Why do some people not understand power steering?

I had to laugh at the first letter in your column: “Let's have an intelligent conversation about electric power steering.” Amazingly the writer then proceeded not to have an intelligent conversation by slating it across the board. To have an intelligent conversation, surely as your reply indicated, you need to have driven a large number of cars with it and be able to compare that to a large number without it and weigh up the pros and cons against no power steering, rear or front drive and finally, of course, electric.

In my limited experience I'd say it's set up rather than what type, although it does appear from reading and driving that manufacturers seem to be finding it harder to get proper ‘feel’ with electric power steering. Rear-wheel drive with no power steering would be purest. I assume you are never going to get perfect feel and handling in a front wheel drive car, but for most of us the benefits (safety etc.) far outweigh the cons.

For the record I have a 2010 MINI, which I assume has electric power steering, and it is nothing short of fantastic: stable, nippy and lots of feel for electric, especially compared to the dreadful Honda Jazz Mk1 and Hyundai i20 which had no centre feel at all and did as your writer says, ie wander all over. Porsche has adopted electrics now for its 911 991 and there is some resistance in the press. I’ll bet the ordinary punter would be happy, though. And of course the benefits of weight, no maintenance (fluid top up), cost and economy must be important or they wouldn’t have bothered developing it.

Asked on 2 February 2013 by JB, via email

Answered by Honest John
Initially the R56 MINI had truly terrible steering and it was us who criticised it to the chassis engineer on the launch and pushed him into improving it. See: www.honestjohn.co.uk/road-tests/mini/mini-cooper-d.../

The best electric power steering on any car is in the RenaultSport Megane 250 and 265, and that's a lot to do with the geometry of the hubs as well as the fine tuning of the steering software: www.honestjohn.co.uk/road-tests/renault/renaultspo.../
Similar questions
My Fiat 500's steering suddenly feels heavy when going in a straight line but feels normal when I turn the wheel. What's the issue?
On taking ownership of this car almost a year ago I noticed a soft whine that varied with engine speed. Not being used to twin clutch boxes I took it to the local Ford dealer for confirmation that disaster...
Having read several road tests on-line, it seems my Lexus GS is prone to twitchy steering at low speeds. This is due to the variable-ratio, speed-sensitive, electronic power steering, which gives a high...
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer