any car - soundproofing - gordonbennet

Some modern cars have little if any soundproofing under the thin plastic trim, or under the very thin boot coverings.

Road noise can be awful in some and thats without the cars in question being fitted with elastic band tyres.

If you remove the plastic interior trim covering the rear wheelarch on your car have a look see what isn't there, on far too many cars (worse on hatchbacks and estates obviously) you will find no sound insulation there or under the boot covering or around the spare wheel well (if its got a spare) or up the rear quarter panels, nor under the back seat for when its folded forward.

I think this problem is getting worse and makers are cutting costs where the average car buyers wouldn't look...probably find the luxury brands are better for this but i haven't dug into them.

Oddly enough in the cars in question the front end wasn't bad in this respect and neither was the underfloor, though thats not to say your car is good in these areas, another place is the inside of doors (pad between inside skin and door card) and blank quarter panels especially on 3 door models.

I have on several family cars removed those trims and put self adhesive soundproofing pads in the affected areas, in all cases the improvements have been huge, especially at higher speeds when road roar increases.

(does anyone remember we used to be able to buy soundproofing kits of cut to size to suit the model felt panels from Exchange and Mart many years ago, i never did by the way)

Anyway this isn't an advert and i don't know this geezer but i have bought self adhesive panels from Ebay and these were easily cut to size, easy to work with and did the job well. Ebay number 271280863285

Only a suggestion as you can buy soundproofing from hundreds of places, your present noisy car if it annoys can be transformed in a couple of hours for little cost.

Edited by gordonbennet on 28/09/2013 at 09:45

any car - soundproofing - Chris M

Looking at the ebay listing, it appears these are used to cover the entire floor or boot area. Is this how you used them? How did you apply them in enclosed spaces? I'm thinking particularly of the rear panels of three door cars (e.g. your Aygo) where there may only be relatively small access holes and it could be difficult positioning a sticky sheet into place.

any car - soundproofing - gordonbennet

Luckily the family Aygo is a 5 door, on doors its possible to remove the door card and stick some cut out panels on the inner skin between door and card, i've seen thinner say 3mm (and thicker around 10mm) panels for sale which would be easier in such places, unless i had to gain access to the door interior mechanism i'd be inclined to not muck about with the waterproof membrane.

I don't know what the trim covering the rear blank on the 3 door Aygo is like, doesn't it clip off like a door card leaving you free to stick a panel or several jigsaw style over the bare primed metal?

If you have an Aygo, the car in question i also revamped the sound system, bought all four replacement speakers via the net and a £40 Sony head unit from Halfords better than half price sale (also an under the seat Pioneer active sub which was the icing on the cake but it was fine without it)...its not worth replacing just the speakers or the head unit without the other, neither is worth a light and will only frustrate more when linked to a good piece, i fitted the head unit first which showed just how awful the standard speakers are.

My inspiration came from this chap and his blog is well worth a peruse, click on the soundproofing link on the right of his page for the way it should be done, i didn't get quite this involved..:-) but his tips on interior removal etc were very handy for fitting the audio.

my107.blogspot.co.uk/

Edited by gordonbennet on 28/09/2013 at 10:27

any car - soundproofing - gordonbennet

it appears these are used to cover the entire floor or boot area. Is this how you used them?

Just realised i didn't actually answer this question, sorry Chris M.

Yes i fully lined the entire boot area, took out the spare wheel and side trims and covered all areas fully jigsaw like cutting round bolts holes, etc, same with the wheelarches covered them entirely inside and extended that coverage as far as possible under the seat and along the sill as practicable in order to lessin the sound creep, make holes in the pads as you go for any bolt or trims holes, dashed difficult to find them afterwards..:-)

any car - soundproofing - mss1tw

Am I the only one that just turns the volume up?

No way in my world it would take a couple of hours by the time various door card/interior trim clips have snapped/bent/broken/rolled away/got lost.......

I'll leave it to those luckier than me.

any car - soundproofing - Chris M

Mine is a 3 door C1 and when I first got the car five months ago, if fact even before I had the car, I was thinking that some sound proofing would be desirable. However, I seem to have got used to the noise and the car's other more endearing features tend to have cancelled out the issue, but your post on another thread has got me thinking that maybe I'll take the plunge. Not sure I'll go to the lengths of stripping the entire car, but the boot floor, rear panels and rear floor may get some attention. My order will be going in.

Regarding the sound system, I'm not big on radio or music in general. I have the local radio station on for traffic news in the car and the admittedly poor system in the C1 is good enough.

As a aside, looking at the CitybugBlog and the c1oc sites, I must get a baseball cap.

any car - soundproofing - John Boy

Many thanks for posting this topic, GB. Also, the link to CitybugBlog is really useful in showing what is involved.

any car - soundproofing - gordonbennet

mss1tw...as always these jobs are best done on a warm day when those pesky annoying and difficult to source correctly clips don't break quite so easily, to be fair i don't think any broke for me. Turning the radio up on this car isn't the answer it just distorts to a mess.

edit...though more clips than enough broke on the C2 to compensate, that definately a car to do on a hot day..;)

Chris M...let us know how you get on when you've completed the task, the owner of the family Aygo is overjoyed and she's very into music which was purgatory before with the poor audio. As you rightly say its such an good little motor in other ways, and i wouldn't mind donning a baseball cap to own the one in the linked site that has a Toyota 1.6 twin cam shoehorned in.;)...mind you @ £3400 plus VAT fitted not so sure about supercharging the existing engine as one link shows.

John Boy...thanks, i made the posting as CM had asked about the soundproofing i mentioned on another thread and the info would have been soon lost, thought it might be useful to others who might be interested in easily and cheaply soundproofing their cars that they otherwise like.

I do like that CityBugBlog, the man has gone to extraordinary lengths and made a very interesting site too.

One other thing about soundproofing, you can buy those 600ml cans of Hammerites underbody seal with added Waxoyl for about a £fiver a can on Amazon, if you buy half a dozen cans and coat the whole underside and suspensions of your jalopy then not only does it help to protect against corrosion (especially with the sparingly painted suspension parts) but its quietens things down quite a bit too as a bonus, lots of coats in the wheelarches. Similar sound suppression has been a useful and unexpected bonus whenever i've done a thorough inside panel and cavity waxoyling, either DIY or pro.

Edited by gordonbennet on 28/09/2013 at 12:19

any car - soundproofing - corax

I did the front doors on my Forester, adding some damping mats to the inside of the outer door skins. I did take the plunge and take the door membranes off, but luckily the mastic that Subaru uses was pliable enough for me to refit them, although I did have to cut them slightly to get around fittings.

I also fitted some 3mm foam to the insides of the door cards, nothing too thick so that they would go back without fouling. I didn't want to cover any of the holes on the inner door skin just in case I need an electric window repair.

With better speakers it was well worth doing - you can hear the music without road roar from the doors drowning it out.

I also did the boot floor and spare wheel well.

One tip - don't use foam that is too thick like the 10mm stuff I used. I can't fasten my full size spare wheel down properly because the threaded bolt now won't reach :)

I would like to soundproof the whole floor, but I'm not sure that I want to go through all the hassle of interior removal.

any car - soundproofing - gordonbennet

Well done Corax, thats just one more thing in the favour of Japanese cars, made with in life service/maintenance in mind, unlike too many others where they are made with manufacturing cost/simplicity as the seemingly sole concern and Heaven help the poor soul who has to work on the thing later.

The most hateful job of all must be when my lad and i fitted a new heater matrix and main radiator to his Seat Toledo, the first item fitted at the factory must be the heater matrix as the entire dash had to be removed...which meant the seats and centre console too, then half the bulkhead engine side to gain access to securing bolts, never again would i touch a VW product and the lad hasn't either. The main radiator change involved removing the entire front of the car, ludicrous, give me Far Eastern design any day.

Where did you source your soundproofing please C if its not an impertinent question?

Edited by gordonbennet on 28/09/2013 at 12:54

any car - soundproofing - corax

Where did you source your soundproofing please C if its not an impertinent question?

Not sure if you can provide links on this website but it was foamsolutionsuk.co.uk.

http://www.foamsolutionsuk.co.uk/soundproofing-9-c.asp

A good range of thicknesses at reasonable prices.

And SilentCoat is a good, cheaper alternative to Dynamat for deadening pads.

Just went outside to see if I could sort out the spare wheel problem and the clamp now fits! Must have settled a bit lower, enough for the thread to reach.

I like Japanese stuff, but find that the German cars suit me better seat wise.

Taking the interior apart and looking into all the nooks and crannies is a great way of finding where manufacturers cut corners, and I've found that the quality of Japanese build is very impressive.

any car - soundproofing - Chris M

The product range on the foamsolutionsuk site is too confusing for me. What do you stick where? That's why, for me at least, GB's recommendation of a one size fits all product is useful.

any car - soundproofing - corax

The product range on the foamsolutionsuk site is too confusing for me. What do you stick where? That's why, for me at least, GB's recommendation of a one size fits all product is useful.

Fair enough Chris M, GB asked for the source so I gave it.

After a while, you become a foam 'expert' :)

any car - soundproofing - RT

Some modern cars have little if any soundproofing under the thin plastic trim, or under the very thin boot coverings.

That was certainly true of cars in the 1970s but hardly true of "modern" cars.

Small, cheap cars are noisier than larger, more expensive cars - 'twas ever thus.

If I though a car was too noisy during the test drive, I wouldn't buy it. Trying to redesign, respecify a car after purchase seems a futile exercise to me.

I have bought and fitted full sound-deadening kits for a Hillman Imp and Mk 1/2 Ford Escort Estates but not need to on more recent cars than that.

any car - soundproofing - Avant

There was a company called Interior Silent Travel which made soundproofing kits for most popular cars, I think in the 60s and 70s. No doubt they stopped when manufacturers put in their own - but I wonder if they're now making economies where they hope customers won't notice, so that there may be a need for kits again.

I had a Mercedes diesel B-class a few cars ago which was quite unacceptable in terms of noise: I had some soundproofing put on the underside of the bonnet, but it made little difference, and I think the engine noise was coming in through the bulkhead.

any car - soundproofing - gordonbennet

''Small, cheap cars are noisier than larger, more expensive cars - 'twas ever thus.

If I though a car was too noisy during the test drive, I wouldn't buy it. Trying to redesign, respecify a car after purchase seems a futile exercise to me.''

Fair comment RT, but i've found the opposite in recent years and especially when you get cars fitted with elastic band overwide tyres, the noise from whch can be terrible.

I've noticed saloon cars to be a lot better, obviously the rear seat is deadening the boot noise but the wheelarches can still be a problem, obviously delve under the wheelarch covers on a proper MB and you'll find thick felt but you're paying for it.

''No doubt they stopped when manufacturers put in their own''

was that the case Avant or had motorists been eating too much laziness by then, seeing as it became increasingly impossible for the average motorist to manage to raise his own bonnet and check his oil or change a flat tyre, the chances of him rolling up his sleeves and stripping the interior were pretty slim..;)

''and I think the engine noise was coming in through the bulkhead.''

Not great cars were they, nor the truly horrid A class, never really accepted by MB enthusiasts especially my venerable MB indy who avoids them like the plague.

any car - soundproofing - Bobbin Threadbare

My MX-5 is noisy as hell, as you might imagine from a soft top. It has a good radio though, with a 'roof up' setting and a 'roof down' setting. The fun of driving it completely negates the noise, for me.

any car - soundproofing - kiss (keep it simple)

A layer of old carpet across the boot floor of a hatchback gives good bang for the buck. I did actually go as far as to put underlay beneath the carpets on one car (Golf). It made a big difference.

any car - soundproofing - gordonbennet

A layer of old carpet across the boot floor of a hatchback gives good bang for the buck. I did actually go as far as to put underlay beneath the carpets on one car (Golf). It made a big difference.

