Is a cold-start knocking in my Superb Estate the result of contaminated diesel or a failing DMF?

Having given my local Skoda garage £370 to flush contaminated diesel from my Superb estate, a serious cold-start knocking issue persists as bad as ever, disappearing once the engine is just a little warm. A phone call to a local independent VAG-Skoda specialist this morning has thrown up another option, where the mechanic immediately suggested that the issue was with a failing Dual-Mass Flywheel. Upon mentioning this idea to Skoda, they insisted that fuel contamination was the issue, and that I should run the car for at least another 400 miles "to fully flush the system", before I think about further investigations.

I would have thought that if fuel contamination was the cause, flushing/cleaning the system would be an immediate fix, and would not require several hundred miles to complete. As I'm working in Ireland for a few days next week, I will have an opportunity to leave the car at the specialist and get all the DMF work done before I return, as Skoda will not be able to undertake further investigations until much later next week. Whilst all the fuel contamination work was explicitly excluded from any warranty claim, I am assured that failure of the DMFW will be covered. I would appreciate your guidance.

Asked on 3 August 2013 by DE, Munich

Answered by Honest John
The Skoda dealer has said the problem is due to the fuel contamination. Your dual mass flywheel is only covered under warranty if the Skoda dealer agrees this is the problem and agrees to replace it. If you have it replaced by an independent you will not get any money to pay for it from Skoda, and the cost is probably in the region of £1500.
Similar questions
The clutch in my partner's C4 Picasso is screaming like a Banshee when depressed. My local independent garage guy tells me the clutch needs replacing and it would be foolish not to change the dual mass...
I have a 2009 Toyota Land Cruiser LC5 3.0 diesel manual D4D with 29,000 miles. This week it suffered what appears to be clutch failure. I recovered the car to my local independent garage (the nearest Toyata...
I have a Peugeot 207 SW with just 30,000 miles on the clock. It is still within its three-year warranty and at 29,000 miles the clutch went. Peugeot would not repair this under warranty and the new clutch...
Related models
Huge interior and load space. More legroom in the back than a Mercedes-Benz S-Class. Clever touches throughout. Well specified as standard and great value for money.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer