Can I insist my insurer uses a main dealer to repair my car after a hit and run?

What are my rights when having my car repaired after a hit and run? I have specified it should be repaired at the main dealers thinking they would do a better repair than using my insurer's network of repairers. It has dents to both drivers and rear doors. The garage has told me that the repair would involve pulling out the dents and using body filler before re-painting, and have priced it at just under £2500. This will lower the value of my car, will it not? Am I entitled to insist that two new doors be fitted, thus returning my car to how it was before the accident or should I just let them repair it as they see fit? Many thanks.

Asked on 1 June 2020 by will

Answered by Tim Kelly
You should not be able to tell the vehicle has been repaired irrespective of repair method. Virtually every car on the road will have some body filler in it somewhere, it is not something that will necessarily devalue a vehicle. Any body filler applied should be no thicker than 2mm, if the doors needs more body filler than that, then new door skins or new doors should be considered. However, you are not entitled to insist on new doors being fitted if they are not required. If the vehicle is not repaired correctly, you then would have the right to reject goods and services under the 2015 Consumer Rights Act.
Similar questions
Why does insurance cost so much? Let me tell you. I was involved in a minor bump with a parked car. No damage to mine, and only door skin and window glass to his new Mazda 6. I was willing to pay and not...
I’d like to offer a tip from a long-retired cop. When your car suffers accident damage and there is any possibility of an unwanted write off, first have it appraised by your local small man before letting...
My locked 2007 Mazda 6 TS 5-door auto parked on my driveway was struck by a car veering off the road at speed. After demolishing part of my neighbour's wall and part of my hedge it bounced off the rear...
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car