qashqai plus 2 replacement

We are considering whether to replace a 5 year old 2 litre petrol qashqai which has covered 34000 miles mainly on sub 4 mile trips around town. It is also used for 30 mile trips some weekends and family holidays ( twice a year).
We really like the idea of a panoramic glass roof and a decent sized boot .Seven seats was an advantage but no longer necessary
The latest qashqai has the roof in Tekna spec and a 1.6 dci is around £23000 discounted .
The cx5 only has a small sunroof . The Evoque is available with the roof at £28000 discounted via drive the deal.
The secondhand options look overpriced when compared to new via a broker
My question is do you think the evoque or qashqai diesel will be ok for mainly short trips around town.
Thank you
Ps the q2 has been a really good car. Reliable and comfortable in acenta spec.
There is a huge advantage that by only using 6 seats you still have a reasonable sized boot.. may be worth adding that to car by car. As a seven seater bootspace minimal !
The evoque is only available as a diesel, in our price bracket..£ 15000 /30000

Asked on 16 April 2014 by sisi95

Answered by Honest John
The 1.6DCI 130 has a sophisticated heat management system, low compression and exhaust manifold in head so the DPF can be close coupled and heat up faster. It's been in the Scenic, Megane and Qashqai for at least 3 years now with no reports of any DPF problems. The CX-5 2.2 Skyactiv engine uses similar technology. The Evoque doesn't. of the three, the Evoque is most likely to suffer DPF problems if used fort repeated short runs from cold.
Tags: owning
Similar questions
I own a 2013 Nissan Qashqai 2.0. In your review of the car, you mention MPG Extra Urban 45.6 mpg. What is Extra Urban? I don't get anywhere near 45.6mpg.
The engine management light came on in my 2012 Nissan Qashqai 1.6 diesel, which has done 42,000 miles. RAC diagnosed and exhaust and throttle control actuator fault, and felt that the turbo was about to...
I own a Nissan Qashqai 1.9 petrol automatic. When I accelerate up to a certain speed and then ease off the accelerator, the revs increase considerably, although the speed remains constant. When I then...
Related models
Very comfortable front seats with good ride. Feels well built. Strong Renault sourced dCi diesels. Elevated driving position and good visibility.