Yes i have used underlay before now and very effective it is too, but as far as i'm aware its not fire resistant and being rubberised i would suspect a nasty thing once alight..not as the rest of a car isn't. I don't know whats fire resistant or not in modern cars, but adding something known for noxious fumes wouldn't help...or is modern underlay fire resistant and i'm missing out on the very cheapest of insulators..

Corax, i forgot earlier sorry, thanks for the lin k to the foam site, serious range they carry, must admit a lot to choose from and i can't work out how much they work out at per sq metre unless i missed an obvious thing.

Bobbin, i suppose an MX5 is designed to be a seat of the pants driving experience, but i really can't stand excess road noise..

Edited by gordonbennet on 28/09/2013 at 19:08

any car - soundproofing - John Boy

I don't know whether modern carpet underlay is fire-resistant or not, but I read somewhere that it shouldn't be used in cars because it absorbs water. Nevertheless, I lined around the spare wheel well in my car with some, which made a noticeable difference to the noise level. When the spare rusts, I'll report back!

any car - soundproofing - Chris M

Update.

Ordered item as per GB's recommendation above. £30 on a best offer plus £7.95 P&P. Arrived yesterday from Latvia.

Fitted to a C1 3 door. Three sheets inside each rear panel, two under the rear seat, three around the rear footwell, two and bit on each rear wheelarch and two along the rear panel. Ran out before I could do the boot floor & spare wheel well, but then I don't think they would have proved very durable as the foam would disintegrate. Instead, I cut a commercial quality carpet tile to fit the bottom of the well. A very straightforward job with the trim easily removed with no breakages. Took about 2 hours.

I'm very pleased with the result with a significant reduction in noise from the rear and in particular, tyre roar - a weak point on this model. Thanks for the tip GB.

any car - soundproofing - gordonbennet
I'm very pleased with the result with a significant reduction in noise from the rear and in particular, tyre roar - a weak point on this model.

Good job well done then, thanks for the update.

any car - soundproofing - corax

So I had already treated the front doors on the Forester to some foam and it yielded fairly good results.

But after reading up a lot on the subject, I decided that the foam in the spare wheel well was just along for the ride and not contributing anything, so I ripped it out ( wasn't that easy being self adhesive). But I left the deadening pads in place.

I decided to remove the interior trim from the tailgate and sides of the boot, and deadened the now exposed outer panels with silent coat deadening pads. The tailgate in particular gives a really hollow resonating sound when rapped with the knuckles. What you want is a dull thud. I stuffed the tailgate aperture and hollow side boot openings with acoustic foam, and also deadened the plastic tailgate panel, before putting it all back together, The acoustic foam is supposed to stop noise reflection in hollow voids.

I drove the car and noticed some difference. The noise was lower, not so annoying, but I felt that there were other areas that needed improving. It's the sum of the parts that you do that add to the overall effect.

The piece de resistance for blocking road noise is mass loaded vinyl, because it's good at stopping low frequency road roar. The car related stuff is a bit pricy, so I went for stuff that is used between plasterboard in rooms called SBM5. Tecsound T50 seemed a good one too, but the former sold in smaller quantities and was cheaper. One thing about mlv is that it's very dense and heavy - 5kg per square metre, and is as good if not better at blocking noise than lead. So if you order some, make sure you get enough as carriage can be pricy. Price goes down the more you order. I ordered two rolls at 18 kg per roll.

If you are laying mlv on metal, you must use a thin layer of foam as a decoupling layer. Mlv works best as an isolated limp material. It can transmit the noise if not decoupled. It's also best as a single uninterrupted layer, but you will have to cut it slightly to allow fixings, wires through it.

Instead of messing about cutting it to fit the boot and spare wheel well, I just used the boot sections (you can pull them out as molded pieces of polystyrene that contain jack, tools e.t.c) as a template to cut a single piece of mlv to go over the top of the boot floor. I didn't have to use foam this way because the floor was the decoupling layer.

