Best Breakdown Cover 2021

If you're looking for who provides the best breakdown cover, look no further. These breakdown companies were the best rated in the Honest John Satisfaction Index 2021.

We collected more than 5,000 of your experiences from breakdowns, whether they were a provider you chose yourself or manufacturer-supplied cover. 

The top ten independent providers all scored more than 7.9 out of 10 for customer satisfaction. To see how the AA and RAC fare against the competition, read our guide to the best breakdown cover.

1. Start RescueStart -rescue -jpg -1

Breakdown Cover Satisfaction Score 9.18

Start Rescue is one of the newer breakdown cover providers in the market, operating through Call Assist Ltd and recording an impressive score of 9.18 out of 10 based on 33 respondents. Start Rescue offers five levels of cover with prices starting from £19.75 for local roadside cover, making it a popular choice for anyone looking to keep costs as low as possible. Personal cover starts at £53.12 a year.

How much does Breakdown Cover cost with Start Rescue?

Recovery Type Price
Roadside assistance, local recovery up to 10 miles £19.75*
Nationwide recovery £25.00*
Nationwide recovery, home assist £30.80*
European roadside assistance in 42 countries £59.80*
Euopean roadside plus home assist and vandalism cover £72.80*

2. Auto AidAuto Aid Logo _thumb

Breakdown Cover Satisfaction Score 8.99

Auto Aid is part of a group of companies including Auto National Rescue and Euro Rescue all owned by Right Choice Insurance Brokers, but its strong showing here is based only on customers of Auto Aid. Its impressive score of 8.99 is based on 77 respondents, putting it in second place. These prices are based on covering a car rather than an individual but personal cover starts from £59.99 a year.

How much does Breakdown Cover cost with Auto Aid?

Recovery Type Price
Roadside Only £20
Roadside & Recovery  £24
Total UK £33

3. GEM Motoring Assist Gem

Breakdown Cover Satisfaction Score 8.86

Placed third in our ranking table was GEM Motoring Assist, with a score of 8.86 from 90 responses. GEM policies offer personal cover so there is assistance available in any of your vehicles or if you are driving a hired or borrowed vehicle, and there are membership benefits such as discounted motor and travel insurance too. 

How much does Breakdown Cover cost with GEM?

GEM's cover is fullly comprehensive (aside from European Cover), with costs varying for the number of people that are included on the policy

Number of People Price
Single  £96.66*
Two people £129.21
Three People £184.69*
Four People £184.69*

4. LV= Britannia RescueDj B9ily X0AASVB8

Breakdown Cover Satisfaction Score 8.34

Britannia Rescue is part of the LV insurance group, so it is no surprise to see it ranked in the top five,  based on 118 responses. Anyone with an LV car insurance policy can add Britannia breakdown cover easily, with five levels of cover available. LV=Britannia also claims an impressive average response time of 53.45 minutes to callouts.

How much does Breakdown Cover cost with Britannia?

Recovery Type  Cost
Roadside Assist  £30
Roadside & Home Assist  £63
UK Recovery £70
UK Recovery & Home Assist  £99
UK & European Assist £142

5. AA Logo -aa (3)

Breakdown Cover Satisfaction Score 8.55

The first of the breakdown giants, the AA finished in fifth place, scoring 8.55 out of 10, based on 643 users. Thanks to a strong reputation the AA has tradtionally been one of the most popular breakdown cover providers, but has increased its range of products to compete with newer rivals. Various types of cover are available with monthly or one-off annual payment plans. Below we show the annual cost for cover of a vehicle. Personal cover starts at £79.

How much does Breakdown Cover cost with The AA?

Recovery Type Price
Roadside assistance and home start  £119*
Roadside assistance, national recovery and home start  £149*
Roadside assistance, national recovery, home start and onward travel £179*

 

Car Breakdown Cover: Who's Cheapest?

Notes 1 (1)

There are many different types of breakdown cover and the level is in the detail. That’s why we’re here to guide you through what’s on offer to get you the best policy at the keenest price.

 Which companies are offering breakdown cover for under £30?

6. Nationwide Download (5)

Breakdown Cover Satisfaction Score 8.54

This breakdown cover is offered by Nationwide Building Society as a part of its FlexPlus current account, so it is not available to those who are not customers. However, it received a rating of 8.54 out of 10 from 75 respondents, indicating a good level of service as well as impressive value for money. Because the breakdown cover is provided in a bundle of insurance products, the effective cost is currently £13 per month if you have a FlexPlus current account.

7. RAC Download (5) (1)

Breakdown Cover Satisfaction Score 8.45

Another of the big breakdown providers is RAC in seventh place, scoring 8.45 out of 10 based on 676 respondents, which puts it just fractions behind the AA. The RAC offers a choice of personal breakdown cover or vehicle breakdown cover, and builds a price depending on the options you add in - with things like battery cover, tyre replacement and key replace available. It is currently offering cover on 18 month fixed plans.

How much does Breakdown Cover cost with the RAC?

Recovery Type Price
Roadside assistance, local recovery and home rescuet (18 months) £162*
Roadside assistance, national recovery, home rescue and onward travel (18 months) £252*
Roadside assistance, national recovery, home rescue, onward travel and 7 days car hire (18 months) £342*

8. Green Flag 0ay 0QFH1_400x 400

Breakdown Cover Satisfaction Score 8.44

Close behind the RAC in eighth place is Green Flag, another of the better-known breakdown cover providers, which was rated 8.44 out of 10 by 565 respondents. Green Flag offers a choice of cover policies specifically for your cars or you as an individual, with a tailored quote based on your circumstances. Unlike its main rivals, Green Flag uses a network of independent providers rather than branded vehicles and mechanics. It promises that its online prices are up to 40 per cent cheaper than if you buy over the phone. 

9. AXA 2000px -AXA_Logo .svg

Breakdown Cover Satisfaction Score 8.16

In ninth place is AXA, which offers breakdown cover as a part of its comprehensive car insurance policies, with four levels of cover including European coverage. As one of the newer providers its score of 8.16 was based on fewer than 20 respondents, but bodes well for anyone who currently has an insurance policy with the firm.

10. Emergency Assist 

Breakdown Cover Satisfaction Score 7.94

Rounding out the top ten is Emergency Assist with a respectable score of 7.94 out of 10 from 16 respondents. Although this is a relatively low number Emergency Assit is one of the newer breakdown providers and will likely be scored by more users in the next poll. Emergency Assist offers three different levels of cover. Personal cover is not an option. 

How much does Breakdown Cover cost with Emergency Assist?

Recovery Type Price
Roadside assistance and local recovery  £24*

Roadside assistance, local recovery, national recovery, homestart and onward travel

£33*
Roadside assistance, local recovery, national recovery, homestart, onward travel and European cover £90*

* Sometimes we show a link with a * next to it. It means that it is an affiliate link and as a result helps HonestJohn.co.uk stay free to use. It's tracked to us and if you go through it, it can sometimes result in a payment or benefit to the site.

 

Value my car