Top 10: Petrol or diesel in 2017?

Everyone will be paying more for fuel in 2017, with Brexit, the crash in the value of the Pound and a cut in the global production of oil set to add up to 9p to a litre to petrol and diesel. Despite the doom and gloom you can avoid the hike in fuel prices by finding a car with the lowest running costs. 

We've compared 10 of the UK’s most-popular petrol and diesel cars to find out which give the best value for money over three years and/or 30,000 miles. However, please note that modern diesels - with a diesel particulate filter - require more than 15 miles to operate properly and are not suitable for a succession of short runs from cold. 

Can't find the car you're interested in? Make your own comparison with the Honest John Fuel Cost Calculator

Read more

Previous Next

Volkswagen Golf - Buy a petrol

Diesel requires 53,904 miles to break even

Its reputation might have taken a hammering in the Volkswagen Emissions Scandal, but the Golf has endured the tidal wave of negative publicity to retain its place as one of the UK’s most-popular family hatchbacks. 

The 1.6 TDI 110PS (three-door in S trim) costs £1005 more than the 1.4 TSI with 125PS to buy, but promises 74.3mpg and 99g/km of CO2. However, Real MPG shows it to take 53,223 miles to return the initial extra cost, which means the petrol is the best value over three years. 


angelcyn    on 11 January 2017

It's going to be interesting in the next two or three years as the political forces against diesel and the extra filtering requirements begin to make diesel an expensive and pointless exercise as there MPG advantage is whittled down further and the extra costs unless you are a very high mileage driver make the whole point of diesel ownership disappear.
All the major manufacturers are bringing in new petrol engines in anticipation of a swing away from diesel and it is surely only a matter of time to when the have no advantage at all.

Diesellol    on 5 February 2017

Angelcyn is spot on. Diesel is going to be gutted over the next few years by the bureaucracy.

With oil unlikely to return to three figures for a few decades due to Shale, diesel is a pointless throwback to a particular point in time when politicians were obsessed controlling plant food and peak oil was just around the corner.

Looking forward to scrapping those diesels and breathing more easily!!

Add a comment


Value my car