Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - redcard

Interested in opinions. I think it's probably a must have, considering the weather we've had the last couple of months.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - gordonbennet

Its a nice bonus, but hardly essential, i drove lorries for 29 years before i got one with aircon, and still drive with the window always open by choice.

If it's fitted to a car i'm thinking of buying thats great, but not a deal breaker, i wouldn't buy a black car without aircon though, but then not fussed about black cars anyway, boring colour.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - madf

Let me recall my moments of motoring pain.

Did I enjoy driving in the winter in a 1929 Riley with no heater? No. I got very very cold.

That was the last car I drove without a heater (1969)

Did I enjoy going down teh A1 in summer and sitting in 25C in a jam for hours with windows open, sun blazing down and burning my arms and cooking due to the fumes and heat? No

Have traffic conditions improved since then? No.

I last drove a car without aircon in 1994: a 1.8 Sierra estate.. .My summer driving since then has been comfortable.

Except for a Rover 825D which was new and boiled in a jam on the way to Bournmouth and I had to switch off the aircon and switch on the heater...in 30C.. It was a company car. I have never driven a Rover since after the company ditched Rover cars.

So No. I will never buy a car without aircon. I have never had an aircon issue.. Our 11 year old Yaris has had one regas and the aircon works perfectly.. No reason not to enjoy one...

Edited by madf on 31/07/2014 at 17:19

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - HandCart

Depends on how the climate changes in future. My current car is the first I've ever had which has aircon, and it definitely was useful sometimes in the past few weeks, but otherwise I've hardly used it in the the 2.5 years I've had the car. Most of the time I forget the car even has it available.

In my childhood when most summers seemed to be like the recent month, my dad frequently simply drove topless (clothes-wise). Oh, how on earth did we all manage?!?! (In the house, frost on the inside of the (totally-unheated) bedrooms' windows was standard every winter morning too, but again, somehow we didn't all die.)

A friend of mine nowadays classes aircon as utterly essential. But he and his wife are somewhat well-built. So maybe as the shape and size of the British populace tends towards the American, it will indeed become essential.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - alan1302

In my childhood when most summers seemed to be like the recent month, my dad frequently simply drove topless (clothes-wise). Oh, how on earth did we all manage?!?! (In the house, frost on the inside of the (totally-unheated) bedrooms' windows was standard every winter morning too, but again, somehow we didn't all die.)

Don't need to 'cope' anymore as we have the technology to put aircon in all new cars cheapy and efficiently so might as well have it. Not sure why anyone would not want it.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - HandCart

For myself, I didn't say that I would NOT want it - i'll have it if it's there. My previous 2 cars (spanning 11 years of ownership) had aircon fitted: On one it didn't work, and on the other it stopped working not long after I got the car, and I never bothered getting it fixed.

So for me it's a nice-to-have, but it wouldn't be a showstopper if was absent but the rest of the car fitted the bill.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - Manatee

No I wouldn't have a 'utility' car without it, because there's no reason to any more.

It makes long journeys much easier in heat, strong sun or even wet conditions where it keeps the windows clear effortlessly. Remember people forever wiping a hole in the mist with their hands before you could stop them, leaving grease and sometimes ring scratches on the glass?

I've done 12 hour drives in France going on holiday in the 70s/early 80s that would have been a lot less exhausting with some cool air available.

No aircon in the MX5 of course. But I only drive that when I want to.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - P3t3r

No. I almost never open the windows because:

It's noisy

It can let dust etc. in

It will use more fuel at higher speeds

You can get sun burn

As it's standard for most trim levels on modern cars, I don't really see a reason to not have it.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - skidpan

Last car I bought without air con was in 1996.

Would I buy another car now without air con, no way.

Wifes car has climate, only car we have had with such a system. It is much better than simple air con and I would prefer to have it fitted on my car (it was an option) but when I bought the car it would have been a factory order and loads of extra cash on top of the stock car (not simply the extra for climate). Air con suffices.

Done about 400 miles this week, without air con most would have been unbearable.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - Wackyracer
Done about 400 miles this week, without air con most would have been unbearable.

I did 390miles yesterday in a car without air con. Just bearable but, would have been alot nicer with air con.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - Cyd

No. I almost never open the windows because:

It's noisy

It can let dust etc. in

It will use more fuel at higher speeds

You can get sun burn

And...for those of us who get hay fever it defeats the object of having a pollen filter.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - Andrew-T

I should think most cars now have air-con, except maybe the entry-level models?

Early cars with air-con did use more fuel, but I believe that is much less of an issue now. It has certainly been useful recently, especially with 3 passengers, but it's equally (if not more) useful in colder weather for demisting the screen.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - Happy Blue!

No. Unthinkable now to buy a car without. Electric and heated mirrors are another must, but thereafter I could cope without most modern toys.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - Andrew-T

Electric and heated mirrors are another must, but thereafter I could cope without most modern toys.

I had a 1983 Cavalier estate with those, a fairly novel gimmick at the time. Most cars now have electric mirrors, but that Cavalier was the only car I have owned with heated ones. Can't say I have ever missed them since.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - Trilogy

Depends what you are buying. And do you have a family to consider?

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - AlexT

Maybe in the uk. But where I live there were 32 degrees Celsius today, so that is aa definite no no. I'd rather drive without power steering and loads of other things than without an aircon.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - RT

Aircon isn't just about temperature reduction/control - it also provides humidity reduction/control - in the UK climate that's the more valuable!

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - Smileyman

No, I've got used to not baking in the car on hot days - even more so not sweating on humid days ... getting out the car on such days is awful ... shirt wet with sweat for instance.

BUT, I also have a sunroof, and on the less hot days I prefer to open the roof, it's also good for working on the suntan!

I live & work in the southeast, if I were based further north, in Scotland for instance I might be willing to do without the aircon, but will never give up the sunroof (nice to see Nissan have re-introduced sunroof to their range)

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - quizman

I could at a push manage without air con on my car. But I couldn't manage without it on my tractor and especially on my combine. They get very hot!

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - coopshere
Wouldn't dream of buying one without climate control. Can't imagine what my health would be like having to open a window to breathe in all the diesel pollutants in the air now. Mine is on permanently and just adjust the temperature accordingly.
Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - mss1tw

I did on purpose. More to go wrong, and it doesn't stop me sweating in summer anyway.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - focussed

Aircon just makes life more comfortable in summer, it has been 35C mid afternoon here most days and it's much nicer to cool down in the car or truck with aircon rather than suffer the noise and buffeting of having to drive with the windows open. In winter it's the quickest way of demisting the screen without waiting for the heater to warm up to get the demist working. Would I buy a vehicle without it? No - my minimum standard fit is leccy windows+leccy and heated mirrors+basic aircon+ a half decent sound system, anything over and above this is a bonus.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - alan1302

I did on purpose. More to go wrong, and it doesn't stop me sweating in summer anyway.

How can it not stop you sweating? It makes the car cool so your body does not need to.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - mss1tw

I did on purpose. More to go wrong, and it doesn't stop me sweating in summer anyway.

How can it not stop you sweating? It makes the car cool so your body does not need to.

Well, tell that to my arnpits ;)

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - Manatee

I did on purpose. More to go wrong, and it doesn't stop me sweating in summer anyway.

How can it not stop you sweating? It makes the car cool so your body does not need to.

Well, tell that to my arnpits ;)

Any excuse to watch this again - Swedish Chemist's Shop, NTNON.

www.youtube.com/watch?v=sI45Q_Rp11A

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - Wackyracer

Air con will be top of my list of must haves when I buy another car in the future.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - Engineer Andy

Air con will be top of my list of must haves when I buy another car in the future.

Ditto. My first car (1996 Micra) had no electronic 'gizmos' like A/C or electric windows, so I relied on opening the front windows, rear quarter-lights/manual sunroof and the fan. When on the move, things were OK (unless it was a really hot day [over 28degC]), but horrible in slow/non-moving traffic jams.

