Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 [Read Only] - Pugugly

***** This thread is now closed, please CLICK HERE to go to Volume 4 *****


To continue the debate on the effects of the so called Credit Crunch.

Vol: 2 can be found by clicking:- here


All CC related stuff will be decanted in here.


Keep it relevant, motoring is linked to the crisis, any "Yah Booh Poltics" will be chopped.

Edited by Dynamic Dave on 10/11/2008 at 18:54

Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - Bill Payer
Another one bites the dust:

Administrators have gone into the Sidlow Group, which has dealerships for Audi, Volkwagen, Seat, Peugeot, Citroen and Alfa Romeo.

Its dealerships included VW Horsham, Seat Gatwick, Audi Gatwick, Citroen East Grinstead, Alfa Romeo Gatwick and Peugeot Gatwick.
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - alex

That's not all ...

According the the Motor Trader website today:

* "Renault is poised to close several dealerships in its retail division following a review of the business. The group is considering the future of its Dartford and London City dealerships as well as its Beddington Farm bodyshop and Croydon Service Centre."

* "Barkers Motor Group (the NE Lincolnshire-based dealer) has ceased trading at its Citroen site in Grimsby."
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - charlesb
Crikey! I take a week off with the kids for half term - no computer access - come back to find I've spawned 3 volumes of Credit Crunching Threads!!!


Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - madf
Year over Year UK car new car sales fell
Auguust 2008 : 18.6%
September :21.2%..


I reckon by the end of the recession (2010?) we will see UK new car sales fall 50%...(on a month by month basis)..
So what is happeing now can only get worse.
Yes credit is getting easier to obtain (not that that means much) but the real economy is deteriorating quickly.

I do fancy a Bentley Continental...
under £25k...

Edited by madf on 03/11/2008 at 14:10

Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - TheOilBurner
* "Renault is poised to close several dealerships in its retail division...


Is that the credit crunch or just Renault finally realising that "some" of it's dealerships are beyond a joke?
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - charlesb
Anyway... having read all the volumes....amazing how many people actually have a clue about what's happening in the world.

I did see last week that the brand spanking new Honda Dealership in Reading, which has been ready for a few weeks is completely deserted.

The carpark has NO cars outside, the inside is squeaky clean and I can't help feel that they won't open it as it will cost them too much.

I mean, the land costs and the building costs have all been paid, but without buyers, why would you employ people and fill it up with vehicles that can't be sold during this crunch.

I'm with several other people here, nervous about my own employment
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - alex

More news on Motor Trader today (www.talkingmotors.com):

"Pendragon has closed its Stratstone Volvo dealership in Reading."

"The London Road site closed its doors on Friday afternoon [Oct 31] after nearly 28 years of trading."

Says a Pendragon spokesperson, "We have sustained continued losses at this business for some time."
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - Alanovich
I'm not surprised. My next door neighbour went there, cash in hand, to buy a brand new S40 a few years back. They would not give him a penny off list price, so he rang a dealer in Barnsley who gave him a very nice discount.

I drove past there this morning and the forecourt was very much full, looked business as usual. There is also an attached Cadillac showroom, I suppose that will go too.
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - alex

Re: Stratstone Volvo in Reading

When "Alanovich" drove past he found it business as usual ..

According to the local Reading Evening Post (online edition) dated October 31, a staff member at the dealership was quoted as saying:

"I can't say too much because, although we close today, we still have to work here for a couple of weeks more to clear up everything."

"To be honest, I don't think they [the management] have even put up a notice on the door to tell the customers what is going on."
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - oldnotbold
www.reuters.com/article/marketsNews/idUSSAT0058212...9

Volvo Trucks making 600 redundant in Belgium and Stockholm in addition to 1380 redundancies already announced.
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - malden blue
I have heard that up to 50,000 construction workers will be laid off by xmas in London alone, I work on large commercial projects in the City and on all of the 20 odd sites I am dealing with at the moment not one of the project teams running the sites or the construction staff have a a 'next project' to go to when the one they are on finishes


It has NEVER been this bad, and because the people are being laid off in dribs and drabs it is not making headlines


And to keep things car related I am getting 5 calls a day from car leasing companies who I have contacted in the past, they are telling me business is down 50-75%, some of the lease deals are amazing however! (if anyone was buying that is)
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - Alanovich
Update on Stratstone Volvo, Reading.

On this morning's fly-by (before I hit the multi-mile tail back crawling down the A4 in to Reading centre), there was an empty car transporter in the layby outside and a load of brand new unregistered Volvos being lined up to go on the trailer.

So long, Stratstone.

Edited by Alanovich on 04/11/2008 at 11:48

Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - Falkirk Bairn
So long Stratstone Volvo Reading


Looked last week and Pendragon(parent of Stratstone & Evans-Halshaw) shares were 6p each valuing the company as £30m+/-

That is for 300+ branches that include Evans-Halshaw, Stratstone, + leasing Cos + commercial. (£30m divided by 300 only gives a value of £100,000/outlet - not enough to buy 2 upmarket Jaguars -or 5 x Jaguarnots (X-types)

It might mean that a few other outlets may follow Volvo Reading unless the car strapped manufacturers dig deeper into their pockets to sustain dealer outlets.
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - henry k
Timing is all important !!!!

