Which company car for my colleague will handle A and B-roads, congestion and motorways?

A colleague travels from work in Lancashire to home in mid-Wales every week. She runs a company car on a three-year lease. For the first time she has decided to run a 4WD to cope better with the journey in bad weather. She has a short list of two cars, either a Volkswagen Tiguan 2.0 TDI 170ps 4-Motion, or the new Honda CR-V. Which of the two cars would serve her best on winter A and B-roads, the summer congestion going from work to home, and business motorway miles covering 70,000 miles?

Asked on 2 February 2013 by MN, via email

Answered by Honest John

There's less need to worry about diesel particulate filters when it's not your car. The Tiguan is a sharper, sportier drive. The CR-V on 17-inch or 18-inch wheels is more comfortable. In that price range there is also the Mazda CX-5 with Skyactive engine. There will soon be a new Ford Kuga: www.honestjohn.co.uk/road-tests/ford/ford-kuga-20-.../. There's also the Audi Q3 and, later this month, there will be a new Toyota RAV4.

Tags: company cars motorways high mileage

Similar questions

I need to replace my Skoda Octavia with something to cover high mileages - what about the Toyota Avensis diesel?

I run my own furnishing business and cover about 50,000 miles per year. I currently have a 2006 Skoda Octavia Mk2 1.9TDI estate which is coming up to 165,000 miles. It has been very good, but the driver's...

Company lease Tiguan 4x4 - should I be looking at other models?

I currently have a company lease VW Tiguan (which I'm happy with) and was going to exchange for another in March next year. I do 15K miles per year (22 mile each way commute) and am thinking about the...

Do hybrids perform well for high-mileage drivers?

My lease car is due for renewal through my NHS leasing scheme. At the moment, I have a diesel Kia Ce'ed, for which I pay £105 per month. Prices have increased and the same car will cost me £165 next time,...

Related models

Audi Q3 (2011 - 2018)

Stylish. compact SUV in a similar fashion to the Range Rover Evoque. Impressive fuel economy and low CO2. Two and four-wheel drive available.

Volkswagen Tiguan (2008 - 2016)

Decent SUV with diesel automatic option. Comfortable seats. Escape version capable off-road. Optional Park Assist works well. Much better from September 2011 facelift.