My 2nd (and current) car has climate-controlled A/C, something I'd not compromise on for my next car. Far, far better than manual A/C as its an extra distraction to keep altering the cooling and/or airflow level on the move, and I'm sure the climate-controlled A/C's 'auto' function saves on fuel by only providing exactly what cooling/airflow is necessary to achieve the desired temperature. I also like its ability to know when its best to have the air recirculator on/off as well to ensure the car (in very hot weather) cools down very rapidly.

I wonder if (and when) cars will have full-on (proper) A/C with the ability to heat as well as cool (revsersible heat pump), as presumably most cars (perhaps except the most expensive ones) use an electric heating coil until the engine warms up (I hoping they use the heat emitted from the engine as its just wasted otherwise).

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - mss1tw

I did on purpose. More to go wrong, and it doesn't stop me sweating in summer anyway.

How can it not stop you sweating? It makes the car cool so your body does not need to.

Well, tell that to my arnpits ;)

Any excuse to watch this again - Swedish Chemist's Shop, NTNON.

www.youtube.com/watch?v=sI45Q_Rp11A

Yes, grateful it is just my armpits :-D

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - bintang

No.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - idle_chatterer

Very simple answer - no. I haven't had a car since 1996 without air conditioning (incidentally also ABS and increasing numbers of airbags too).

Air con is widely fitted these days, it's not *that* expensive to maintain and repair and greatly increases comfort all year round (when the temperature is above 4C).

I wouldn't prioritise it above ABS, EBD, EBA (brake asist), ASC (stability control) and a full compliment of airbags (6 or 7) but then I wouldn't consider any car without ALL of these things nowadays. They are readily available and have been fitted for 10+ years so I'd walk away from anything that doesn't have them all.

Interestingly, public information advertising in Victoria (Australia) where I currently live is pushing the selection of cars with collision avoidance systems fitted and uses graphic footage to demonstrate it.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - mss1tw
Interestingly, public information advertising in Victoria (Australia) where I currently live is pushing the selection of cars with collision avoidance systems fitted and uses graphic footage to demonstrate it.

Every car and motorbike I've ever driven has had that by default...

True it hasn't always worked faultlessly (What ever does?), but well enough to keep me and all other road users I've ever encountered, alive and uninjured.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - idle_chatterer
Interestingly, public information advertising in Victoria (Australia) where I currently live is pushing the selection of cars with collision avoidance systems fitted and uses graphic footage to demonstrate it.

Every car and motorbike I've ever driven has had that by default...

True it hasn't always worked faultlessly (What ever does?), but well enough to keep me and all other road users I've ever encountered, alive and uninjured.

I assume that this new electronic variety never checks its mobile phone, makes or answers calls (handsfree or otherwise), tunes the radio, changes the CD/iPod track, is distracted by passengers in the car, drinks alcohol, lacks sleep or is distracted by the scenery or other events occuring other than in the direction of travel ?

There was previously advertising suggesting that people shouldn't buy new cars without stability control fitted and this changed buying behaviour. Of course your driving abilities might outrank the electronic systems, I don't think that mine do though - which is the point isn't it ?

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - gordonbennet

I'm not convinced by electronic collision avoidance or any other system that allows the car to control itself.

Do not want to be in such a vehicle when the brakes and possibly steering get commandeered by the electronics of the car having a mardy through not getting an unplanned reboot.

Doesn't bother me in the least if everything else is controlled by that which knows best, but brakes and steering, no ta they can keep that.

Part of the reason i shall never have a electric parking brake on any vehicle i own (won't have any choice on lorry i drive soon unless i get the HINO requested)...in the event of brake failure you still have the handbrake, not wonderful by any means but better than nothing...

..and yes i have had full brake failure and yes the very good rear drum handbrake saved the day.

Edited by gordonbennet on 03/08/2014 at 09:48

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - Manatee
I wonder how long it will be before I hear somebody say, after an accident, "it wasn't my fault, the collision avoidance system didn't work"?

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - gordonbennet

Lorries in many ways are now getting sillier than cars for electronic take over, its going to lead to further dumbing down of the skills of the person required to attend the wheel, thats a very serious issue in my opinion and needs looking at by those who have the power to apply some common sense brakes.