With its contemporary new facility in Johannesburg, South African now boasts the largest Porsche Centre in the world.

A key part of ensuring seamless servicing and growth to appease their loyal customer base locally, the new Porsche Centre Johannesburg covers 18 781 square meters and houses 334 parking bays.

No expense spared

A R110 million investment, the Centre is seen as a commitment to the Porsche brand in South Africa, which has been around locally since 1952. ( approx 15 Rand / £ )

Local Porsche boss Toby Venter regards it as money well spent. "The Centre's construction seeks to reinvest in and demonstrate commitment to our customers and to the Porsche brand and is the first in a series of developments we are undertaking around the country."

...Porsche is ensuring it has brings similar levels of service to its customers at the coast too. "We have already broken ground in Umhlanga Ridge, Durban, and Porsche customers in Cape Town can look forward to modern facilities as construction commences at a new site in Century City during September this year," Venter said.

Full customer experience

Featuring a state of the art workshop, including body shop and separate pre-delivery centre, Porsche customers are set for a hassle free servicing experience.

The large parts warehouse supplies both the dealership and distribution channels around South Africa, endeavouring to swiftly dispatch even the most bespoke parts for delivery.

Porsche customers can work up a sweat whilst their vehicles are being fettled in the on-site gym, or relax in the either the adjacent environmental wetland area or coffee shop.

A comprehensively quipped 72-seater auditorium will host training seminars for Porsche personnel and technicians from accross the country whilst dovetailing as a new model launch centre and Porsche Club events venue.

I guess a few people are keeping everything crossed on this one .:-)


Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - alex

More gloomy news, I'm afraid ...

The SMMT will publish its October car sales figures tomorrow.

According to today's The Times (online edition) "British car sales are expected to show their sharpest fall for 17 years. The Times has learnt that sales were worse than in September, when they fell 21 per cent, and could have fallen by as much as 25 per cent. This would be the steepest decline since 1991."

But the UK isn't alone.

According to The Times, new car sales in October fell by 8 per cent in Gremany, 18.9 per cent in Italy and by a whopping 40 per cent (forty per cent) in Spain.
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - daveyjp
I've just had an e-mail from my local Audi dealer. Apparently autumn is the ideal time to buy a cabrio because it allows you to use all the gadgets to keep you warm with the roof down!

PCP rates are quite low though 6.5-7%.

I'll give it a miss.
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - Screwloose
Apparently autumn is the ideal time to buy a cabrio...


.... or they're going to be stuck financing it until the first nice day in May.
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - Lud
autumn is the ideal time to buy a cabrio...


Always was. Not that one would want a bargain one these days.
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - Kevin
Japanese domestic car sales down 6.6% in October. Sales of small and standard-sized cars down 13.1% to their lowest level for 40 years.

tinyurl.com/68w22h

Kevin...

Edited by Kevin on 05/11/2008 at 19:17

Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - gmac
13.1% of what though ? We see Italy sales off 18.x%, German sales off 8% but what is that in real terms and what is the break even of the manufacturers ?
If manufacturer X only needs to make and sell Y cars per month to breakeven and sales down 13.1% is equivalent to Y + 500% is it such a disaster ?

It's like reading other media sources of doom round here...
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - henry k
BMW details
The Munich-based company said net profit for the July-September period fell to £250m from £690m a year ago. Sales were down 9% to £10.5bn from £11.66bn.

...and that it would cut output by another 40,000 units this year, on top of 25,000 announced earlier.


Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - gmac
I know it was reported yesterday BMW would not announce what they thought the end of year figures would be as basically they had no idea.

When Ford refinanced twelve to eighteen months ago I thought it might be a big mistake. In light of what is happening it may just prove to be a master stroke. Imagine being a car manufacturer now going cap in hand to the bank asking for a $23bn remortgage today...
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - madf
GM are within weeks of going bust...
tinyurl.com/5utwap

and even IF they are rescued US car sales are falling 40% vs last year.

I expect oil prices to collpase next year due to world wide recession: the worst since 1929...(all my view: official forecasts are much more optimistic)
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - madf
And with UK interest rates likely to fall below 3% in 2009, now is NOT the time to borrow money..

but as most cars are imported and sterling is quite liely to fall to £1= $1.2 US , imported cars could rise a lot in price.

On the other hand, oil prices are also likely to fall below $50...
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - tyro
And with UK interest rates likely to fall below 3% in 2009 now is NOT
the time to borrow money..


Sorry about asking a stupid question, but could you explain? I would have thought that if interest rates were going to be low, it would be a good time to borrow money, because one would be have lower interest payments.
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - madf
"Sorry about asking a stupid question, but could you explain? I would have thought that if interest rates were going to be low, it would be a good time to borrow money, because one would be have lower interest payments."

I meant: wait till they fall to 3%.. Which could take 12 months. Once they get there, markets will start /may start to recover.. so the time to lock in low rates is when they have fallen a lot.

Loans now will be at higher rates : and are usually fixed.
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - madf
Update: BOE may redcue rates to zero!

tinyurl.com/5azbf8
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - ForumNeedsModerating
I wonder if the reluctance of the BoE to substantially lower rates is more to do with the effect on the exchange rate - and consequent effect on imported inflation - than any idea it might stoke consumer demand too much & ignite a home-grown inflation spiral?

