Which car | Motoring discussion | Back Room Forum

Thu 26 Mar 2009 09:40

Which car - Alex147

Hi

i am looking to replace my car and have narrowed it down to BMW 330i \ 330d or a Subaru Legacy. I was wondering what peoples thoughts were, especially on the Legacy, which at the moment looks great value for money used.

I would love the 3.0 Legacy, but understand they are really thirsty? The BMW i know is okay, as i used to run a 328i some years back and averaged 30mpg. Also. BMWs tend to make the driving experience feel special.

any comments \ thoughts \advice most welcome

Reply | Report as offensive | Link

Thu 26 Mar 2009 10:07

Which car - gordonbennet

I'd be happy with any of those, if you drive enthusiastically in the wet then maybe the Legacy makes better sense, similarly if your regular routes are slippery country roads.

Subaru's are fine cars and i considered a 3 litre meself, in the back of my mind though there nags the fact there's no GSF/Eurocarparts etc for them, and fine cars or not, they'll all need discs, pads, shockers etc at some point, not saying you can't get good aftermarket stuff, but maybe not so easily.

Maybe be flexible for any of them but be ready for when that combination of everything you want, colour, interior, history, spec all come together at a bargain not to be missed price and snap it up.

Times i've missed really good value cars because i've been stubbornly looking for my required combination in one model only.

Reply | Report as offensive | Link

Thu 26 Mar 2009 11:14

Which car - oldtoffee

I had a Legacy 3.0R Spec B estate which I traded in for a Legacy diesel - the company car tax and fuel bills being the main reasons. If you see low 20's mpg you'll be doing well but it is a hoot to drive with massive grip and traction helped a bit by the Bilstein suspension - corners flat, great steering. Downside? Slightly firm ride (not as hard as a BMW 320D M Sport that I tested) and road noise and tyre rumble transmit through to the cabin at high speeds. The Spec B comes wth just about every extra except auto and sat nav. I had the auto; if I had one again I'd have the manual - quicker.

I've driven a 330d auto and to me it felt as quick as the Legacy auto once moving. Having now had 4WD in last two cars and enjoying the extra traction, grip and feeling of security I don't think I'd ever go back to 2WD. But if I did, a 330i is the type of car and engine that would do it. Or a 335i in a few more years!

Reply | Report as offensive | Link

Related questions

Should I get a Mazda 3 or a Honda Civic for a reliable auto?

I'm looking for a reliable torque converter hatchback, must be a petrol automatic. I've narrowed it down to either a Mazda 3 2.0 (2014 -) or a Honda Civic 1.8 (2012 -). Can you help me decide which to...

What cars could you recommend that have a smooth and reliable automatic gearbox?

I have the wonderful 8-speed ZF auto box in my 2015 BMW 4 Series. I can't afford to keep the BMW but I do like a silky smooth automatic transmission. What cars have the best automatic transmissions, in...

What should we replace our BMW 1 Series with for a spacious boot, quality interior and a competent drive?

We need to change our 3 year old BMW 118d M Sport for a petrol automatic with a better boot than the 1 Series, an easy lift hatch, and the refinement you get with the BMW. Good roadholding and a competent...

Which petrol auto would you suggest for a disabled passenger?

Can you suggest some models that are petrol automatics and have room for a folded wheelchair, walking frame, etc in the boot? It needs a front passenger seat that a disabled person can get into without...

Ask Honest John

Sell Your Car

Real MPG

Fuel Calculator