The other area that looked suspect was under the rear seat. Apart from some Subaru deadening pads there is no soundproofing, just bare metal. I took the rear seat base out, laid foam over the area up to the boot floor, and covered this with mlv, cutting and shaping to make it fit. It took a bit of persuation to get the seat back, but it went back OK.

None of the products I used this time were self adhesive. If you make a mistake, it's a pain to remove, and the mlv holds everything in place anyway.

I put everything back and drove the car. The results I have to say are pretty fab. It's now quiet enough for me to pinpoint where the noise is mainly coming from, and that's the rear doors, which I haven't treated yet. And the front doors will be done again using mlv as I feel this could be improved. I reckon that will be good enough for me, as I don't think much noise is coming from the floor, although I might change my mind when the doors are done!

The added bonus is that the ride quality has improved, with what must be around 12 kilo's (I used two thirds of a roll of mlv) spread evenly over the rear suspension.

Don't use this if you want to keep your car light ;)

The Forester really is a noisy car in terms of road noise, but this latest mod has really made it much more of a pleasure to drive.

Edited by corax on 14/05/2015 at 18:43

any car - soundproofing - gordonbennet

Wow Corax you've trumped my puny efforts at soundproofing, hats off to you that's very involved and just shows what can be done, makes you wonder why people put up with the horrid road roar of modern hatches with elastic band solid tyres on marques that you would expect to be better.

You're our soundproofing Guru from now on.

I meant to ask you in another thread about the Forester, pleased to see it's still with you and obviously still worth doing the jobs on , any probs?

The Outback we have continues to perform well, that didn't need any extra proofing, nor it must be said does the Landcruiser i bought in Jan or Feb this year which i've fully rustproofed this week...though i now have to decide whether to LPG convert it or give it three years or so with me on petrol alone and then replace it with a grey import late as possible 70 series again...the 90 i have now features the 3.4 V6 petrol which sounds glorious so if anything some bulkhead proofing needs removing..:-)

any car - soundproofing - corax

To be honest gb it wasn't too bad to do. The worst bit is taking out the trim, and making sure you don't break the clips, but I have to say I'm impressed with the Subaru ones, very strong, and I only broke one - that was down to my own ham fistedness. It can be a bit intimidating seeing all these bits of plastic dotted around the car and wondering whether it will all go back, but again, the Forester is lovely - like a big mechano set.

This website is great for info about soundproofing

www.sounddeadenershowdown.com/home

No problems and it's all I hoped to expect in terms of reliability. I wouldn't do this work if I didn't think it was worth it, but it honestly feels a very solid car, mechanically and bodily.

The other thing I'm sorting out is the seats which I find a bit uncomfortable, so I've bought some Impreza WRX ones from Ebay. They bolt in, but sit much lower, so I will be seeing a car upholstery man soon to see what he can do regarding the runners. The drivers one could do with refoaming too.

Those Landcruisers have really got under your skin and I can see the appeal. I won't be soundproofing the bulkhead of mine either. Call me strange but I like the sound of the transmission whirring under my feet :)

any car - soundproofing - John F

Not a problem for most journeys, which are short and slow. For long ones, try the aircraft solution - soft earplugs (minimal additional weight). If listening to music, increase the treble.

any car - soundproofing - Wackyracer

The Outback we have continues to perform well, that didn't need any extra proofing, nor it must be said does the Landcruiser i bought in Jan or Feb this year which i've fully rustproofed this week...though i now have to decide whether to LPG convert it or give it three years or so with me on petrol alone and then replace it with a grey import late as possible 70 series again...the 90 i have now features the 3.4 V6 petrol which sounds glorious so if anything some bulkhead proofing needs removing..:-)

It seems the weather stayed good for you then GB.

any car - soundproofing - gordonbennet

It seems the weather stayed good for you then GB.

Yes, a little windy but otherwise all went well thanks.

I'll try and find the relevant thread and update it.