Maybe they think the only reason the £ has maintained any sort of value is that the attractiveness of our relatively high IRs keeps £ investors invested.

I don't know enough to judge the balance point between high IR induced (or aided) recession & a run on the pound due to unattractive local IRs, but surely these chaps at BoE can make judgements that at least give the impression of active, thoughtful demand management rather than this impression of rabbits caught in headlights?

Edited by woodbines on 06/11/2008 at 09:43

Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - madf
I agree exchange rate considerations must play a part but the BOE seems determine dto fight the last war. Inflation - certainly oil price driven inflation - is dead. Oil prices are likely to fall below $50 due to the coming recession.
The BOE is in my view like an accountant .."walking purposely into the future with his eyes firmly turned to the past"..:-)

A policy with terrible economic consequences..
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - tyro
madf

Thanks for that.

I must confess that I had not realised that loans these days tend to be at fixed rates - it is a while since I paid off my mortgage, and in those far off days, I got the impression that interest rates on loans went up and down.

(I might add that the question was of purely academic interest - I have no expectation of doing any borrowing.)
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - Bill Payer
I meant: wait till they fall to 3%.. Which could take 12 months.


Or 4 hours. :)
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - qxman {p}
It has to be said that when you look at some of the mega-investment showrooms built in the last 10 years the profitability of main dealers must have been a bit shaky even in the boom times. Now that things have taken a dive a lot must have very quickly gone into loss.

Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - ukbeefy
I've always thought looking at alot of these "glass palace" versions of new showrooms that they literally look like a large mecano set and almost identikit in shape/finish with very basic design finishes, I am presuming they are not that expensive to put up. They are really glorified B&Q shed type construction surely?



Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - qxman {p}
I've always thought looking at alot of these "glass palace" versions of new showrooms that
they literally look like a large mecano set and almost identikit in shape/finish with very
basic design finishes I am presuming they are not that expensive to put up. They
are really glorified B&Q shed type construction surely?


I think they are generally very expensive and a long way from B&Q sheds. All the fittings and finishes are usually in 'brand colours' and they are usually in prime locations, meaning that land costs must be very high. Sheffield's revamped Audi dealership is opening next month:

"Gilder Group is counting down to the opening of the first half of its £15 million flagship site in December after spending more than a year on the build."

Didn't the Mercedes dealer network collectively spend something like £250m refitting all of their sites over the last couple of years?
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - Kevin
>13.1% of what though ?

It's a consumer barometer. The absolute value is less meaningful than the trend.

>but what is that in real terms..

It means that many companies will take the only short-term action they can to maintain the bottom line by reducing outgoings and expenses - production cuts and staff layoffs.

>It's like reading other media sources of doom round here..

In that case you'd hate to hear an American colleague's extrapolation which ends in protectionism, national isolation and war :-0

Kevin...
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - audiA6tdi
I used to work for Pendragon. I was offered shares at a reduced rate of £3 each a few years ago. I didnt take them at the time. Those that did now find they are worth 5p. Poor sods.
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - smokie
Huh! You should see SWMBOs Taylor Wimpey shares (sharesave scheme) - were around £5 down to about 14p now (they've nearly doubled in the past week!!). There once was a time when I was close to retiring at 52 (see other thread...)
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - L'escargot
What's wrong with just saving up until you can afford to buy what you want? I don't see the point of trying to haggle the price down and then buying it on the drip and paying interest.
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - Big Bad Dave
"What's wrong with just saving up until you can afford to buy what you want?"

Because the vast majority of us aren't movie stars or footballers and with the few quid we have left at the end of the month wouldn't ever have the necessary quarter of a mil to buy a cheap London home plus People Carrier while we were still young enough to benefit from it. Probably.
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - Clk Sec
>>>wouldn't ever have the necessary quarter of a mil to buy a cheap London home plus People Carrier while we were still young enough to benefit from it. Probably.

And that?s half the problem in my opinion.

I did not buy my first new car until I was 35, by which time I had saved enough to pay cash.

Clk Sec

Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - L'escargot
Because the vast majority of us aren't movie stars or footballers ........


When I got my first job I got lodgings within walking/cycling distance. I saved up for four years until I could afford to buy a car. From then on I part exchanged my car and paid the cash difference from what I had saved in the meantime. I had the choice of either saving the same amount as what I would have had to pay in loan installments and buying a better car each time, or saving less and buying another car of the same standard. I chose the former and consequently got a better car each time, until I reached the size/standard of car with which I was completely happy. As a result of never paying interest on a loan I have spent less on cars than if I had bought them on the drip. Consequently, apart from the first four years of my working life, I have been able to have a better standard of living than if I had bought everything on the drip.

You don't need to be a movie star, you just need to initially make a bit of a sacrifice. Apart from mortgages I've been debt-free the whole of my life. Anyone could do it if they started out right. It's what's known as cutting your coat according to your cloth.
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - Big Bad Dave
"When I got my first job I got lodgings within walking/cycling distance. I saved up for four years until I could afford to buy a car"

If that's not an advert for cheap credit, I don't know what is.

You're never going to get laid with that attitude in the 21st century. "Mum, Dad, I'd like you to meet my new boyfriend. He lives in lodgings next to the factory and we haul a week's shopping from Tescos on the bus every weekend."

Not as sexy as you might think. Chicks want men with cars, and an annual foreign holiday. All the good breeding stock will be married off in the 4 years you've been cycling to work and saving pennies in whiskey bottles.
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - Screwloose
All the good breeding stock will be married off in the 4 years
you've been cycling to work and saving pennies in whiskey bottles.


Valid point; but unfortunately, the "ladies" that think that superficially, are just the type to wait until they've extracted as much as they think is available - before "trading on" to a better deal.

If you think credit is expensive; wait until you see the costs of divorce....
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Volume 3 - Big Bad Dave
"If you think credit is expensive; wait until you see the costs of divorce..."

Been there. Got a new model for myself too. Totally worth it!
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - Avant
It's worth making a comment if only to get the unwanted apostrophe out of 'its' in the heading!

I know a lot of Volvo owners in the Reading area who wouldn't touch what used to be Lex, now Stratstone. It was always a typical chain-owned business with very little attempt to make customers feel valued, and the sort of people who buy Volvos are often thoughtful types who value good service. You could walk around there for ages, looking round and sitting in cars without anyone asking if they could help. They didn't do good deals, as someone has said above, and they were one of the last to offer courtesy cars when this first became common. I've never had a Volvo, partly for that reason.

I hope that the dealers who try harder than that and attract repeat business, will survive, although as we all know it'll be hard for everyone. Most dealers make more money on repairs than car sales, so good customer care could well carry the good ones through.

Edited by Avant on 05/11/2008 at 23:51

Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - pd
Maybe somebody better will pick up the franchise in Reading when things take a turn for the better.

Edited by pd on 06/11/2008 at 09:54

Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - jbif
It's worth making a comment if only to get the unwanted apostrophe out of 'its' in the heading!


Same point made in volume 2 by someone, and pointedly told off by a Moderator to stop being pedantic! So it carries on to volume 3.
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Repo's Up. - Ian (Cape Town)
WesBank, our local vehicle financiers, say that repossessions are up 93% year-on-year.

Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Repo's Up. - alex

SMMT have just released its new car sales figures for October.

Some big sales declines for certain manufacturers. The worst affected include:

Alfa down 42.95 per cent
Aston Martin down 32.93 per cent
Bentley down 47.59 per cent
Chrysler down 75.75 per cent
Daihatsu down 42.20 per cent
Honda down 35.37 per cent
Jeep down 62.58 per cent
Land Rover down 57.92 per cent
Lexus down 45.14 per cent
Mercedes down 31.84 per cent
Mini down 40.13 per cent
Mitsubishi down 47.29 per cent
Peugeot down 38.29 per cent
Porsche down 38.29 per cent
Renault down 53.74 per cent
Saab down 36.66 per cent
Smart down 40.28 per cent

I am surprised at the steep sales declines seen at Honda, Mini, Peugeot and Renault as I thought these firms made economical vehicles which are supposed to be in tune with the times.
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Repo's Up. - alex

I forgot to add that the overall sales decline for October was 23 per cent.
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Repo's Up. - boxsterboy
Yes, same applies to Smart and MINI, both down 40%, whereas Merc down 'only' 32%, Aston down 'only' 33%.
Credit Crunch Takes it's toll: Repo's Up. - tintin01
Chrysler down 75%. Crikey.
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - tyro
>>sales decline for October was 23.0 %.

And the fact that the crunch is getting tighter is indicated by the fact that:
Sept was down 21.2% on Sept last year,
Aug was down 18.6% on Aug last year
July was down 13.0% on July last year
June was down 6.1% on June last year
May was down 3.5% on May last year

The thing that interested me is that in Sept, guess who were the fourth best selling marque behind Ford, Vauxhall and VW?


BMW.

And perhaps even more interestingly, they are in 5th place in the year to date.

Edited by Honestjohn on 06/11/2008 at 12:08

Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - movilogo
BoE rate is now 3%!!!
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - The Gingerous One
Leyland Trucks to make just over 100 redundant (announced last week)
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - NowWheels
BoE rate is now 3%!!!


That's a good indication of the state of the economy, but don't expect to be able to get a loan more cheaply. The actual retail cost of borrowing will continue to rise, as lenders try to cover the cost of bad debts
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - charlesb
A member of a work colleagues' family works for BMW. When you hit a certain job level you get a new BMW every 4 months, but currently BMW are apparently not making any money in the UK so peeps will only get a new BMW every 9 months now.

I know this is industry practice as someone else I know works for Peugeot and they get a new car every 6 months.
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - alex

According to The Independent (today's online edition) even the successful Mini plants at Oxford and Swindon are not immune from the cutbacks.

Normally both plants would close for two weeks over the Xmas/New Year period but this year the shutdown is extended to four weeks.

Meanwhile, another Renault dealer has closed. Website www.talkingmotors.co.uk has just reported that the Walker Renault dealership in Stourbridge has shut down. However it appears the firm's servicing department remains trading.
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - Falkirk Bairn
reported that the Walker Renault dealership in Stourbridge has shut down. However it appears the firm's servicing department remains trading.


