I've been accused of misfuelling a rental car - how many miles can you theoretically drive after misfuelling?

I'm in dispute with a car rental provider who want to sue me for a small fortune. They allege I filled up a diesel car with petrol but some things are not adding up. Is it possible to drive a car for 60+ miles if you put petrol in a diesel engine because that's how far I travelled after filling up? The dashboard came up with a catastrophic engine failure warning light and then died on me. But 60 miles on the wrong fuel? Every article that I have read says the engine will conk within a couple of miles.

Asked on 28 October 2021 by Anthony Brown

Answered by Dan Powell
It's theoretically possible. For example, if the car had a significant level of diesel in the tank when you filled up with petrol then the car could have travelled 60+ miles without a problem, with the petrol floating on top of the diesel until it reached the fuel pick-up point.
Similar questions
We were due to go to Spain for a week last August until travel restrictions forced us to postpone to the end of June/start of July this year. When booking our car last August we had booked a mini class...
My son has a 5 year old diesel car and told me that he had a half tank full (about 28 litres) of premium diesel in it and then went to top up to full but accidentally put about 4 litres of petrol in. After...
Does putting petrol in a diesel car cause damage?
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer