Wankel - CM
Being quite simple I haven't a clue what the difference between a wankel and "normal" engine is. Could someone explain in simpple terms the difference ?

Also, i was led to believe that they offer a much higher rate of bhp/litre, meaning smaller & lighter engines could be used. What is the problem with them as they are not mainstream? Are they too thirsty?
Wankel - Dynamic Dave
A quick search using google found this:

www.qsl.net/xq2fod/aeromod/wankel/wankel.html
Wankel - Dorian
They do produce a lot more bhp/litre. I think on TG last night they mentioned the new Mazda RX8 - 1.3litre Wankel producing over 200bhp.

They have problems with the oil seals at the tips of the rotor - I guess this is caused by not changing the oil frequently enough or using the wrong type.

I'm off to NZ in November, and I've got my eye on a 1980's Mazda RX7 for NZ$5000 (approx £1500). I like the look of them, and would love to try one out...
Wankel - Toad, of Toad Hall.
Erm while were in an explanatory mood anyone care to go through Rotary engines for me?
--
These are my own opinions, and not necessarily those of all Toads.
www.private-eye.co.uk/innews
Wankel - Monaro
There are lots of RX7s out here Dorian - they are one of the favourite cars to be modified by the boy racers. Just go into Auckland or Christchurch on a Friday or Saturday night and it will be like a car showroom for you.


Paul C
Wankel - Dorian
Hi Paul,

I'm under strict instruction to buy the missus a decent car, but she'll let me spend $5000 (wow - so much!) on my car. Generosity knows no limits with her... Anyhow I wanted to spend my pittance on something slightly exciting. As I haven't been home for years, any suggestions welcome!

PS - gonna be staying in Hamilton for a while, then hopefully off to Tauranga/Whakatane.

Dorian.
Wankel - John S
I believe the main problem with tip seal wear on Wankels is caused by the loading. Unlike a piston engine where the ring pressure is constant and set by the spring in the ring, a wankel forces the seals against the casing by centrifugal force. Therefore load increases with engine speed. So, drive one hard (and that's easy given the lack of vibration) and tip seal life suffers. It's needed some clever work on materials to get the seal life acceptable. Trying to improve lubrication of the seals also, I think led to oil consumption problems.

I understand the other problem is emissions. Because the combustion chamber shape is constrained by the basic engine design, it's been hard to meet current emission limits.

Regards

John S
Wankel - CM
So if the seal life and fuel consumption could be sorted out, would a wankel engine become the norm?

If so is there much reserch by the big companies into this. Presumably if Mazda are doing it then there is some research going on.
Wankel - Dizzy {P}
CM, I just spotted your posting from 2nd October.

The research into the Wankel was done many years ago, about 1960. Practically every car and truck engine maker spent money researching it but discarded it - all except NSU (it sent them to the cleaners) and Mazda.

Mazda are also the only engine maker, so far as I know, to have adopted pressure wave turbocharging (the Brown-Boveri system) about five years ago. Again, everyone else discarded it many years ago, which is just as well since the 2-litre Mazda diesel engine to which it is/was fitted developed only 75 bhp and, according to one report, it made a horrendously loud noise like a jet aircraft coming into land!
Wankel - matt35 {P}
CM
There is a L of a difference between your subject and what drew it to my attention.
Regards,
Matt35.
Wankel - Vin {P}
I think everything you need is at
www.howstuffworks.com/rotary-engine.htm
Wankel - Toad, of Toad Hall.
I meant radial. B*gger.
--
These are my own opinions, and not necessarily those of all Toads.
www.private-eye.co.uk/innews
Wankel - madf
Radial? I think it's where the cylinders are mounted as a series of cylinders surrounding the crankcase/shaft. They rotate when the engine runs so usually are enclosed in a cowl. See most US Air Force engines in WW2.. Pratt & Whitney specialised in them. Hence the bulbous front (and poor performance) of many US fighters before the Mustang. See also the FockeWulf 190.
Wankel - Toad, of Toad Hall.
Radial? I think it's where the cylinders are mounted as a
series of cylinders surrounding the crankcase/shaft. They rotate when the engine
runs so usually are enclosed in a cowl.


Yeah! Still don't get how it works!

I guessed the yanks used them. Corsairs etc...
--
These are my own opinions, and not necessarily those of all Toads.
www.private-eye.co.uk/innews
Wankel - Archie
Toad,

Try this link

www.enginehistory.org/

Should explain it all!
Wankel - Vin {P}
Toad,

Sorry to be dull, but try

www.howstuffworks.com/radial-engine.htm

That has to be the best site in the world ever. Unless you know different.

While you're on, as a biker, you should send me an email (see my profile) for an MPEG of a beauty of a stoppie.
Wankel - John Davis
If you have a spare day and are anywhere near to Newark or Cambridge, the splendid Air Museums have plenty of engines to look at, ie, rotary's, radials, and in line multi's like the Rolls Royce Merlin. Also, in London, the Science Museum have many vehicle engines on display including, I think, a Wankel. In the aircraft section, you can see a vast range of all types of aero engines, ie, rotary,radial and some of those massive Maybach and Daimler Benz, airship engines.
Wankel - Toad, of Toad Hall.
Toad,
Sorry to be dull, but try
www.howstuffworks.com/radial-engine.htm
That has to be the best site in the world ever.
Unless you know different.


Brilliant! Should have gone straight there! No indication of where the engine oil goes though!
While you're on, as a biker, you should send me an
email (see my profile) for an MPEG of a beauty of
a stoppie.


I think I know the one you mean!
--
These are my own opinions, and not necessarily those of all Toads.
www.private-eye.co.uk/innews
Wankel - Vin {P}
"No indication of where the engine oil goes though!"

Toad, it goes in the engine.

For God's sake, Mark, is there any way we can raise the intelligence of this forum?

V
Wankel - Toad, of Toad Hall.
"No indication of where the engine oil goes though!"
Toad, it goes in the engine.
For God's sake, Mark, is there any way we can raise
the intelligence of this forum?


I think we should work on the quality of the humour first!!!!

;-) ;-) ;-)
--
These are my own opinions, and not necessarily those of all Toads.
www.private-eye.co.uk/innews
Wankel - jc
A Radial is an engine with a fixed circle of cylinders and a crankshaft that goes round(eg.Pratt & Whitney).A Rotary is where the crankshaft is fixed and the drive is taken from the cylinders that are whirling around-spewed out oil and fuel in all directions(Gnome le Rhone 1917).To my memory Wankels either had very good bhp/litre or very bad on the same engine because no-one could agree on a method of calculating the swept volume(cubic capacity).
Wankel - Dizzy {P}
jc, I beg to differ very slightly.

I regard an engine with the cylinders arranged in a circle around the crankshaft as a Radial engine irrespective of whether the crankshaft or the cylinders do the rotating.

In a rotary engine, the gas compressing element (e.g the Wankel rotor) moves in a generally rotating direction -- as opposed to a conventional piston which reciprocates in a linear direction.
Wankel - madman
I think you will find that because a wankel does not have pistons in cylinders it is difficult to measure a swept volume.
Radial engines are those with the cylinders radiating from the crankshaft as per most WW2 american aircraft.
Rotating engines are accepted as being those with the cylinders radiating but spinning around a fixed crankshaft as per lots of WW1 aircraft this application has the prop bolted to the cylinders and no throttle, the engine was either running at full chat or shut down. To land these aircraft one had to switch the magneto on and off!
Rotary engines are the same as wankel engines.
Wankel engines were not only used in Mazdas. There is an aircraft engine wankel for light aircraft in production at the moment. Motorbikes that have used this engine are: Suzuki RE5, Norton Rotary, and NSU.
Cars are: NSU RO 80 and Citroen GS. I once drove the GS and it was perfectly smooth and got quieter the faster it was driven.
Wankel - RichardW
>I once drove the GS and it was perfectly smooth and got quieter the faster it was driven.

How jealous does that make me? I only discovered they existed a few months ago - not being old enough to remember them first time around (but old enought to remember my parents having 2 GS's)

Richard
Wankel - John S
madman

Citroen GS? No, surely this didn't have a Wankel engine - IIRC it had an extremely smooth running flat-four of about 1.1 litres. I'm pretty sure of this as a work colleague had one many years back, and it spent plenty of time with the bonnet up!

Regards

John S
Wankel - RichardW
John,

Yep, most GS's were fitted with the flat four. However there was a small production run of wankel engined beasts - the GZ Birotor:

www.citroen.mb.ca/citroenet/html/b/birotor.htm

I don't think many survive....

Richard
Wankel - Onetap
It's curious that the, otherwise over-enthusiastic, swear filter didn't amend 'wankel'. Presumably the software is american and the cousins aren't familiar with that word.

Something to be added to the dictionary maybe, Mark?

Wankel - madman
What are you on about? Stop babbling and get back to subject.
Wankel - jc
I don't think many Ro80 survive ;all the ones I knew about had Ford V4/6 fitted.
Wankel - Jonathan {p}
this link offers a very good non technical explanation and gif animation showing how it works

www.mazdarx8.co.uk/rotary/rotaryhow.asp?documentid...8
Wankel - dan
Wankel engines burn oil as they go. Just no way to seperate it from the combustion areas as it operates unlike rings and seals in a piston engine. Oil is injected into the wankel cavity to lubricate the tips of the triangular blob rotating in the middle. (see how the level of technical knowledge disintigrates before your very eyes)
Very popular in the US, don't expect much life from any in the UK that has done more than 100K without a total rebuild. (e.g. Old RX7's no matter HOW cheap they are, watch out!)
Wankel - Dizzy {P}
20,000 miles was the usual tip seal mileage of an NSU RO80 Wankel engine, a costly thing to put right. I'm sure the Mazda engines have improved on this a great deal but it must still be a weak point, thus the need to inject oil as Dan so eloquently explained.

Regarding an earlier comment about swept volume -- this can in fact be measured quite easily but confusion arises as to whether you take the volume swept by one of the lobes or all three in calculating engine size. If only one, the power output per cc is very high - but so is the fuel consumption!
Wankel - T Lucas
If you have ever had the chance to drive a Mazda Rotary you will know just how good they are.My 1st Mazda Rotary was a'73 RX3 coupe in 1977, my 1st car top speed in excess of 120 mph when all my mates Fords would struggle up to 90 mph but about 20 mpg on 2 star petrol.The most recent Mazda Rotary i have owned was a '95 RX7 twin turbo straight from Japan,top speed too fast for me but the sound and power along with the fact that you are driving something so different is quite satisfying.Fuel consumption probably in the late teens though.
Wankel - Bromptonaut
jc, I beg to differ very slightly.
I regard an engine with the cylinders arranged in a circle
around the crankshaft as a Radial engine irrespective of whether the
crankshaft or the cylinders do the rotating.
In a rotary engine, the gas compressing element (e.g the Wankel
rotor) moves in a generally rotating direction -- as opposed to
a conventional piston which reciprocates in a linear direction.


In aviation usage the Rotary engine was the species of radial like the gnome Rhone where the cylinders whizzed round. The Wankel with rotating compressing element came much later.

The oil from the rotary aero engine has the special capacity of finding any exposed bits of the pilot, failing which it is programmed to go for the goggles!!