KIA Sorento - KIA Sorento Manual Gearbox Failure - Peter P

Hi,

I would like to hear from anyone who has had a gearbox failure on a KIA Sorento 2003-2009.

Many thanks,

PeterP.

KIA Sorento - KIA Sorento Manual Gearbox Failure - injection doc

is this you ? or are these more failures !

http://honestjohn.co.uk/forum/post/index.htm?t=77744

KIA Sorento - KIA Sorento Manual Gearbox Failure - Peter P

Hi,

Yes, I have had a failure of a 2005 Sorento manual gearbox (at 38900miles) and to date I know of two other identical failures.

Have you had a gearbox failure too? If so, I would like to hear from you, please.

PeterP

KIA Sorento - KIA Sorento Manual Gearbox Failure - LucyBC
On a 2005 car you are beyond any warranty and beyond (or at the very far reaches of) the Sale of Goods Act.

If these cases are resolved it is nearly always through a "goodwill payment" from the manufacturer. Generally speaking you will need a full service history and are more likely to succeed if there is a full main dealer service history. The very low mileage in your case helps.

The immediate questions arising are where you bought the car and when and then where you had it serviced and what use you have made of it.

Cars are complex and do go wrong and on a 6 year old car, while unfortunate, is not entirely surprising.
KIA Sorento - KIA Sorento Manual Gearbox Failure - Peter P

Thank you for your comments and observations.

I bought the car new on the 28th September 2005 directly from a KIA Dealer in Staffordshire. The gearbox failure occurred on the 5th January 2011. The car has a fully documented service history carried out at the recommeded intervals by a KIA Dealer except for the last (minor) service which was carried out by an Independent Daewoo Specialist Garage. The last gearbox oil change was documented as being carried out by the original supplying KIA Dealer on the 25th September 2009.

The car is occasionally used to tow a caravan, but certainly well within the guidelines set in the manufacturers' handbook guidelines. The car has never been off-roading, has always been driven with great respect and this breakdown is the first thing ever to go wrong with it.

All KIA Sorento's sold between 2007 and 2009 came with a full seven year manufacturers' warranty and I am led to believe that they were fitted with an identical gearbox to mine. Surely if KIA have the confidence to offer a seven year warranty on mechanically identical models to mine then they should acknowledge that the gearbox fitted to my car should have remained seviceable longer?

I would like to ask this question: Would the manufacturer argue that towing a caravan, albeit occasionally, did contribute to my gearbox failure? Or would they aknowledge the fact that there are many Sorento's out there, manufactured between 2003 and 2009, bought especially as a towcar? It is also well noting that the KIA Sorento was given the Towcar of the Year Award by the Caravan Club in 2004.

Any comments and observations would be greatly appreciated.

Many thanks,

PeterP.

KIA Sorento - KIA Sorento Manual Gearbox Failure - LucyBC

All KIA Sorento's sold between 2007 and 2009 came with a full seven year manufacturers' warranty and I am led to believe that they were fitted with an identical gearbox to mine. Surely if KIA have the confidence to offer a seven year warranty on mechanically identical models to mine then they should acknowledge that the gearbox fitted to my car should have remained seviceable longer?

A warranty is a contract. Your car was purchased in 2005. The warranty would not be retrospective on earlier models so what was introduced in 2007-2009 would not apply and hence no warranty protection would apply in this case.

Furthermore as I understand it the seven year warranty is not without numerous conditions which you may or may not have complied with (had you had a warranty).

As I stated earlier the resolution is probably through negotiation and reaching agreement with Kia.

If you want me to try and seek resolution on your behalf I am happy to do so. Otherwise I don't see you having many other options.

KIA Sorento - KIA Sorento Manual Gearbox Failure - Peter P

Hi,

I would be grateful if you would seek resolution on my behalf. I have the faulty gearbox in my possession if that helps.

Many thanks,

PeterP.