Pre-retirement choice - Honda, BMW or other?

Due to our low mileage (9k/year) and pollution concerns we seek a small/medium petrol automatic to replace our much loved 2001 Honda Civic auto. My wife wants a new Jazz or Yaris but we fear these might be too small for our only car. We liked the A3 and Golf but were put off by concerns about DSG gearboxes. We thought the new Civic auto OK but discounted the new A class after a previous bad experience with a rusty E class. Out of curiosity we looked at the new BMW 118i auto and, to my surprise not thinking of ourselves as “BMW people", really liked it. What do you recommend?

Asked on 4 September 2015 by CountryCousin

Answered by Honest John
A Jazz is bigger inside with the seats folded than a Golf. Go and have a look at one, flip down the seats and you'll be amazed. It's the most space efficient hatchback you can buy. The new modular 1.5 3-cylinder and 2.0 4-cylinder BMW engines seem fine so far. Good performance. No complaints. But these are early days. Much smaller inside than a Jazz. Production of the Jazz Iat Swindon has now ended. New Jazz will come from Japan. Expect at least a £2000 discount on the outgoing Jazz. Civic continue at Swindon, with even more voluminous interiors and the 1.8 136PS engine is outstandingly reliable.
Similar questions
About three years ago you kindly recommended that I buy a Honda Civic, which I did. My Civic 2.2 -i-CTDI has now done 71000 miles and I am looking to change it for something about 1/2 years old. I have...
I am looking to buy a Honda Civic 2015. I am currently doing fairly short trips to work 5 days a week with my Ford Focus diesel (around 15 mins in the city area) creating all sorts of engine troubles....
I currently drive an 07 GT TDI Golf which is ready to be replaced. I have a wife, a child and a baby on the way.I have a budget of up to £19k and am thinking of buying a family motor that is new/nearly...
Related models
Punchy and efficient diesel engines, class-leading practicality, excellent reliability record.
A very entertaining car to drive, efficient yet powerful engines, superb infotainment.