Which petrol car offers good performance without big wheels?

I'm looking to change my 2007 BMW 120D SE (I have been really happy with this car) and would welcome your advice on possible replacements. My annual mileage of 7000 precludes a diesel with a DPF, but I would prefer a petrol car with a similar performance so I am looking for one with a sporty performance but not with big wheels and "sports" suspension. Does the new 118i BMW SE fit the bill or is the Golf 1.4 TSI a better bet?

Asked on 2 March 2013 by MS, Newcastle, Staffs

Answered by Honest John

The huge benefit of a BMW 1 Series is rear wheel drive and steering uncorrupted by driveshafts. But actually, a Golf VII 1.2TSI 105 SE does the job astonishingly well and is a very satisfying car to be in. I’d say that is now the class leader. However, a Honda Civic 1.8iES is more economical. I saw 47mpg over 650 miles in one; 4mpg better than I got from the Golf 1.2TSI 105.

Tags: performance fuel economy wheels and tyres sports cars

Similar questions

Can changing tyre brand really affect the handling of my Mazda MX-5?

I purchased my Mazda MX-5 1.6 in 2006 having read your in-depth review. At the time I recall that you recommended ensuring that the car came with Yokohama tyres, which I did. After 42,000 miles, the front...

Could you suggest something sporty, with good performance, that isn't too expensive?

My partner has owned her Puma from new for 17 years, but it's now ready for changing. She loves it and wants something close to it. She wants something easy to drive that has four seats, sporty looks,...

I get good mileage from my BMW 5 Series on low profile tyres.

I have read with some interest your reader reports about low profile tyres and their problems. I have had a 2007 BMW 535d Sport from new with 245/35x19 (front) and 275/30x19 (rear), all Conti Sport Contact...

Related models