What should we buy to replace our Toyota Auris?

I am about to part exchange my 2012 Toyota Auris and can't decide what to go for. The car has been almost faultless in the eight years I have owned it and I will miss it but my wife wants something more modern. Top of the requirement list is reliability and safety. We can spend perhaps £15,000 or so.

Should I go for a medium SUV which would have better all round vision and perhaps easier access as we are both pensioners? We prefer diesel engines but can't have one as we only do a small mileage and would have DPF problems.

We have a reasonable relationship with our local Toyota dealer but their range doesn't seem to offer something suitable. I read the the newer Auris is lower than ours which might make getting in and out of it more difficult

What would you suggest as a replacement? We don't want a hybrid.

Asked on 7 February 2022 by

Answered by Russell Campbell
I would encourage you to try the new Toyota Corolla – the Auris replacement is available for £15,000 or less. It is a hybrid – so I'm playing devil's advocate, here – but it does get great fuel economy, is safe and reliable. It also has a taller driving position than most hatchbacks.

The Toyota CH-R is also worth a look. It'll come in around the top of your budget but the 1.2-litre petrol models are less popular than the hybrids and you should be able to get a nice example for less than £15,000. The CH-R has a raised ride height and will about match your Auris for interior space. It's also very reliable and won't cost much to run. Links to both cars' reviews below:

Corolla: www.honestjohn.co.uk/carbycar/toyota/corolla-2019/

C-HR: www.honestjohn.co.uk/carbycar/toyota/c-hr-2016/

Similar questions
My husband has arthritis and early Parkinsons, so we need to move from a low convertible to a sensible and safe car with comfort features. We need high adjustable seats, an automatic gearbox, petrol and...
I am looking for a petrol automatic five-door hatchback that is not a crossover, too large or firm riding. The car must be comfortable, well-equipped, reasonably economical, reliable and ULEZ-compliant. Are...
What are the best used cars for fuel economy for less than £20,000?
Related models
Characterful design. Efficient engines. Comfortable and well made.
Very efficient hybrid hatch with surprisingly upmarket interior. Good to drive, too, while standard equipment levels are generous.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer