Which diesel pick-up should I buy?

I am considering purchasing a high spec double cab pick-up for use as a family car and 'gardening/camping' duties. My mileage would be some 6000 per annum and the longest average journey would be some 20 miles round trip each week. My choices are the Isuzu D-Max or Nissan Navara. Do you think there are better alternatives? Also I am somewhat concerned about the diesel particulate filter issues. The dealerships say they see very few problems, despite being used by builders, and for agricultural use on many short trips. I am looking for durability and longevity, so auto or manual?

Asked on 25 May 2013 by JD, Minchinhampton

Answered by Honest John

It's a toss-up between the latest D-Max and the Ford Ranger, not the Nissan Navara. Don't touch an auto pick-up. Very sluggish, inefficient and unpleasant to drive. My sister-in-law has one because she can't drive properly. Yes, there is potential for DPF problems.

Tags: automatics dpf diesels pick-ups

Similar questions

Can you recommend a diesel automatic for £10,000?

With a budget of £10,000, what Focus or bigger-sized diesel auto would you recommend secondhand? I'm running 30,000 miles per year, so it shouldn't be too expensive to run in fuel/parts, and needs to be...

Is the Mazda 6 Tourer automatic known for DPF problems?

I'm thinking of buying a Mazda 6 Tourer, but the auto version that I want is only available with a diesel engine and 19-inch wheels. Have the DPF problems been sorted and is the ride ok on these wheels?

Can I buy a diesel automatic crossover without fear of DPF problems?

I am about to retire and looking to buy a crossover, but am put off by all the dealers telling me I have to do at least 15,000 miles per year if I want a diesel. I do 10,000 miles. I also have driven automatics...