Good morning everyone,
The time has come to say goodbye to my trusty Toyota Corolla, and welcome a different car to the family.
My needs are:
- Petrol (short journeys)
- 5 Door (current car is 3 door, people hate clambering in to the back)
- Quick-ish (i'm an enthusiastic driver at times)
- Quiet and refined (nice relaxing commutes)
- Reliable!
From those needs and a bit of research I came to a few options, which I could afford on my £8k budget. Which are:
- 2010 VW Golf Mk6 1.4 TSI SE (122)
- 2013 Vauxhall Astra J 1.4T SRi (140)
- 2012 Toyota Auris 1.6 Valvematic SR (130)
- 2010 VW Polo Mk5 1.2 TSI SEL (105)
From further research and test drives I narrowed this down to just the Astra and the Golf. My pros and cons for each car are as follows.
2013 Vauxhall Astra J 1.4T SRi (140)
Pro
- Enjoyable driving experience
- Seems quite powerful
- Positive gear changes
- Good leg room in the front and rear
- Very comfortable and very well refined
- Good boot space
- From all research the engine seems to be pretty solid
Con
- Internal pillars are quite obstructive at junctions
- Turbo lag was noticeable
- MPG is nowhere near the quoted figure
- Tyres size with the 18" rims are a bit pricey
2010 VW Golf Mk6 1.4 TSI SE (122)
Pro
- Superior switchgear
- Superior refinement
- Good visibility
- Better throttle response
- Engine feels smoother
Con
- Ride felt overly firm
- Dealership was very pushy
- From research there seems to be concerns over the timing chain tensioner causing catastrophic engine failure, how common this is, I don't know
So...here is my dilemna, I can't for the life of me choose between the cars.
From my experience, they both drive very similarly...and while there are qualities about the VW that I prefer, I have been put off by a lot of negative comments regarding timing chain issues. Which is something I am yet to see about the Vauxhall.
I would like to know which car you would pick? And why?
Especially if you own either of these cars!
Any guidance/advice would be greatly appreciated, as at the minute I'm in a bit of a pickle :)
Thanks in advance!
|