Volkswagen Golf GTI - Winter Tyre Rotation - ahxcjb

Hi -

I run summer / winter tyres throughout the year.

I'm unsure whether I should rotate the tyres when putting my winters back on this year (I mark the tyres so I know which axel they were attached to) or should I simply put them back on to the axel they previously were fixed to?

When replacing tyres, I always take the fronts off, put rears to front and new to the rear. So, the concept of tyre rotation isn't one I feel hugely comfortable with, especially as I always want my best tyres on the rear to prevent oversteer.

What do others recommend when putting their seasonal tyres back on? Do you simply rotate (ie, Front Left goes Rear Left, Rear Left goes Front Left etc) or do you put the tyres back to the same axel they were previously on?

Thoughts, input, welcome.

Volkswagen Golf GTI - Winter Tyre Rotation - RobJP

It depends on how much tread is left on them, I suppose. As a FWD Golf, you'll probably have used a bit more tread on the fronts, so I'd put those onto the back axle to even out wear. However, that approach means that when you need to replace tyres, you'll have worn all 4 down evenly, so larger outlay in one go.

Alternatively, if you keep fronts on the front, then those tyres will wear out a lot sooner, but the back tyres will go on for a lot longer.

Volkswagen Golf GTI - Winter Tyre Rotation - ahxcjb

Yeah, that's my thinking.

I have no problem with the fronts wearing out sooner. My issue isn't cost related (the main reason people rotate tyres IMO), it's about having the best grip available to me, as I like to make good progress, plus here in the North East USA we get brutal winters so it's important when I need to stop or correct my steering that I'm able to do so with my wheels in the optimum configuration.

Volkswagen Golf GTI - Winter Tyre Rotation - gordonbennet

Yes i too judge the wear and fit accordingly, and prefer to replace all four together.

Can't say as i'm that bothered about the new to rear trend (another one size fits all solution), when its been two new tyres they have always gone on the drive axle.

Volkswagen Golf GTI - Winter Tyre Rotation - ahxcjb

New tyres to the drive axle (if FWD) is dangerous.

www.tirerack.com/winter/tech/techpage.jsp?techid=52

Edited by ahxcjb on 15/08/2016 at 22:09

Volkswagen Golf GTI - Winter Tyre Rotation - galileo

The link you give is to a US site and refers to a Michelin test on a flooded, curved track.

On a surface flooded to a depth sufficient to cause aquaplaning the results are exactly what one would expect. If a road is that wet, it would make sense to slow down to a speed at which aquaplaning won't occur.

In a straight line, as the rears follow in the track of the fronts, the fronts will have dispersed most of the water so less for them to shift.

Some of us are old enough to remember the days when there was NO legal minimum tread depth, so it was legal to drive smooth treaded tyres and as most cars then were rear wheel drive, we soon learned that the rear wheels would break away with anything but gentle acceleration on wet or even damp roads.

(And in those days there was no such thing as stability control or antilock brakes)

Volkswagen Golf GTI - Winter Tyre Rotation - RT

Some of us are old enough to remember the days when there was NO legal minimum tread depth, so it was legal to drive smooth treaded tyres and as most cars then were rear wheel drive, we soon learned that the rear wheels would break away with anything but gentle acceleration on wet or even damp roads.

(And in those days there was no such thing as stability control or antilock brakes)

I certainly learnt a lot on a 90 mile drive on packed snow in a '56 Hillman Minx on bald tyres.

Volkswagen Golf GTI - Winter Tyre Rotation - Theophilus

Can I commend ahxcjb for using British spelling "tyres" and not US variant "tires"

Volkswagen Golf GTI - Winter Tyre Rotation - ahxcjb

The thought of me using American English fills me with despair ;)

Volkswagen Golf GTI - Winter Tyre Rotation - Brit_in_Germany

Winter tyres are more likely than not directional and so can only be swapped front to back if they are on their own rims.