Volkswagen emissions scandal - has it been over dramatised?

You seem to think that the emissions scandal is all a bit of a storm in a tea-cup. Why is this?

I have an A4 Allroad on a PCP deal and I was wondering the same thing as the Tiguan driver who asked you if he could reject the car.

Your answer was "don't be ridiculous".

I was just wondering if you think it has all been over-dramatised? I was wondering the same thing about the guaranteed future value of the car.

Asked on 12 October 2015 by JuniorOeuf

Answered by Honest John
Yes, it has all been over dramatised. I think it is unforgivable of the CEO of VW/Audi Group that such a climate of fear existed within the organisation that could lead to this cost-saving shortcut, and he cannot expect me to believe that he knew nothing about it. But the cheat itself is not very serious. It simply means that the vehicle ECU recognises that the car is not being steered, and in that situation alters the parameters of the engine to reduce NOx emissions to a level below that when the car is being driven normally. So, in traffic, driving slowly in a straight line, NOx would be reduced as it is for the tests and pedestrians on sidewalks in cities would not actually suffer from inhaling too much of the stuff. Unfortunately, hard acceleration and deceleration massively increase NOx emissions from any diesel powered vehicle (not merely Volkswagens), so unnecessary obstructions such road humps and artificial stoppages are actually more harmful than emissions test cheating. Your car still runs exactly as it did before the scandal broke and it will continue to run exactly the same. By the end of 2016, VWG will have deleted the 'cheat' software in all of the affected cars and modified the EGR systems and DPF systems of those that need it. The greatest damage is to the perception of VWG cars as somehow being superior to other makes, but everyone who bought one is effectively a subscriber to brand snobbery and is likely to continue to support that to protect their investment.
Similar questions
How do I know if I have a EA 189 engine? My car is a Skoda Octavia 2012 SE TDI CR 1986cc.
I have just read your news story on Volkswagen's legal settlement over the emissions scandal claim: https://www.honestjohn.co.uk/news/legal-motoring-advice/2022-05/volkswagen-group-agrees-gbp193m-settlement-for-dieselgate-claimants/ Where...
I owned an Audi for seven years that was affected by the diesel emission scandal. Although I sold the car twi years ago I notice that there are legal firms offering to make a group claim against Volkswagen....
Related models
As good to drive as standard A4 Avant but with quattro four-wheel drive and raised ground clearance. Ideal for towing. Refined and well built.