Why are some over-50s insurance policies more expensive than normal policies?

People over 50 should be very careful when dealing with insurance companies who purport to offer a special service to them. My wife, with an impeccable driving record, recently went to renew her insurance on her tiny (but excellent) Toyota Aygo. She obtained quotations from four companies who advertised particularly for the over 50s. They were RIAS, Saga, Age UK and Castle. Their quotes were £900, £590, £950 and £688. The quote from Sainsbury's, which does not profess to specially serve the over 50s, was £366 for a higher spec policy. I can easily understand many people using the companies who "serve" the over 50s, because they believe they are getting a better deal because of their age. Buyer beware.

Asked on 2 April 2012 by DM, via email

Answered by Honest John
Good advice, properly researched. Thank you
Similar questions
I have received notification of my insurance renewal from Churchill, which is £408.20 - a 41% increase on last year. I live in Sutherland and my mileage was 8586 last year. I have one car a Skoda Octavia...
We recently bought a 2008 Volvo V50 SE Lux as a replacement for my wife’s 1997 Volvo S70 CD. The new car has a 2.4i petrol engine, whereas the old one had a 2.5 turbo petrol engine. I spent many hours...
I'm comprehensively insured as the sole owner and driver of a 2005 Jaguar S-Type. I'm 77 years of age and have maximum protected no-claims. I fancy some top down motoring this summer so found a Volkswagen...
Related models
Low road tax and insurance. Averages a claimed 60mpg. Cheap to run and drives decently. 99g/km CO2 from 2012.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer