Ask Honest John  
Ask a Question

What's your question? Search here

How long should brake discs last?
Front brake discs and pads replaced by BMW 18 months/approx 12,000 miles ago.

Now they appear to have warped, causing vibration/juddering when braking at speeds above 50 mph.

Independent garage says no problem with wheels or brake callipers sticking, etc. The car is not left standing with wet discs (e.g. after washing) - there does not seem to be significant corrosion.

Could you kindly tell me whether it is reasonable to expect discs to last longer than this? The first set had been fine for over 70,000 miles! Do I have any legal comeback?

Asked on 16 November 2011 by AFA

Answered by Honest John
They might need skimming in situ.
Similar questions
Can adjusting the handbrake cause the rear calipers to seize? The reason i'm asking is that I had the handbrake adjusted on my MR2 and I was told the brakes...
I purchased a Volkswagen Polo in December 2010. The car was serviced in December 2011 with no concerns. The car is now making a noise when brakes applied....
My E-Class started perfectly and did a 5km run and I put on the screen heater briefly. The following day the car started perfectly but the screen warning...
Related links
Looking for a garage you can trust? Honest John's Good Garage Guide has thousands of reader recommended garages, plus how-to guides and tips on servicing.
Related models
Some great engines. Good ride and handling. Classy looks. Performed well in JD Power Customer Satisfaction surveys.

Honest John's Car Buying Advice

Get the low-down on how to buy and sell cars the hassle-free way

Sign up for Honest John's Email Newsletter

Road Tests • Buying Tips • Deals

Related News & Road Tests

  • Road Test: BMW 5-Series F-10
    The first UK BMW 5-Series F10s, that go on sale on 20th March, will all be SE spec, which includes the luxury of Dakota leather upholstery, BMW Professional Radio/CD, Bluetooth hands-free phone preparation, Dynamic Stability Control, front and rear pictogram Park Distance Control, Cruise Control and Climate Control air-conditioning.
  • Ask HJ: How long should brake discs last?
    Front brake discs and pads replaced by BMW 18 months/approx 12,000 miles ago. Now they appear to have warped, causing vibration/juddering when braking...
  • Road Test: Toyota GT86 Road Test
    Toyota's perfectly balanced sub £25k 200PS 2+2 coupe impresses both on the road and on the track.
  • Road Test: Audi S7 Sportback
    The high performance version of the sleek and stylish A7 gets a twin-turbocharged V8 engine with 420PS which gives it effortless acceleration.