've noticed on the BBC news website that Renault is considering killing of diesel engines - Is this the beginning of the end for diesel cars?

Renault - Future of diesel cars - RobJP

I seem to recall Toyota declaring the same thing a while back. They're still making diesel cars.

Here's an article asking 'Is diesel dead ?' in the Telegraph ... from 2010 !

www.telegraph.co.uk/motoring/green-motoring/716644...l

I note that the BBC article is un-confirmed by Renault, and Renault's sales last year in Europe are reported at 1.6 million cars, 60% of them being diesels. Can't see them throwing away over half of their sales, somehow.

Renault - Future of diesel cars - RT

Diesel car sales will no doubt drop back below the 50% level - but while fuel throughout Europe is highly taxed, it's economy advantage will ensure its survival for non city-dwellers at least.

Renault - Future of diesel cars - Big John

Petrol technology has moved on somewhat. I remember my 1984 1.4 Ford Escort that only just did 30mpg whereas my 2014 1.4tsi Skoda Superb barge does about 46mpg (51mpg at last fill!)

However I do miss the out and out range of my old Skoda Superb I 1.9 pd which did 650-700 miles on a tank of diesel - always 50+mpg

I might consider a hybrid next time. Two friends both swear by Toyota hybrids (Prius and Auris Touring) with stunning fuel economy in real life (60mpg+ with the Prius and 70mpg+ with the Auris). Capital cost much higher though

Edited by Big John on 08/09/2016 at 22:53

Renault - Future of diesel cars - RT

Petrol technology has moved on somewhat. I remember my 1984 1.4 Ford Escort that only just did 30mpg whereas my 2014 1.4tsi Skoda Superb barge does about 46mpg (51mpg at last fill!)

However I do miss the out and out range of my old Skoda Superb I 1.9 pd which did 650-700 miles on a tank of diesel - always 50+mpg

I might consider a hybrid next time. Two friends both swear by Toyota hybrids (Prius and Auris Touring) with stunning fuel economy in real life (60mpg+ with the Prius and 70mpg+ with the Auris). Capital cost much higher though

Oddly enough, virtually all the cars I've owned in nearly 50 years have done low 30s mpg - from a mk1 Escort 1100 thrashed mercilessly between the Midlands and Aberdeenshire regularly through to my current 3.0 V6 SUV - the exceptions were a 2.5 Subaru and a fully expensed 1.8 Cavalier, both doing 27 and a 3.0 Senator doing 18.

A friend has a company Prius, getting 50 mpg overall, but to me it feels tinny (metallic not small) to ride in.

Renault - Future of diesel cars - Metropolis.

I'd like to see the end of all diesel engines with 4 cylinders or less. Horrid things. Makes any car sound like a transit van coming down the road. Even the best attempts at making them refined end up with a dreadful metallic din. Anything over 2 litres and vibrations will be felt throughout the cabin. Anything above 3 litres becomes difficult to engineer because of said vibrations. Truly awful...

Should be 5 cylinders minimum!

Renault - Future of diesel cars - Bolt

I'd like to see the end of all diesel engines with 4 cylinders or less. Horrid things. Makes any car sound like a transit van coming down the road. Even the best attempts at making them refined end up with a dreadful metallic din. Anything over 2 litres and vibrations will be felt throughout the cabin. Anything above 3 litres becomes difficult to engineer because of said vibrations. Truly awful...

Should be 5 cylinders minimum!

4 Cylinders are fine, I would agree the old diesels were not too clever for revs but the new ones are much better, rev high, power when needed and quieter than they used to be. some are as good as petrols so not sure what your talking about

some companies are trying to refine them even more with lower emissions and even lower particulate levels

Renault - Future of diesel cars - cocorico

Maybe Renault is hoping to source this new engine from Nissan to replace Diesel ?

jalopnik.com/worlds-first-variable-compression-rat...8

Renault - Future of diesel cars - FP

Nissan's variable-compression petrol engine (designated the VC-T) sounds fascinating. The key innovation is its ability to "...seamlessly raise or lower the height the pistons reach". I don't know how that is possible, but it's a clever idea. Apparently its compression ratio varies between 14:1 and 8:1. This is the engine that the tabloids have been claiming will signal the end of diesels.

