Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - Steveieb

Noticed an article in yesterday's Sunday Times linking into a company who profess to remove the DPF from your car and then reseal the exhaust, leaving it inperceptable to MOT test engineers.

Spoke to a local German car specialist who says no such thing they can tell straight away and fail the car. They spell lthe death knell for the urban diesel. So how do buses conform? I regularly see new ones belching out black fumes.

Its all down to these new EC emisiions regulations he says. An exhaust is meant to extract the fumes fom the car not recycle them until they are cleaner than the air going in.

Another reason to vote UKIP?

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - groaver
Another reason to vote UKIP?

You're going to have to tell me the first one.

A free years subscription to the Daily Mail, perhaps?

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - gordonbennet

Whether UKIP do well or not won't make a scrap of difference to this, the DPF is here to stay, and the VED situation is bound to change on Diesels in due course now they've found out that umpteen thousand people are dying of respiratory exacerbated illnesses, due to Diesels apparently.

You have to decide what you want and don't want in a car and buy accordingly, don't want the latest electronics and things like DPF's don't buy them, you can buy simple but maybe have to go older, and maintain/rustproof to make them last (our choice) or buy outside the box, Hilux sort of thing, or go petrol/hybrid, but they'll have achilees heels too, some due to electronics and emission controls..

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - madf

Another reason to vote UKIP?

If you seriously think voting UKIP will allow the UK car industry to jettison DPFs, you are either naive or stupid. The car industry is worldwide committed to reducing air pollution and has been since California started the trend in the early 1970s..

UKIP can say or so what they like: world trends to cleaner vehicles will continue...

Edited by madf on 05/05/2014 at 17:56

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - thunderbird

Another reason to vote UKIP?

If you seriously think voting UKIP will allow the UK car industry to jettison DPFs, you are either naive or stupid. The car industry is worldwide committed to reducing air pollution and has been since California started the trend in the early 1970s..

UKIP can say or so what they like: world trends to cleaner vehicles will continue...

Totally Agree.

Perhaps the OP's original post should be edited due to its less than subtle political content..

Any thoughts moderators?

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - Avant

Broadly I agree, Thunderbird, but it's difficult to delete anything as it makes the subsequent comments meaningless.

Everyone - Stick to motoring in this thread please: if you want to discuss politics, there is a 'general discussion' thread where people who have more time on their hands than I do can shoot from the hip if they wish to.

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - Gibbo_Wirral

On Peugeots its quite common to open up a DPF and gut out the internals, and put it back together. This is done because there's no pass through pipes generally available to put in place of the DPF. Most DPFs are a two part system, but there is one which needs to be cut and welded back together.

It all depends on how detailed the MOT inspection is if they'll pick up the unit is hollow, or the welded ones look obvious. Maybe they'll introduce x-ray scanners to see inside the DPF!

Personally I'd rather leave things as they are, replacing the part when its reached the end of its life. I can't see the point of remapping and deleting the DPF from the ECU, its caused some people lots of hassle with unexpected limp modes and EMLs.

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - diddy1234

tell that to the owners of Mitsubisihi Shogn's.

no end of problems there.

Also as a side note, I have no idea why but for some years Mitsubishi had dpf filters on their shogan's and the following year they did not.

Overall the idea of a DPF just doesn't work on 4x4's that (if used for what they were designed for) would be pottering about on farmers fields.

not exactly driving at 55mph for long perriods !

Edited by diddy1234 on 06/05/2014 at 17:06

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - bananastand

Hey Thunderbird and the others thanks for the excellent posts on a certain thread now closed.

The EU is run by lobbyists for big business. It does not own the means of production, but controls them by regulation and bureaucracy. This means that it is becoming more and more difficult, to the point of impossibility, for smaller businesses to start up or survive.

There was a report recently that told of independent ironworkers being forced to get a CE mark on their products, to have visits from inspectors, display various certificates, go on training courses, etc etc. Obviously they can't. BUT they MIGHT get an "excemption", for which they are meant to be grateful.

ANYWAY - ON THE SUBJECT OF CARS - within a few years regulation and bureaucracy (see above) coupled with technology will see MANDATORY self-drive safety systems and real-time GPS tracking of all vehicles. For our own good, as always.

Now before you start shouting "Daily Fail" or "Fruitcake", or other insults, consider where exactly I might be *factually* wrong.

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - Ed V

Getting rid of nutters who might kill me, stopping all speeding cars sounds good to me! From the man with a red flag to GPS - terrific.

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - Trilogy

I have a feeling that DPFs are not fitted to cars in some countries. An Aussie was telling me they are not fitted down that way. TBH, no idea if he was correct.

