Should I buy a Jaguar XF or a Skoda Superb as a private hire vehicle?

I am struggling to decide which car to purchase for use as a private hire taxi: a 2016 Jaguar XF 2.0 Portfolio or a Skoda Superb 2.0 TDI CR SE L Executive DSG.

I will be averaging 100-plus miles per day, and would be grateful for any suggestions/advise on which would be the better vehicle to purchase.

Asked on 11 July 2022 by Mani Singh

Answered by Lawrence Allan
Jaguar as a brand performs less strongly in our Satisfaction Index (which takes views on reliability from owners) than Skoda. While you might buy an XF and find it faultless, the risk of problems is likely to be greater than on the Superb, as is the cost of replacement parts and servicing. If cost of ownership and dependability is important then the Skoda would be our choice.
Similar questions
I have about £20k including trade in and am looking for a vehicle for private hire work. What do you think about the Mercedes E-Class?
I am considering buying a three or four-year-old Ford Mondeo or Skoda Superb estate for my taxi business. Are there any issues with the auto gearboxes, on either of these cars?
I am planning to buy used (one year old) car to start my private hire job; however, I can't choose between the Toyota Avensis and Prius. Which is more reliable?
Related models
Offers limousine levels of comfort and space, but with a very affordable price tag. Efficient engine options include plug-in hybrid models. Boot capacity is truly huge.
Great blend of ride quality and enjoyable handling. Comfortable and refined. Well-equipped as standard. Fleet-friendly diesel engine.