However, Mazda already produces a petrol engine with 14:1 compression and presumably the manufacturer has solved the problem of knocking (apparently by a sophisticated - and bulky - exhaust manifold), so I'm not sure of the need for variable compression. (14:1, of course, is close to diesel territory.) In the CX 5 this engine gives 165 bhp and a wide torque band peaking at 155 lb-ft. Combined fuel consumption: 47.1 mpg.

Mazda's engine is not turbo-charged; Nissan's is.

Full technical details of the Nissan engine are unavailable at the moment, though vague claims are being made about its performance and economy. It will be unveiled at the Paris Motor Show next month.

Edited by FP on 09/09/2016 at 12:35

Renault - Future of diesel cars - Metropolis.

I'm not against diesel as a whole, I own one and i do appreciate the extra torque. But i'd never buy one with less than 5 cylinders. The Volvo d5 unit has a nice burble.

I have been in most of the newer german models with a 4 cylinder diesel, plus freelanders and a discovery sport (Ford 2.2 and ingenium). Not terribly impressed with any of them. Still clattery, most either sound like a trawler, or if they are VW group they make that glug glug sound similar to someone pouring water. Pet hate of mine i guess. V6, I6 or v8 diesels can sound lovely and so much more refined. However much they emit and all that green stuff has never been on my list of priorities.

Renault - Future of diesel cars - Bladerrw

Well I don't stand outside listening to my 2L four cyl diesel. Inside the car it is smooth and quiet.

Renault - Future of diesel cars - slippy118

I wont buy another diesel because of DMF and DPF.

My 1985 diesel fiesta did 60 mpg with no expensive bits to replace. Diesels haven't improved mpg they have just improved performance with turbos. The petrol cars have improved on fuel a lot.

Renault - Future of diesel cars - Gibbo_Wirral

The article in question:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-37287129

Renault - Future of diesel cars - RobJP

I've been running diesels with DMF/DPF for a fair few years.

520d touring did the most in, 120k miles. The one and only problem I had was a stuck EGR valve.

In all honesty, I think wrecked cluches / DMFs are down to driver incompetence in 90%+ of cases. Just as it always was.

Petrol cars haven't inproved fuel economy by much - or rather, they haven't inproved REAL fuel economy by much. You only have to look at the RealMPG section to see that petrol Fiestas are returning 38-46 mpg, diesels are returning 55-62 mpg.

Your 1985 diesel fiesta had 54 bhp. The current one has 75 or 95 bhp. So that's a 39% or 75% improvement in power for the same fuel consumption.

Now, the petrol version ... again, lets go from the 1.0 in the 1985 car (45bhp), and had a combined mpg of 44 - and 'official' mpg figures were pretty accurate back then (the official for the diesel was 59mpg). The Realmpg figure for the 1.0 petrol fiesta now ... 43-47.

So in both types of fuel, you've got a great improvement in how the fuel is being used to generate power and torque (which we need to compensate for the far heavier newer cars), but the economy is virtually identical.

Renault - Future of diesel cars - Big John

Official mpg for my 2014 (facelift) Superb II 1.4tsi is 47.9mpg. Actual thus far mpg is 45.7 mpg, not too far off the official:- www.spritmonitor.de/en/detail/720963.html

Still have memories of my 1984 1.3 Escort that only did 30mpg if you took it steady

For ref I got about 50mpg out of my previous Superb 1.9pd on same journey types

BUT- if you stress it the petrol drops proportionally more mpg than the diesel ever did - dropped to 37 mpg when full of people and lots of luggage cruising at 130kph

Edited by Big John on 11/09/2016 at 21:56

Renault - Future of diesel cars - Bolt

I'm not against diesel as a whole, I own one and i do appreciate the extra torque. But i'd never buy one with less than 5 cylinders. The Volvo d5 unit has a nice burble.

I have been in most of the newer german models with a 4 cylinder diesel, plus freelanders and a discovery sport (Ford 2.2 and ingenium). Not terribly impressed with any of them. Still clattery, most either sound like a trawler, or if they are VW group they make that glug glug sound similar to someone pouring water. Pet hate of mine i guess. V6, I6 or v8 diesels can sound lovely and so much more refined. However much they emit and all that green stuff has never been on my list of priorities.