Not sure if cars have got to this stage yet, but when you switch the ignition off on some of the latest lorries, the engine obviously switches off, the electric parking brake is applied, the gearbox is put into neutral and the lights turned off for good measure.

Now i'm a bit old fashioned here, and its not that long ago when as a lorry driver you also left the vehicle in gear just as you would a car (thats not as straighforward as its used to be with automated manual on any vehicle), i've driven lorries with a transmission handbrake drum so effectively working on one drive axle wheel only with a normal diff (secondary dead man brake you used as a whilst driving temp parking barke would come off in those days as air pressure dropped if you applied it when parked), on some designs the parking brake worked on the drive axle only and i've had drive brakes worn enough that the lorry has started to roll away when warm with parking brake fully applied....even now some lorry designs only apply the parking brake to the tractor unit and not the trailer.

In an ideal world things like this don't happen, but when everything becomes automated the person behind the wheel, bike, car, bus , van or lorry loses the feel for whats normal and whats happening, the world isn't perfect hwoever and things go wrong, systems fail, people make mistakes, vehicles get neglected maintained badly and abused.

In practice whats going to happen is that drivers will increasingly come to rely on these systems, in theory they could switch off the ignition when the lorry is still doing 5mph and step out leaving the thing to its own devices....and quite how you're supposed to leave one of these new things (i do not want) in gear is anyone's guess, probably end up on a disciplinary at some companies for even considering such a thing.

Edited by gordonbennet on 03/08/2014 at 10:57

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - Wackyracer

When I worked for one company about 10 years ago, They had these engine cut off timer installed on all there FM12's If you did not touch the throttle for 2 or 3 mins it would stop the engine. It was a pain as usually you'd stop in traffic and just as the traffic started moving it would cut the engine.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - bintang

Farm-type Landrovers I drove in the 50s-60s had transmission handbrakes. Maybe they still do?

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - HandCart

>>”greatly increases comfort all year round (when the temperature is above 4C).

4 degrees Celsius?!?! I doubt I even switch my simple (on-or-off) aircon on unless the temperature is above 20 C. And my wife and kid (who are fussy) have never complained. (In fact, does it ever even get down as low as 4C in Australia?)

>>”EBD, EBA (brake assist), ASC (stability control) and a full complement of airbags (6 or 7) but then I wouldn't consider any car without ALL of these things nowadays. They are readily available and have been fitted for 10+ years so I'd walk away from anything that doesn't have them all.

You must have plenty of money then - I consider anything beyond just a driver airbag a bonus!

>>”public information advertising in Australia is pushing the selection of cars with collision avoidance systems.. ..There was previously advertising suggesting that people shouldn't buy new cars without stability control fitted and this changed buying behaviour.

Are driving standards worse in Australia then, or the roads coated in teflon or sumfink?? because in the UK I’ve never seen ANY public information advertising about stability control or collision-avoidance systems.

Crikey, it sounds calamitous outdoors – sounds like we shouldn’t even dare venturing out in anything less than a Chieftan Tank (with climate control, of course) !


Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - Manatee

Are driving standards worse in Australia then, or the roads coated in teflon or sumfink?? because in the UK I’ve never seen ANY public information advertising about stability control or collision-avoidance systems.

Perhaps Oz goes doen the route of advice rather than compulsion. Stability control is compulsory on new cars sold in the EU and the same has been mooted for collision avoidance.

I think I'd rather have the Oz approach if that's the case.

Would you buy a car without air conditioning? - jamie745

Answer to the original question is no. I had a problem with my climate control in the S-Type this year but got it fixed without costing too much and it was worth it, as the first day I had it working again it wasn't far off 30 degrees C in my office that day. I went out for a while to cool down by sitting there running the car, not going anywhere.

I've always had the climate control on since I bought the car 3 years ago and it makes a difference. If you're chilled to 16C on a blazing hot day, you feel cool and relaxed. You don't want to be hot in the car. It makes you uncomfortable, which makes you impatient and stressed. Not a bright plan.