Ask Honest John

Honest John Ask Honest John » Do I need to change both tyres if I get a puncture on one?

Do I need to change both tyres if I get a puncture on one?

I have just had to replace a rear runflat tyre due to having had a puncture on my BMW 420i Convertible which had only done 8,000 miles, so I now have a new rear tyre and one that has about 4mm of tread . Do I need to bite the bullet and replace the other tyre, or am I okay with two tyres of different tread depth on the same axle?

Asked on 11 December 2023 by william smitham

Answered by David Ross
BMW recommends that there is a difference of no more than 2mm between tread depths on the same axle, so if you fit a new tyre on one side we would expect the difference to be 3 or 4mm. You could ignore this advice, but an alternative would be to get two new tyres but keep the older tyre as a back up in case of another puncture.

From choosing the right tyre to what to do when it goes wrong - we have the answers.

Tyre News And Advice
Similar questions
The front tyres on my Kia Sorento are MOT advisory, the back tyres are fine. All four are Michelin Cross Climate SUVs 235/60R/18 and are 3 years old. Can I just replace the front tyres (same make & size)...
I have had three tyres failing MOT test due to cuts to the chord, They had done 2,0000 miles and are fitted on a Volvo V40. I have never had this happen before, is it due to the potholes which I try...
I was involved in an accident in poor weather which resulted in me skidding across a junction into another car. My insurance is now refusing to pay out as they claim that one of my tyres was below the...
Related models
Handles as impressively as you’d hope, handsome styling makes the newer 4 Series look fussy, wide range of strong petrol and diesel engines, plenty on the used market.