Cynic might say

What does that say abouts Renfaults? - cannot sell them and make a profit buy plenty repair work!!!
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - Bill Payer
but currently BMW are apparently not making any money in the UK so peeps will only get >> a new BMW every 9 months now.

I would have thought they'd change more frequently, not less, to keep turning over the cars.

Neighbour is retired Vauxhall manager and gets a new car every 4mths or so.
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - Robin Reliant
I've never understood why anyone would want a new car every four or six months. You've just loosened the engine up, the seats have contoured to you back and bum, any teething problems have been sorted and then you have to start the whole process all over again.
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - jbif
>> but currently BMW ... peeps will only get a new BMW every 9 months now.

I would have thought they'd change more frequently, not less, to keep turning over the cars.


Is it not the case that these cars are "given" to staff so that they can then be sold on as nearly new "demo" car under 6 months old?

Now that the market has stalled, the Dealer will not want to add to his dead 2nd hand stock and on top of that be faced with the cost of getting another brand new one for the staff.

Until the turnover improves, they will be trying to cut down their "inventory".

Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - Bill Payer
Now that the market has stalled the Dealer will not want to add to his
dead 2nd hand stock


These are not dealers - this is for people who work directly for the manufacturer.

I got my Mercedes like this - it was used for 5mths/6K miles by an MB manager and I bought it 3yrs ago at a third less than new price (which was a good deal then).

Certainly my neighbour with the Vauxhall thinks it's fantastic - he literally only has the put fuel in the car and check the levels now and again, wash it a few times and then it goes back and he gets a new one. Would do me!
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - mike hannon
Presumably as the glass palace main dealers fall over and their workshops close the knock-on effect will hit the parts manufacturers quickly. There won't be so much of this '10,000 miles so it's new discs and pads sir' nonsense.
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - Pendlebury
>>That's a good indication of the state of the economy, but don't expect to be able to get a loan more cheaply. The actual retail cost of borrowing will continue to rise, as lenders try to cover the cost of bad debts <<

Which is a good example of how impotent this government is. It cannot force the banks to really do anything even when they own a big slice of them.

The other thing the government can do though is reduce VED or at least stop the increases they have planned. Let's see how serious they are about helping the hard working families in the pre-budget report or if they will actually do nothing but cry foul when the banks do not pass on the reduction.
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - Screwloose

I believe the best way to describe the latest madness is to visualize it as pushing on the reins.

The BoE has just shown the world that it has lost it's one control over the UK economy.
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - madf
The Government - as usual - talks with forked togue. On the one hand it says it wants lenders not to repossess homes too quickly... but one of the most ruthless repossessors is: Government owned Northern Rock. You could not make it up...

I am more and more reminded of 1971-74 : events are different of course and people are more indebted.. and the financial system then was stronger so I expect the stock market to fall at least as much as it did then: 70%...

The BOE lost the plot 9 months ago and made things worse. And then has done too little too late. 1.5% smacks of panic.

Expect lots more very bad news to come.


Edited by madf on 06/11/2008 at 18:34

Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - NowWheels
Which is a good example of how impotent this government is. It cannot force the
banks to really do anything even when they own a big slice of them.


So you'd like the government to force the banks to charge interest rates which don't generate enough profit to cover the mounting cost of bad debts. Are you prepared to pay more tax increases to cover the cost of the extra cash injections required to bail out the banks again?

It's one of the basic rules of interest-based lending: if the risk of default goes up, so does the interest rate. Part of the reason we got into this mess was that the banks were under-pricing risk.
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - Pendlebury
That is not my point NowWheels, my point is that the Prime Minister is telling the banks they should be passing on the rate cuts and they are clearly ignoring his comments and that is even after we have gained control. It is about the government being completely impotent to managing it's way out of a situation it created. My view of bad debt is that more of the banks should have been allowed to collapse like any other company would have done for such poor business management. The subject of paying more tax is a no-brainer anyway. We WILL all be paying allot more tax soon to pay for the first bail out. Borrowing is spiralling out of control and if you listen to the Chariman of the Banking Committee - a Labour MP on R5 live tonight when questioned about the impact of the rate cut would have on savers, his response was that it is not about getting people to save, it's about people borrowing more so they can spend - and here's me thinking that is what got us into this mess.
The government took control of the Banking sector away from the BoE when it gave them independence - you know the independence where the Chancellor appoints MPC members and as a result we are in a right mess because they all failed in the basic laws of banking. You lend no more than you have saved in deposits. My point then is that even with the PANIC measures from the BoE made today the banks will not reduce rates to stimulate the economy and we will continue to be in a mess and pay heavily for it over the coming 3-5 years.
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - PhilW
I really don't get this. (And here I might be repeating a previous post to an extent)
I can see the point that lower interest rates should make borrowing easier which might stimulate the economy.
However,
1. Wasn't it the case that "easy credit" got us into this situation in the first place - sub-prime mortgages, billions of pounds worth of creditcard debt etc?
2. Given the above, what is the point of penalising savers by low interest rates (and isn't it through these savings that investment originates?) and "benefitting" those with debts? It's a bit like saying to me - "you drive too much, you drink too much wine and smoke too many cigars so, in order to cure you of these bad habits we will reduce the price of all of them by 30% - that should do it - oh and here's a few thousand quid to help your cure"
3. Won't reducing interest cause a (further) flight from the pound, and since we don't seem to manufacture much, we will be putting more money in peoples pockets to spend on goods produced abroad hence increasing the deficit causing further flight from the pound and increasing our problems?
4. The banks have apparently "lost" £118 billion/trillion/ (?) pounds this year. Now as far as I know, money can't be "lost" - someone has got it and someone is spending it and it must therefore end up in someones bank account. So where is this "lost" money? And if it is in bank accounts, why can't the banks lend it out again - someones spending is someone else's income isn't it? Someones saving is some bank's money to lend??
5. If the banks have lent so much to "sub-prime" mortgages, they have swapped money for some rubbishy shacks in the USA. This presumeably means that there are lots of people who now have lots of money instead of a shack. What do they do with this money? Spend it or save it - so it goes to a bank one way or another
5. Gordon and Alistair darling have apparently given the banks the equivalent of £19000 for each person in the UK in their "bailout" of the banks. Now here's an idea - why didn't they give each of us £19000 to spend as we wish? Would that have not ended up in the banks? I could have bought my wife the new car she craves, she would have stashed hers away in the bank. Either way it ends up in a bank. As it is, the banks have the money, they still won't lend it - the same could have been done but wife would have had a new car, wife would have had new car and £19000 in bank earning interest.
Sorry for long post, only vaguely related to motoring - bad day at work!!
Phil
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - PhilW
Oh, and by the way, a pound to a penny that savings interest rates go down tomorrow and mortgage/creditcard/overdraft rates don't go down for a few weeks if at all.
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - oilrag
I was minded to take off and fly at 37,000 feet - hoping to spot a gleam of bone, but I can`t, I`ve had too much pudding....

Its tough being a vulture sometimes....

Edited by oilrag on 06/11/2008 at 20:03

Credit Crunch Takes its toll - Robin Reliant
General Motors third quarter figures are out tomorrow, and if this report on CNN is anything to go by they won't make pretty reading -

tinyurl.com/6z9lrz
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - drbe
Oh and by the way a pound to a penny that savings interest rates go
down tomorrow and mortgage/creditcard/overdraft rates don't go down for a few weeks if at all.

>>

Well, you got the first bit right, but not the second.
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - jbif
4. The banks have apparently "lost" £118 billion/trillion/ (?) pounds this year. Now as far as I know, money can't be "lost" - someone has got it and someone is spending it and it must therefore end up in someones bank account.


China, India, Germany, Middle East mainly.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trade_deficit
"Strong GDP growth economies such as the United States, the United Kingdom, Australia and Hong Kong run consistent trade deficits, as well as poorer countries also experiencing a lot of investment.
Developed nations such as Canada, Japan, and Germany typically run trade surpluses. China also has a trade surplus[citation needed]. A higher savings rate generally corresponds with a trade surplus. "

... This presumeably means that there are lots of people who now have lots of money instead of a shack.


It was the same £10 note that was going around and around, making everyone think they were £10 richer when it passed through their hands. The World's economy is founded on a big lie. In fact there is only one real £10 note in the whole world, the rest are just fakes. ;-)

Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - PhilW
"there is only one real £10 note in the whole world, the rest are just fakes. ;-)"

"Bad money drives out good" - Gresham's Law or something - that one real £10 note is long gone!!

Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - adverse camber
reducing interest rates has to be to reduce the cost of working capital to business rather than anything to do with savings/mortgages.
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - jbif
"Bad money drives out good" - Gresham's Law or something - that one real £10 note is long gone!!


And I thought you did not know the answer to the question you had asked!

Gresham's Law is what has been going on: www.fff.org/comment/com0306q.asp

?Bad Money Drives Out Good?
by Charles Adams, June 25, 2003
"This is what has been called Gresham?s Law. It was formulated by Sir Thomas Gresham to explain to Queen Elizabeth I what was happening to the English shilling. Her father, Henry VIII, had been adulterating the English shilling, the basic coin of the realm, by replacing 40 percent of the silver in the coin with base metals ? a clever way, so he thought, to increase the government?s income without raising taxes. It was, in short, a sneaky devaluation device; ...

Queen Elizabeth realized that Gresham was right and formulated a bold plan to restore the shilling with pure silver. .... The English shilling became the most sought-after coinage in international commerce and put Britain on the road to become the superpower of the world for centuries to come. For the next 300 years it was the basis for long-term prosperity, economic stability, the expansion of trade and industry, the development of natural resources, and the founding of a colonial empire stretching over the globe ? so that the sun never set on the British Empire ....

Elizabeth?s fiscal policy did not come easy, .... , she had to borrow heavily from the City of Antwerp to finance the cost of the new shillings.
....
the Romans, like Henry VIII, started putting copper in the once-pure drachma, now called a denarius. It was so easy, but, again, the Roman fiscal authorities ? like all fiscal authorities since the beginning of time ? did not fool anybody with their debased coinage. Today would be an exception, with the whiz-kids at the U.S. Treasury having debased U.S. coinage and currency far beyond anything Henry VIII had done in England, and the frightening thing is that no one said a word.
.....
The United States has been on a policy of phony money for only 70 years; it took the Romans a few hundred years for their fiscal stack of cards to collapse, so we can anticipate a long decline in value until the inevitable collapse, maybe two or even three centuries hence. .... "


Except that it has happened, not in two centuries, but within 5 years of the above article having been written.

