Why does our Mercedes-Benz CLS 320 cut out for no reason?

In May this year our 52,000 mile 2006 Mercedes CLS 320 CDI suddenly stopped without warning with the ignition switching itself off and the key rotating one position anti-clockwise. This in turn shuts everything down. The car was returned to the garage for diagnosis and repair but no fault showed up on the diagnosis computer. This cut-out has now happened seven times and the car was back with the garage for two weeks for further investigation and testing without this intermittent fault reoccurring with their mechanics.

The ignition key was exchanged for the spare in case the key was the cause, but the cutting out continued. The crankshaft sensor was replaced to no avail. Now it is suggested that that the ignition E.I.S. control switch could be replaced at a cost to us of some £800 plus labour, but no guarantee is given as to the correction of the fault. Have you come across this situation before? Apart from the danger aspect to ourselves we are concerned about causing an accident involving others. Driving the car as it is puts us in an invidious situation with our insurance company as you will appreciate.

Asked on 10 June 2012 by GW, East Ilsley, Berks

Answered by Honest John
A diesel doesn't have an ignition switch. Rather, the switch does the opposite. A diesel is a compression ignition engine so will simply run unless the fuel supply to it is shut off. So turning off the key switch electrically switches off the fuel supply, so this is where the fault must lie. Either in the switch itself or in the fuel shut off valve.
Similar questions
As a regular reader of your column in ‘Motoring’ in the Telegraph I am concerned about your comments, on a regular basis, about ownership of diesel-powered vehicles. I own a 2009 Mark 6 VW Golf with the...
I have a 2007 Astra Twintop diesel with 51,000 miles that I love, apart from a recent problem with the emissions warning light frequently lighting up. About eight weeks ago this happened on the way home...
I am 83 and have a Ford C-Max 1.6 diesel automatic, registered in 2006. I am very concerned about the many reports of gearbox trouble and I am beginning to listen for problems when I am driving now. However,...
Related models
Dramatically different from any other Mercedes, wonderful styling, great engines and transmissions, incredibly refined with a forgiving ride.