I think you been listening to the wrong engines then, I get the impression a lot of diesel drivers are not interested in the carp that comes out the exhaust, I still doubt they will dissapear anytime soon

besides what will we do with all that redundant oil eh?

Renault - Future of diesel cars - Big John

NB There is currently a problem with the latest direct injection petrol engines though - they spew out more particulates than the latest euro 5 &6 diesels

Fixed in the next release though - GPF's (Gasoline Particulate Filter) coming our way real soon now to help comply with euro 6c

www.autoexpress.co.uk/volkswagen/tiguan/96578/vw-t...s

Edited by Big John on 11/09/2016 at 22:50

Renault - Future of diesel cars - Sofa Spud

The future of diesel cars will be determined by the pace of progress in electric cars, in particular battery technology. A few years ago Renault announced they were going to develop electric cars and they've done a couple but other manufacturers have since pulled ahead in the race. Surely all eyes must be on the new Tesla Model 3 and how well that performs when deliveries begin. If it lives up to the promises in the way that the existing Model S has, then there will be a move away from internal combustion engines, both diesel and petrol.

Edited by Sofa Spud on 11/09/2016 at 23:53

Renault - Future of diesel cars - Bolt

The future of diesel cars will be determined by the pace of progress in electric cars, in particular battery technology. A few years ago Renault announced they were going to develop electric cars and they've done a couple but other manufacturers have since pulled ahead in the race. Surely all eyes must be on the new Tesla Model 3 and how well that performs when deliveries begin. If it lives up to the promises in the way that the existing Model S has, then there will be a move away from internal combustion engines, both diesel and petrol.

I think diesel will be harder to produce anyway if emmisions are forced any lower, but I wonder if when electric cars do become more popular, are power stations going to be built to supply the electricity, as it will have to come from somewhere?(electric companies had warned were not producing enough for the winter so power cuts possible) charging stations are another problem, I gather not all stations available at the moment have the same connections/plugs so not all makes can use them all?

So there are as many problems with electric cars as there are emmisions with ICE motors

Renault - Future of diesel cars - brum

The cat is out of the bag with emission cheating. That spells big problems for most diesels to even meet current regualtions never mind the next generation of euro regs. Even petrol engines with direct injection are now in the spotlight for partculates.

Just like coal, the writings on the wall for internal combustion engines in their present form.

Renault - Future of diesel cars - gordonbennet

Electric cars, smart meters, makes you wonder just how much control a government of the day could exercise as and when they wished, targeted/selectively.

Renault - Future of diesel cars - RT

Range is still the big issue for EVs, particularly if load weight needs to be carried - so diesel will remain king for vans and towing as long as it's not banned altogether.

I don't drive a van but do tow a 1500 kg caravan - currently I can tow for 9 hours (plus breaks) and refuel once/day - with the best EV, a Tesla, I'd be stopping every 2 hours for a full recharge taking an hour.

When EV range gets up to a genuine 500 miles on a 1 hour charge, then they'll make real inroads into sales.

Renault - Future of diesel cars - davecooper

If my memory serves me well, I believe that SAAB tinkered with a variable compression design at least ten years ago. I think the compression was varied by effectively changing the distance between the crank and the block/head assembly. This was achieved by tilting the block slightly, although the movement required was fairly small I believe.

Edited by davecooper on 12/09/2016 at 17:26

Renault - Future of diesel cars - Bolt

If my memory serves me well, I believe that SAAB tinkered with a variable compression design at least ten years ago. I think the compression was varied by effectively changing the distance between the crank and the block/head assembly. This was achieved by tilting the block slightly, although the movement required was fairly small I believe.

I remember it as well.2000/1

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saab_Variable_Compression_en...e

Renault - Future of diesel cars - focussed

I've noticed on the BBC news website that Renault is considering killing of diesel engines - Is this the beginning of the end for diesel cars?

I can't somehow see this happenng -it's unlikely that Renault will cease making diesels because the current French car market is about 75-80% diesel engined cars.

You only have to sit in your car in a French supermarket car park as I do most Saturdays waiting for my OH, and watch which fuel pumps get used most.

Distances are greater in France - it's four times the area of the UK and the road system encourages long distance travel on decent roads, so the economy of diesels makes sense.