Edited by jbif on 06/11/2008 at 21:24

Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - madf
Well I will buy gold: but not yet..

We need deflation first and then inflation...

Batten down the hatches time and treat politicians with the contempt they deserve.

The BOE have lost the plot - about 6 months ago and are now panicking when they see the mess we are heading into: they and the FSA should be jailed for incompetent recklessness. Like bank Directors.. In the US they will be. .

I am seriously expecting to see the FTSE - currently above 4000 - to be below 2000 by 2010.

And all those insurers who invest in equities - and are solvent now - will be insolvent.

Properly. Not like 2002-3 - they were only practising.
As for company pensions :-(



Edited by madf on 06/11/2008 at 21:47

Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - Screwloose
Well I will buy gold: but not yet..

>>

Why not now - surely the pound is going to collapse? As the carry trade unwinds, won't the dollar fall make moving into gold dearer?
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - PhilW
"a bold plan to restore the shilling with pure silver"

jbif,
I may be wrong, but I think the silver shilling existed until relatively recently. I have a few somewhere which my grandparents gave as "bonus" birthday and christmas presents (or were they in the Christmas pudding? - that rings a bell, that us kids always found them and none of the adults did - this would be in the 1950s/early '60s) when we wre kids. Must look them out but I seem to remember that they had 1930s dates on them and were well worn.
Not occurred to me before but maybe it is an example of Greshams law - they took the silver shillings (or were they sixpences??) out of circulation, saved them and presumably used "debased" shillings or sixpences for everyday spending.
Or maybe I'm talking rubbish??!!
Regards
Phil
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - henry k
The silver sixpence was popped into Christmas pud.
Silver shillings and Silver Florins ( two bob) were in circulation in small numbers until those Texas bros tried to command the silver supply.

"Beginning in the early 1970s, Hunt and his brother William Herbert Hunt began accumulating large amounts of silver. By 1979, they had nearly cornered the global market. In the last nine months of 1979 the brothers earned an estimated $2 billion to $4 billion in silver speculation, with estimated silver holdings of 100 million oz,"

The silver price went up and the coins were worth more than face value so the got melted. Sadly lots and lots of silver items also got melted down.
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - mike hannon
I think people are beginning to realise that the whole international financial system is, as a concept, not unlike religion. You have to make a gigantic leap of faith to believe in either of them.
If, like me, you believe that - a, there is no basis for religion; and - b, there is no real money any more, just computer-generated figures, you can't have any faith in either.
So you begin to feel that the world is becoming a rather scary place...
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - Altea Ego
> a concept

banking has always been based on the fact that there is never enough ready cash on deposit to pay out all the depositors if they asked for it back. The fear of all bankers is queues of people outside the door - the famous "run on a bank"

what we have is , in effect, a run on the global finance system - which uses the same principals as banks - ie money is never left lying around doing "nothing"
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - L'escargot
The silver sixpence was popped into Christmas pud.


In my younger days it was a silver thrupenny bit. tinyurl.com/62pk9l
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Repo's Up. - CGNorwich
The silver shilling and indeed florin (two shillings of the under 40s) were in circulation until the introduction of decimal money. The traditional christmas pud coin was the silver threepenny bit (withdrawn I believe with the introduction of the flat sided coin in the nineteen fifties.

The silver content of the coins made them more valuable than face value so they did indeed become scarce . Old copper coins suffered the same fate with many being melted down for scrap (although illegal) - The present "copper" coins have a steel core
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - L'escargot
I know everyone says there's a "credit crunch" but has anyone on here (with a normal/good credit rating) not been able to get credit when they wanted it?
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - Altea Ego
No what it means is that people with a higher credit risk wont get easy money.
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - L'escargot
No what it means is that people with a higher credit risk wont get easy
money.


I would have thought the majority of people would have a good credit rating, in which case there shouldn't be a widespread problem. Or am I being naive?
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - Screwloose
There doesn't seem to be any great shortage of mortgages for sensible purchases - just no demand - although you may need to pay for insurance on any high LTV ones.

The banks are simply deleveraging; they really believed the hype that financial risk was history, [CDSs etc.] have had a brutal wake-up call - and are now desperate to reclaim all their excessive loans to sit on their devalued capital for a bit.... until their knees stop trembling.

Edited by Screwloose on 08/11/2008 at 16:19

Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - Robin Reliant
I would have thought the majority of people would have a good credit rating in
which case there shouldn't be a widespread problem. Or am I being naive?

>>
One day overdue with a credit card payment can get you a black mark. There must be many millions who fall below A1, it just depends how far down the ratings lenders are prepared to go before they decide the risk isn't worth it.
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - Falkirk Bairn
In "normal times" about 50% of UK pop cannot borrow from High St Banks & B Soc. They have to go to "other lenders" or live on what they have i.e. no credit at all!