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - thunderbird

I have a feeling that DPFs are not fitted to cars in some countries. An Aussie was telling me they are not fitted down that way. TBH, no idea if he was correct.

Found this when i searched

Lower ‘Euro 5’ exhaust emissions standards will be imposed for all new cars in Australia from 2013 – and further tightened to ‘Euro 6’ levels in 2018. The move will progressively slash new car emissions, and by 2018 particulate matter emissions (of diesels in particular) will drop by up to 90 per cent, NOx (oxides of nitrogen) by up to 70 per cent and unburned hydrocarbons by 50 per cent. All three pollutants are known to have adverse impacts on human health – in particular respiratory health

Looks like your Aussie was right before 2013 and wrong since 2013 (presuming like Europe DPF is mandatory with Euro 5 - but there is no way they can reduce particles without one).

Appears they are several years behind Europe.

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - Bolt

If no one wants a DPF why buy a motor with one,especially as its being said all the time petrols are now as economical as diesels.

I dont see that DPF will ever go away anytime soon, they are supposed to help clean up the air (or prevent the air getting any worse) but if they help to cut down peoples breathing problems then they are worth whatever cost,I dont see where the politics comes into it health wise

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - nortones2

Euro 6b will introduce PM control on DI gasoline engines, when and if a new particulate measurement technique is developed. tiny.cc/u9phfx See introduction dates.....

Edited by nortones2 on 07/05/2014 at 14:58

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - Bolt

Are these limits reachable by manufacturers ?,I would have thought they would be close to impossible or at least very expensive to implement

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - Bromptonaut

Its all down to these new EC emisiions regulations he says. An exhaust is meant to extract the fumes fom the car not recycle them until they are cleaner than the air going in.

Do you accept that particulate matter in exhaust emissions is a health hazard? If so how else do you propose controlling hem?

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - sam87
Are we sure this is a bad thing? Yes it probably was when the likes of vw where shoving dpf's into the 2.0 diesels back in the mid 2000's but manufactures seem to have things pretty well sussed now.. Actually it interests me to read what many manufactures are trying to lower co2 emissions and the like. Unfortunately dpf's and stop start etc etc got a bad name before the game properly began because of the antics vw and Peugeot got up to.
Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - Steveieb

I was speaking to a commercial vehicle mechanic yesterday and he said that the DPF problem is also affecting the van and lorry markets to the extent that large operators are buying up old stock which do not have DPF's fitted and spending up to £40k on refurbishing them before putting them into service.

Personally speaking I prefer the characteristics of the old 1.9 PD VW engine which is fitted to my A4 which I understand was replaced because it would not meet current emission parameters.

In a reply to a reader HJ listed to B - V of manufacturers who have been able to successfully fit DPF's. It started with BMW and finished with Vanxhall if my memory served me right. Renault seem to have sorted it too by fitting the DPF on the engine block.

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - Bromptonaut

They spell lthe death knell for the urban diesel. So how do buses conform? I regularly see new ones belching out black fumes.

Where do you see new buses belching out black fumes? If you can name the operator and make/model or reg then report them.

OTOH I cycled daily in Central London from 1999 until redundancy in November 2013. Smoke free buses were new in '99 and had exhausts that smelled like a dustcart. They soon sorted that though and I've not seen a TfL bus belch fumes in intervening years. Lots, including the so called 'Borismaster' are hybrids.

Even the retianed Routemasters have been sorted out.

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - dan86

All new lorries and buses use as blue and u no longer see black smoke belching from them. Adele is different to do as far as I know but I don't know why they don't use it on cars and only on larger commercial vehicles.

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - Andrew-T

< Where do you see new buses belching out black fumes? If you can name the operator and make/model or reg then report them. >

The new Arriva buses running in NW Cheshire run on gas. There's a big tank on the roof, and the vehicle is noticeably quieter than a diesel. Not sure of the makers, but it looks like a standard bus.

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - dan86

We had a gas power lorry on trial it was quiter than the diesel ones but I don't it worked out economically for the company.

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - Ethan Edwards

I followed a Blue metallic S type Jag from Colchester to Chelmsford the other evening. Memorable as I couldn't work out what kind of vehicle was making it's own smokescreen. It must be the James Bond Aston Martin DB5 I thought. But no a 54 reg (I think from memory) creating its very own smoke screen...must be a factory option for wannabe spies? I see this guy regularly on the A12 and he doesn't look like he works for Mi5 but who knows. When he toes it he leaves a splash of black soot on the ground in the lane behind him...even at 50 plus mph thats the kind of cloud I'm talking about.

HOW DOES HE GET AN MOT !!!!! Are they blind deaf and dumb these testers?

Yesterday a 55 reg pale metallic blue Focus near Chelmsford on the A12 ..he had his lights on but the only one that worked was one headlight and that was badly adjusted as to dazzle. No brake lights nothing (I declined to be behind someone who gives no warning of stopping whilst your in heavy traffic at speed) - again MOT test? How? I believe Its not a lack of cash but lack of grey matter between the ears imo that leads to this procession of pr4tts.

I have all this on my in car video and now really I'm thinking about sending the video evidence to the authorites as these people cause accidents.

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - Ed V

Do you not think an MOT can be bought for about £50?

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - alan1302

I followed a Blue metallic S type Jag from Colchester to Chelmsford the other evening. Memorable as I couldn't work out what kind of vehicle was making it's own smokescreen. It must be the James Bond Aston Martin DB5 I thought. But no a 54 reg (I think from memory) creating its very own smoke screen...must be a factory option for wannabe spies? I see this guy regularly on the A12 and he doesn't look like he works for Mi5 but who knows. When he toes it he leaves a splash of black soot on the ground in the lane behind him...even at 50 plus mph thats the kind of cloud I'm talking about.

HOW DOES HE GET AN MOT !!!!! Are they blind deaf and dumb these testers?

Yesterday a 55 reg pale metallic blue Focus near Chelmsford on the A12 ..he had his lights on but the only one that worked was one headlight and that was badly adjusted as to dazzle. No brake lights nothing (I declined to be behind someone who gives no warning of stopping whilst your in heavy traffic at speed) - again MOT test? How? I believe Its not a lack of cash but lack of grey matter between the ears imo that leads to this procession of pr4tts.

I have all this on my in car video and now really I'm thinking about sending the video evidence to the authorites as these people cause accidents.

Why do you think it's something that has been missed whilst having an MOT? Unless you have been watching them for a year you don't know when the test will have been.

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - jamie745

Well I'll be voting UKIP anyway but not because of diesel motor regulations.

Even if the UK pulled out of the EU, the multinational manufacturers would still have to comply with these rules to sell to what's left of the EU, so they'll likely sell us the same cars anyway.

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - Bromptonaut

Even if the UK pulled out of the EU, the multinational manufacturers would still have to comply with these rules to sell to what's left of the EU, so they'll likely sell us the same cars anyway.

Spot on. Outside the EU we'd still be seen by multinationals as in same European 'region'. Only difference would be we'd lose any oppotunity to influence the rules governing that region.

My EU version Sony MP3 player has volume limiter which makes keeping it at max output to play through home or car Hi Fi problematic. I don't think there's a different version for Switzerland or Norway.

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - jamie745

Spot on. Outside the EU we'd still be seen by multinationals as in same European 'region'. Only difference would be we'd lose any oppotunity to influence the rules governing that region.

Well no the big difference would be we'd no longer pay around £35,000 every 60 seconds to have absolutely no influence over these rules at all, as is currently the case. We have no influence as a paying member, in a voting minority.

We have no influence over the United States' regulations, but we still have to comply with them if we want to flog them something. It's called business, and I couldn't give a toss what multinationals think.

I'll have my £35k a minute back please.

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - bananastand

Nice one Jamie

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - Ian_SW

Where do you see new buses belching out black fumes? If you can name the operator and make/model or reg then report them.

There's plenty of buses belching out black smoke in York, including several with a council advert on the back to encourage you to "go green" and take the bus! Admittedly most of these buses are over ten years old, probably London's cast offs.

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - bananastand

Brompto and everyone - please don't shout, but the EU is on the point of collapse, and we are an island with hundreds of years of trading history. We are (I think) the sixth largest trading nation. We do not need the EU and we don't need to "influence" the super-corrupt politburo that dreams up the "rules". Teddy "bachelor boy" Heath gave away our seas, yes OUR seas - but we can take them back. The EU has virtually denuded them of fish but that can be repaired.

Anyway - real time GPS tracking of all cars, the recording of all your movements, fines for the least infarction, infraction, what's the word? Of the rules. Remote control of your speed. Remote control of your car use. Immobilising of your car if you are disobedient.

If you are one of those who sticks to the line "if you have nothing to hide you have nothing to fear", then I can't help you.

I've got plenty to hide, and so have you.

Diesels - DPFs When will the EC leave us alone! - madf

Brompto and everyone - please don't shout, but the EU is on the point of collapse

Err:

When a system of Government is "on the point of collpase".. there are riots in the streets or Opposition Parties who agree on breaking it up - and have a strong chance of power - or the people are starving..

The EC has none of those.###

I have read about the "EC being on the point of collpase" for the last decade... Meanwhile the UK has had riots and has a Party wanting to break it up which may very well win this year's referendum

.Pots calling kettles black...

#### the UK has had worse riots.


Edited by madf on 10/05/2014 at 03:34