Of the remaining "good 50%" many will struggle to cope with current loans & commitments.

Hence the crunch for many!
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - Screwloose
FB

That's a staggering statistic. Does that include sub-18s; EMI etc. or is it just the economically active?

[Loan sharking... Hmmm; now that could be a growth industry....]
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - Falkirk Bairn
50% who cannot borrow are 18 yrs+

The 50% does not include children!
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - malteser
Once upon a time, in a village, a man appeared and announced to the villagers that he would buy monkeys for $10 each.

The villagers seeing that there were many monkeys around, went out to the forest, and started catching them.

The man bought thousands at $10 and as supply started to diminish, the villagers stopped their effort.

He further announced that he would now buy at $20. This renewed the efforts of the villagers and they started catching monkeys again.

Soon the supply diminished even further and people started going back to their farms.

The offer increased to $25 each and the supply of monkeys became so little that it was an effort to even see a monkey, let alone catch it!

The man now announced that he would buy monkeys at $50!

However, since he had to go to the city on some business, his assistant would now buy on behalf of him.

In the absence of the man, the assistant told the villagers,

"Look at all these monkeys in the big cage that the man has collected.

I will sell them to you at $35 and when the man returns from the city, you can sell them to him for $50 each."

The villagers rounded up all their savings and bought all the monkeys.

Then they never saw the man nor his assistant again, only monkeys everywhere!

Now you have a better understanding of how the stock market works.
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - mike hannon
No I don't actually. This allegory may relate to a capitalist scam but we all know the stock market these days isn't that - it's just a casino, isn't it?
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - Bill Payer
I will sell them to you at $35 and when the man returns from the
city you can sell them to him for $50 each."

In the real stock market, villagers would have short sold monkeys to the businessman for $50 before they bought them for $35 off his assistant.

However if the assistant realised the villagers had done that he would put his price up to $1000. Just like VW did a couple of weeks ago. :)

Edited by Bill Payer on 09/11/2008 at 17:04

Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - jbif
Silly Money

www.comedy.org.uk/guide/tv/silly_money/

Currently broadcasting Sundays @ 19.00 on C4. [repeated on c4+1 and again on other days?]

Rory Bremner takes a satirical look at the credit crunch. The comic and impressionist looks at the historical background of the west's current economic climate and questions the chances of a recovery in these four hour long specials. He is, as usual, aided by co-stars John Bird and John Fortune.

Bremner spoofs politicians and other public figures to tell the story of the US and UK financial markets. The final episode will look forward to a new president in the White House and question whether he will be able to make a difference.


Just finished watching today's episode which was all about China's part in the world economy.

Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - nick
It's very amusing to see all the armchair experts in the papers and elsewhere but I've yet to see a better system than good old capitalism. A few tweaks need maybe, but that's all.
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - smokie
I know it was probably him being humorous, but that well known comedian and Communist Alexie Sayle was on TV last week (Never Mind the Buzzcocks maybe). He was asked why he wasn't a communist any more - he said it doesn't work.

Edited by smokie on 10/11/2008 at 15:36

Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - Lud
There's nothing like learning a bit of history, which takes decades to sink in properly. The state economic dirigisme built into the Soviet and Chinese communist systems, and copied by smaller emergent countries under their influences, can work, sort of, up to a point, but involves a lot of coercion sometimes and can blight economic performance to an enormous extent. This is essentially because it is even less efficient and more wasteful than the capitalist non-system, people being so useless and bolshy, but can't admit it ('Comrades! Onward, ever onward to the overfulfilment of the Five Year Plan!'), creating yet another layer of hypocrisy and oppression.

I've seen it happening and had much conversation with its often (but by no means always) bewildered victims. I was surprised and a bit miffed at the time being more of a conventional lefty in those days. But you can't gainsay what surges up and bites you in the bum.
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - madf
Capitalism has periodic bubbles which pop and explode.. starting iirc about 2000BC. All to do initially with harvest surpluses: which drove down prices and made farmers grow less - to famines which drove up prices and made farmers grow more.

What we are seeing now is the 4th recession I have lived thorugh and knew it was a recession.... 71-74, 81-2, 90-91...

Part of a natural cycle... going to be a bad one...
Guess I 'll have to buy a second hand Lexus as they are dirt cheap... or a Mercedes ditto.

Fancy a gold bling one:-)
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - nick
I'm wishing I had more garage space, some tremendous cars out there for little money.
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - qxman {p}
So we have a US neoconservative government which owns half the country's mortgages, major insurance co., possibly car manufacturers soon, etc., bankrolled by Chinese communists and Middle Eastern oligarchy.. Hmm...?
Credit Crunch Takes its toll: Volume 3 - Baskerville
So we have a US neoconservative government which owns half the country's mortgages major insurance
co. possibly car manufacturers soon etc. bankrolled by Chinese communists and Middle Eastern oligarchy.. Hmm...?


While consumer capitalism, Western Style* has been eating itself over the last decade or so the Middle-Eastern oligarchs and Chinese and Russian former-communists have been working out another way of doing business: state capitalism. We'd better get used to it I think.

*Which isn't really capitalism because the capitalists don't own the means of production. They flogged it all the Middle-Eastern oligarchs and Chinese and Russian former-communists.